Power level of a PC
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
Boddynock
- Posts: 834
- Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am
Re: Power level of a PC
The ultiply thing is basically already being done though, isn't it. You have to imagine that there was a reason the hardest boss on the server is a great WHITE wyrm, basically the weakest color, and not a red. Yet if you look at the PnP stats for a great red wyrm, our white would roflstomp it with little to no effort.
Our setting is already basically multiplying monster CR by elevating the CR of mobs way way above normal. This sort of mechanically enforces the lvl/2 thing already.
My only big beef is that town guard, which even with their CR doubled should only have a CR of like 6 max, end up being level a bajillion so we PCs don't walk all over them. We should walk all over them, they are nothing compared to a PC, literally. They shouldn't even have levels in PC classes with a few exceptions (named NPCs, mostly).
Our setting is already basically multiplying monster CR by elevating the CR of mobs way way above normal. This sort of mechanically enforces the lvl/2 thing already.
My only big beef is that town guard, which even with their CR doubled should only have a CR of like 6 max, end up being level a bajillion so we PCs don't walk all over them. We should walk all over them, they are nothing compared to a PC, literally. They shouldn't even have levels in PC classes with a few exceptions (named NPCs, mostly).
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
-
metaquad4
- Posts: 1532
- Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm
Re: Power level of a PC
Neither is above the other. Without the mechanics, you have IRC or pure fourm RP (or a variant, on another text-only medium). Without the RP, you have an action PW. D&D (and really, any D20 RPG) has always been about using mechanics to determine how RP can play out (using your skills and abilities to determine what your character can do, for example). Both components are essential to this, as they form the game we play on when joined together.TheLier wrote:
That might result in giant number fests, which never look good IMO. And this is still mostly about how the world (alias, the DMs) handle the PCs. Mechanics are second at best, RP is the key in my eyes.
@Boddynock:
That is a very good point, the already present mechanical enforcement of level multiplication. Not only there, but in events too (ones with tougher and more interesting mobs, like Bloodlust's events). That mechanical enforcement is what gives us a challenge in PvE. I hadn't thought of that, thanks for mentioning it.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
-
Storm Munin
- Posts: 1355
- Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:03 am
- Location: Sweden, Alfheimar expat
Re: Power level of a PC
Maybe I read the OP wrong but the issue I percieve him addressing isnt the pumped up dragon, angel or professional soldier, archwizard e t c.
What I believe gets to him as it once in a while has gotten to me are when the equivalent of the common townwatch volunteer Jim Bob and his trusty ageing watchdog Snuffles in Backwater village readily detects a sneaking epic rogue (H/ms 70+ and invisible) at a distance of half a mile. It doesnt get better from there on, yes Snuffles do divine damage and lots of it.
So your trusty rogue, the archmages and most everyone else spend the event dying all over the place to most anything while the DM desperately tries and sometimes succeeds to do something to the favored soul or its equivalent.
A dragon, a cowled wizard and his entourage, a squad of the Fist e t c sure they are supposed to be downright hard to beat.
But Jim Bob and Snuffles?
I know, I know never underestimate the small guy.
Basically I guess what I am saying let our toons look good at the beginning of events then do feel free to unleash the slaughterfest, please.
Or at least begin with believeable foes to pawn us.
/M
What I believe gets to him as it once in a while has gotten to me are when the equivalent of the common townwatch volunteer Jim Bob and his trusty ageing watchdog Snuffles in Backwater village readily detects a sneaking epic rogue (H/ms 70+ and invisible) at a distance of half a mile. It doesnt get better from there on, yes Snuffles do divine damage and lots of it.
So your trusty rogue, the archmages and most everyone else spend the event dying all over the place to most anything while the DM desperately tries and sometimes succeeds to do something to the favored soul or its equivalent.
A dragon, a cowled wizard and his entourage, a squad of the Fist e t c sure they are supposed to be downright hard to beat.
But Jim Bob and Snuffles?
I know, I know never underestimate the small guy.
Basically I guess what I am saying let our toons look good at the beginning of events then do feel free to unleash the slaughterfest, please.
Or at least begin with believeable foes to pawn us.
/M
"Drojal zhah obdoluth dorb'd streeak, Lueth dro zhah zhaunau dorb'd ogglin."
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.
PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.
PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.
-
V'rass
- Posts: 1251
- Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2015 1:48 pm
- Location: Concord, N.H., USSA
Re: Power level of a PC
If there are going to be caps then have it either soft cap 15, hard cap 20 or just a straight cap of 20.
"To understand magic one must first understand magic."
Agathion Benedictus: Holy Priest. Retired for now.
Tiax Rules-All: Gnomish madman. Retired permanently.
Exordius Vrass: Cleric/Mage. Currently active.
-
Tsidkenu
Re: Power level of a PC
The power level of PCs in relation to NPC guards has been a RP sticking point for some time. It is unfortunate that there is a mentality that NPC guard forces are an elite police force and not just regular mercs and soldiers who probably would be more likely to place bets on the people fighting, and then arrest the exhausted and wounded victor/s and throw them in the cells to sleep it off, than to act like the interventionist police forces of our own day. And the way some NPC guards are given nigh unbypassable detection skills. A level 5 rogue ought to have reasonable success in sneaking past a wary guard. On this server a level 30 rogue can barely do that because guard NPCs have 50+ spot.
One thing that always made me chuckle a bit was when DMs say things like, "The walls of the FAI are lined with crossbowyers, etc etc". No. They're not. You don't keep your guard force on 100% active duty all the time. You rotate them. I somehow doubt Bentley of FAI fame would have more than a dozen guards at the most, four shifts of 6 hour rotations or perhaps 12 shifts of 2 hour rotations, when 3 are on duty at a time (two by the gates and that one guy that patrols the courtyard). If there's some situation then you might call up those who were sleeping/idling etc., but the FAI does not (or, should not!) have a standing army and shouldn't be RPed in the manner it so very often has, as if Bentley's goons were a crack riot squad ready to swoop on the most minor of transgressions.
But that's the impossible balance isn't it, when you've got level 30 Avatars of a Deity FS wandering the wilderness whose players have OOC knowledge that seeps IC that very little can defeat them, especially not some puny level 1 peasant militiaman guarding a gatehouse? So there's a responsibility on players not to RP with that kind of I-Am-God mindset.
A level 15 or 20 cap would be nice (with DM-granted advancement beyond for exceptional character RP), but this server is too far gone for that now, notwithstanding a complete vault wipe. Good luck passing that by the community, let alone staff & QC.
One thing that always made me chuckle a bit was when DMs say things like, "The walls of the FAI are lined with crossbowyers, etc etc". No. They're not. You don't keep your guard force on 100% active duty all the time. You rotate them. I somehow doubt Bentley of FAI fame would have more than a dozen guards at the most, four shifts of 6 hour rotations or perhaps 12 shifts of 2 hour rotations, when 3 are on duty at a time (two by the gates and that one guy that patrols the courtyard). If there's some situation then you might call up those who were sleeping/idling etc., but the FAI does not (or, should not!) have a standing army and shouldn't be RPed in the manner it so very often has, as if Bentley's goons were a crack riot squad ready to swoop on the most minor of transgressions.
But that's the impossible balance isn't it, when you've got level 30 Avatars of a Deity FS wandering the wilderness whose players have OOC knowledge that seeps IC that very little can defeat them, especially not some puny level 1 peasant militiaman guarding a gatehouse? So there's a responsibility on players not to RP with that kind of I-Am-God mindset.
A level 15 or 20 cap would be nice (with DM-granted advancement beyond for exceptional character RP), but this server is too far gone for that now, notwithstanding a complete vault wipe. Good luck passing that by the community, let alone staff & QC.
-
fearknight2003
- Posts: 354
- Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 8:53 pm
Re: Power level of a PC
A vault wipe would deal with people being bitter about grandfathered items, allow for any economy problems to be fixed, and completely level the playing field. I don't see what's so bad about it.Tsidkenu wrote:The power level of PCs in relation to NPC guards has been a RP sticking point for some time. It is unfortunate that there is a mentality that NPC guard forces are an elite police force and not just regular mercs and soldiers who probably would be more likely to place bets on the people fighting, and then arrest the exhausted and wounded victor/s and throw them in the cells to sleep it off, than to act like the interventionist police forces of our own day. And the way some NPC guards are given nigh unbypassable detection skills. A level 5 rogue ought to have reasonable success in sneaking past a wary guard. On this server a level 30 rogue can barely do that because guard NPCs have 50+ spot.
One thing that always made me chuckle a bit was when DMs say things like, "The walls of the FAI are lined with crossbowyers, etc etc". No. They're not. You don't keep your guard force on 100% active duty all the time. You rotate them. I somehow doubt Bentley of FAI fame would have more than a dozen guards at the most, four shifts of 6 hour rotations or perhaps 12 shifts of 2 hour rotations, when 3 are on duty at a time (two by the gates and that one guy that patrols the courtyard). If there's some situation then you might call up those who were sleeping/idling etc., but the FAI does not (or, should not!) have a standing army and shouldn't be RPed in the manner it so very often has, as if Bentley's goons were a crack riot squad ready to swoop on the most minor of transgressions.
But that's the impossible balance isn't it, when you've got level 30 Avatars of a Deity FS wandering the wilderness whose players have OOC knowledge that seeps IC that very little can defeat them, especially not some puny level 1 peasant militiaman guarding a gatehouse? So there's a responsibility on players not to RP with that kind of I-Am-God mindset.
A level 15 or 20 cap would be nice (with DM-granted advancement beyond for exceptional character RP), but this server is too far gone for that now, notwithstanding a complete vault wipe. Good luck passing that by the community, let alone staff & QC.
It was a fun year (I think). Bye.
-
Young Werther
- Posts: 863
- Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 8:42 pm
- Location: Azkaban
Re: Power level of a PC
Would just make the game less fun. More levels, more possibilities, more dreams morelevel 15 or 20 cap
Lockonnow wrote:greatest fear like the movie Hellraiser they show you what you most fear and take a Image of IT
-
metaquad4
- Posts: 1532
- Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm
Re: Power level of a PC
The way to make guards reasonable, would be to do a couple things:
1) Allow NPCs to be attacked (except for named NPCs, for obvious reasons. DMs should handle these imo). Allow NPCs who are attacked to respawn after a time.
2) Create/Implement an AI which is capable of handling #1. If NPCs or PCs are attacked in its (it would likely be placed on guards and combat-capable NPCs) sight lines, it goes hostile against the person it saw attacking until that PC is "beated" and arrested (at which point, the PC goes to jail until the reset). If two PCs attack each other, then it would select the PC who attacked first and attack it.
3) Create a variety of guard NPCs, some balanced around lower levels, some around higher levels. Some magical, some mundane. Lower level guards might be present around the middle class and lower class sections of town, and higher level guards might be present around the richer sections of town and where nobles are.
The "NPCs being immortals" thing is really just a way to stop people from doing things without DMs around. NPCs stop being immortal, generally, when (good) DMs are around. Yes, there have been some more shoddy DMs who turn guards into immortals. But ideally, a (good) DM will allow a PC to do certain things, as if it were an event (which, I suppose it would be).
Allowing NPCs to attack, and allowing guards to react would both make DMs not have to be around 24/7 for all the little stuff, it would make guards into actual people instead of god killing machines, and it would create a more natural roleplaying environment (one where the mechanics are interlinked with roleplay, instead of creating something artificial like the current state of the guards). Something similiar to Ultima Online, or the like. Guards are tough (especially when they come in groups) but at least beatable. This also opens up new avenues for criminal and chaotic RP. And on top of that, it would give our PW something that no other PW on nwn2 has (an environment that reacts to the player actively).
This also opens up avenues for NPC-RP. An example of this, would be beggars who come up to you begging for money, and attack you if you don't give them any (and take some of your money if they succeed). Case in point, it allows for a far more active environment (the environment should be part of the story that is being told too!) and it would really be something unique (and probably unprecedented? Maybe someone else did it.) in the nwn2 community.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another way, is to allow for PC guards (but no silly PRCs for them. Really, that was a stupid idea). Contrary to popular belief, this does work. Dalelands and Sigil are proof of that (though, we are a "PG-13/Teen" community and they are both "Mature" communities
).
Heck, we even have our fair share of it still. Candlekeep and Darkhold are both areas where PCs can patrol and arrest in their jurisdictions (not to mention, PCs sometimes bring other PCs to jurisdictions, then PM a DM to help them with the next step). It can work, here, still. Have Bentley hire FAI guards, let players join the flaming fist, let players get involved with the various governments, etc. It'll open up a bunch of new RP avenues and make life a bit more interesting. Creating RP is what we should be all about.
Just, instead of making the mistake of giving PCs a kick ass PRC and an insta-arrest button, don't give them that!
1) Allow NPCs to be attacked (except for named NPCs, for obvious reasons. DMs should handle these imo). Allow NPCs who are attacked to respawn after a time.
2) Create/Implement an AI which is capable of handling #1. If NPCs or PCs are attacked in its (it would likely be placed on guards and combat-capable NPCs) sight lines, it goes hostile against the person it saw attacking until that PC is "beated" and arrested (at which point, the PC goes to jail until the reset). If two PCs attack each other, then it would select the PC who attacked first and attack it.
3) Create a variety of guard NPCs, some balanced around lower levels, some around higher levels. Some magical, some mundane. Lower level guards might be present around the middle class and lower class sections of town, and higher level guards might be present around the richer sections of town and where nobles are.
The "NPCs being immortals" thing is really just a way to stop people from doing things without DMs around. NPCs stop being immortal, generally, when (good) DMs are around. Yes, there have been some more shoddy DMs who turn guards into immortals. But ideally, a (good) DM will allow a PC to do certain things, as if it were an event (which, I suppose it would be).
Allowing NPCs to attack, and allowing guards to react would both make DMs not have to be around 24/7 for all the little stuff, it would make guards into actual people instead of god killing machines, and it would create a more natural roleplaying environment (one where the mechanics are interlinked with roleplay, instead of creating something artificial like the current state of the guards). Something similiar to Ultima Online, or the like. Guards are tough (especially when they come in groups) but at least beatable. This also opens up new avenues for criminal and chaotic RP. And on top of that, it would give our PW something that no other PW on nwn2 has (an environment that reacts to the player actively).
This also opens up avenues for NPC-RP. An example of this, would be beggars who come up to you begging for money, and attack you if you don't give them any (and take some of your money if they succeed). Case in point, it allows for a far more active environment (the environment should be part of the story that is being told too!) and it would really be something unique (and probably unprecedented? Maybe someone else did it.) in the nwn2 community.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another way, is to allow for PC guards (but no silly PRCs for them. Really, that was a stupid idea). Contrary to popular belief, this does work. Dalelands and Sigil are proof of that (though, we are a "PG-13/Teen" community and they are both "Mature" communities
Heck, we even have our fair share of it still. Candlekeep and Darkhold are both areas where PCs can patrol and arrest in their jurisdictions (not to mention, PCs sometimes bring other PCs to jurisdictions, then PM a DM to help them with the next step). It can work, here, still. Have Bentley hire FAI guards, let players join the flaming fist, let players get involved with the various governments, etc. It'll open up a bunch of new RP avenues and make life a bit more interesting. Creating RP is what we should be all about.
Just, instead of making the mistake of giving PCs a kick ass PRC and an insta-arrest button, don't give them that!
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Power level of a PC
maybe less fun for some, maybe more fun for othersYoung Werther wrote:Would just make the game less fun. More levels, more possibilities, more dreams morelevel 15 or 20 cap
"There was a time when men were kind
When their voices were soft
And their words inviting
There was a time when love was blind
And the world was a song
And the song was exciting
There was a time...
...when it all went wrong."
- ~Fantine, Les Miserables
-
Boddynock
- Posts: 834
- Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am
Re: Power level of a PC
((My emphasis added))Tsidkenu wrote: But that's the impossible balance isn't it, when you've got level 30 Avatars of a Deity FS wandering the wilderness whose players have OOC knowledge that seeps IC that very little can defeat them, especially not some puny level 1 peasant militiaman guarding a gatehouse? So there's a responsibility on players not to RP with that kind of I-Am-God mindset.
There is the little rub I have with what you said. It isn't OOC knowledge when your character can walk alone into a dragon's lair of a Frost Giant's Throne room, kill everything, and walk out alive. That is very very IC knowledge that you are extremely powerful and some nobody militiaman is nothing to you. That's not metagaming, that is using a character's personal experience to influence their actions.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
-
metaquad4
- Posts: 1532
- Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm
Re: Power level of a PC
At the very least, it would make Sigil very popular! As would a 20 level cap.fearknight2003 wrote: A vault wipe would deal with people being bitter about grandfathered items, allow for any economy problems to be fixed, and completely level the playing field. I don't see what's so bad about it.
To many people (myself included), having years of accumulated process just wiped away would essentially be a giant middle finger. And (as seen with Dalelands), servers in dwindling communities don't exactly recover from giant middle fingers.
As for the level cap...it might reduce the numbers but the ratio will still stay the same (the original campaign was level 20, many of us [should] know how to power build for lower levels). There are some serious broken things, even with caps of 10. The balance shifts, but there are under powered and overpowered things. Not to mention, all the servers which have had those kinds of caps have failed (people do like their epic feats, they offer some fun new options and some classes actually fail without them [fighters are even more crippled, warlocks are *#@#ed without them, rogues have severe difficulties without them, etc.]). Even level 10 would be pretty broken. Epic levels actually do work to equalize the classes somewhat in terms of power.
Oh, and don't forget the developers (like our jesus: Rasael). I won't speak for them (I have no idea if they would do this or not), but if a bunch of my work got thrown out I'd be pretty miffed. Their work into the server is something to consider too, not just the player's work.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
-
Atlas
- Posts: 1289
- Joined: Sat May 16, 2009 2:00 pm
-
-
Last edited by Atlas on Tue Jul 17, 2018 6:23 am, edited 1 time in total.
Character Profile and The Battles of Sir Amalric of Germont aka Sir Arkaine Halforken Link:
viewtopic.php?f=153&t=18827&p=836119#p836119
viewtopic.php?f=153&t=18827&p=836119#p836119
-
Kagger911
- Posts: 432
- Joined: Sat Sep 07, 2013 5:57 pm
- Location: USA, Florida
Re: Power level of a PC
Hidden: show
Kagger Redyard
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=kagger
"Finally found where I belong."
Amabiro "Shekels" Shyste
"How can I be of service today?"
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=kagger
"Finally found where I belong."
Amabiro "Shekels" Shyste
"How can I be of service today?"
-
kkrazlite
- Posts: 321
- Joined: Thu Oct 03, 2013 10:25 pm
Re: Power level of a PC
@Atlas
Listen man if you want to achieve Saitama hero status why not just work with the DM team to NPC your character in a way you want him to be? ? ?
Listen man if you want to achieve Saitama hero status why not just work with the DM team to NPC your character in a way you want him to be? ? ?
Royalty? No it was simply an Election.
Player 1 Select Your Character:
Lo' - The Waunderer of Shou Lung
Aeb'el - Lord Cold Circle, Temple of the Great Blizzard
Player 1 Select Your Character:
Lo' - The Waunderer of Shou Lung
Aeb'el - Lord Cold Circle, Temple of the Great Blizzard
-
kkrazlite
- Posts: 321
- Joined: Thu Oct 03, 2013 10:25 pm
Re: Power level of a PC
I have to agree with Kagger here, we did test a lot of the "Beta" versions of mobs for Bloodlust. And i must say the final versions those mobs were DRAMATICALLY reduced to fit party-play strategy and tactics rather then cheesy wins from "One Hit DC Spells" And "Favored Soul Buff Buff BASH!" options. So trust me if you think those mobs were unfair they went through many phases of testing with a 6 man PC testing team. And they all were beatable at their states but required alot more thinking and planning rather then charging straight in and being a "Leeroy Jenkins".Kagger911 wrote:He did that because he was the dead crows Dm. He would summon things that we couldn't kill so I understand how over powering they would be. He would use all the dead crows to test the mobs he made.Hidden: show
Royalty? No it was simply an Election.
Player 1 Select Your Character:
Lo' - The Waunderer of Shou Lung
Aeb'el - Lord Cold Circle, Temple of the Great Blizzard
Player 1 Select Your Character:
Lo' - The Waunderer of Shou Lung
Aeb'el - Lord Cold Circle, Temple of the Great Blizzard