How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

Mallore
Posts: 458
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2016 3:08 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Mallore »

I have always come from the school of thought that dice should only be used in situations where the chance of failure is critical to the story. Though dice are fine for comic relief to, such as you know you are so bad at a skill and want to illustrate it for everyone. I had a great rp with a fellow who had a -2 to diplomacy. He rolled the dice and got a -1 total. Hilliarous to me.


Mundane tasks are not meant to have dc's. After all really your character would just take 10 or 20 on say pitching a tent. Not like she's trying to pitch a tent in a hailstorm while fighting a Naga on the side of a cliff. I prefer things that move the story along rather then bog down with mechanics.


I always enjoy dice less rp.

Though in the end I usually just roll with the fun of others. So if someone gets a kick out of mechanics I'm going to support them as much as someone who wants to go dice less. I can find my rp needs in any style.
Jane of Here and There (Jane Price)

...also

Jennifer and A Drow.
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by aaron22 »

i am not saying that people should roll dice to pitch a tent. it was a point to express difficulty of things relative to the numbers needed to place in a skill. I do not roll to pitch a tent but then again i supply most of my PC's some survival, because it makes sense.

now about what I AM talking about. the skills you want your PC to have should be quantified by a expenditure of your available skill points. They should not have to be rolled because you should RP your PC properly. not make the points suit your desire for a powerful mechanical build but RP a whole different set of skills because that is how you like it best.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

Very interesting comments so far.

About Skills: I would not say that Skills on a Character Sheet represent a thing your PC can do—or cannot do—as much as it represents the investment in being able to do a thing, and succeed.

For a purely mechanical example: encounters will FORCE your Character to make a Tumble check, in certain instances. So even if your PC has no points in tumble, it STILL may succeed or fail (according to the DC). Any Character can turn on the Search toggle, but are they going to find a trap? Maybe...if the DC is low and the Skill Check roll is high. And think! They have no points in Search?!? :shock:

In addition, on a more RP of Character point: a Character may attempt to be Diplomatic, even if they have not a single point in the skill, and depending on the DC the DM determines, it is possible the PC can roll a d20 and succeed. Of course, had they made a study of diplomatic reasoning and such, maybe the Sheet would reflect a 10 pt investment, and thus, depending on the DM's DC, the PC has a much greater chance of success.

Essentially, in Role-play, a Character can do anything they want—except were certain mechanical limits such as only Simple Weapon Feat will not allow a Character to pick up a Battle axe (at least in this Engine)—including take actions that would require Skills—as we have them available to us in NWN2—, however, it is the DC that makes or break the result.

So in this line of thought, to RP your Character Sheet of 33 Lore: Arcana, as being the most knowingest of Mages about the Art, is totally possible...until said Mage fails a DC check setup by either the Engine or the DM. And then, that PC is NO LONGER the knowingest Mage, are they?

And then how does that result, affect the RP of the Character, from that point on?

One other way to say it, is: the fluidity in which our Characters believe they can or cannot do a thing, depends more on the result of Difficulty Challenges we put them through, does it not? And a success this week in swinging over that chasm may make our Character think they are the medieval version of Spiderman, until next week...they slip and fall 30 feet, breaking a leg, and breaking their ego. :twisted:

Carry on! I find it fascinating...especially since, I noticed TheVoid lurking in the viewers section! Beware....

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Deathgrowl
Recognized Donor
Posts: 6604
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2011 6:10 pm
Location: VIKING NORWAY!

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Deathgrowl »

TheLier already nailed this one pretty well.

I would say, however, that it depends a bit on what kind of RP you're trying to go for. For instance, it is vital for my character Nëa to have HiPS, as shadowdancing is such a huge part of her personality. Shadow jump and the ability to summon a shadow also goes with that of course.

Also, as a player of a scholar, having high scores in knowledge skills is important.

Perhaps the question you should be asking is why people don't want to RP low-skill and/or low-power characters?

I'm guessing most want to be a hero (or villain), and you can't be the archetype without being significant in one way or another. Most want to have an expertise. A skill to impress someone with. While people complain about some characters becoming Mary Sues because "they have no flaws", it is also wise to note that while flaws are indeed important for a character to seem real, having certain strengths are just as important.
Laitae Lafreth, became Chosen of Mystra, former Great Reader of Candlekeep
Nëa the Little Shadow
Uranhed Jandinwed, Guide of Candlekeep

Free music:
http://soundcloud.com/progressionmusic/sets/luna
User avatar
LISA100595
Retired Staff
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2011 12:23 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by LISA100595 »

I like flaws, take my turning cleric for instance. Laughable skill points .. well she tells people "My one calling in life the one thing i'm truely good at... that's killing undead. Not much good for anything else." (concidering she doesn't even have enough points to put in HEAL)

Her moto " I'll stop em you drop em ". (It's funny cause it's true) :lol:
Lady Elvina Aira-S'efarro - The Order of the Silver Rose
Nai'KaBael Oakenshadow - EDE former ArchDruidess and Wife and Mate of Mendel
Salaria - Bounty Hunter half-sister of Darius Brothers
Angelina Northstar - Holy Warrior of Tyr / Knight of the Silver Rose
User avatar
Garn Greymoon
Posts: 288
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 12:19 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Garn Greymoon »

aaron22 wrote:
Garn Greymoon wrote:This sort of stuff doesn't thankfully come up very often, at least in my travels. I usually let the RP dictate the direction and if the other player can convince me of their character doing something without a roll - good on ya! Your rping like a pro and have my utmost respect.
So if my zero skill half orc with 6 cha and 6 int tells you the history of kalimshan and convinces you to part with your favorite sword because it would be best for his holy knighthood of orc saints without even a roll then that is good rp? sounds like everyone has done poorly there
I'm talking about believable things. Not so far left field it can't be considered seriously. Of course i'm not going to give a sword to a complete stranger, but if someone tells me they are from XYZ, sure why not i'll give them the benefit of the doubt.

If they tell me something ridiculous "hayz i'm from the 9th circle of hell" i'll ignore them.

Vabo . . . . . Gnome Druid - The Mushroom Man
Dag . . . . . Gnome Bard - The Twang Fury
User avatar
Garn Greymoon
Posts: 288
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 12:19 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Garn Greymoon »

To tack on some stuff:

1. I don't think anyone should be considered the foremost expert in anything, since that really seems like godmoding to me. Unless your full of air and that's the way your character is, by all means.

2. it's ok to say you're knowledgeable about a subject, but even if you botch your roll, that's ok - you may have just not heard about that ONE bit of information.

3. Let's say your in a political situation, sometimes it's best to say you character knows his / her politics even though you may not or express it adequately enough to give that impression, in that case a roll is almost mandatory.

A good example of this is, I've got a character in a PnP game, he's great at history, but I may not know a ton about a specific subject matter, so I just roll the skill and let the GM assume my character knows or doesn't know based upon that outcome.

In any case, I think rolls are great if it really comes to that "do or die" moment where you're upon that precipice or fork in the road where a decision is critical.

Vabo . . . . . Gnome Druid - The Mushroom Man
Dag . . . . . Gnome Bard - The Twang Fury
User avatar
thids
Posts: 1252
Joined: Sat May 25, 2013 11:05 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by thids »

aaron22 wrote:i believe that the things you want your PC to know or have knowledge in should be represented in your sheet.. if you have 0 bluff you should either not try to lie or be quite incapable of doing it properly. with 3-5 being likely the gross average. if you have 0 survival skill skill you should have much difficulty putting up a basic tent. WAY TOO OFTEN do i see people not play their sheet and do what they want instead.
As someone mentioned above, this is a d20 system, everyone gets to roll a d20 unless the skill in question is noted as not usable untrained.

Since you took survival as an example, this is what every single character is capable of with a good enough roll, unless their wisdom modifier is -6 somehow:

Survival DC Task
10 Get along in the wild. Move up to one-half your overland speed while hunting and foraging (no food or water supplies needed). You can provide food and water for one other person for every 2 points by which your check result exceeds 10.
15 Gain a +2 bonus on all Fortitude saves against severe weather while moving up to one-half your overland speed, or gain a +4 bonus if you remain stationary. You may grant the same bonus to one other character for every 1 point by which your Survival check result exceeds 15.
15 Keep from getting lost or avoid natural hazards, such as quicksand.
15 Predict the weather up to 24 hours in advance. For every 5 points by which your Survival check result exceeds 15, you can predict the weather for one additional day in advance.


People very often forget that this IS indeed a d20 system, where the majority of skills are usable without any training. And while skills do and should affect the RP of our characters, it's not nearly as much as we often think they do. Even knowledge (lore) can be used untrained up to common knowledge (DC 10).
Lord Maximilian Blackthorne - retired
Grinning
Posts: 57
Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2015 5:04 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Grinning »

Remember also that take 10/20 is a feature of these kinds of systems that attempts to take into account focus or effort. Pitching a tent is a good example of a mundane action that someone with average intelligence could do given a small amount of time. If you're not confident in your survival skills, you could just take 10/20 and auto-succeed.
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by aaron22 »

how many of you have a embarrassing low amount of points in your social skills. and now you wish to justify this by saying i dont like rolling conversations.. well i dont want to roll tumble when my fat dwarf wants to cross the chasm. if you had penalties that made you look stupid when you failed your bluff or diplomacy check in a conversation. more people would put points into it. or stop trying to do something they are evidently not good at.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
chad878262
Posts: 9332
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:55 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by chad878262 »

while roll's can only be enforced with a DM present, they can make for enjoyable RP. I will generally roll a bluff check for things like 'Why, Jane, we've met before don't you remember?' *jane beats bluff by sense motive* 'well, perhaps it was some other Jane...' Or some such. Rolls can add to the RP, but in general I will only roll something if there is a roll to oppose it, such as bluff / sense motive or sleight of hand/spot (I use it to do magic tricks!) I don't really see the need to roll against a self imposed DC when no DM is present/requested the roll, but nor do I consider it an issue if one of my party mates does roll their own DC's... Live and let play and all that.

Had a really cool RP with Grym and another player a while back with grappling, spell casting, bluff/diplomacy, etc. she'd be a good person on this topic as her RP during that 'off the cuff' interaction was really spot on.
Chord Silverstrings - Bard and OSR Squire / Tarent Nefzen - Arcane Wand Merchant and Master Alchemist / Irrace Arkentlar - Drow Adventurer / Finneaus Du'Veil - Gem Merchant and Executive Officer of SCCE

Tarent's Wands and Elixirs

A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
Mallore
Posts: 458
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2016 3:08 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Mallore »

Garn Greymoon wrote:To tack on some stuff:

1. I don't think anyone should be considered the foremost expert in anything, since that really seems like godmoding to me. Unless your full of air and that's the way your character is, by all means.

2. it's ok to say you're knowledgeable about a subject, but even if you botch your roll, that's ok - you may have just not heard about that ONE bit of information.

3. Let's say your in a political situation, sometimes it's best to say you character knows his / her politics even though you may not or express it adequately enough to give that impression, in that case a roll is almost mandatory.

A good example of this is, I've got a character in a PnP game, he's great at history, but I may not know a ton about a specific subject matter, so I just roll the skill and let the GM assume my character knows or doesn't know based upon that outcome.

In any case, I think rolls are great if it really comes to that "do or die" moment where you're upon that precipice or fork in the road where a decision is critical.

I like everything you have pointed out here


Number 2 has something I like to mention. Sometimes and more often I feel failure to make a roll doesn't mean you screwed up. Failures should be complications as well. In pnp if I was running; a failure could mean you accidentally named king Louie the 12th for the Bastille attack and not the King Louie the 13th. No one but one major npc would catch that.

Sometimes people take dice rolls as all or nothing. I do not see them as pass/fail but rather as complications to the course of action taken. Sorta opens more up to role play and is much closer to playing your sheet. Though sometimes you just do fail. ;)
Jane of Here and There (Jane Price)

...also

Jennifer and A Drow.
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by aaron22 »

if you were in a DM event and he asked for a volunteer to track a sneaky kobold through a winding cave. would you jump to the front of the line with your arch mage with a zero survival skill knowing it is quite unlikely that you will succeed and will look like an a-hole in front of everyone else. if so than your PC wizzy is very overconfident in his abilities or the dumbest smart guy in history.

this is the same thing that should happen when your zero diplomacy PC makes speeches at a campfire about the many dramatic events that occur on the server. it is not only necessary to have skill of knowledge in the subject but be able to know how to deliver these messages.

and to acknowledge the actual out come of the roll. sometimes it is just good to see the +number there to know that the character has the skill even if it did not meet a particular number that you think it should.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
User avatar
Kauaiian
Recognized Donor
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:59 am
Location: Europe

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Kauaiian »

For me, dip classes for benefits without proper RP to back it are more irksome. Non worshipping clerics for example.
User avatar
Flasmix
Posts: 2504
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Flasmix »

arakes99 wrote:If you are a 10 int, non human fighter / paladin / name any other 2 skill point per level class, arguing that without at least 1 rank in this or that skill means your character can't even walk through a forest only goes to highlight limitations and failings of balancing a game like this. Whereas bards/rangers/rogues can be good at everything there is with almost no sacrifice to the main skills they want.

Survival being required to do something like putting up a tent, or bluffing to even attempt to tell a lie seems like a far stretch to me.
Well.... Survival to set up a tent, you're right, it doesn't make sense. Survival to create a lean-to though? Makes sense.

One thing to remember in regards to rolls is you don't always have to roll. There's always the option to take 10 or take 20. Taking 20 merely turns a skill that normally takes one round (6 seconds) and let's you accomplish it after 2 minutes. This is semi-represented with the open lock skill. Most other skills can be used this way as well.

As for bluff... Ugh... I've done rants before on how social skills mean nothing in PC interactions but should, I'm not going to go into too much detail aside from my dislike of seeing characters with 0 or negative bluff telling elaborate lies but without any enforcement of rolls other PCs can only take it at face value. Kudos to those who actually roll though and another kudos to those who don't metagame failing a sense motive but still thinking they're lying.

What I personally do is say for diplomacy, I'll roll before hand and make my response be based on how well I did.

Ex. Low roll: "There's no need for this violence."

High roll: "If we must come to arms we will ruin our chances for success in the future. Hold off for now, let us strike when the moment is right."
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."

Return to “General Discussion”