Why is Necromancy evil?
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
It's not on the same level as animate dead but over a super long period of time it might affect alignment. So technically... Yes. Lol. It's an odd scenario because you can easily counter the effects by doing evil.
Uses protection vs evil to fight orcs (Good adjustment)
Tortures the leaders child in front of him for answers (evil adjustment)
And now we break even
Uses protection vs evil to fight orcs (Good adjustment)
Tortures the leaders child in front of him for answers (evil adjustment)
And now we break even
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Hmmm... in PNP 3.5
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/classes/cleric.htm
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/classes/cleric.htm
A cleric casts divine spells, which are drawn from the cleric spell list. However, his alignment may restrict him from casting certain spells opposed to his moral or ethical beliefs; see Chaotic, Evil, Good, and Lawful Spells, below. A cleric must choose and prepare his spells in advance (see below).
Chaotic, Evil, Good, and Lawful Spells
A cleric can’t cast spells of an alignment opposed to his own or his deity’s (if he has one). Spells associated with particular alignments are indicated by the chaos, evil, good, and law descriptors in their spell descriptions.
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Lol that would be an interesting rule if we enforced it.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
I would donate $100 and offer to permadeath and delete (no rcr) any one character by popular vote to see that happen!Flasmix wrote:Lol that would be an interesting rule if we enforced it.
-
V'rass
- Posts: 1251
- Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2015 1:48 pm
- Location: Concord, N.H., USSA
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Lol the gods say its evil so its evil... who asked them their opinion in the first place, my characters know the gods for what they are, incredibly powerful beings who claim to be gods and immortal but are in fact neither. He serves various gods because they embody similar beliefs to his not because they are gods. Several core books state that the gods did not create the universe at all, they just stole it from the demon's/primordial's and altered it to fit their desires. Stealing is considered an evil act yet the gods of good were perfectly fine with doing so. They are basically hypocrites and liars all of them lol.
"To understand magic one must first understand magic."
Agathion Benedictus: Holy Priest. Retired for now.
Tiax Rules-All: Gnomish madman. Retired permanently.
Exordius Vrass: Cleric/Mage. Currently active.
-
Young Werther
- Posts: 863
- Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 8:42 pm
- Location: Azkaban
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Several spells are already restricted by deity and even alignment. Righteous smite the goodie spell I think is one. Those were implemented in the update-athon. I suppose it makes sense seeing how the deity is the one doing the spell work "on call". I suppose neutral deities would be great for utility while the others might get some powerful effects for their commitment to a particular end of the spectrum.
All in all I don't see anything wrong with the current system of letting people police their own role-play though.
All in all I don't see anything wrong with the current system of letting people police their own role-play though.
Lockonnow wrote:greatest fear like the movie Hellraiser they show you what you most fear and take a Image of IT
-
Aspect of Sorrow
- Custom Content
- Posts: 2702
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 7:11 pm
- Location: Reliquary
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Especially that Leira.V'rass wrote:They are basically hypocrites and liars all of them lol.
-
Moltrazahn
- Posts: 915
- Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:33 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
I think we just found how to nerf Favored souls from that other thread! (and clerics I suppose )Flasmix wrote:Lol that would be an interesting rule if we enforced it.
Za'than Za'amal(Elsewhere!)
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)
Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"
"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)
Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"
"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
-
Moridin
- Retired Staff
- Posts: 582
- Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2012 10:14 pm
- Location: SK, Canada
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Well if that went in suddenly Drow would be defenseless against illithid.
-
Boddynock
- Posts: 834
- Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
This conversation crops up every once and a while and always someone manages to mention this same idea, that "good, evil, law, and chaos are objective ideals" in D&D. This isn't true, has never been true, and in no D&D setting I am familiar with could it even possibly be true.
The reason is two fold. The metagame reason is that good and evil are social constructs that are only defined by the presence of the other. You cannot have good without evil, because they are defined as the opposites of one another.
The second reason, with lore supporting it, has been touched on in this thread. What is good in D&D is defined by what the gods say are good. But the gods are not actually infallible, they are really just very powerful beings with personalities like mortals have. They make mistakes, change their minds, die, etc. For good and evil to be objective then the sames things that are good would be good regardless of what any deities had to say about it, but that isn't true. AS long as alignments are dictated by religions that follow fallible deities, alignment will be subject to a change in perspective of those deities views. If it is subject to change based on something simply changing it's mind, it is not objective. Objective thing simply are, or are not, regardless of what anyone or anything thinks about it.
Consider the Dawn Cataclysm, basically a coup staged by Lathander in which he killed (or caused the death of) another deity (Murdane, goddess of pragmatism and reason) for disagreeing with his ideas of idealism. That makes Lathander a traitor and a rebel, guilty of who knows what list of crimes (as we has literally trying to take control of the entire pantheon and reshape it in his image) against Ao, and he still isn't evil, despite commiting "evil" acts.
People also frequently mention that intent doesn't matter in D&D. Yes it does, and once again it always has, and there is no setting where it hasn't. There is a reason that paladins are specifically forbidden from KNOWINGLY committing evil acts, not accidentally, see the class description excerpt on ex-paladins: "A paladin who ceases to be lawful good, who willfully commits an evil act, or who grossly violates the code of conduct." See how it says willfully, as in he or she intended to do evil. Intent is equally important, if not more so in most situations.
The reason is two fold. The metagame reason is that good and evil are social constructs that are only defined by the presence of the other. You cannot have good without evil, because they are defined as the opposites of one another.
The second reason, with lore supporting it, has been touched on in this thread. What is good in D&D is defined by what the gods say are good. But the gods are not actually infallible, they are really just very powerful beings with personalities like mortals have. They make mistakes, change their minds, die, etc. For good and evil to be objective then the sames things that are good would be good regardless of what any deities had to say about it, but that isn't true. AS long as alignments are dictated by religions that follow fallible deities, alignment will be subject to a change in perspective of those deities views. If it is subject to change based on something simply changing it's mind, it is not objective. Objective thing simply are, or are not, regardless of what anyone or anything thinks about it.
Consider the Dawn Cataclysm, basically a coup staged by Lathander in which he killed (or caused the death of) another deity (Murdane, goddess of pragmatism and reason) for disagreeing with his ideas of idealism. That makes Lathander a traitor and a rebel, guilty of who knows what list of crimes (as we has literally trying to take control of the entire pantheon and reshape it in his image) against Ao, and he still isn't evil, despite commiting "evil" acts.
People also frequently mention that intent doesn't matter in D&D. Yes it does, and once again it always has, and there is no setting where it hasn't. There is a reason that paladins are specifically forbidden from KNOWINGLY committing evil acts, not accidentally, see the class description excerpt on ex-paladins: "A paladin who ceases to be lawful good, who willfully commits an evil act, or who grossly violates the code of conduct." See how it says willfully, as in he or she intended to do evil. Intent is equally important, if not more so in most situations.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
mindblank (and a few other spells) would still work.Moridin wrote:Well if that went in suddenly Drow would be defenseless against illithid.
-
Deathgrowl
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 6604
- Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2011 6:10 pm
- Location: VIKING NORWAY!
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
TheLier and I had an IC discussion (Red Wizard and sun elf wizard!) about the IC nature of good and evil. It was entertaining!
You can look at it through a lens of planar cosmology. You have the great wheel cosmology, for instance, where there are planes that are placed in order of whether they are inherently good or evil, lawful or chaotic. They have varying degrees of good, evil, law and chaos, even. And creatures are affected by these traits when they are on the various planes.
So what is evil? Well, it is the set of values and actions associated with the hells, gehenna, pandemonium, the abyss and so on (but not the Plane of Negative Energy - this is a common misconception). What is good? The set of values associated with the opposite planes, such as Celestia, Arvandor, Bytopia and Elysium. You can do the same for law and chaos. These are objective values. Whether you label them "good" and "evil" or "automobiles" and "huba huba dance carrots" doesn't matter. They're just words describing sets of values.
How would you otherwise explain IC how the spells "protection against evil" or "protection against good" work?
You can look at it through a lens of planar cosmology. You have the great wheel cosmology, for instance, where there are planes that are placed in order of whether they are inherently good or evil, lawful or chaotic. They have varying degrees of good, evil, law and chaos, even. And creatures are affected by these traits when they are on the various planes.
So what is evil? Well, it is the set of values and actions associated with the hells, gehenna, pandemonium, the abyss and so on (but not the Plane of Negative Energy - this is a common misconception). What is good? The set of values associated with the opposite planes, such as Celestia, Arvandor, Bytopia and Elysium. You can do the same for law and chaos. These are objective values. Whether you label them "good" and "evil" or "automobiles" and "huba huba dance carrots" doesn't matter. They're just words describing sets of values.
How would you otherwise explain IC how the spells "protection against evil" or "protection against good" work?
Laitae Lafreth, became Chosen of Mystra, former Great Reader of Candlekeep
Nëa the Little Shadow
Uranhed Jandinwed, Guide of Candlekeep
Free music:
http://soundcloud.com/progressionmusic/sets/luna
Nëa the Little Shadow
Uranhed Jandinwed, Guide of Candlekeep
Free music:
http://soundcloud.com/progressionmusic/sets/luna
-
Boddynock
- Posts: 834
- Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Well, except that those values and actions are associated with the inhabitants of the plane, not the plane itself; and it is those inhabitants that define them as good. The planes don't do anything but exist, they have no opinions regarding values and take no actions. And since all of the outer planes are divinely morphic, it is highly likely that the environment being favorable to a certain type of being is simply a response to a long period of habitation by a certain type of being causing the plane to morph.Deathgrowl wrote:
So what is evil? Well, it is the set of values and actions associated with the hells, gehenna, pandemonium, the abyss and so on (but not the Plane of Negative Energy - this is a common misconception). What is good? The set of values associated with the opposite planes, such as Celestia, Arvandor, Bytopia and Elysium. You can do the same for law and chaos. These are objective values. Whether you label them "good" and "evil" or "automobiles" and "huba huba dance carrots" doesn't matter. They're just words describing sets of values.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
-
Arn
- Posts: 906
- Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2012 7:44 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Yes, I follow and agree so far.Boddynock wrote:What is good in D&D is defined by what the gods say are good. But the gods are not actually infallible, they are really just very powerful beings with personalities like mortals have. They make mistakes, change their minds, die, etc. For good and evil to be objective then the sames things that are good would be good regardless of what any deities had to say about it, but that isn't true. AS long as alignments are dictated by religions that follow fallible deities, alignment will be subject to a change in perspective of those deities views. If it is subject to change based on something simply changing it's mind, it is not objective. Objective thing simply are, or are not, regardless of what anyone or anything thinks about it.
That makes sense. But as you mentioned later in your post, maybe intention matters here?Boddynock wrote:Consider the Dawn Cataclysm, basically a coup staged by Lathander in which he killed (or caused the death of) another deity (Murdane, goddess of pragmatism and reason) for disagreeing with his ideas of idealism. That makes Lathander a traitor and a rebel, guilty of who knows what list of crimes (as we has literally trying to take control of the entire pantheon and reshape it in his image) against Ao, and he still isn't evil, despite commiting "evil" acts.
What do you think of selfish intention vs. selfless intention as an objective metric?Boddynock wrote:People also frequently mention that intent doesn't matter in D&D. Yes it does, and once again it always has, and there is no setting where it hasn't.
You could then argue that the Dawn Cataclysm was fueled by selfish intent, insofar as it was a vain and arrogant action. But maybe Lathander still gets to be called "Good" because his overall intent was generally to benefit the world instead of himself.
My quibble with that is that values are generally subjective and change over time and different societies. Boddynock brought up a good point with the Dawn Cataclysm. If "Evil" is simply a set of fixed values and actions, then why weren't Lathander's actions during the Dawn Cataclysm considered "Evil"?Deathgrowl wrote:Whether you label them "good" and "evil" or "automobiles" and "huba huba dance carrots" doesn't matter. They're just words describing sets of values.
But I think maybe if you use selfish/selfless as a metric, it might work. Whether an act is intended to benefit the actor or intended to benefit others is (arguably) objectively measurable.
Mi-Le (彌勒) - "Meditate, monks. Do not be negligent, lest you regret it later." ((-Saṃyutta Nikāya 35.146))
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-
Boddynock
- Posts: 834
- Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Perhaps, but in my opinion that is an over complication. Yes his intent matters, or would if he were not a deity. But the simpler explanation is that he remains good because he espouses beliefs that are primarily the opposite of what is considered "evil." The fact is, that even with the "selfish vs. selfless" metric, you still use one to define the other, and so they aren't objective. Something is selfless if it is intended only to benefit others, selfishness is acting to benefit solely oneself. The are opposites, and in the absence of selfishness, no one would be considered selfless, they would just be normal.Arn wrote: What do you think of selfish intention vs. selfless intention as an objective metric?
You could then argue that the Dawn Cataclysm was fueled by selfish intent, insofar as it was a vain and arrogant action. But maybe Lathander still gets to be called "Good" because his overall intent was generally to benefit the world instead of himself.
Any time something has a polar opposite that, once removed, changes how we view the remaining thing, it cannot be objective; it is always subject to the other things existence to help define it. This holds true even with things that appear, on the surface, to be totally objective. Take up and down, for example. They are opposites of one another, but if you remove down, up no longer holds value as a descriptor. There is no up or down in space, for example, there is simply one direction versus another.
If the definition of a thing is dependent on the existence of another thing to help define it's value as a descriptor, then it is not, by definition, objective. There is no hot without cold, no dark without light, no law without chaos, and no good without evil.
You explain it by explaining that this is a game that needs rules to function. As to how the magic works, that is not explained, and therefore doesn't shed much light on the nature of alignments. The spells works the way the rules say because the rules say it does, they offer nothing about the why of it, just the how.Deathgrowl wrote:How would you otherwise explain IC how the spells "protection against evil" or "protection against good" work?
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016