Re: Linela Susan Fryar
Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2018 5:33 am
Linela began keeping a journal. She had been unable to hold her tongue twice now. Her current situation... The likely end of her life and the damnation of her soul was looming. She wanted a record of it all. All her investigations and thoughts on it. She felt certain that her defense of Bran would invite wrath any day.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
When Bran told me of the horrible things the Radiant Heart had done... Of Kald especially, I took it for a grain of salt. Sure, I wanted to believe him... We were becoming friends, but I knew better than to trust one man's witness. Then I met Arkaine.
On the beach by Candlekeep Arkaine and Bran spoke. Bran seemed reluctant and first to give the information Arkaine asked for. Eventaully, Bran gave it, and cast many wards upon Arkaine when the half-orc proclaimed that there would be justice.
I have few accounts of where Arkaine took it from there... Given the after events... I can only assume he took things very... Very far...
Before the incident on the Tradeway, right outside of the Friendly Arm, I began to ask around. I began to accumulate very different accounts of what happened with the man named "Serb". The perception of events seemed to be almost wholly different depending on who you spoke to. Events were jumbled at out of order. As best I could tell... Bran was telling the truth of how much was known to him. But that does not make it the actual truth.
A person's perception becomes their reality. I thought on gentle ways to nudge people toward the truth, not just because I think that seeing yourself and others in a truthful light is important, but because all these people on the Coast... They want to kill each other. Now that Bran is speaking his truth and stirring things up. He is an apt target for their wrath.
He was wrong though. His truth does not match the real truth so far as I can see it. I used my invisibility spells to listen to people. Sometimes I merely walked slowly by a fire or started a conversation and let other people talk. I collected stories that said Arkaine lost his mind, attacking his own men. Some that a woman name Erza betrayed the Radiant Heart and brought in Serb, with Kald and with offer of unlawful sanctuary after he tortured a woman named Sharra. I have searched for this woman to get her account to no avail.
Serb apparently dated the Guide of Candlekeep, Alexandra? Wow... That woman had shown very little taste in men since as well. I have an entire file of asking around on her next engagement; Cosimo... But that is for another time and needs more investigation. Calad, her current man seems extremely gruff, but perhaps it is an act?
I hadn't gotten at most of the truth yet when Bran, then Corvin, encountered Kald. Kald was entrenched with 5 or so friends, including Thedran, outside and to the left of the gate of the Friendly Arm. I still do not know why the Guards did not react to the fighting. Piecing together a coherant story from those events was harder still. I did find a halfling, who claimed to speak to two direct witnesses. I also found a Tiefling who hid in the shadows, witnessed the events and eventually dug up Bran. She didn't tell me she had done it... But Bran did.
I hung around the fires and collected bits of Kald's, and Rania's account. As I merely passed behind them and got only pieces, so I don't have their full account. I will say I have heard Rania speak of it three times now and her witness has changed over time. In Sembia, we have studied this. A witness changes over time as co-witnesses speak to each other. They convince each other of their own perceptions of the truth, creating often a whole new truth that is no nearer the truth than one person's perception to begin with. That is why it is important to speak to witnesses alone and immediately after an event. I doubt much good will come of taking a full account from them now. I doubt they would give it if I asked.
I spoke to a man I trust about the direct witness of one of his students, who was very upset by what she saw. Emotion can be clouding too, but I will say that she has never stopped speaking of what she saw. I have heard her account from multiple sources now. Huego has spoken to her recently directly as well, and her account has not changed over time, which is actually abnormal. It does show great dedication to telling it exactly as she saw it. I wish I could speak to her directly.
From these accounts, this is the best that I can piece together...
Corvin was walking toward the arm and encountered Kald and his band of friends. Already somewhat upset and talking about Arkaine and his outbursts at the Chapterhouse, Thedran and Kald made a some passing harassing comments to Bran. Bran, who believed them evil and bloodthirsty and unrighteous, drew his blade.
Drawing a blade is as much a declaration of the desire to fight as any words. He called Kald and Thedran more cutting things, he pointed his blade at Kald. He told Kald that Kald was a coward, still hiding behind groups of thugs and stronger men. Kald ushered the group aside and said he would "handle this".
Bran was wrong in his perception of the events and Kald's accountability on Serb. I can find little to refute Bran's description of Thedran as a thug however... I did find an account of Thedran pulling the members of the Northern Watch from a watery grave after they were attacked by drow, so he may require further investigation. Kald is certainly self-righteous... But I do not believe him to be a fallen paladin. Regardless, Bran was wrong to draw his blade and unwise to sling insults at a mob. You should not give a group of emotionally elevated people an excuse to attack you. He should have run or teleported away. He had to have known he was gravely outnumbered.
Kald challenged Bran to single combat. Bran used only natural shamanistic spells to fight him. He unintentionally tripped multiple members of Kald's group with the spell "Whirlpool". I think most people understand the spell has a wide area of effect and no one was actually hurt by it.
The fight was intense, accounts vary, but until recently no one claimed he used any ill tactics in his fight with Kald. Nor did Kald attempt any ill tactics or ask for aid. It was an honorable duel.
Recently accounts have been changing. This is a function of time and of people's desire to be right and justified. I can only trust the accounts I collected immediately after at this point.
The accounts of what happened next vary. I have heard from one person that Bran insulted and threatened Thedran, but most witnesses seem to agree that was before the challenge of single combat. Most witness accounts are that Kald was beaten but left alive by Bran, but as Bran began to move along, Thedran jumped him.
This, seems to be widely accepted as a violation of the code of honor in single combat. I would not condemn Kald for the actions of his over zealous friend except that he was overheard many times after saying that what Thedran did was okay because Bran had no honor and thus no right to expect the rules of single combat to apply. He seemed to imply that is was okay to lie to Bran, to dishonor the codes of conduct because of who Bran was.
It still twists my stomach. Your word does not have value because of who you keep it to. Your word has value because you keep it.
The battle with Thedran did not go as well for Bran. He was already exhausted from his fight with Kald, and most of his offensive spells were spent. Bran is, by his own admission, a fallen shaman. He left that note on the Halls of Inner Light for all the world to see... Signed a fallen shaman... As such he does know the fell spell, Vampiric Feast.
Already exhausted, bleeding, and without other places to turn. Bran used the last resort left him and called upon the awful necromantic spell... It did not save him, however, and gave the angry mob all they needed to justify themselves. Bran left Kald breathing... Thedran was not so kind.
They also spoke of him using blood magic and finding several vials of blood on him. It takes a good deal of questioning to get at the truth that all the blood on him was animal blood, not human. It is no less macabre however, for a person that may not understand his rituals to consider him walking around with vials of animal blood on him.
Kald and the rest left for the chapterhouse. Their self-righteous and condeming behavior seemed to cool considerably and excuses began when Lord "Shinybritches" showed up. The Lord required that Bran's remains be covered. It was claimed by a few witnesses that rather than teleport Bran to the chapterhouse, his remains were then marched miles, slung unceremoniously over Thedran's shoulder. Also that Thedran made comments about desecrating the remains and placing Bran's head on a pike outside the chapterhouse.
The accounts of two witnesses then say his body was plundered, and dumped in a shallow grave without ceremony or care. One of the witnesses found the grave and accounted that it "required very little digging to pull him out". The other found the empty grave and stated that it was a "Shallow and careless hole".
For burring him in an unmarked grave in the forest to "hopefully be sure he is not found and brought back by his followers" they did not take care in it. The first to his grave said it was not difficult to follow them even without the shadows to veil her. They were loud and boastful, traveling in a large, well-armored group. The second said the clumsy tracks of the large group as much as pointed and arrow to the swallow grave.
Of these two witnesses, I am not sure I trust the testimony of the one, and the other is a second-hand account of the witness' testimony. While the account is from a person I trust... It is second hand and I have not been able to track the direct witness down. It is a pity... As this woman seems honorable in all accounts I have found of her.
I am sure that is not the whole story. It is hard to get at the real events as the story continues to change at this point. I believe it is as close to the truth as can be managed at this point.
A bunch of people... Married to their perception of reality. Bran himself is not excluded in this. He makes himself easy to hate and has committed so much to his perception of reality that he will eventually fall into the abyss for it.
I got back to digging at my Serb investigation, and finally struck dirt when someone admitted that they were not there when "Arkaine went berserk" but Derik Ranloss was. I trust Derik... He is one of the few people on the Coast I do trust to be fair and consistent about what he sees. He told me the account of Arkaine's attack on members of his own chapterhouse. He said Erza had brought Serb. He made no mention of Kald. Even Erza had brought him on honorable promise of safety to the Chapterhouse because Serb claimed to have information on the Enclave that might save lives.
Once a promise of safety for witness is given, in can only be honored. Even if you doubt the witness, and even if you disagree with the offer. The honrable thing to do would have been to dismiss him and admonish any further dealings with him. Again, it is a matter of honoring the word given, not because of who it was given to... But that it was given in the first place.
Seems that more than one member of the Radiant Heart had problems with this concept.
Of course, a paladin's zeal might justify many things to themselves.
On speaking to Derik, I can only deem the actions of Arkaine dishonorable. Derik saw to the release of Serb, who Derik then admitted tried to kill one of the Chapterhouse members that fought Arkaine to free him. Derik stopped this as well, sighting that he had seen to the upholding of honor here, but Serb was delivered from the chapterhouse and beyond his promise of safety. He instructed Serb to leave now, or expect that Derik himself would execute him.
These truths would likely destroy Bran... As Arkaine was one the only paladin on the coast for which he had any respect. He had refused to believe stories of Arkaine going berserk and attacking his own men... While I believe those accounts are over-dramatized... They are not wholly false.
=======================================================
She sighed and put down her pen for now. She stared up at the ceiling. Bran was by his own admission a fallen shaman. He would eventually do something indefensible...
But for now there was still hope for everyone but her. If she could just get them all to see. tears spilled out of the corners of her eyes as she stared upwards. She felt the hopelessness of this sinking into her chest. She had already encountered how set people were on hating Bran. He was set on hating them right back.
Here she was in the middle... She couldn't help feeling hated by everyone because she was the only one saying...
You're both wrong.
She at least wanted it to be true that when Bran was brought down for some fell deed that he actually deserved it. That seemed less... and less possible.
She should probably stop letting Derik or Huego associate themselves with her... For their own good... But the idea of being all alone again...
Back behind the glass...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OOC Note: I know some of the events are not wholly correct as described here. I had characters present for Serb and other events and have diligently upheld that Linela does not know what they know and cannot question my other characters. Therefore, I cannot "fix" her view of events without meta-gaming. I hope that can be respected that this is the truth as best as she can suss it out with appropriate RP.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
When Bran told me of the horrible things the Radiant Heart had done... Of Kald especially, I took it for a grain of salt. Sure, I wanted to believe him... We were becoming friends, but I knew better than to trust one man's witness. Then I met Arkaine.
On the beach by Candlekeep Arkaine and Bran spoke. Bran seemed reluctant and first to give the information Arkaine asked for. Eventaully, Bran gave it, and cast many wards upon Arkaine when the half-orc proclaimed that there would be justice.
I have few accounts of where Arkaine took it from there... Given the after events... I can only assume he took things very... Very far...
Before the incident on the Tradeway, right outside of the Friendly Arm, I began to ask around. I began to accumulate very different accounts of what happened with the man named "Serb". The perception of events seemed to be almost wholly different depending on who you spoke to. Events were jumbled at out of order. As best I could tell... Bran was telling the truth of how much was known to him. But that does not make it the actual truth.
A person's perception becomes their reality. I thought on gentle ways to nudge people toward the truth, not just because I think that seeing yourself and others in a truthful light is important, but because all these people on the Coast... They want to kill each other. Now that Bran is speaking his truth and stirring things up. He is an apt target for their wrath.
He was wrong though. His truth does not match the real truth so far as I can see it. I used my invisibility spells to listen to people. Sometimes I merely walked slowly by a fire or started a conversation and let other people talk. I collected stories that said Arkaine lost his mind, attacking his own men. Some that a woman name Erza betrayed the Radiant Heart and brought in Serb, with Kald and with offer of unlawful sanctuary after he tortured a woman named Sharra. I have searched for this woman to get her account to no avail.
Serb apparently dated the Guide of Candlekeep, Alexandra? Wow... That woman had shown very little taste in men since as well. I have an entire file of asking around on her next engagement; Cosimo... But that is for another time and needs more investigation. Calad, her current man seems extremely gruff, but perhaps it is an act?
I hadn't gotten at most of the truth yet when Bran, then Corvin, encountered Kald. Kald was entrenched with 5 or so friends, including Thedran, outside and to the left of the gate of the Friendly Arm. I still do not know why the Guards did not react to the fighting. Piecing together a coherant story from those events was harder still. I did find a halfling, who claimed to speak to two direct witnesses. I also found a Tiefling who hid in the shadows, witnessed the events and eventually dug up Bran. She didn't tell me she had done it... But Bran did.
I hung around the fires and collected bits of Kald's, and Rania's account. As I merely passed behind them and got only pieces, so I don't have their full account. I will say I have heard Rania speak of it three times now and her witness has changed over time. In Sembia, we have studied this. A witness changes over time as co-witnesses speak to each other. They convince each other of their own perceptions of the truth, creating often a whole new truth that is no nearer the truth than one person's perception to begin with. That is why it is important to speak to witnesses alone and immediately after an event. I doubt much good will come of taking a full account from them now. I doubt they would give it if I asked.
I spoke to a man I trust about the direct witness of one of his students, who was very upset by what she saw. Emotion can be clouding too, but I will say that she has never stopped speaking of what she saw. I have heard her account from multiple sources now. Huego has spoken to her recently directly as well, and her account has not changed over time, which is actually abnormal. It does show great dedication to telling it exactly as she saw it. I wish I could speak to her directly.
From these accounts, this is the best that I can piece together...
Corvin was walking toward the arm and encountered Kald and his band of friends. Already somewhat upset and talking about Arkaine and his outbursts at the Chapterhouse, Thedran and Kald made a some passing harassing comments to Bran. Bran, who believed them evil and bloodthirsty and unrighteous, drew his blade.
Drawing a blade is as much a declaration of the desire to fight as any words. He called Kald and Thedran more cutting things, he pointed his blade at Kald. He told Kald that Kald was a coward, still hiding behind groups of thugs and stronger men. Kald ushered the group aside and said he would "handle this".
Bran was wrong in his perception of the events and Kald's accountability on Serb. I can find little to refute Bran's description of Thedran as a thug however... I did find an account of Thedran pulling the members of the Northern Watch from a watery grave after they were attacked by drow, so he may require further investigation. Kald is certainly self-righteous... But I do not believe him to be a fallen paladin. Regardless, Bran was wrong to draw his blade and unwise to sling insults at a mob. You should not give a group of emotionally elevated people an excuse to attack you. He should have run or teleported away. He had to have known he was gravely outnumbered.
Kald challenged Bran to single combat. Bran used only natural shamanistic spells to fight him. He unintentionally tripped multiple members of Kald's group with the spell "Whirlpool". I think most people understand the spell has a wide area of effect and no one was actually hurt by it.
The fight was intense, accounts vary, but until recently no one claimed he used any ill tactics in his fight with Kald. Nor did Kald attempt any ill tactics or ask for aid. It was an honorable duel.
Recently accounts have been changing. This is a function of time and of people's desire to be right and justified. I can only trust the accounts I collected immediately after at this point.
The accounts of what happened next vary. I have heard from one person that Bran insulted and threatened Thedran, but most witnesses seem to agree that was before the challenge of single combat. Most witness accounts are that Kald was beaten but left alive by Bran, but as Bran began to move along, Thedran jumped him.
This, seems to be widely accepted as a violation of the code of honor in single combat. I would not condemn Kald for the actions of his over zealous friend except that he was overheard many times after saying that what Thedran did was okay because Bran had no honor and thus no right to expect the rules of single combat to apply. He seemed to imply that is was okay to lie to Bran, to dishonor the codes of conduct because of who Bran was.
It still twists my stomach. Your word does not have value because of who you keep it to. Your word has value because you keep it.
The battle with Thedran did not go as well for Bran. He was already exhausted from his fight with Kald, and most of his offensive spells were spent. Bran is, by his own admission, a fallen shaman. He left that note on the Halls of Inner Light for all the world to see... Signed a fallen shaman... As such he does know the fell spell, Vampiric Feast.
Already exhausted, bleeding, and without other places to turn. Bran used the last resort left him and called upon the awful necromantic spell... It did not save him, however, and gave the angry mob all they needed to justify themselves. Bran left Kald breathing... Thedran was not so kind.
They also spoke of him using blood magic and finding several vials of blood on him. It takes a good deal of questioning to get at the truth that all the blood on him was animal blood, not human. It is no less macabre however, for a person that may not understand his rituals to consider him walking around with vials of animal blood on him.
Kald and the rest left for the chapterhouse. Their self-righteous and condeming behavior seemed to cool considerably and excuses began when Lord "Shinybritches" showed up. The Lord required that Bran's remains be covered. It was claimed by a few witnesses that rather than teleport Bran to the chapterhouse, his remains were then marched miles, slung unceremoniously over Thedran's shoulder. Also that Thedran made comments about desecrating the remains and placing Bran's head on a pike outside the chapterhouse.
The accounts of two witnesses then say his body was plundered, and dumped in a shallow grave without ceremony or care. One of the witnesses found the grave and accounted that it "required very little digging to pull him out". The other found the empty grave and stated that it was a "Shallow and careless hole".
For burring him in an unmarked grave in the forest to "hopefully be sure he is not found and brought back by his followers" they did not take care in it. The first to his grave said it was not difficult to follow them even without the shadows to veil her. They were loud and boastful, traveling in a large, well-armored group. The second said the clumsy tracks of the large group as much as pointed and arrow to the swallow grave.
Of these two witnesses, I am not sure I trust the testimony of the one, and the other is a second-hand account of the witness' testimony. While the account is from a person I trust... It is second hand and I have not been able to track the direct witness down. It is a pity... As this woman seems honorable in all accounts I have found of her.
I am sure that is not the whole story. It is hard to get at the real events as the story continues to change at this point. I believe it is as close to the truth as can be managed at this point.
A bunch of people... Married to their perception of reality. Bran himself is not excluded in this. He makes himself easy to hate and has committed so much to his perception of reality that he will eventually fall into the abyss for it.
I got back to digging at my Serb investigation, and finally struck dirt when someone admitted that they were not there when "Arkaine went berserk" but Derik Ranloss was. I trust Derik... He is one of the few people on the Coast I do trust to be fair and consistent about what he sees. He told me the account of Arkaine's attack on members of his own chapterhouse. He said Erza had brought Serb. He made no mention of Kald. Even Erza had brought him on honorable promise of safety to the Chapterhouse because Serb claimed to have information on the Enclave that might save lives.
Once a promise of safety for witness is given, in can only be honored. Even if you doubt the witness, and even if you disagree with the offer. The honrable thing to do would have been to dismiss him and admonish any further dealings with him. Again, it is a matter of honoring the word given, not because of who it was given to... But that it was given in the first place.
Seems that more than one member of the Radiant Heart had problems with this concept.
Of course, a paladin's zeal might justify many things to themselves.
On speaking to Derik, I can only deem the actions of Arkaine dishonorable. Derik saw to the release of Serb, who Derik then admitted tried to kill one of the Chapterhouse members that fought Arkaine to free him. Derik stopped this as well, sighting that he had seen to the upholding of honor here, but Serb was delivered from the chapterhouse and beyond his promise of safety. He instructed Serb to leave now, or expect that Derik himself would execute him.
These truths would likely destroy Bran... As Arkaine was one the only paladin on the coast for which he had any respect. He had refused to believe stories of Arkaine going berserk and attacking his own men... While I believe those accounts are over-dramatized... They are not wholly false.
=======================================================
She sighed and put down her pen for now. She stared up at the ceiling. Bran was by his own admission a fallen shaman. He would eventually do something indefensible...
But for now there was still hope for everyone but her. If she could just get them all to see. tears spilled out of the corners of her eyes as she stared upwards. She felt the hopelessness of this sinking into her chest. She had already encountered how set people were on hating Bran. He was set on hating them right back.
Here she was in the middle... She couldn't help feeling hated by everyone because she was the only one saying...
You're both wrong.
She at least wanted it to be true that when Bran was brought down for some fell deed that he actually deserved it. That seemed less... and less possible.
She should probably stop letting Derik or Huego associate themselves with her... For their own good... But the idea of being all alone again...
Back behind the glass...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OOC Note: I know some of the events are not wholly correct as described here. I had characters present for Serb and other events and have diligently upheld that Linela does not know what they know and cannot question my other characters. Therefore, I cannot "fix" her view of events without meta-gaming. I hope that can be respected that this is the truth as best as she can suss it out with appropriate RP.
