UD/Surface Rules
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
V'rass
- Posts: 1251
- Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2015 1:48 pm
- Location: Concord, N.H., USSA
Re: UD/Surface Rules
One should always go spell penetration regardless of caster class... without at least two of the spell-penetration feats you will fail almost every time against high lv pve and pvp. It is a must take feat group imo.
"To understand magic one must first understand magic."
Agathion Benedictus: Holy Priest. Retired for now.
Tiax Rules-All: Gnomish madman. Retired permanently.
Exordius Vrass: Cleric/Mage. Currently active.
-
fearknight2003
- Posts: 354
- Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 8:53 pm
Re: UD/Surface Rules
My point was that drow aren't really overpowered.V'rass wrote:One should always go spell penetration regardless of caster class... without at least two of the spell-penetration feats you will fail almost every time against high lv pve and pvp. It is a must take feat group imo.
It was a fun year (I think). Bye.
-
Zanniej
- Posts: 2454
- Joined: Sat Jan 11, 2014 11:28 am
- Location: The dark parts of the forum
Re: UD/Surface Rules
Please keep this on topic. This post is about UD/Surface travel and rules. Not about which race has more power. Though feel free to open a new topic about that, if you wish to discuss it. (or take it to PMs)
Thank you.
Thank you.
Off to greener pastures
-
Israe
- Posts: 431
- Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2012 3:22 pm
Re: UD/Surface Rules
I've been making interactions eventful for a while, taking PC slaves for 24 to 48 hours would be nice. You can create good to opportunities and rivalry.fearknight2003 wrote:Drow spell resistance and ability scores aren't that big a deal. A 30th level surfacer will still easily stomp a 22nd level drow. Two 30th level surface people, if they aren't taken by surprise with a bad sneak attack, can take down a 30th level drow. Most wizards go Spell Penetration anyways.Lyrae wrote:xLegionx wrote: Yeah seeing this every evil player I've encountered so far wants to run around with their super op mechanically based evil character and take pleasure in trying to destroy every rp based good character they run across. Most of all, people want their precious evil drow on the surface so that they can make use of their op spell resistance, high ability bonuses, and extra drow abilities that they get to stomp every surfacer that gets in their way. I've yet to see an evil character that actually turns their evil character into a creative and memorable villain as opposed to an evil character that runs around trying to wreak havoc where they can.
Lol.. Guess you've never run into any of my characters then..
I would personally like neutral grounds. Like hunting areas where encounters would be more frequent. I remember running the nethereze to return a prisoner before the surface faction would fight us for it, and as we entered the surface side there was a small warband on that side. My wonderful drop partner without a word invisibled out and ran, and there I was facing off with 10+ surfacers. I wasn't rested enough to make it back, and no tricks up my sleeve so with a huge grudge I surrendered. I found myself a prisoner to Thedran for 72hours, humiliated in character. I returned and my character fears him to this day.
So encounters can be positive, conflict can be an amazing rp experience, and pvp can't be the focus of it. I rarely kill someone, and usually leave a witness if I do. It leaves rp to follow up on. I request to capture players legally for 72 hours as a slave, compete for epic areas, and see conflict again. The cross realm player just needs to be responsible and remember it's about rp, not pvp. Leave a low level with a story if they want to clash. I've ran from 5 low levels due to numbers. Killing 5 players instead of just one ruins an experience.
Permenant scars, injuries, imprisonment time, and being robbed of gold or supplies would be a decent punishment for losing cross realm. A banishment time from going back. I believe a cross realm player should forfeit the ability to deny any rough role play, capture, or imprisonment.
Maybe drop should be application only. I also feel many drow feel dm's are against them. A responsible approach to conflict rp is needed by all parties involved, and consequences or consideration. I miss the days of kicking the crap out of surfaces in the UD because of their mouths, and robbing them dry. Now cross realm interactions approached with fear of ooc punishment or hassle for either side so most seem to just avoid it
-
Lyrae
- Posts: 48
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2015 5:10 pm
Re: UD/Surface Rules
Currently, the way I see it.. If you play in the UD, you are just playing a single player version of bgtscc.. Now that's fine, but after a certain extent you start to crave some interaction with others. It shouldn't be such a big deal for drow to run up to the surface. When we do, we accept the risks and consequences. (sometimes whenever I run up, I get a tell saying that there is an army after me..)
UD gets so boring, we need:
More Dm events (thanks echo for making an attempt at this)
Dm support
More players
Perhaps having more of those will create less travel opportunities?
UD gets so boring, we need:
More Dm events (thanks echo for making an attempt at this)
Dm support
More players
Perhaps having more of those will create less travel opportunities?
-
Mordael
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2016 10:36 pm
Re: UD/Surface Rules
Speaking as a new player (to the server, to NWN2, and D&D 3.5), the Underdark is boring as crap. There's almost nothing a new player can do other than grind because there are so few other players, that RPing becomes a chore, and only two easily done quests. I have practically abandoned my first character for my surface one, because the surface has more of everything it feels like. More accessibility, more help for new players, more DMs, more players and most importantly, doesn't feel so lonely. I have tried a few times to play in the UD again, but, it feels... shallow. What is the point of being in the Underdark if nothing and no one is there?
So, people wanting to go above ground to RP and hunt is bound to happen. Boredom and playing as an evil character leads to a desire to raid. Not saying it is right or wrong, simply saying that's what happens. I agree with Lissal in this matter. I think having more in the UD will help players feel more welcome there and more willing to experience IT and stay down there.
So, people wanting to go above ground to RP and hunt is bound to happen. Boredom and playing as an evil character leads to a desire to raid. Not saying it is right or wrong, simply saying that's what happens. I agree with Lissal in this matter. I think having more in the UD will help players feel more welcome there and more willing to experience IT and stay down there.
-
Maecius
- Retired Admin
- Posts: 11639
- Joined: Sat May 16, 2009 4:24 pm
Re: UD/Surface Rules
I know Cubicle is working on something to begin to help set right the status quo, and I agree that it's not really fun for anybody the way it is right now.
It's up to the DMs as to whether a review of the UD/Surface rules is required though.
It's up to the DMs as to whether a review of the UD/Surface rules is required though.
r e s o u r c e s :
- BG:TSCC Wiki
- Community News
- Server Rules and Information
- Supporting BG:TSCC-
pwdcrk1
- Posts: 140
- Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 9:13 pm
- Location: Europe
-
Maecius
- Retired Admin
- Posts: 11639
- Joined: Sat May 16, 2009 4:24 pm
Re: UD/Surface Rules
We're currently testing some new content on our test server, including areas, in preparation for an August update. I'm not sure whether any Underdark areas are in this current batch, but one of the devs, DMs, or QCers who have done some of the testing might know more.
r e s o u r c e s :
- BG:TSCC Wiki
- Community News
- Server Rules and Information
- Supporting BG:TSCC-
Side
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Sun Jun 27, 2010 8:29 pm
- Location: Michigan USA
Re: UD/Surface Rules
I don't mean to bring back an aging thread, but after stalking the forums for a bit and reading this thread and other recent ones like it I couldn't help myself from adding to a topic so close to my heart. Please forgive me!
I've personally gone up a few times with my drow. It's been a fun experience, and as a naturally nervous person I was freaking out the whole time that someone was going to catch me. No one ever did, but that idea was still there. As things are now I could see that feeling dulling over time if I went up regularly, which is a shame.
That all said my nervousness was split between the understandable IC side and the less than preferred OOC side. While I was watching over my shoulder for surfacer threats I was also worried my RP reason wouldn't be good enough, or that the amount of time I spent getting to the surface would be wasted. I've known enough people in the UD to hear some of the bad OOC stories, most but not all of which would never happen today.
I would personally like to see the rules regarding travel between the UD and Surface altered to only cover the people who would end up ruining the link again. People who cannot help but rampage around the other side for their own benefit, rather than the benefit of all who participate in the RP should be the focus of the OOC rules, with only a few punishments ranging from banning travel between the two areas to permastrikes.
Any issues that are not severe enough to warrant a harsh punishment should be handled ICly. Give players tools to "properly" handle characters who were caught causing trouble on the wrong side of the maze. How this is handled would depend on a bunch of stuff that I don't feel is needed in a rules focused thread, but I do believe Surface players should have some amount of power on the Surface, with the same going for UDers in the UD.
Yes my idea here is partially based on the memory of a few good (good for me, not my character) encounters with the old player police factions, but the key difference would be player consent. You choose to travel to the other side of the ruins. You choose to accept the risk of getting caught. You choose to leave the safe area you have and you enter that dangerous place under your own power.
Those factions were shut down after players could not keep themselves in line when given power over their peers, but if we properly and ICly separate the need to consider UD characters and Surface characters as peers to one another we might be able to bring back some of those good aspects we lost when players were stopped from playing police. We would need to make sure there is no way to get to the other side without actively consenting to the OOC terms of being on the other side, but in the end it would be worth it.
To put it simply there is too much OOCness to worry about when going from one side to the other. If we can manage to find a way to transfer most of that to an IC threat to the player character we might be able to afford some wiggle room on the mechanical barriers holding everyone back. There's obviously a lot of technical problems with my idea of how to pull it off, but these are my feelings on the matter.
I've personally gone up a few times with my drow. It's been a fun experience, and as a naturally nervous person I was freaking out the whole time that someone was going to catch me. No one ever did, but that idea was still there. As things are now I could see that feeling dulling over time if I went up regularly, which is a shame.
That all said my nervousness was split between the understandable IC side and the less than preferred OOC side. While I was watching over my shoulder for surfacer threats I was also worried my RP reason wouldn't be good enough, or that the amount of time I spent getting to the surface would be wasted. I've known enough people in the UD to hear some of the bad OOC stories, most but not all of which would never happen today.
I would personally like to see the rules regarding travel between the UD and Surface altered to only cover the people who would end up ruining the link again. People who cannot help but rampage around the other side for their own benefit, rather than the benefit of all who participate in the RP should be the focus of the OOC rules, with only a few punishments ranging from banning travel between the two areas to permastrikes.
Any issues that are not severe enough to warrant a harsh punishment should be handled ICly. Give players tools to "properly" handle characters who were caught causing trouble on the wrong side of the maze. How this is handled would depend on a bunch of stuff that I don't feel is needed in a rules focused thread, but I do believe Surface players should have some amount of power on the Surface, with the same going for UDers in the UD.
Yes my idea here is partially based on the memory of a few good (good for me, not my character) encounters with the old player police factions, but the key difference would be player consent. You choose to travel to the other side of the ruins. You choose to accept the risk of getting caught. You choose to leave the safe area you have and you enter that dangerous place under your own power.
Those factions were shut down after players could not keep themselves in line when given power over their peers, but if we properly and ICly separate the need to consider UD characters and Surface characters as peers to one another we might be able to bring back some of those good aspects we lost when players were stopped from playing police. We would need to make sure there is no way to get to the other side without actively consenting to the OOC terms of being on the other side, but in the end it would be worth it.
To put it simply there is too much OOCness to worry about when going from one side to the other. If we can manage to find a way to transfer most of that to an IC threat to the player character we might be able to afford some wiggle room on the mechanical barriers holding everyone back. There's obviously a lot of technical problems with my idea of how to pull it off, but these are my feelings on the matter.
Passiflora wrote: AS A DROW you will kill DUERGARS for like..... lvl 9 to 25. A DAMN LOT OF DUERGARS.
-
V'rass
- Posts: 1251
- Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2015 1:48 pm
- Location: Concord, N.H., USSA
Re: UD/Surface Rules
Aye lessen the UD/Surface rules... the current version is outdated.
"To understand magic one must first understand magic."
Agathion Benedictus: Holy Priest. Retired for now.
Tiax Rules-All: Gnomish madman. Retired permanently.
Exordius Vrass: Cleric/Mage. Currently active.
-
lilani
- Posts: 52
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 8:13 am
Re: UD/Surface Rules
As a new player, it sadly seems the case that a few people have ruined what would otherwise be able to an otherwise enjoyable playable experience.
While the rules put in place quite some time ago prevented the problems caused at the time, they have also created their own issues that have led to a large portion of the server being a single player environment for a large portion of the day.
This combined with a much larger and diverse surface area has led to a steady decline and self perpetuating problem that has been reported by several people on this thread.
I'd like to offer some suggestions / framework that could be built on & considered for a more moderate rule set to handle under dark & surface interaction.
- UD players travelling to the surface & vice versa would not be welcome in settlements until they have done heroic / villainous deeds that would earn them recognition as a non typical member of their race - I.e they need to partake and demonstrate this in DM events and earn 'papers' which would grant them access to towns (probably on a settlement by settlement basis). When a player has gained trust of a town, only then would they be allowed to interact with merchants, quest givers & have the protection of the guards.
- players simple should not be allowed to travel to the other side to hunt out other people for pvp (unless said player has consented). Duegar raiding patrols should be supervised at first by DMs (which lobo has led recently). Once players show responsibility perhaps put control of this into a patrol leaders hand but the point here is they shouldn't be an every day occurrence.
- allow unrestricted movement & hunting between the areas - it would be quite good for the UD population to see some red wizards, evil surfacers coming to hatch villainous schemes in the UD.
Players should ultimately police this themselves and need to realise if they are on the 'other' side, then they are at risk of confrontation with players who don't want them there - with that said it should be encouraged that a player be given IC chance to back down before pvp ensues (it's a thin line between IC and OOC sometimes I know, but decency should prevail)
- add new & use some existing areas as 'no mans land' - best suited for epic areas & outer planes etc, but in these lands there would be far less restrictions and people can Rp / pvp as they wish with neither side being considered the 'home' team. Again, pvp should not come without an Rp reason & as a rule of thumb, give players an RP 'out' before attacking.
While the rules put in place quite some time ago prevented the problems caused at the time, they have also created their own issues that have led to a large portion of the server being a single player environment for a large portion of the day.
This combined with a much larger and diverse surface area has led to a steady decline and self perpetuating problem that has been reported by several people on this thread.
I'd like to offer some suggestions / framework that could be built on & considered for a more moderate rule set to handle under dark & surface interaction.
- UD players travelling to the surface & vice versa would not be welcome in settlements until they have done heroic / villainous deeds that would earn them recognition as a non typical member of their race - I.e they need to partake and demonstrate this in DM events and earn 'papers' which would grant them access to towns (probably on a settlement by settlement basis). When a player has gained trust of a town, only then would they be allowed to interact with merchants, quest givers & have the protection of the guards.
- players simple should not be allowed to travel to the other side to hunt out other people for pvp (unless said player has consented). Duegar raiding patrols should be supervised at first by DMs (which lobo has led recently). Once players show responsibility perhaps put control of this into a patrol leaders hand but the point here is they shouldn't be an every day occurrence.
- allow unrestricted movement & hunting between the areas - it would be quite good for the UD population to see some red wizards, evil surfacers coming to hatch villainous schemes in the UD.
Players should ultimately police this themselves and need to realise if they are on the 'other' side, then they are at risk of confrontation with players who don't want them there - with that said it should be encouraged that a player be given IC chance to back down before pvp ensues (it's a thin line between IC and OOC sometimes I know, but decency should prevail)
- add new & use some existing areas as 'no mans land' - best suited for epic areas & outer planes etc, but in these lands there would be far less restrictions and people can Rp / pvp as they wish with neither side being considered the 'home' team. Again, pvp should not come without an Rp reason & as a rule of thumb, give players an RP 'out' before attacking.
-
Blame The Rogue
- Posts: 653
- Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am
Re: UD/Surface Rules
i understand the desire to travel one way or the other for rp purposes
unfortunately, every time the passage between surface and ud is unlocked, it has lead to numerous pvp issues. and i don't mean a few or occasionally. i mean every single time travel between surface and ud is open, dms and staff are flooded with pvp complaints/issues, which forces the passage to be blocked again
i don't know what the answer is here. some of the things in the previous post are interesting ideas
i just wanted to post this so that newer players understand the situation fully
unfortunately, every time the passage between surface and ud is unlocked, it has lead to numerous pvp issues. and i don't mean a few or occasionally. i mean every single time travel between surface and ud is open, dms and staff are flooded with pvp complaints/issues, which forces the passage to be blocked again
i don't know what the answer is here. some of the things in the previous post are interesting ideas
i just wanted to post this so that newer players understand the situation fully
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."
-
chad878262
- Posts: 9332
- Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:55 pm
Re: UD/Surface Rules
It should be noted that the rules are also there to respect the lore/timeline we are operating in (i.e. the time of troubles has not yet occurred, we are still in 1st edition timeline!!!) Drizzt is not yet (or just becoming, I don't pretend to know where his arrival in IWD lies on the timeline precisely) known as an ok guy outside of Icewind Dale. There should really be no knowledge of 'neutral / goodly' Elistraen Drow societies and all Drow are completely hated without exception. Frankly the RP I've had where another player tried to convince my character that not all Drow are evil has always been met with appropriately bigoted responses. The simple fact is that any travel between the two is supposed to be very hard and very scary, but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen! A traveling drow once took my poor bard hostage back to the Underdark for a time and it was great RP. Opening up travel between the two simply does not fit with the lore of the time period our server is in.
Chord Silverstrings - Bard and OSR Squire / Tarent Nefzen - Arcane Wand Merchant and Master Alchemist / Irrace Arkentlar - Drow Adventurer / Finneaus Du'Veil - Gem Merchant and Executive Officer of SCCE
Tarent's Wands and Elixirs
A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
Tarent's Wands and Elixirs
A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
-
Side
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Sun Jun 27, 2010 8:29 pm
- Location: Michigan USA
Re: UD/Surface Rules
Completely unrestricted travel shouldn't be the goal here of course, but it should also be possible for a small group of high teen/low epic characters to make it up/down if they are very careful. How you can do that without making it too easy for high epic characters is beyond me.
In any case this thread should be more about the OOC rules that hinder people from traveling between the UD and Surface, not the mechanical side of things that happens IC.
In any case this thread should be more about the OOC rules that hinder people from traveling between the UD and Surface, not the mechanical side of things that happens IC.
Passiflora wrote: AS A DROW you will kill DUERGARS for like..... lvl 9 to 25. A DAMN LOT OF DUERGARS.