Agreed; people are definitely not wired to work that way. If it's at all possible, it's certainly not something that can be forced.Boddynock wrote:But I am not really convinced someone can so completely separate themselves from their own idea of self-identity that they could pursue a lifetime of goals with no self-gratification or sense of reward. People aren't wired to work that way.
Why is Necromancy evil?
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
Arn
- Posts: 906
- Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2012 7:44 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Mi-Le (彌勒) - "Meditate, monks. Do not be negligent, lest you regret it later." ((-Saṃyutta Nikāya 35.146))
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-
Karond
- Posts: 2221
- Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 10:47 am
- Location: Sweden
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
It's even more ingrained in forgotten realms. In a world where everyone knows where they'll go after they die, as long as they remain faithful to a specific deity, many actions or limitations upon actions become entirely selfish. It's weird because selfishness is inherently evil in FR, but sticking to a deity for fear of repercussions is in itself selfish. Logically, most people would be evil.Boddynock wrote: But I am not really convinced someone can so completely separate themselves from their own idea of self-identity that they could pursue a lifetime of goals with no self-gratification or sense of reward. People aren't wired to work that way.
But, one can't argue logic with FR. It's a bit haphazard, because unlike other fantasy realms like star wars, warhammer, lord of the rings etc., the entire focus is on dungeon crawling, not presenting believable environments or reasoning for why the world is as it is.
So, necromancy is evil because a book said so. Just like anything else with intent, consequence etc., being entirely absolute.
-
thids
- Posts: 1252
- Joined: Sat May 25, 2013 11:05 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
I was being sarcastic.TheLier wrote:A paladin knows, that if he can "detect" you, you are evil. That is PnP. He won't say, that you are LE/NE/CE, but he will know you are evil. Also, toons must have at least some kind of knowledge of this. And if the spell works against you, that means, by definition, you are either good or evil. You can argue about the definitions, -IC-, but OOC, it is quite clear how it works.Thids wrote:Detect [Alignment] spells are totally OOC mechanics.
Lord Maximilian Blackthorne - retired
-
TheLier
- Posts: 388
- Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
A emoticon or something, would not have hurt then. Hard to grasp context through internet.Thids wrote:I was being sarcastic.TheLier wrote:A paladin knows, that if he can "detect" you, you are evil. That is PnP. He won't say, that you are LE/NE/CE, but he will know you are evil. Also, toons must have at least some kind of knowledge of this. And if the spell works against you, that means, by definition, you are either good or evil. You can argue about the definitions, -IC-, but OOC, it is quite clear how it works.Thids wrote:Detect [Alignment] spells are totally OOC mechanics.
-
Hoihe
- Posts: 4719
- Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 2:25 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Karond wrote:It's even more ingrained in forgotten realms. In a world where everyone knows where they'll go after they die, as long as they remain faithful to a specific deity, many actions or limitations upon actions become entirely selfish. It's weird because selfishness is inherently evil in FR, but sticking to a deity for fear of repercussions is in itself selfish. Logically, most people would be evil.Boddynock wrote: But I am not really convinced someone can so completely separate themselves from their own idea of self-identity that they could pursue a lifetime of goals with no self-gratification or sense of reward. People aren't wired to work that way.
But, one can't argue logic with FR. It's a bit haphazard, because unlike other fantasy realms like star wars, warhammer, lord of the rings etc., the entire focus is on dungeon crawling, not presenting believable environments or reasoning for why the world is as it is.
So, necromancy is evil because a book said so. Just like anything else with intent, consequence etc., being entirely absolute.
Said books are full of Good descriptor necromancy spells!
For life to be worth living, afterlife must retain individuality, personal identity and memories without fail - https://www.sageadvice.eu/do-elves-reta ... afterlife/
A character belongs only to their player, and only them. And only the player may decide what happens.
A character belongs only to their player, and only them. And only the player may decide what happens.
-
Karond
- Posts: 2221
- Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 10:47 am
- Location: Sweden
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Right. I meant creating undead, not necromancy in general 
-
Boddynock
- Posts: 834
- Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Also not an evil act in every case.Karond wrote:Right. I meant creating undead, not necromancy in general
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)
"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a..." - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
-
Garn Greymoon
- Posts: 288
- Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 12:19 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
My super simple answer is aa follows. Fantasy in general especially high fantasy as such is dnd (Greyhawk, forgotten realms, eberron) is typically very black and white. It's fantasy so there's a certain suspension of disbelief there...so without all the moral and ethical debate see it from the PoV of the reader.
You see....a walking corpse!
You see....a walking corpse!
Vabo . . . . . Gnome Druid - The Mushroom Man
Dag . . . . . Gnome Bard - The Twang Fury
-
Sokolsky
- Posts: 144
- Joined: Tue Jun 28, 2016 2:24 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Without having read the entire fast-growing thread, here are my two cents:
Evil is what the source books say is evil. No more, no less.
Evil is what the source books say is evil. No more, no less.
HOWEVER...
Characters don't know about source books. They can have their own interpretation. Most (my) evil characters do not consider themselves evil, but their actions are considered evil by the source books and thus they are evil.Wise men speak because they have something to say; fools because they have to say something - Plato
-
Necromantis
- Posts: 261
- Joined: Mon Jul 25, 2016 8:04 pm
- Location: Belgium
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
With every single act you make within the world of Faerun, somewhere out there, a God or Goddess is (perhaps, if they're not occupied elsewhere) frowning upon you. Good or Evil. If you're asking the question of 'Why is Necromancy Evil?', then the follow-up question should absolutely be 'In whose perspective?'. The Gods of Faerun govern their domains, and more often than not have absolute opinions on certain actions. But what would they really do, think or feel? Can anyone truly know?
Example 1: Let's say a male Banite falls in love, and marries a person of high stature, so much so that they are able to exploit their power later on, becoming a tyrant. Now what would Bane's view on this be, with portfolio's of Strife, Hatred, Tyranny and Fear? Would Bane condemn the man for falling in love (Sune's domain), or would he commend his loyal follower for becoming a tyrant in this manner?
Example 2: A dwarven hold is under siege by Drow. They are losing, and a cabal of desperate Dwarven wizards conjures infernals to defend the hold, succesfully so. Do any Dwarven Gods show signs of wrath? Contempt?
Example 3: Lawful Neutral wizards, followers of Jergal, destroy large fields of crops using Necromancy because it is the village's time to perish, according to Jergal. A few Lawful Evil wizards (Let's use Banites again) use the same Necromancy to defeat the other wizards, in order to become it's saviors and gain more influence within the town. Does Chauntea care that Necromancy was used to save the fields? Are all Necromancers in this example Evil in the same manner? Even when following a Neutral God?
Does the Evil alignment depend -entirely- on the spells used, or the moral choices behind them? When you corrupt someone's soul, to resurrect an undead, and save many people's lives by commanding it, are you essentially not shifting in alignment? And what if the people you save with it are followers of a God or Goddess that condemns the use of Undead? I believe that, while the Gods have minds of their own, and would definetly confront mortals for many actions, they also greatly look to the races of Toril to resolve the conflicts of their domains, and gain experiences of the practice of their domains that may or may not constantly alter their own views on the domains they unfailingly govern. There's a reason the Gods leave many things up to their followers, because the Gods do not live in Toril (yet/fully). Our characters do. The ruler of a nation doesn't go out of his way to arrest petty criminals (though that would be highly amusing to watch).
Is Necromancy Evil? Is animating the dead bodies of someone's children or parents and binding them to your will a wicked deed? I think most people would unanimously say yes. Is sapping something else's strength and adding it to yours a wicked deed? Opinions begin to differ here for most people. I would say that Necromancy is a perfectly viable school of magic, with certain spells that are exceptionally vile, so much so that they draw the attention of the Gods. Is the whole school of Necromancy evil? No. If that were the case, I daresay at least half if not more of all characters on BGTSCC would be considered Evil, at least in the eyes of the Gods, for using simple Necromancy buffs like 'False Life', or using enchanted items with 'Vampirism'. (Because appearently pouring 'evil' magic into a weapon suddenly makes it not evil anymore, and freely sold on the markets! Bought by paladins of Lathander!)
Example 1: Let's say a male Banite falls in love, and marries a person of high stature, so much so that they are able to exploit their power later on, becoming a tyrant. Now what would Bane's view on this be, with portfolio's of Strife, Hatred, Tyranny and Fear? Would Bane condemn the man for falling in love (Sune's domain), or would he commend his loyal follower for becoming a tyrant in this manner?
Example 2: A dwarven hold is under siege by Drow. They are losing, and a cabal of desperate Dwarven wizards conjures infernals to defend the hold, succesfully so. Do any Dwarven Gods show signs of wrath? Contempt?
Example 3: Lawful Neutral wizards, followers of Jergal, destroy large fields of crops using Necromancy because it is the village's time to perish, according to Jergal. A few Lawful Evil wizards (Let's use Banites again) use the same Necromancy to defeat the other wizards, in order to become it's saviors and gain more influence within the town. Does Chauntea care that Necromancy was used to save the fields? Are all Necromancers in this example Evil in the same manner? Even when following a Neutral God?
Does the Evil alignment depend -entirely- on the spells used, or the moral choices behind them? When you corrupt someone's soul, to resurrect an undead, and save many people's lives by commanding it, are you essentially not shifting in alignment? And what if the people you save with it are followers of a God or Goddess that condemns the use of Undead? I believe that, while the Gods have minds of their own, and would definetly confront mortals for many actions, they also greatly look to the races of Toril to resolve the conflicts of their domains, and gain experiences of the practice of their domains that may or may not constantly alter their own views on the domains they unfailingly govern. There's a reason the Gods leave many things up to their followers, because the Gods do not live in Toril (yet/fully). Our characters do. The ruler of a nation doesn't go out of his way to arrest petty criminals (though that would be highly amusing to watch).
Is Necromancy Evil? Is animating the dead bodies of someone's children or parents and binding them to your will a wicked deed? I think most people would unanimously say yes. Is sapping something else's strength and adding it to yours a wicked deed? Opinions begin to differ here for most people. I would say that Necromancy is a perfectly viable school of magic, with certain spells that are exceptionally vile, so much so that they draw the attention of the Gods. Is the whole school of Necromancy evil? No. If that were the case, I daresay at least half if not more of all characters on BGTSCC would be considered Evil, at least in the eyes of the Gods, for using simple Necromancy buffs like 'False Life', or using enchanted items with 'Vampirism'. (Because appearently pouring 'evil' magic into a weapon suddenly makes it not evil anymore, and freely sold on the markets! Bought by paladins of Lathander!)
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Necromantis wrote: Example 1: Let's say a male Banite falls in love, and marries a person of high stature, so much so that they are able to exploit their power later on, becoming a tyrant. Now what would Bane's view on this be, with portfolio's of Strife, Hatred, Tyranny and Fear? Would Bane condemn the man for falling in love (Sune's domain), or would he commend his loyal follower for becoming a tyrant in this manner?
Example 2: A dwarven hold is under siege by Drow. They are losing, and a cabal of desperate Dwarven wizards conjures infernals to defend the hold, succesfully so. Do any Dwarven Gods show signs of wrath? Contempt?
Example 3: Lawful Neutral wizards, followers of Jergal, destroy large fields of crops using Necromancy because it is the village's time to perish, according to Jergal. A few Lawful Evil wizards (Let's use Banites again) use the same Necromancy to defeat the other wizards, in order to become it's saviors and gain more influence within the town. Does Chauntea care that Necromancy was used to save the fields? Are all Necromancers in this example Evil in the same manner? Even when following a Neutral God?
1) Bane isn't a mind reader. He wouldn't know that his servant fell in love. From his view, his servant took advantage of the woman and became a tyrant. He would be commended. It's not like the Gods control emotions. You'll be hard pressed to actually find a God of true emotions. The vast, vast majority are based around either actions, something physical or metaphysical (magic). Sune for example, whose dogma primarily concerned love based on outward beauty, is not the 'Love' you are referring to.
I've noticed a lot of that in this thread where people are talking about good vs. bad with emotions. I spit on that belief. The Gods give sets of ideals or morals, they don't command their followers not feel good for being selfless. Emotions have NOTHING to do with alignment. If an Evil dude feels good after murdering someone and a Good dude feels good after helping someone, should they be switching alignments? No... Just leave emotions out of it.
2) I'm not at liberty to speak for Dwarven Gods but I'd like to think the Gods would be rather upset. When you look at most lore, books and history, the Dwarves would rather fight and die with honor than have to turn to summoning devils/demons. It just makes me think of more questions that make it all seem odd...
- Why do they have Spells that summon Devils/Demons?
- If it was Gate, why didn't they choose for some sort of giant Elemental?
It's sort of the same reason why you won't find a Chaotic Evil worshipper of Lathander joining him in the afterlife. You have to uphold their ideals and beliefs too! The Dwarven Gods do not condone using infernals as it generally does more harm than good.
3) This question is flawed in logic and actions. Jergal is a glorified bookkeeper who records deaths and where spirits go to. Nothing has a set 'time' to die when spells such as Raise Dead and Resurrection exist. Wizards of Jergal wouldn't go around killing CROP FIELDS of all things to progress Jergal's dogma as there's no souls to record.
P.S. Yes, Chauntea would be upset that Necromancy was used on the fields since now it's probably tainted. I.E. See Triel, the BG Farmlands, you know, anything where there's lots of negative energy (anti-thesis of life, aka, positive energy) Besides, whose to say she didn't want the Crops dead in the first place? You know how there's this whole cycle of the seasons where crops naturally die and are reborn in the spring?
Here's how a Jergalite progresses Death.
- Necromancer uses Trap the Soul on their rival, denying the soul from moving on and being recorded.
- Priest of Jergal demands the soul back so it can move on, summons undead to get it.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
Garn Greymoon
- Posts: 288
- Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 12:19 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Watch stranger things enough said 
Vabo . . . . . Gnome Druid - The Mushroom Man
Dag . . . . . Gnome Bard - The Twang Fury
-
Necromantis
- Posts: 261
- Joined: Mon Jul 25, 2016 8:04 pm
- Location: Belgium
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
I -completely- agree with you Flasmix (and yes, I know I gave terrible examples, I was trying to make a point out of them), and you bring out the points I've been trying to make:
I took the second (another terrible) example, because I wanted to present a case where either a whole people would either die, or perform an act of 'Evil' and save themselves from harm. Of course their Gods would condemn the action, but to what extent would their wrath be? Wouldn't a God(dess) attempt to use every extent of their power, no matter how vile, to keep themselves alive? After all, they -are- the epitome of their domain.
(I read the Jergal thing earlier in this thread, which is why I used it)
(The third example was put forward to make a comparison with two uses of Necromancy with different moral reasons behind it. And I asked if Chauntea cared about the use of Necromancy for -saving- said crops. As in, was the use of Necromancy redeemable in that moment. )
The reason I'm bringing up these examples is to ask, would a God(dess) respond (not emotionally) to Necromancy differently if their followers were protected / their domain respected? Or would they see it as an absolute 'Evil' that must be stamped out, along with those responsible, no matter the actions done with it? Or would there be a certain amount of forgiveness for the deed, this one time?
Because if it -does- depend on circumstance (and seeing as you answered every example with more questions, I'd say it does for many), the Gods' judgement on Necromancy/Evil Necromancy just became a whole lot more complex. Then again... they can't read minds. So is it absolute, or not?
EXACTLY! The Gods don't know -every- single thing that people in Faerun think, and the reasons behind them, which makes most of the non-magical moral issues and the way they are dealt with almost entirely up to people! There are plenty of 'Evil' aligned people that use reason or common sense behind their actions!Bane isn't a mind reader. He wouldn't know that his servant fell in love.
I took the second (another terrible) example, because I wanted to present a case where either a whole people would either die, or perform an act of 'Evil' and save themselves from harm. Of course their Gods would condemn the action, but to what extent would their wrath be? Wouldn't a God(dess) attempt to use every extent of their power, no matter how vile, to keep themselves alive? After all, they -are- the epitome of their domain.
(I read the Jergal thing earlier in this thread, which is why I used it)
(The third example was put forward to make a comparison with two uses of Necromancy with different moral reasons behind it. And I asked if Chauntea cared about the use of Necromancy for -saving- said crops. As in, was the use of Necromancy redeemable in that moment. )
The reason I'm bringing up these examples is to ask, would a God(dess) respond (not emotionally) to Necromancy differently if their followers were protected / their domain respected? Or would they see it as an absolute 'Evil' that must be stamped out, along with those responsible, no matter the actions done with it? Or would there be a certain amount of forgiveness for the deed, this one time?
Because if it -does- depend on circumstance (and seeing as you answered every example with more questions, I'd say it does for many), the Gods' judgement on Necromancy/Evil Necromancy just became a whole lot more complex. Then again... they can't read minds. So is it absolute, or not?
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
The few Gods that tolerate Necromancy that aren't evil would need strict RP reasons for their actions. The whole point I was making by originally mentioning Jergal is that while he does exist, a solid reason for using undead is needed still. The crops was just bad lol. The answer is yes, very, very, very rarely does it depend on circumstances. The other 99% of the time it's still evil. Summoning an undead to save a life is still evil. One of those road to hell paved with good intentions thing.
If you want to know who created the evil vs good system, look to the nameless being who Ao calls master.
If you want to know who created the evil vs good system, look to the nameless being who Ao calls master.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
Tekill
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 921
- Joined: Wed Jun 18, 2014 10:12 am
- Location: BC, Canada
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
I have read fantasy fiction that showed necromany in a more scientific light. It was more of a study of death as a way to do things like prolong life. Those necromancers were creepy but respected.
Necromancy used to kill cancer cells. Necromancy used to reanimate dead tissue..etc.
In Forgotten realms Necromancy is more about entrophy and undeath and not about just the study of death itself. The spells used in Necormancy as previously mentioned all tend to be pretty wicked.
Necromancy in Forgotten realms is more about controlling 'negative energy'.
Forgotten realms has focuses strongly on the duality of good vs evil. Negative energy being the opposite of positive energy - well thats guilt by association right there.
It should be easy to list reasons why undead are evil. Most societies would consider the desecration of a dead body as immoral or evil. Undead carry diseases. Undead attack the living. Even the non wicked undead are considered unaturally trapped between this world and the afterwold- often also trapping a soul.
Because negative energy is the unlife force of undead and because negative energy is the bread and butter of the schools of necromancy - we can logically conclude that -Undead is bad, therefor necromancy is bad.
So play it safe and burn the necromancers!!!
Necromancy used to kill cancer cells. Necromancy used to reanimate dead tissue..etc.
In Forgotten realms Necromancy is more about entrophy and undeath and not about just the study of death itself. The spells used in Necormancy as previously mentioned all tend to be pretty wicked.
Necromancy in Forgotten realms is more about controlling 'negative energy'.
Forgotten realms has focuses strongly on the duality of good vs evil. Negative energy being the opposite of positive energy - well thats guilt by association right there.
It should be easy to list reasons why undead are evil. Most societies would consider the desecration of a dead body as immoral or evil. Undead carry diseases. Undead attack the living. Even the non wicked undead are considered unaturally trapped between this world and the afterwold- often also trapping a soul.
Because negative energy is the unlife force of undead and because negative energy is the bread and butter of the schools of necromancy - we can logically conclude that -Undead is bad, therefor necromancy is bad.
So play it safe and burn the necromancers!!!
Malodia - Bae'qeshel - The Dark Minstrel - https://www.bgtscc.net/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=76945
Gilthisanthilas - Pryat of Helm - Everwatch Knight
Skagrot Skullsplitter - Mountain Orc Warrior - The Last Skullsplitter https://www.bgtscc.net/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=79740
Gilthisanthilas - Pryat of Helm - Everwatch Knight
Skagrot Skullsplitter - Mountain Orc Warrior - The Last Skullsplitter https://www.bgtscc.net/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=79740