Page 1 of 1

Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:05 am
by Green Monster
I have the Shadow Legion Armor and took armor optimization. Now it's ac 0 cloth instead of studded leather.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:17 am
by BloodRiot
so now it's probably worth a damned fortune for a 30+ Dex sneak :D

i0'm sure Rhi will get back to you on that but had to say

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:18 am
by DaloLorn
Have you tried putting it off and on again? Or going through a map transition?

So far this has been believed to be a transient and probably-visual bug.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:19 am
by izzul
Visual bug. check the armor AC when you open inventory and the distribution is there

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:52 am
by Green Monster
izzul wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:19 am Visual bug. check the armor AC when you open inventory and the distribution is there
Nope. It's not. Equipping it raises my AC by 4. It should be 7 (3 base ac, 4 enchantment). It's also changed from weighing 20lbs to weighing 2 lbs. This happened when I transferred it to RCR.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 11:15 am
by izzul
yea, i think thats the original bug

i hade few leafweave that became like that but it happened waaaay last year i thought it does not happened to anyone else

deleted all of them and put in campfire since its the earlier stage of armors

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 11:49 am
by Rhifox
You can ask a DM to replace it.

Not sure why this happened, we fixed this bug a year ago as Izzul mentioned.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 12:22 pm
by Hullack
BloodRiot wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 9:17 am so now it's probably worth a damned fortune for a 30+ Dex sneak :D

i0'm sure Rhi will get back to you on that but had to say
Yeah, I'd happily trade you my shadow legion armor for it. That's really good for a high-dex sneaker. Being a bug, it's likely better to just get it replaced.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 3:13 pm
by Green Monster
It happened as a result of an RCR. My halfling bard had the Shadow Legion armor and armor opt and I had noticed the visual bug but didn't think anything of it because the AC still added up correctly. But then I RCRed when I noticed that deadly defense doesn't work with short swords and maces wielded by a halfling. So I unequipped the Shadow Legion, put it in a fire in the nexus, and then picked it up with the new char with a slightly different name ("e" at the end) and suddenly instead of being a 20lb studded leather it's a 2lb cloth.


So now with the new char I didn't take armor opt, I took stealthy instead and am using a +4 ac leafweave.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 3:30 pm
by Rhifox
Green Monster wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 3:13 pm It happened as a result of an RCR. My halfling bard had the Shadow Legion armor and armor opt and I had noticed the visual bug but didn't think anything of it because the AC still added up correctly. But then I RCRed when I noticed that deadly defense doesn't work with short swords and maces wielded by a halfling.
You didn't need to RCR for this, given that it will be fixed. That was a product of coding the check for whether something is finessable/light per pnp rules, but those rules assume the existence of differently sized versions of weapons, which we don't have.
So I unequipped the Shadow Legion, put it in a fire in the nexus, and then picked it up with the new char with a slightly different name ("e" at the end) and suddenly instead of being a 20lb studded leather it's a 2lb cloth.
Okay, thank you for the information.

Likely we will change it to work like staff attunement where you actively optimize an armor, making it untradeable/droppable until unoptimized. This also allows us to remove equip issues with the current auto-optimization function.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 4:35 pm
by Green Monster
Rhifox wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 3:30 pm
Green Monster wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 3:13 pm It happened as a result of an RCR. My halfling bard had the Shadow Legion armor and armor opt and I had noticed the visual bug but didn't think anything of it because the AC still added up correctly. But then I RCRed when I noticed that deadly defense doesn't work with short swords and maces wielded by a halfling.
You didn't need to RCR for this, given that it will be fixed. That was a product of coding the check for whether something is finessable/light per pnp rules, but those rules assume the existence of differently sized versions of weapons, which we don't have.
That's ok. Upon further reflection, this halfling's BAB isn't going to be high enough to run around with combat expertise active all the time like my tiefling main character does. The RCR was a good thing, but I'm glad that Deadly Defense will be fixed for small characters.

Rhifox wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 3:30 pm
So I unequipped the Shadow Legion, put it in a fire in the nexus, and then picked it up with the new char with a slightly different name ("e" at the end) and suddenly instead of being a 20lb studded leather it's a 2lb cloth.
Okay, thank you for the information.

Likely we will change it to work like staff attunement where you actively optimize an armor, making it untradeable/droppable until unoptimized. This also allows us to remove equip issues with the current auto-optimization function.
That is a great idea, I like it. When I noticed the problem with the armor, I got frustrated and took Stealthy instead of Armor Opt and used my +4 leafweave studded. This gives me the same AC as optimized Shadow Legion, but 3 less hide and move silent. Would it be possible for a dm to replace my broken shadow legion AND swap Stealthy for Armor Optimization, or will I need to RCR again if the shadow legion is replaced?

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 4:38 pm
by Rhifox
Green Monster wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 4:35 pmThat is a great idea, I like it. When I noticed the problem with the armor, I got frustrated and took Stealthy instead of Armor Opt and used my +4 leafweave studded. This gives me the same AC as optimized Shadow Legion, but 3 less hide and move silent. Would it be possible for a dm to replace my broken shadow legion AND swap Stealthy for Armor Optimization, or will I need to RCR again if the shadow legion is replaced?
Replacing the armor is doable of course, but I can't guarantee the feat swap. Given the RCR was due to bugs, though it may be possible, but you'll have to ask them. You can ofc link this thread when making the request.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 6:58 pm
by Green Monster
I forgot to add that the Shadow Legion Armor had been altered with the new appearance system. I didn't think that was relevant, but just now I changed the appearance of the leafeweave armor I have and the same visual bug that causes the examine description to show that it's ac 0 cloth has affected that too. I don't have armor optimization at this time. I relogged and same visual bug. I relogged to the other server and that fixed it.

I was tempted to drop the leafweave in a fire to see if the new appearance system was the cause of the shadow legion's destruction, but I was afraid that if the leafweave also got borked I'd be out of luck for armor for this character until such time as I am lucky enough to find a dm. I don't happen to have a spare +4 ac leafweave studded. If you want me to experiment while you or a dm is there to fix it if that breaks it, I'd be happy to, but not on my own.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 7:25 pm
by Green Monster
Rhifox wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 4:38 pm
Green Monster wrote: Thu Aug 31, 2023 4:35 pmThat is a great idea, I like it. When I noticed the problem with the armor, I got frustrated and took Stealthy instead of Armor Opt and used my +4 leafweave studded. This gives me the same AC as optimized Shadow Legion, but 3 less hide and move silent. Would it be possible for a dm to replace my broken shadow legion AND swap Stealthy for Armor Optimization, or will I need to RCR again if the shadow legion is replaced?
Replacing the armor is doable of course, but I can't guarantee the feat swap. Given the RCR was due to bugs, though it may be possible, but you'll have to ask them. You can ofc link this thread when making the request.
Well, since I have no idea when I'll be online at the same time as a dm I guess I will continue on as I am for now. I don't want to shelf this character while I wait.

Oh, btw, to be clear, there are 2 bugs: 1 causes the description to say that the armor is AC 0 cloth but the weight and actual equipped AC are correct. The other bug has actually turned the armor into AC 0 cloth, including weight. The description bug has occurred both because of armor optimization and because of the new appearance customization. I don't now know whether it was optimization or the new appearance system that caused the second, more serious bug.

Re: Armor Optimization destroyed studded leather

Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2023 1:30 am
by Green Monster
I went ahead and RCR'ed and built around not having stealth bonuses on my armor. Went with the Bearskin Armor from the epic shop, will give me better AC and this character will eventually have 23 levels of bard so I can use Inspire Competence to make up the difference. Hopefully.


Would it be considered exploiting a bug if I gave the broken AC 0 Shadow Legion to my 30 dex main rogue?