Based on what is written on the source books; 'Total Concealment until spotted' is the only thing that matches without rather substantial creative freedoms.Nihm wrote:Are you saying you are going to disagree with me simply because I disagree with you..?
And as for the methods of initiating "HiPS" - players and dungeon masters have the freedom of description. For example; 'Spellcasters' can freely describe their spell effects as long as they do not make their spells far stronger than what they are or too far away from the spell's name. 'Warriors' can describe their attacks, instead of just saying they are doing a either standard or full attack. Hence, Shadowdancers too can describe how they enter "HiPS."
The supernatural pull and spin of shadows really fits a class called Shadowdancer. Jumping into a shadow as if it were a puddle of water, little less so. But in my books you are free to do so as long as your attitude follows the 'live and let live' principle. Based on your previous post this does not appear to be the case, and hence; we play what we got, and what we got is a slow fade away when "HiPS" is turned on.
It is not. Using the source books as a reference helps to determine what characters can or cannot do - while maintaining the same set of rules for everyone. But considering how PnP is only really used in DM events, in which case the dungeon master just asks the players to roll something, there is absolutely no reason to feel antagonized for not knowing a lot how things work in PnP.18Rabbit wrote:All of this "Source Book" bible thumping is kind of pointless.
The source books are also a great source for fleshing out the setting details, and possibly to prevent them from making antagonisingly silly decisions. For example all my early elven D&D characters should be taken behind a barn and shot.
And what comes to Hoihe's question:
Shadowdancers use the many shadows in their proximity to acquire total concealment until spotted, hence the question about hiding within a shadowshield spell is irrelevant.
- As I mentioned earlier, total concealment saves us from headaches, even the ones caused by Hoihe's questions.