The terrible truth in Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them

Off-Topic Community Conversations and Discussions

Moderators: Moderator, DM

Post Reply
User avatar
Charraj
Posts: 2741
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2010 5:38 pm
Location: EST

The terrible truth in Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them

Unread post by Charraj »

Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them (the book, not the movie) reveals a horrifying truth about the wizarding community's attitude and treatment towards Muggles. I refer you to the book's Introduction:

"Older British readers will remember the Ilfracombe Incident of 1932, when a rogue Welsh Green dragon swooped down upon a crowded beach full of sunbathing Muggles. Fatalities were mercifully prevented by the brave actions of a holidaying wizarding family (subsequently awarded Orders of Merlin, First Class), when they immediately performed the largest batch of Memory Charms this century on the inhabitants of Ilfracombe, thus narrowly averting catastrophe."
-Magical Beasts and Where to Find Them, pages xxvii-xxviii

Please note that fatalities were prevented NOT by driving off or fighting the dragon, but by CASTING MEMORY CHARMS. So what "catastrophe" was averted by casting Memory Charms? It wasn't the dragon; the dragon only swooped down upon a crowded beach. No attack or violence was mentioned. Besides, how would Memory Charms save people from an attacking dragon? They wouldn't; they can't. The implication here is that the Muggle fatalities would have been caused by something (someone) else.

Consider that this book talks about the extreme lengths to which the wizarding community hides the existence of magic from Muggles. So again, how did Memory Charms prevent fatalities? Because it meant that the wizarding community didn't have to kill all the Muggles at Ilfracombe.

TL;DR: The wizarding community is willing to commit mass Muggle murder to hide themselves.
Molly Longshot - Wheeee!
Sempo - Former butler, wandering priest
Mara - Paladin of Jergal
Tabby - Hedge witch, former bandit
Charraj Cain - Mystran. Dead.
DM Mister Rogers - It's such a good feeling to know that we're lifelong friends.
User avatar
Maecius
Retired Admin
Posts: 11640
Joined: Sat May 16, 2009 4:24 pm

Re: The terrible truth in Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find T

Unread post by Maecius »

Charraj? This crazy conspiracy theory of yours?
Image
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: The terrible truth in Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find T

Unread post by TheLier »

Charraj wrote:Fantastic Beasts & Where to Find Them (the book, not the movie) reveals a horrifying truth about the wizarding community's attitude and treatment towards Muggles. I refer you to the book's Introduction:

"Older British readers will remember the Ilfracombe Incident of 1932, when a rogue Welsh Green dragon swooped down upon a crowded beach full of sunbathing Muggles. Fatalities were mercifully prevented by the brave actions of a holidaying wizarding family (subsequently awarded Orders of Merlin, First Class), when they immediately performed the largest batch of Memory Charms this century on the inhabitants of Ilfracombe, thus narrowly averting catastrophe."
-Magical Beasts and Where to Find Them, pages xxvii-xxviii

Please note that fatalities were prevented NOT by driving off or fighting the dragon, but by CASTING MEMORY CHARMS. So what "catastrophe" was averted by casting Memory Charms? It wasn't the dragon; the dragon only swooped down upon a crowded beach. No attack or violence was mentioned. Besides, how would Memory Charms save people from an attacking dragon? They wouldn't; they can't. The implication here is that the Muggle fatalities would have been caused by something (someone) else.

Consider that this book talks about the extreme lengths to which the wizarding community hides the existence of magic from Muggles. So again, how did Memory Charms prevent fatalities? Because it meant that the wizarding community didn't have to kill all the Muggles at Ilfracombe.

TL;DR: The wizarding community is willing to commit mass Muggle murder to hide themselves.
Well if I recall correctly, there were implications of such in the books, like some people never gave a damn about them.

Maybe it will be explained?
Post Reply

Return to “Community”