UD/Surface Rules

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Nomster
Posts: 1941
Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2012 12:41 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Nomster »

I would be quite curious to see how a test trial for a few months would work, by relaxing the rules a little. Because, let us face it, the situation we have now is not lore correct. It is entirely OOC based. Lore-wise, a character -even an elf- could go and live in Sshamath. A drow could live on the surface. Now, I am not sure if we want to go to such lengths... but relaxing the travel rules could be a start. It would place a lot of responsibility on the players... and I reckon the DMs would think, 'Are players responsible enough?'. Keeping in mind, that DMs are the ones who see all of the irresponsible actions that happen on the server.

I do wonder though if there would be any drow left in the UD and if there would not be more surfacers in UD than drow... :lol: but that is what a trial period would show.


It is up to each player to play their character as a living person in this world setting, with appropriate views etc. Is it the character, or the player, that wants to interact with the other side?


As a note, I have only had one character be on the other side and it was for 24h. I am not affected by increased or decreased interaction rules.
"I don't want to pretend at magic anymore. I want to be magic."

Telia Santraeger - Emotional sorceress & priestess of Mystra. [Retired]
User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Maximvs »

indeed, but a lot of pvp will ensue. And pvp doesn't work well when you give players modern day rights to their characters. Giving players modern day rights ( never lose xp or gear, appeal every pvp incident, etc ) creates sensibility within the player base, which in turn creates enormous crap storms.
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!
User avatar
Flasmix
Posts: 2504
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Flasmix »

There is something that could be implemented to stop the "Hey I killed you yesterday" syndrome that came up before.

Have the final divider between UD/Surface be a portal. If someone is killed after using the portal via PvP, the portal will not work for them for 2 RL weeks.

This would work because the DMFI tool already differentiates if someone is a UD character or Surfacer by Mystra's login options when you choose where to go to.

The only way to circumvent this would be via teleporting, but I would be in favour of not allowing teleporting from the Surface to the UD and vice versa. The teleporting system can already tell if you're moving between either by the increased DC.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by TheLier »

What I'm going to say is possibly biased, and is a personal opinion.

That said I would like some reminders that the drow are something everyone, except a very select few, hate. Not for doing evil deeds, altough that is the source of the hatred, but now for existing.

Remember the story Viconia tells you in BG:2? She was nearly killed for being a drow, when the otherwise friendly farmers found it out.

Why?

Becuse people hate the drow that much. Among elves this should be even more severe, considering that their relations with them are even worse (altough at that point, that does not really matter, does it?). I don't say this is how all PCs should react. But NPCs, yeah.

And before gyrm, or any other player who plays those type of toons, take this as a personal attack, I would like to say, that I have respect for doing it differently. But it should be very difficult, and even "good" aligned people could kill you for saying that drow are not evil to their core. If I understand the setting right, they are just like orcs. Evil in nature.

Hating drow and orcs is the norm, everything else means that you are deviant in the eyes of nearly all societs on Faerún.

Regarding rules:
Yes, I would like to see severe punishments for dying in the UD if surfacer and the oppsite too. And I fully support KOS rules. The reason is simple. Against drow (and orcs in my opinion, but that would not work becuse they don't have thier own "safe" areas), some toons would not give an "RP out", they would just attack them and try to kill them. It is fully OOC to give a chance for them to run ( keep in mind, this is not regular PvP, and if you want in the case of drow, treat "not coming to the surface" as the PvP out). And I don't think this is unfair, they came up willingly. Same goes for surfacers in the UD.
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by aaron22 »

TheLier wrote: Regarding rules:
Yes, I would like to see severe punishments for dying in the UD if surfacer and the oppsite too. And I fully support KOS rules. The reason is simple. Against drow (and orcs in my opinion, but that would not work becuse they don't have thier own "safe" areas), some toons would not give an "RP out", they would just attack them and try to kill them. It is fully OOC to give a chance for them to run ( keep in mind, this is not regular PvP, and if you want in the case of drow, treat "not coming to the surface" as the PvP out). And I don't think this is unfair, they came up willingly. Same goes for surfacers in the UD.
+1

inmo this should be the greatest and also most dangerous expedition the game could create. the cost of death there should be great as well.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
User avatar
Aspect of Sorrow
Custom Content
Posts: 2702
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 7:11 pm
Location: Reliquary

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Aspect of Sorrow »

aaron22 wrote:
TheLier wrote: Regarding rules:
Yes, I would like to see severe punishments for dying in the UD if surfacer and the oppsite too. And I fully support KOS rules. The reason is simple. Against drow (and orcs in my opinion, but that would not work becuse they don't have thier own "safe" areas), some toons would not give an "RP out", they would just attack them and try to kill them. It is fully OOC to give a chance for them to run ( keep in mind, this is not regular PvP, and if you want in the case of drow, treat "not coming to the surface" as the PvP out). And I don't think this is unfair, they came up willingly. Same goes for surfacers in the UD.
inmo this should be the greatest and also most dangerous expedition the game could create. the cost of death there should be great as well.
As a primary UDer, this is the message I preached.
User avatar
Flasmix
Posts: 2504
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Flasmix »

The problem with surfacers in the UD is that Sshamath allows people to come in for trade and there are laws that will offer protection to those who can cast Arcane spells. It's a bit rigged in favour of the surfacers.

95% of the surfacers that do come to the UD are evil/self-serving and end up fitting in perfectly anyways.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Boddynock »

This may be a bit off topic, but my problem with the setup we have now has always been the path required for you to go from one to the other. I don't disagree with the trip being difficult, per se, but the way it is now it is SO difficult that it ruins all of the suspense.

For example, Little Bo Peep is herding her sheep on the surface, and is a level 18 ranger (or whatever) and she spots a drow roaming around. From an RP perspective, she should react somehow to that, but in our reality, due to the difficulty of the trip, odds are that drow is lvl 30 or very very close to it. If the trip were manageable for a solid lvl 16-18 party, you would still have that feeling of suspense, that nagging question in the back of your head "What do I do if this goes south? What should I do? Holy crap!" which is what your reaction SHOULD be when seeing a drow.

The way it is now it is more like "Hey there is a lvl 30 here to PVP bait, better go get some epics to come take care of it..."

If the trip were more manageable at a lower level, it would increase the number of people making the trip for reasons other than PVP, it would increase interaction between the two sides, and it will bring back some of that fear of the unknown (Instead of the certainty that the out of place PC is probably lvl 26+).
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by TheLier »

Boddynock wrote:This may be a bit off topic, but my problem with the setup we have now has always been the path required for you to go from one to the other. I don't disagree with the trip being difficult, per se, but the way it is now it is SO difficult that it ruins all of the suspense.

For example, Little Bo Peep is herding her sheep on the surface, and is a level 18 ranger (or whatever) and she spots a drow roaming around. From an RP perspective, she should react somehow to that, but in our reality, due to the difficulty of the trip, odds are that drow is lvl 30 or very very close to it. If the trip were manageable for a solid lvl 16-18 party, you would still have that feeling of suspense, that nagging question in the back of your head "What do I do if this goes south? What should I do? Holy crap!" which is what your reaction SHOULD be when seeing a drow.

The way it is now it is more like "Hey there is a lvl 30 here to PVP bait, better go get some epics to come take care of it..."

If the trip were more manageable at a lower level, it would increase the number of people making the trip for reasons other than PVP, it would increase interaction between the two sides, and it will bring back some of that fear of the unknown (Instead of the certainty that the out of place PC is probably lvl 26+).
Honestly, running away from them is a perfectly valid option too. That is the other reaction which seems logical to me.

Either you try to kill them or run away. Most people would run away, but PCs tend to be different.
User avatar
Blackman D
Retired Staff
Posts: 4818
Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 5:43 am
Location: IL

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Blackman D »

the original passage was manageable in a small group around 18...
everyone is evil till proven otherwise
User avatar
Thorsson
Posts: 1293
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Thorsson »

Blackman D wrote:the original passage was manageable in a small group around 18...
And that worked so well...
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
User avatar
Blackman D
Retired Staff
Posts: 4818
Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 5:43 am
Location: IL

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Blackman D »

well, the issue wasnt with the trip it was more with those who were making it

so what happened? it was completely shut off and then opened up with a wall so high only 30s could get over it
everyone is evil till proven otherwise
DreWalker
Posts: 253
Joined: Wed Mar 20, 2013 12:43 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by DreWalker »

I kinda wonder why going to the surface to Kill and plunder the most epic Dragon on the server isn't acceptable. I dont think you will find too many Drow Grinding on the surface for very long, but if they happen to be there and see a chest why would a full lvl be taken away for looting it? its very not IC to pass treasure up for many toons.

non of my characters desire this, but I think if a Drow wants to risk their life living around surface races that want to kill them, let them. That seems like a really reasonable RP reason to be on the surface. hell even give them a starting point so they dont have to find their way back up after server updates. After they get killed enough times maybe a forced RCR with the 50% xp loss, not just a name change would be a good idea. It should be a very dangerous lifestyle.

Sshamath is a very liberal city compared to a Llothite UD city. surface races can come and trade and I think are even protected from being attacked while inside the city and Varralas passage. This is off topic but It would be fun to have a city where if a surface race entered without a Master, they would be most likely killed or taken. having only one city in the UD is limiting, how many cities are even on the surface? Ive met lots of newcomers to bgtscc that come to the UD wanting that Llothite city experience and I think are disappointed with the only option they get. ((I think this section kinda isnt about the rules the OP posted about but..))

Even if things dont change Ill still be in the UD having a blast like I always have here on this server. Not everyone is as easy to please as myself and I think listening to them could make allot of players time spent on bgtscc much more enjoyable
Irrtana-Yathrin
Draya- surviving
User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Maximvs »

Beyond the drow question, I'd like to give my opinion on what this server currently is, at the core.

The staff that created this server is gone. It was, essentially, inherited. The people now running this server really keeps it as it used to be, which, from an inheritance point of view, is good. You are worthy of it. But you are so worthy, that you change almost nothing. Unable to change with the time. Worthy of inheritance to a fault.

Times change. Here's what changed with the time, and how BG fails to adapt.

1- Kids today do not play roleplaying games anymore. They play hero brawls, shooting games and stuff with more instant action. The average age of people that used to play here 10 years ago was 20 years old average. Now, it's 30. Yet, the server is still PG 13. A PG 16 or 18 would certainly make the underdark a more underdark place to be, and my little finger tells me that the silent majority wants it to be 18.

2- Other, very RP servers died, and the players came back here. Also, people's RP got better in time. The ratio of good RPers versus not so good has increased. Yet, the rules are still written as if poor RP happens all the time. Maybe giving more freedom between UD and Surface would bring back some drama, but I'm pretty sure the drama wouldn't happen as often as it used to be years ago.

3- In time, a server becomes a patched job. So many different people worked on it, things doesn't always make sense anymore. Cohesion fades and is replaced with... weird stuff. Clunky stuff. A great way to counteract that is to just elect a grand master DM artist and let him do whatever he wants to the setting. Paint something wild. Remove the MMO feeling. A council of elders will always yield predictable and boring results.

Either way, the current UD Surface rule and implementation is a horribly outdated, patched work that should be looked at. As in simplified. For example, as the above post says, the risk of perma strike makes the -no grinding on the other side- and -no search for loot- rules pointless.
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!
User avatar
Aspect of Sorrow
Custom Content
Posts: 2702
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 7:11 pm
Location: Reliquary

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Aspect of Sorrow »

Maximvs wrote:The staff that created this server is gone.
I haven't left, only some pauses of activity for various reasons.
Maximvs wrote:1- Kids today do not play roleplaying games anymore. They play hero brawls, shooting games and stuff with more instant action. The average age of people that used to play here 10 years ago was 20 years old average. Now, it's 30. Yet, the server is still PG 13. A PG 16 or 18 would certainly make the underdark a more underdark place to be, and my little finger tells me that the silent majority wants it to be 18.
Suggestive mature themes only should be treated as angles of immersion and not content delivery mechanisms. Player fetishes are often put on display and the representation of a playerbase paralleling Haven and Sinfar isn't in the best interest of all. This isn't to discourage what two players will do under their own communicative medium to further their character plots, but that shouldn't be a selling point for BGTSCC.
Maximvs wrote:2- Other, very RP servers died, and the players came back here. Also, people's RP got better in time. The ratio of good RPers versus not so good has increased. Yet, the rules are still written as if poor RP happens all the time. Maybe giving more freedom between UD and Surface would bring back some drama, but I'm pretty sure the drama wouldn't happen as often as it used to be years ago.
Behaviors can be mitigated through code.
Maximvs wrote:3- In time, a server becomes a patched job. So many different people worked on it, things doesn't always make sense anymore. Cohesion fades and is replaced with... weird stuff. Clunky stuff. A great way to counteract that is to just elect a grand master DM artist and let him do whatever he wants to the setting. Paint something wild. Remove the MMO feeling. A council of elders will always yield predictable and boring results.
I understand your point but one problem the 'council' aspect brings is multiple voices making a decision in the favor of the server, if even contrarian. A single individual calling all of the shots may not have the full answer, or even understanding of problem resolution.
Maximvs wrote:Either way, the current UD Surface rule and implementation is a horribly outdated, patched work that should be looked at. As in simplified. For example, as the above post says, the risk of perma strike makes the -no grinding on the other side- and -no search for loot- rules pointless.
Knowing that it wouldn't be difficult to roll and alt and run the top-side loot runs to hand off to a UD alt in the Nexus (or even through Mudd), I have to agree that there are some unavoidable items on that list that needs revisited.

Return to “General Discussion”