UD/Surface Rules

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Maximvs »

Aspect of Sorrow wrote: Suggestive mature themes only should be treated as angles of immersion and not content delivery mechanisms. Player fetishes are often put on display and the representation of a playerbase paralleling Haven and Sinfar isn't in the best interest of all. This isn't to discourage what two players will do under their own communicative medium to further their character plots, but that shouldn't be a selling point for BGTSCC.
No no no, No ERP, just PG 18 for more details. Dnd is not a sex game. No Haven. No Sinfar. Just lore. A lot of drow dress (fun person), more details allowed when emoting violence, etc.
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!
User avatar
Thorsson
Posts: 1293
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Thorsson »

Maximvs wrote:...my little finger tells me that the silent majority wants it to be 18..
Ah, the good old silent majority. Pretty hard to prove if they stay silent, isn't it?
Maximvs wrote:...just PG 18..
PG18?
What sort of issues might I find in an 18 film or video?

18 works are for adults and can contain strong issues such as:

very strong violence
frequent strong language (e.g. 'f***') and / or very strong language (e.g. ‘c***’)
strong portrayals of sexual activity
scenes of sexual violence
strong horror
strong blood and gore
real sex (in some circumstances)
Which of those do you want?
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
xLegionx
Posts: 113
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2012 8:09 pm
Location: United States

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by xLegionx »

I thought Drizzt was the only real good drow to have ever been encountered on the surface? Or am I wrong? Idk if playing a good drow on the surface is a real possibility.

Also, idk why drow would want to come to the surface aside from raiding at night? The drow I believe are aware that they are weakened by sunlight or blinded by sunlight I think due to light sensitivity so roaming around during the day will be a big pain for them as opposed to the underdark where they aren't affected by sunlight or anything similar plus they are familiar with the underdark which is dotted with caverns, caves, and mushroom forests as opposed to the surface which has green tree forests, deserts, snow and mountains which are completely foreign and nonexistent in the underdark so I mean. . . being on the surface to them would probably be more of a punishment than a blessing. Running up to the surface just to kill stuff is more of an OOC reason than an IC reason and in my opinion is not a good enough reason for a drow to want to go to the surface because as I stated the surface is completely foreign to them and they will have a lot of trouble adapting to it for a good long while.

You want an IC reason to run up to the surface? Put your drow in a situation where he is literally forced to run up to the surface such as having all the great houses of the drow wanting you dead for instance or maybe he is being hunted by mind flayers and beholders or something.
Thorsson wrote:What happened last time is this:

1. Numbers of Drow were bigger, because without the restrictions lots of people wanted to be Drizzt-a-likes; i.e. the power of Drow without any drawbacks (even light sensitivity is mechanically bugged)

2. There were constant streams of Drow on the surface, acting like they owned the place

3. Most actively sought PvP, often with lower level surface characters

I really don't want to go back to those days.
Yeah seeing this every evil player I've encountered so far wants to run around with their super op mechanically based evil character and take pleasure in trying to destroy every rp based good character they run across. Most of all, people want their precious evil drow on the surface so that they can make use of their op spell resistance, high ability bonuses, and extra drow abilities that they get to stomp every surfacer that gets in their way. I've yet to see an evil character that actually turns their evil character into a creative and memorable villain as opposed to an evil character that runs around trying to wreak havoc where they can.

You want to make a creative villain? Give him a goal such as attempting to topple the dukes. Or trying to make himself a duke so that he can command and corrupt authority in the name of his god (bane would give countless blessings for the worshiper that accomplishes this I imagine). And then figure out on your own how your character would try to do that and work with a willing dm and other players on trying to accomplish your goal. That's something that can be done right? Or am I wrong?
"You must not fight too often with one enemy, or you will teach him all your art of war."

Loghain Keswick- Paladin of Tyr and Squire of the radiant heart-(biography-reediting)
ctothep
Posts: 484
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2014 7:06 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by ctothep »

Drizzt is not the only one, there are many more.

Both Eilistraee and Vhaeraun want to see drow live on the surface again.
Characters:

Zaraun - Vhaeraunite Deathsinger, School of Illusions and Phantasm

Retired Characters:

Iston - Lost within the void ... (deceased)
User avatar
Endelyon
Posts: 3606
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2014 4:24 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Endelyon »

@ last poster:
Lore-wise, there are pockets of good-natured Eilistraean drow all over the surface, even some as close as the Reaching Woods.

I don't have a stake in this argument, I just wanted to chime in for the minor lore correction. :)
xLegionx
Posts: 113
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2012 8:09 pm
Location: United States

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by xLegionx »

"Oh. . .well, I guess I'll have to read up on the lore based around them then. Sorry for my ignorance." :D
"You must not fight too often with one enemy, or you will teach him all your art of war."

Loghain Keswick- Paladin of Tyr and Squire of the radiant heart-(biography-reediting)
User avatar
Moltrazahn
Posts: 915
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:33 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Moltrazahn »

These discussion UD/Surface pops up every so often, so instead of adding to all the "Bad case senarios" I think ill give some of the good ones I've had.

Once upon a tine, I played my Teifling Warlock!
I remember the day clearly... I was at the Fai, just Roleplaying .. and was 300ish exp of level 30. Then... RANDOM EVENT HAPPENS! - In this case, undead swarm the FaI. The merri adventures happily go about their buisness slaughtering. As do i, thinking "Yay! level 30 here i come!" - Problem is, i end up with undead on all sides, low hp... So i Panic and do the stupid thing, i Use vamperic feast. SURE! It kills the undead, but being stupid, i just used an outlawed spell. This promtly results in a certian mr. Thedran "the" rock walking up to me, and decapitating my warlock.

Having played the "But im not evil!" card for a while, I totally panicked at this. So, whats a sane Teifling warlock to do? ... after getting ressed... I FLEAD like there was no Tomorrow to the underdark.

Image

Now, server-rules back then stated that "you needed a good reason to be in the UD". I figured "fleeing for my life because I thought Thedran would finish the job"- fitted that discription quite well!

Ergo, I went to the UD, and after a few months even got a spawnpoint set up so I did'nt have to run every login. And over the next 8-10 months ish, my character pratically lived in the UD. Now, being a surfacer (granted Tieflings can now start both places) made it a challange, because Drow are Drow, so I was kissing rears like there was no tomorrow. But everyone seemed to have fun, and there was never any PvP conflicts what so ever. IT was fun, immersive and I would later make an UD character just because the general playerbase of the UD are truly awesome folks. Helpful and fun to play with.

While down there, I requested a rebuild (this was before RcR) so I could actually forget Vamperic feast... which rp-wise was fun to do! Plus... I could ague that he "changed his ways to a degree" when it came to draining life-force >.> (Dont do drugs kids).
Anywho. I eventually ran out of patience to wait for Thedran to stop playing, so I came back up. And would'nt you know it he is the first person I Run into... I hoped that he forgot... But 15 min into our conversation, he looks to my character casually and goes... "So... You done with casting horrible spells round' 'ere?" - TO which I lowerd my head, and replyed "Yes sir".

The point of this small tale, is that if you just respect each other, UD/Surface rp can be an immensely fun, and character developing experience! - Yes, there will always be bad apples, but we can't prevent those folks from comming on either side, so best deal with them as they come. And where not everyone wants to go up/down on the same therms or are willing to submit to the ruling majorities laws (aka: "Kissing a##") as my character did... I have pretty much only good adventures to tell from the UD/Surface interaction... and they ain't bad, infact... most are quite fond memories of mine :).. Even that one where Hinzel got sacrificed to Lolth! (But its oke... he got better :mrgreen:)

So the rules can be laxed a bit, but not for the ones who wish to abuse them. Now true, various characters have various reasons... But unless your on a crusade... Few non-psycotic individuels will take a several weeks trip up or down "Just to kill people and wreck someones campfire", and is natrually not the proper thing to do - As for what justifies abuse, neglect or ignorance of the rules... well thats what the community is here for, and given that we all play on this server, we (and the staff) do have an obligation to help uphold the rules of the server.

Anywho. My five cent in the bag.
Last edited by Moltrazahn on Thu Jun 23, 2016 4:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
Za'than Za'amal(Elsewhere!)
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)

Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"

"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
User avatar
metaquad4
Posts: 1532
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by metaquad4 »

PG18 wrote:very strong violence
frequent strong language (e.g. 'f***') and / or very strong language (e.g. ‘c***’)
strong portrayals of sexual activity
scenes of sexual violence
strong horror
strong blood and gore
real sex (in some circumstances)
I'll cross off those ones, as we already have them on the server. And, for the rest of them, we have skype/haven alts for those. "c***" would be nice to say once in a while, but, if the rule-makers want to hold on to their judeo-christian values, then all the stuff they don't like can be kept underground (like it is now. Its present, just kept out of their eyes).

Of late, I have noticed that drug-related RP (and even poison related RP, as poisons are 'drugging' people) has been becoming punished as well in numerous cases. On 'moral' issues.

Apparently, these people's morals condones violence, racism, genocide, torture (yes, it happens. Don't pretend that it doesn't. There have even been public whippings via the shout channel done by DMs, as a more wide-spread example), etc but drugs, swearing, sex, etc? No, no. That is bad. If the argument is on a moral basis, the people who make that argument seriously need to examine their own morals.

D&D is not a kiddie place. Its not a carebear land filled with sunshine and unicorns. So, don't pretend it is. That is just demeaning the setting, and demolishing it. If you want to make a server like that, make nwn2's first MLP server.

If you don't want ERP, its simple. Tell people to keep it in tells or ban it, whilst still making the server 18+. That is simple enough, and has been done before on most other servers, if not all of them.

Also, bear in mind. By promoting PG-13 rules, you also promote an immature "13 year old" mindset. So don't be shocked when some of your players turn out to be brats. You invited them in, and that PG-13 reminds them that immature ('teenagerish') bickering and complaining is acceptable.
Last edited by metaquad4 on Thu Jun 23, 2016 4:47 am, edited 2 times in total.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
Kagger911
Posts: 432
Joined: Sat Sep 07, 2013 5:57 pm
Location: USA, Florida

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Kagger911 »

metaquad4 wrote:Of late, I have noticed that drug-related RP (and even poison related RP, as poisons are 'drugging' people) has been becoming punished as well in numerous cases. On 'moral' issues.


Wait, the Dms didn't allow someone to get poisoned, why?
Kagger Redyard
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=kagger
"Finally found where I belong."

Amabiro "Shekels" Shyste


"How can I be of service today?"
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Boddynock »

Kagger911 wrote:
metaquad4 wrote:Of late, I have noticed that drug-related RP (and even poison related RP, as poisons are 'drugging' people) has been becoming punished as well in numerous cases. On 'moral' issues.


Wait, the Dms didn't allow someone to get poisoned, why?
Wait, what?
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Kagger911
Posts: 432
Joined: Sat Sep 07, 2013 5:57 pm
Location: USA, Florida

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Kagger911 »

Boddynock wrote:
Kagger911 wrote:
metaquad4 wrote:Of late, I have noticed that drug-related RP (and even poison related RP, as poisons are 'drugging' people) has been becoming punished as well in numerous cases. On 'moral' issues.


Wait, the Dms didn't allow someone to get poisoned, why?
Wait, what?
Apparently one of my few ways of assassinating seems to be moot now, great. I'm done, take care everyone.
Kagger Redyard
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=kagger
"Finally found where I belong."

Amabiro "Shekels" Shyste


"How can I be of service today?"
User avatar
metaquad4
Posts: 1532
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by metaquad4 »

*The train quakes slightly, then is slammed off its tracks.* D:

As a partial remedy for contributing to the slamming off the tracks:
Hidden: show
DM Theophanies wrote:I do not wish to derail the thread so i'll start a new one.

Subject: Brain-storming the Underdark / Surface interaction
Flasmix wrote:It is in my opinion that a minority has ruined any surface/UD interaction for the majority. The minority being those who just go to the surface for just PvP purposes. I would like to see the UD/Surface rules slackened to where those who wish to travel can do so freely, but if it's just for PvP and there's repeated complaints about someone, they get punished directly.

To be honest, the current method of enforcement is just in place due to laziness and not wanting to enforce anything.
I noticed a trend in the thread with issues of how the rules are but I find it very hard to get anything actionable from references to the entire ruling. I'll post them below. Please identify what seems to be tripping people up and why. Please be concise and on point. This is a survey more than a discussion on what the rules should be.
– Surface/UD Travel!
-You can be on the other side, but have some roleplay reason to be there (not just an excuse to grind or PvP). Stating that you are there to defeat such and such creature, or to test your skill is not a valid RP reason, that is grinding. We also do not consider general exploration, or Drow raids on the surface as a valid RP reason, although such can be fodder for DM moderated events. Please PM the team regarding this.

Valid RP reasons outside of the above are defined widely and do not require prior DM approval. Examples include meeting another PC to trade, or to RP over religion, or to establish contacts with another guild. We would ask however that you are able to state your reasons when a DM asks and abide by any decision that is made. Please note that it is not valid to grind once the reasons for travelling to the surface or underdark are complete. Stating that you are meeting a PC in Sshamath to acquire via trade rare and valuable items is a valid reason but grinding afterwards with your trading partner is still grinding.

The barrier between the Surface and UD is the Netherese Ruins. Those caught grinding on the opposite side of the Ruins from where they belong will be penalized from 1+ levels to being banned from the server.

Surfacers in the Underdark and Underdark-based characters on the Surface are consenting to certain criteria and vulnerabilities:
- You cannot grind monsters for experience
- You cannot search for loot (exploring dungeons for treasure, picking at gold piles, etc)
- You may not run quests
- If slain in PvP, you may be issued a permastrike. Your character can afford three permastrikes (Permastrike rules: http://www.bgtscc.net/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=25355)

The intent of this is to allow opportunity for ROLEPLAY and this is why we define RP reasons widely. It is not an opportunity to exploit different areas for their resources. The server is designed to allow both sides their share of quests, monsters and dungeons. Taking advantage of both sides is against the intent of our area builders and server design.

We also ask that players are respectful of the setting given the leniency of these rules. On the surface NPCs should be regarded as universally hostile to Underdark PCs and so maps with NPCs should be avoided where possible without DM supervision. In the Underdark, the peculiarities of Sshamath's lore should be respected and the Underdark itself should be considered a dangerous and hostile place. While we wish to facilitate roleplay between surface and Underdark we do not want to erode the setting and so may intervene in RP that is immersion breaking.

The DM team reminds Drow race players that Drow races would feel rather out of place on the surface in many respects even beyond just surface race hostility to them. We ask for the sake of proper lore immersion relating the race on the surface for Drow on the surface to be RPed as such. For example, Drow not living on the surface for a long period of time would have a strong negative physiological reaction to sunlight and other bright sources of light, and open spaces.

We note that the same goes for those visiting the Underdark. Lorewise these caverns are a dangerous, dark and confusing warren and we would ask players to observe their character's limitations as well as RPing around the hazard that travel through the Underdark would represent.
Honestly, I think most of this is fine. I remember earlier, there was some debate over what constituted "valid RP" for surface-to-UD or vise-versa, but, this new rule phrasing seems to have corrected that.

I imagine some people might have issue with certain DM rulings with "We would ask however that you are able to state your reasons when a DM asks and abide by any decision that is made.". If they feel the decision was made arbatrarily, then, they might have an issue. But, that comes with the terrority of people. There are good and bad ones.

Also, from what I've heard from my friends, punishments have historically been severe. I remember (a long time ago) one of my contacts had all their items taken away from them (and I think there was a de-level, too).

For this one:

"If slain in PvP, you may be issued a permastrike."

I know from present experience (and I did do a little test with a black skinned elf, though, I did not take screenshots of it. I'm sure I could do it again and get screenshots of this) that there is a LOT of meta gaming (even reports from my friends of DM metagaming, though, no names were mentioned. I hope they were reported to the HDMs or the Admin.) in particular surrounding drow on the surface. Was this considered, with regard to this ruling? Because, I could see that situation become sticky really quickly. Imo, perma-strikes should only even be given with DM oversight of the situation.

Finally, I wouldn't mind some clarify on this one:

"The barrier between the Surface and UD is the Netherese Ruins. Those caught grinding on the opposite side of the Ruins"

What do you mean by "the other side of the Ruins"? Given it is one giant maze map. Or did you mean, just grinding on surface for a UD char or in the UD for a surface character?
Last edited by metaquad4 on Thu Jun 23, 2016 5:12 am, edited 1 time in total.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Boddynock »

Simmer down you two, no one even got a chance to respond yet. :roll:
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
Kagger911
Posts: 432
Joined: Sat Sep 07, 2013 5:57 pm
Location: USA, Florida

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Kagger911 »

Boddynock wrote:Simmer down you two, no one even got a chance to respond yet. :roll:
Don't need it. I'm tired of the constant "moral" issues. If I wanted to play ''Sjw the game'' I'd be sitting in club penguin.
DM Theo edit: removed image due to language.
Kagger Redyard
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=kagger
"Finally found where I belong."

Amabiro "Shekels" Shyste


"How can I be of service today?"
User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Maximvs »

Thorsson wrote: Ah, the good old silent majority. Pretty hard to prove if they stay silent, isn't it?
That's how it always is, everywhere. People siding with the current rulers/owners/whatever being vocal because they won't get any problems out of it, where as others that disagree with stuff just keep quiet because they can only get problems out of it. Heck, do you know how many people side with the local authority on any and every subject, without even questioning any subject themselves prior to casting their vote?

Note that I'm not saying the BG staff will give you crap if you do voice a negative opinion, just that it is like that -everywhere- in life. And honestly, I wish people would understand how laughable it is to have 30 year olds fighting tooth and nail to keep a world PG 13.
Last edited by Maximvs on Thu Jun 23, 2016 9:15 am, edited 2 times in total.
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!

Return to “General Discussion”