The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole road.

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Ithilan
Posts: 839
Joined: Sun Oct 04, 2009 11:37 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Ithilan »

Flasmix wrote:Quick way to solve the problem; Move the Campfire to be in front of the FAI so the guards would see it.
Or inside the walls, the garden of the FAI is a spot far to rarely used.

But hey everyone might just run back up to the bridge campfire outside the Phoenix Lodge, like in the old days :P I think it will be reoccuring tbh. and it is each individuals responsibility to be considerate of your fellow players when interacting with them, no matter alignment, race or what not.
User avatar
Moltrazahn
Posts: 915
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:33 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Moltrazahn »

Ithilan wrote:
Flasmix wrote:Quick way to solve the problem; Move the Campfire to be in front of the FAI so the guards would see it.
Or inside the walls, the garden of the FAI is a spot far to rarely used.

But hey everyone might just run back up to the bridge campfire outside the Phoenix Lodge, like in the old days :P I think it will be reoccuring tbh. and it is each individuals responsibility to be considerate of your fellow players when interacting with them, no matter alignment, race or what not.
Image

Precious memories!

Also, +1! good post.
Za'than Za'amal(Elsewhere!)
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)

Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"

"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
User avatar
Flasmix
Posts: 2504
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Flasmix »

Ithilan wrote: But hey everyone might just run back up to the bridge campfire outside the Phoenix Lodge, like in the old days :P
I think people like the bit of protection offered in these areas. When I was in the Fist, we'd have Fisters standing on the bridge over watching the Campfire and people always came there. The reason people flocked to the FAI is because it's pretty much the hub between each city/RP location with only 2-3 transitions separating the most popular places.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
User avatar
Ithilan
Posts: 839
Joined: Sun Oct 04, 2009 11:37 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Ithilan »

Flasmix wrote: I think people like the bit of protection offered in these areas. When I was in the Fist, we'd have Fisters standing on the bridge over watching the Campfire and people always came there. The reason people flocked to the FAI is because it's pretty much the hub between each city/RP location with only 2-3 transitions separating the most popular places.
Its location no doubt plays a part and tbh most violence that occured around the fire in the old days involved you Fisters :twisted: 8-)

Also Molt, lol @ that picture.

But before I go completely off topic, wouldnt it be best to have a general ruling that PvP in these guarded areas would result in IC punishment? I had some guy shoot me in the face with a bow once inside the FAI, he ran through 4 zones before I caught him and he instantly logged of. Situations like that (although hilarious) should be impossible from an IC perspective.. I imagine there are guards patrolling the walls of the FAI as well, if he saw someone attack another by the fire, well.. no more adventuring when you take an arrow to the knee.
AlwaysSummer Day
Recognized Donor
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Jun 24, 2012 11:27 pm
Location: Detroit, Michigan

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by AlwaysSummer Day »

Torgerias wrote:So is it obvious yet why people are confused? The official server rules say one thing. Rasael says something that backs that up. The DMs say something that is contradictory to the server rules and Rasael's explanation.
What you quote is not contradictory.

Image

If I tell you "no throwing apples is allowed in the park" and someone else says "no throwing fruit in the park" we are not contradicting each other. I am simply being specific. Honestly though the ruling is fairly obvious. Contact a DM beforehand or walk one transition in any direction to avoid headache. Any discussion about the clearness of the ruling is really just splitting hairs.
Roland; svirfneblin fist of the forest and eco terrorist.
Heinrich Von Rittermark; Everwatch Knights of Helm
Frederick Von Rittermark; Paladin of Azuth/Mystra
Erik Von Rittermark; Unknown
kellendril
Posts: 992
Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2010 7:53 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by kellendril »

Friendly forum moderator reminder to please not let this discussion slip into a flame fest. It has some of the feel of being on that cliff right now, so just remember everyone, keep it civil please! Thanks!
Eowiel Le'liana - Formerly Respected Councilor/Citizen of Doron Amar, now Disrespected Free Agent
Merry Angalagaleil - Strongheart Halfling Sacred Fist
Torgerias
Posts: 153
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 2:31 pm
Location: GMT -4:00

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Torgerias »

AlwaysSummer Day wrote:If I tell you "no throwing apples is allowed in the park" and someone else says "no throwing fruit in the park" we are not contradicting each other. I am simply being specific. Honestly though the ruling is fairly obvious. Contact a DM beforehand or walk one transition in any direction to avoid headache. Any discussion about the clearness of the ruling is really just splitting hairs.
Sure it's contradictory when one rule says that pvp anywhere on any map that has guards on it is verboten (and specifically mentions the FAI) but then another rule, in a completely different location, says that it is only against the rules if pvp takes place in certain parts of the FAI map. This isn't an "All apples are fruit but not all fruit are apples" type of situation, but two rules about the same map that say very different things. You probably could argue that the DM ruling specifies the original rule only if the original rule didn't specifically mention the FAI already. To use your analogy, it's like one sign saying "No throwing fruit anywhere in the park," and another sign across the lawn saying "No throwing fruit anywhere in the park, except on Sundays." Which one do you obey?

Yes, that is splitting hairs, but that's important because what matters is squaring the broader rule in the official server rules to incorporate the more recent and specific DM ruling, right? The DM decision needs to be incorporated in the server rules if the decision is in fact part of the server rules, because the server rules are required reading for players. Unless we're also going to make the DM decisions thread required reading (and even then, again, when you have two different rules saying different things, it is confusing and, yes, contradictory).

Many players on this server love to point to the rules to justify their actions or decry the actions of others, and I'd bet that inconsistencies like this only serve to make their rule-mongering worse for DMs to deal with.
Last edited by Torgerias on Mon Jul 25, 2016 7:41 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Zeligus Cromwell - Faithful of The Black Hand
Oderin Eldoth - Diplomatic Red Wizard Happily Returned to Thay
Jonathan Proudmoore - Knight of Torm Missing in Action
User avatar
Maecius
Retired Admin
Posts: 11639
Joined: Sat May 16, 2009 4:24 pm

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Maecius »

It's a fair point, Torgerias, and we probably do want to do a rules review, not least because of all that's changed on the server with regards to both mechanics and roleplay norms.

It won't happen overnight, though, if it happens at all this year: We haven't seriously taken a long, hard look at the rules since 2014, and it took DM Novus and the DM team many weeks of discussion and drafting before they came up with the most recent rules rewrite.

I do agree with the sentiment that DM rulings should be more related to "RP rulings and guidance," where the server rules should be locked in place as concrete "law." Some of the rulings that are currently "DM Rulings" probably could stand to be updated and moved over to the "PVP Rules."

It's something worth looking at, in any case, and I expect it is something the DMs will take a look at once they are able to; although right now the big, main, immediate goal, I think, is to onboard our new DM selectees and get them trained to go.
User avatar
Xanfyrst
Posts: 1274
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2009 2:12 am
Location: In Sierante's naughty dreams

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Xanfyrst »

Maybe have some of the more "vague" rules be put up for public discussion among DMs and players alike. DMs can still make the decision, but having some constructive discussion with the player-base can be good. And the players might also feel like they're being heard even if they aren't part of the decision making. Just a thought.
SANITY IS FOR THE WEAK.
Alistair the Red - Roaming Bounty Hunter and Underworld Contact.
Lord Eliphas Valkarian "the Deceiver" -Chosen Prophet of Bane, Autonomous Agent of the Zhentarim. Immortal? ×Returned from the Beyond×
Tsidkenu

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Tsidkenu »

What would be awesome was if all 'NPC-guard map PvP' rules were canned entirely and replaced with lay-on-of-hands scripts. So when PvP occurs outside the FAI, for example, the victor gets variable put on their Status Widget which marks them as being unwelcome in that city/area. Scripts (like the FAI guards one that turf out masked people) then prevent the character from entering FAI/ city/ town until the next reset with an IC message, "Troublemakers like you are not welcome here! Get lost!"

In more lawful areas (eg. BG city), assailants should be arrested and jailed, and upon release the banishment scripts apply until next reset.
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Boddynock »

Tsidkenu wrote:What would be awesome was if all 'NPC-guard map PvP' rules were canned entirely and replaced with lay-on-of-hands scripts. So when PvP occurs outside the FAI, for example, the victor gets variable put on their Status Widget which marks them as being unwelcome in that city/area. Scripts (like the FAI guards one that turf out masked people) then prevent the character from entering FAI/ city/ town until the next reset with an IC message, "Troublemakers like you are not welcome here! Get lost!"

In more lawful areas (eg. BG city), assailants should be arrested and jailed, and upon release the banishment scripts apply until next reset.
That would be pretty cool actually. But in the case of cities where arrests happen, the jail time IS the punishment, right? There is no need for both to my mind.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
DM Echo
Posts: 471
Joined: Sat Jul 25, 2015 4:36 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by DM Echo »

DM Theophanies wrote:
Subject: DM Rulings: A Record of DM Decisions
Administrator wrote:
PVP and the Friendly Arm Inn
On PvP: PvP on this map is not allowed inside the courtyard of the Inn, in front of the gate to the Inn or in front of the Order of the Silver Rose Keep.
The Friendly Arm Inn offers a safe haven along the dangerous Trade Way. The road itself enjoys the occassional Flaming Fist patrol from up Baldur's way. But that alone does little to make roadside campsites safe places of respite. Therefor we, as hosts, urge you to find shelter within our guarded walls. What occurs outside our walls does not concern us, lest they are the fruits of an open assault upon our keep. We are a business, however, and so will not allow brawling right before our gates which could harm paying customers. ((OOC: This means PVP at or before the FAI gate should be DM supervised as Bentley's guards will intervene to protect his business))
Screenshots sent to the DM Staff clearly showing any PC initiating PvP in front of guards (FAI, BG, any MAP with an NPC guard on it) may equal either a hanging and/or simple perma-strike against that PC, unless a DM is present to oversee the PvP conflict. This is non-negotiable. Note that RP'ed PVP, such as emotes indicating violence, may well fall within this definition. Its best to consider it does.
It is not contradictory..

One is saying Absolutely no PVP in the FAI courtyard, in front of the gate or in front of the Order of the Silver Rose guards.

The other is saying any PvP that takes place on a map where guards are present or in front of NPCs must be supervised by a DM...

Note the second half of that.. 99% of the problem that we have with PvP is people ignoring NPCs.. NPCs react.. How they will react you do not know.. You may think you know.. You may think they don't care.. And they might not.. But you making that decision equals god moding those NPCs.

The rule is simple.. Are there guards on the map? If yes, contact a DM.

Are there NPCs in view? If yes, contact a DM.

If no to both, then PvP away..

If yes to either.. Are you in the middle of BG, FAI courtyard, Naskel, or Beregost?.. If yes, likely the guards would break it up the moment swords were drawn if not before.. Or break you the moment you took your first swing..

Assume your character knows that and is as scared to draw their sword in those situations as you would be to draw a gun in the middle of a police station..

It seems simple to me..

Edit:
...So now I got a question about in front of guild guards.. Yes, the rule also applies to guild guards in both "Are there guards present" and "Are there NPCs present".. As guild guards are.. guards.. and NPCs.. Soo.. hope that clears that up..

Edit the edit lol:

So I misunderstood the question.. The question I got was- Would a player of a guild need DM supervision to PvP in front of his own guild guards. My answer was as follows:
DM Echo wrote:Any time PvP occurs in front of NPCs, NPCs react. A player, be they of the same faction as the NPC or... IDC if they are the son of said NPC.. the player does not get to decide how the NPC will react.. Period. DMs RP NPCs, not players. Players choosing how an NPC will react is god modding and is not allowed.
I think all these "situational" questions are ignoring the spirit of the rules, and trying to find ways to etch out situations where PvP might be allowed in guarded areas without DM supervision..

Guys.. Don't be Gargauth worshipers..
He embodied the inevitable decay and corruption that accompanied all self-serving, greedy, and power-hungry leaders and groups. Gargauth held to the letter of any agreement, not the spirit, and relished betraying anyone with whom he forged a pact by twisting the contract to serve his own ends.
Be Hoar worshipers..
Uphold true and fitting justice and maintain the spirit of the law, not the letter of the law.
At least how I take that.. Don't try to lawyer every rule.. Understand the purpose of the rule and follow that.. The rule is.. PvP in NPC areas should be overseen by a DM.. It is due to people lawyering the rules to death that the rules get more and more lengthy and convoluted to the point of even confusing us at times..
User avatar
grymhild
Recognized Donor
Posts: 585
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
Location: Chicago, IL

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by grymhild »

DM Echo,

Are you suggesting that hostile RP or PVP by the campfire outside of the Friendly Arm Inn without DM supervision is a rules violation?
User avatar
matelener
Retired Staff
Posts: 972
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 6:02 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by matelener »

grymhild wrote:DM Echo,

Are you suggesting that hostile RP or PVP by the campfire outside of the Friendly Arm Inn without DM supervision is a rules violation?
No. He clearly stated that PvP needs be supervised if you're in sight of NPCs. There are no NPCs present at the campfire near FAI. The 3 guarded areas in FAI are: the courtyard of the inn, the gate of the inn, the gate of the Silver Rose keep.
User avatar
Lux
Retired Staff
Posts: 589
Joined: Wed Jun 17, 2015 11:52 am
Location: In a meadow somewhere

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Lux »

Tsidkenu wrote:What would be awesome was if all 'NPC-guard map PvP' rules were canned entirely and replaced with lay-on-of-hands scripts. So when PvP occurs outside the FAI, for example, the victor gets variable put on their Status Widget which marks them as being unwelcome in that city/area. Scripts (like the FAI guards one that turf out masked people) then prevent the character from entering FAI/ city/ town until the next reset with an IC message, "Troublemakers like you are not welcome here! Get lost!"

In more lawful areas (eg. BG city), assailants should be arrested and jailed, and upon release the banishment scripts apply until next reset.
+1

On the topic of what rules actually apply at the FAI campfire, I'm pretty sure there's a loading screen that says that guards are keeping an eye on it and that lawlessness won't be tolerated.
What we see depends mainly on what we look for

Return to “General Discussion”