DM Theophanies wrote:
Subject: DM Rulings: A Record of DM Decisions
Administrator wrote:
PVP and the Friendly Arm Inn
On PvP: PvP on this map is not allowed inside the courtyard of the Inn, in front of the gate to the Inn or in front of the Order of the Silver Rose Keep.
The Friendly Arm Inn offers a safe haven along the dangerous Trade Way. The road itself enjoys the occassional Flaming Fist patrol from up Baldur's way. But that alone does little to make roadside campsites safe places of respite. Therefor we, as hosts, urge you to find shelter within our guarded walls. What occurs outside our walls does not concern us, lest they are the fruits of an open assault upon our keep. We are a business, however, and so will not allow brawling right before our gates which could harm paying customers. ((OOC: This means PVP at or before the FAI gate should be DM supervised as Bentley's guards will intervene to protect his business))
Screenshots sent to the DM Staff clearly showing any PC initiating PvP in front of guards (FAI, BG, any MAP with an NPC guard on it) may equal either a hanging and/or simple perma-strike against that PC, unless a DM is present to oversee the PvP conflict. This is non-negotiable. Note that RP'ed PVP, such as emotes indicating violence, may well fall within this definition. Its best to consider it does.
It is not contradictory..
One is saying Absolutely no PVP in the FAI courtyard, in front of the gate or in front of the Order of the Silver Rose guards.
The other is saying any PvP that takes place on a map where guards are present or in front of NPCs must be supervised by a DM...
Note the second half of that.. 99% of the problem that we have with PvP is people ignoring NPCs.. NPCs react.. How they will react you do not know.. You may think you know.. You may think they don't care.. And they might not.. But you making that decision equals god moding those NPCs.
The rule is simple.. Are there guards on the map? If yes, contact a DM.
Are there NPCs in view? If yes, contact a DM.
If no to both, then PvP away..
If yes to either.. Are you in the middle of BG, FAI courtyard, Naskel, or Beregost?.. If yes, likely the guards would break it up the moment swords were drawn if not before.. Or break you the moment you took your first swing..
Assume your character knows that and is as scared to draw their sword in those situations as you would be to draw a gun in the middle of a police station..
It seems simple to me..
Edit:
...So now I got a question about in front of guild guards.. Yes, the rule also applies to guild guards in both "Are there guards present" and "Are there NPCs present".. As guild guards are.. guards.. and NPCs.. Soo.. hope that clears that up..
Edit the edit lol:
So I misunderstood the question.. The question I got was- Would a player of a guild need DM supervision to PvP in front of his own guild guards. My answer was as follows:
DM Echo wrote:Any time PvP occurs in front of NPCs, NPCs react. A player, be they of the same faction as the NPC or... IDC if they are the son of said NPC.. the player does not get to decide how the NPC will react.. Period. DMs RP NPCs, not players. Players choosing how an NPC will react is god modding and is not allowed.
I think all these "situational" questions are ignoring the spirit of the rules, and trying to find ways to etch out situations where PvP might be allowed in guarded areas without DM supervision..
Guys.. Don't be Gargauth worshipers..
He embodied the inevitable decay and corruption that accompanied all self-serving, greedy, and power-hungry leaders and groups. Gargauth held to the letter of any agreement, not the spirit, and relished betraying anyone with whom he forged a pact by twisting the contract to serve his own ends.
Be Hoar worshipers..
Uphold true and fitting justice and maintain the spirit of the law, not the letter of the law.
At least how I take that.. Don't try to lawyer every rule.. Understand the purpose of the rule and follow that.. The rule is.. PvP in NPC areas should be overseen by a DM.. It is due to people lawyering the rules to death that the rules get more and more lengthy and convoluted to the point of even confusing us at times..