The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole road.

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
V'rass
Posts: 1251
Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2015 1:48 pm
Location: Concord, N.H., USSA

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by V'rass »

That was back when the fist actually patrolled the fai road... that ceased many years ago im told.
"To understand magic one must first understand magic."






Agathion Benedictus: Holy Priest. Retired for now.
Tiax Rules-All: Gnomish madman. Retired permanently.
Exordius Vrass: Cleric/Mage. Currently active.
Tsidkenu

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Tsidkenu »

Prior to Amn-Gate War, I believe. The Treaty of Beregost stopped most Flaming Fist patrols south of Wyrm's Crossing.

At one stage there was actually a Fist officer garrisoned at the FAI; that is clearly no longer the case though.
Torgerias
Posts: 153
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 2:31 pm
Location: GMT -4:00

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Torgerias »

DM Echo wrote: The rule is simple.. Are there guards on the map? If yes, contact a DM.

Are there NPCs in view? If yes, contact a DM.

If no to both, then PvP away..
See, this is even more confusing. We've already had DMs in this very thread say that even though there are guards on the FAI map, as long as PvP happens outside of the apparently designated areas (courtyard, in front of gates, in front of OSR keep) it's ok, but your post contradicts that.

Let me break it down:

-Your post says that if there are guards on the map, you contact a DM because PvP without DM supervision is disallowed on maps where guards are present.

-There are guards present on the FAI map.

-Therefore, any PvP anywhere on the FAI map shouldn't be allowed (without DM supervision) according to your post.

-This is the opposite of what other DMs here have said, which is that you can PvP on the FAI map without DM supervision as long as you are outside of the designated areas (which are, again, the courtyard, in front of the gate, and in front of the OSR keep). That's what you call a contradiction.

I don't see how this isn't an obvious problem to have so many different rulings posted in so many different places. I'm not trying to pick apart the rules, but this is actually a big deal for characters who are frequently attacked by others, and every additional DM post about it only serves to confuse things more. Like I've said all along, I'm just trying to find clarity here. I thought we had done that, and the only issue was fixing the wording in the official rules, but with the above post we're back to confusion again.

If the DMs can't even be consistent in their explanations of this rule, how can players be expected to understand and follow it?
Zeligus Cromwell - Faithful of The Black Hand
Oderin Eldoth - Diplomatic Red Wizard Happily Returned to Thay
Jonathan Proudmoore - Knight of Torm Missing in Action
User avatar
grymhild
Recognized Donor
Posts: 585
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
Location: Chicago, IL

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by grymhild »

Torgerias wrote:
DM Echo wrote: The rule is simple.. Are there guards on the map? If yes, contact a DM.

Are there NPCs in view? If yes, contact a DM.

If no to both, then PvP away..
Hidden: show
See, this is even more confusing. We've already had DMs in this very thread say that even though there are guards on the FAI map, as long as PvP happens outside of the apparently designated areas (courtyard, in front of gates, in front of OSR keep) it's ok, but your post contradicts that.

Let me break it down:

-Your post says that if there are guards on the map, you contact a DM because PvP without DM supervision is disallowed on maps where guards are present.

-There are guards present on the FAI map.

-Therefore, any PvP anywhere on the FAI map shouldn't be allowed (without DM supervision) according to your post.

-This is the opposite of what other DMs here have said, which is that you can PvP on the FAI map without DM supervision as long as you are outside of the designated areas (which are, again, the courtyard, in front of the gate, and in front of the OSR keep). That's what you call a contradiction.

I don't see how this isn't an obvious problem to have so many different rulings posted in so many different places. I'm not trying to pick apart the rules, but this is actually a big deal for characters who are frequently attacked by others, and every additional DM post about it only serves to confuse things more. Like I've said all along, I'm just trying to find clarity here. I thought we had done that, and the only issue was fixing the wording in the official rules, but with the above post we're back to confusion again.

If the DMs can't even be consistent in their explanations of this rule, how can players be expected to understand and follow it?
thank you, Torgerias.

you worded the question much better than I did when I asked this.
grymhild wrote:DM Echo,

Are you suggesting that hostile RP or PVP by the campfire outside of the Friendly Arm Inn without DM supervision is a rules violation?
Drathyrra [perma-dead]
Gilia Glandertor [inactive]
Grimhildr Ulvsdatter [active]
Iradortha "Iri" Umbrynthal [inactive]
Jhasina Harika yr Nar'ysra el Ifrit Khalid yi Memnon [active]
Lanathalas [retired]
Mhaev of Cathyr [retired]
Nevaetriel Rilae'ar'an, Kerym'quaress ath Eilistraee [jounal] [It's complicated]
N'essa [perma-dead]
Shaytessa Umbrynthal [bio] [journal] [???]
Shryl [retired]
Sssiks [active]
Ssinyrr [bio] [active]
Hathran Tatyana [active]
Vierdra Zau'afin [inactive]
kellendril
Posts: 992
Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2010 7:53 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by kellendril »

It seems to me that what you are asking for is a DM consensus/clarification of the rule. Let's not start nitpicking the DM responding. Ask for a clarification and let's move this forward.
Eowiel Le'liana - Formerly Respected Councilor/Citizen of Doron Amar, now Disrespected Free Agent
Merry Angalagaleil - Strongheart Halfling Sacred Fist
Torgerias
Posts: 153
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 2:31 pm
Location: GMT -4:00

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Torgerias »

kellendril wrote:It seems to me that what you are asking for is a DM consensus/clarification of the rule. Let's not start nitpicking the DM responding. Ask for a clarification and let's move this forward.
I thought that's what I had been doing? I've been asking for a clarification all along, and I also thought I had one after posts by Maecius and other DMs..that is until the latest DM post that didn't make sense with the previous ones. I'm not nitpicking, I'm trying to reach a clarification, as I've said all along.

I'm going to reiterate: If the DMs can't even be consistent in their explanations of this rule, how can players be expected to understand and follow it? What I've taken from this thread is that nobody has a consensus on what this rule really means.
Zeligus Cromwell - Faithful of The Black Hand
Oderin Eldoth - Diplomatic Red Wizard Happily Returned to Thay
Jonathan Proudmoore - Knight of Torm Missing in Action
User avatar
grymhild
Recognized Donor
Posts: 585
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
Location: Chicago, IL

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by grymhild »

I know my question came out wrong, I should have written it better. It does kinda sound like I was being critical of DM Echo - which totally wasn't what I meant to do. :-(

DM Echo, I would like to apologize about the tone of my question. I am sorry. :-(
User avatar
Snarfy
Posts: 1430
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 12:14 pm

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Snarfy »

Torgerias wrote:What I've taken from this thread is that nobody has a consensus on what this rule really means.
I've been around for 5 years and I still don't know what to make of the PvP rules at the FAI campfire and surrounding areas. I've seen everything from undead being summoned and used in PvP(even near the OSR), to full out multi-character brawls, to the guards coming along and smashing people into the dirt at the campfire, and, conversely, I've been given explanations from DM's about such instances that range anywhere from it all being perfectly legal to the other end of the spectrum, as in: illegal and "please send in screenshots". And while the cast of characters and DM's has changed dramatically over the years, altercations in the area seem to be far more subject to "shades of grey" than they have in the past. IMHO your questions and concerns are fair ones Torgerias, and ones that I personally share.
There are no level 30's, only level 20's with benefits...
DM Echo
Posts: 471
Joined: Sat Jul 25, 2015 4:36 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by DM Echo »

At one time the Fist patrolled the Tradeway lightly.. That is no longer the case. At one time the FAI guards also kept an eye on the campfire area. That has since changed as well. As Theo mentions, the ruling for FAI is an exception to the rules held everywhere else.. That said I would still prefer that players contact a DM any time they are PvPing on the FAI map.. If no DM is present.. Move it to the next area.. Understand where you are.. Outside a well fortified business with a small army of guards with archers lining the walls, also in a major hub of business, with adventurers, merchants and travelers coming and going on a regular basis. Ignoring that, you are ignoring the dangers of fighting in such situations. So -I would prefer it- if players did contact a DM before PvPing on this map.. It also recognizes the the guards are people too... Capable of making their own decisions and may choose to do something despite our DM rulings.

PS, No offense taken.. But I do return to what I said. Please don't try to rule lawyer.. Not when it is so much easier just to follow the rules as they are intended.. Contact a DM or move to one of the very close areas with no guards or NPCs present on the map and you know you are safe to PvP.. Well.. in contrast.. It is actually much more simple than any other option.. That include the option to PvP anyway, get reported, have the DMs contact you to get your side of the story, have you search through your screen shots of the incident to show you did nothing wrong, have other people verify it on your behalf, have the DMs review it and further clog our messages and forums... :roll:
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Boddynock »

DM Echo wrote:...But I do return to what I said. Please don't try to rule lawyer.. Not when it is so much easier just to follow the rules as they are intended.. Contact a DM or move to one of the very close areas with no guards or NPCs present on the map and you know you are safe to PvP...
I think most of what needs to be said here has been said already, but on this note, Echo, I don't really think anyone (or at least most people) are intentionally misinterpreting the rules. It isn't really rules lawyering to just read them as they are written, and as written the effect are often different than some DMs interpret them to mean. This is the same reason you and I had a recent discussion about Soubar; the same reason the forum rules were edited recently.

Maecius already touched on the fact that it might be time to review the rules regarding PVP here, and I think that's probably the best bet. If there is a disconnect between the intent of the rules and what they actually say that causes issues. Or if there is a difference between the overall opinion of the DM team now versus when that ruling was made, that can cause issues.

I agree with Maecius, I think it might be time again for you guys (the DMs) to talk about what your expectations are regarding PVP on this map, look over the rules that exist (and also importantly where they are recorded) and make sure the intent of the team is being clearly expressed. That's probably the best way to prevent headache down the road (although Maecius also indicated that there weren't a lot of complaint being generated from this area either, so I am not sure how much headache it actually is).
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
Empoweredfan
Posts: 499
Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2012 3:14 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Empoweredfan »

Or people could use their heads and be considerate towards those they share the space with. If PVP is so important to your character, then you can bloody well find a way for it to actually be fun for others. Both as spectators and participants. Nothing stopping people fom emoting a fight with rolls, except the logic of where it takes place. Who knows, that might actually be less immersionbreaking than two people cutting each others to ribbons every other week. Curiously enough, it being the same 3 people doing it each time.

I am sorry if this is snappish, but the very fact that a rule change is called upon for details on how to PVP in an area, tells me that there shouldn't be any PVP in that area. If pvp leads to ooc trouble, then a search of ones own actions should be the first order if business.
Nawiel: Stubborn woodpecker from the deep.
- "Responsibility is a curse, importance, an illusion."


Deleniel Vanaer: Wood Elven Sor. . . cook.

If you put your foot in your mouth. . . don't start walking. . .
User avatar
V'rass
Posts: 1251
Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2015 1:48 pm
Location: Concord, N.H., USSA

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by V'rass »

Taking away pvp from the fai campfire is a bad idea. Honestly i think pvp should be allowed anywhere guards are not watching constantly. Pvp, aside from dm run events are the only source of excitement and challenge on this server. 90% of the time nothing is happening anywhere on the server, and dont tell me thats not true i have been monitoring the server and what the players are doing and 90% of the time its grinding or doing non-exciting rp. Too many people whine about pvp... honeslty it really is starting to annoy me.
"To understand magic one must first understand magic."






Agathion Benedictus: Holy Priest. Retired for now.
Tiax Rules-All: Gnomish madman. Retired permanently.
Exordius Vrass: Cleric/Mage. Currently active.
User avatar
Empoweredfan
Posts: 499
Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2012 3:14 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Empoweredfan »

What isn't fun to you can be fun for someone else, and what is fun for you, maybe uncomfortable for others. PvP isn't a problem at all if there is ooc agreement present. If that isn't the case, then one can take some responsibility and try to read the situation, to judge if pvp would actually be fun or just a lot of bother waiting to happen.
Nawiel: Stubborn woodpecker from the deep.
- "Responsibility is a curse, importance, an illusion."


Deleniel Vanaer: Wood Elven Sor. . . cook.

If you put your foot in your mouth. . . don't start walking. . .
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Boddynock »

Empoweredfan wrote:Or people could use their heads and be considerate towards those they share the space with.
This goes both ways. I have seen players roleplaying some very very disrespectful characters who get all up in arms when the other PC being disrespected chooses simply to fight over it. Not all PCs are good, and one must also be considerate towards that avenue of roleplay, because it is NOT prohibited on the server. If you don't enjoy that sort of conflict RP, don't RP a character that creates or encourages it (not that I am accusing you in particular of doing so, I am not sure what your situation is).
Empoweredfan wrote:I am sorry if this is snappish, but the very fact that a rule change is called upon for details on how to PVP in an area, tells me that there shouldn't be any PVP in that area. If pvp leads to ooc trouble, then a search of ones own actions should be the first order if business.
A rules review is simply the product of our server, things change over time, the DM team gets new faces, opinions shift. This is simply a call to ensure that what we want to see in this area is properly reflected in what we tell people is expected of them, no more and no less. And if you believe that PVP should be banned on this map, then the forum is exactly the place to say that and give your reasons why. But I encourage you to do so without making assumptions about the intent behind another players RP. We are all acting out a part here, and it is in my experience that OOC problems generally stem from assumptions about players due to a PCs actions.
Empoweredfan wrote:If PVP is so important to your character, then you can bloody well find a way for it to actually be fun for others.
I think what is likely more important to the other player is being allowed to stay true to their character concept. The server allows evil PCs, and by extension that means evil IC actions (with some specific limitations). That means the other PC you are talking to could be a follower of Loviatar, or a Banite, or a Bhaalist, none of whom would think twice before cutting you down for little to no reason. Our server requires them to have a reason, and in fact favors the avoidance of PVP, so if you want to avoid it, don't give a reason for it. However, if staying true to your character means you might come into conflict with another PC, let them stay true to theirs and respond appropriately.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
Aspect of Sorrow
Custom Content
Posts: 2702
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 7:11 pm
Location: Reliquary

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Aspect of Sorrow »

V'rass wrote:Taking away pvp from the fai campfire is a bad idea.
There are literally hundreds of areas the PvP can be conducted elsewhere. This is from someone regularly conducting it.

Return to “General Discussion”