The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole road.

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Boddynock »

Empoweredfan wrote:What isn't fun to you can be fun for someone else, and what is fun for you, maybe uncomfortable for others.
Ok, lets use a real life example. Lets assume for a second that going to a crowded store makes you uncomfortable. Do you: "Try to go to the store when it isn't so busy", or "Block the door and try to keep people out, thus limiting the number inside so you can shop in peace?"

I bet it is the first one, and the same thing applies here. If you don't like PVP you can avoid it, but you don't get to dictate the RP of others in the name of your personal comfort. The vast VAST majority of players I have met here are super cool OOC despite what my character thinks of theirs. I think you might have better results if, instead of shifting the obligation onto them to "read your mood" which is practically impossible through the medium of an MMO (and some people aren't good at anyway), you take it upon yourself to talk to these people you have issues with, person to person. When that fails, you take it to the next step.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
Empoweredfan
Posts: 499
Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2012 3:14 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Empoweredfan »

Regardless of character concept, alignment or situation, this is a cooperative roleplay server. And my own situation is such that I have seen too many people hide behind character alignment, only to act just as badly when I try to speak with them ooc'ly. Frankly, I am disilusioned about the intentions of some, and after a good few years here, I am left with much less than a handful of good pvp memories. And before you ask, I lost most of those that I remember fondly.

I will fully admit that I have probably been extreemely unlucky in this regard, but it is how I've formed my view of pvp. With a deep sense that if pvp makes for a poor ooc situation, then we as players have a responsibity to make things right. Regardless of your character concept, then you, as the player whom is not evil aligned, evil or a criminal murderer, have a responsibility to make sure that things isn't taken too far. If someone is pushy, then give the player a heads up where the situation is going ect.

Conflict rp is fun when done right. It is just a lot of bad experiences when handeled poorly. You might also find that situations can have several different impressions on where something is going. It is quite easy, really, to find out if what you do will be welcome or not.
Nawiel: Stubborn woodpecker from the deep.
- "Responsibility is a curse, importance, an illusion."


Deleniel Vanaer: Wood Elven Sor. . . cook.

If you put your foot in your mouth. . . don't start walking. . .
User avatar
Empoweredfan
Posts: 499
Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2012 3:14 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Empoweredfan »

Seeing as you posted another one and I am on a cellphone, let me give you an example back. If a store have trouble with people causing trouble on a regular basis, then they will hire guards and keep those people that cause trouble out.

So I'll send the 'don't dictate the roleplay of others' right back at you, thank you very much. No reason for law abiding citizen to fear the wrath of criminals right by the best fortified tavern for miles around, ruled over by a powerful mage. It isn't about rules. It's about common sense.

And I am not trying to provoke a fight here. My battery isn't good enough to keep it up. But I do urge people to think of this server as what it is. A place for everyone. As for the next step, is just that. It leads away from the situation by simply walking away.
Nawiel: Stubborn woodpecker from the deep.
- "Responsibility is a curse, importance, an illusion."


Deleniel Vanaer: Wood Elven Sor. . . cook.

If you put your foot in your mouth. . . don't start walking. . .
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Boddynock »

Empoweredfan wrote:No reason for law abiding citizen to fear the wrath of criminals right by the best fortified tavern for miles around, ruled over by a powerful mage. It isn't about rules. It's about common sense.
A person ALWAYS, regardless of location, has to fear the wrath of criminals, just turn on the news. And while there may be punishments for criminal acts, both in game and in the real world, when has that ever stopped them from occurring? The issue, it seems here, is that by calling people to use "common sense" you will always end up with people that land on different outcomes. As you said, your feelings towards PVP has been shaped by our experiences with it, and that holds true for all of us. With that in mind everyone's "common sense" or their expectations of what might occur, are colored by their past experiences. This is the reason for a difference of opinion on what should be expected in this area, because "common" sense isn't often a "common" thought shared between people of different backgrounds (similar to how it si common sense to tip wait staff here in the US, but not in other countries).

What a rules review would accomplish is taking into account the desires of the community and staff to establish a clear set of expectations. And despite several DMs chiming in with the rules and what they say, there is STILL discussion, which tells me that there is still room for a difference in interpretation. If we can take strides to lessen the chance that tw people will read the same rules and come to different conclusions, then we are taking strides to avoid these sorts of things in the future, and THAT is what is being asked for (at least by me, as I speak only for myself).

So when I gave that example, and I make the arguments I did above, I didn't do so in an attempt to convince you that you are wrong, but rather to point out that there is another side to this and that it isn't quite as black and white as we might like it to be. Both sides can be different and both can be valid, but rules can't do that. Rules have to be written in a way that expresses their desired intent as clearly as possible, that gives us all a guideline on which to base our actions despite any differences of opinion that were almost certainly learned by a difference in experiences.

There is currently a discussion going on about the expectations of PC behavior in Soubar as well, that discussion doesn't exist solely because there are no NPC guards there and therefore the rules say PVP is ok. They exist because of the culmination of experiences with different DMs enforing different things in the confines of Soubar added to that fact that the rules say PVP is prohibited only on maps where guards are present. The result of all of that is a number of DM/Player interactions in which no one wins, no one feels good about it. We have DMs who likely feel that they shouldn't have to waste their time enforcing something that everyone should understand already, and players upset that one DM allows a thing that another doesn't but the rules say this, and the lore seems to support it, and blah blah blah blah.

Now that Soubar thing is another conversation, and I am not trying to derail things here, but the solution there is the same as it is here. Ensure that the rules players have available are clearly expressing their intent. If we do that, we won't have any more situations where players are upset because they think someone else broke the rules, we won't have DMs upset they have to spend time dealing with something they think is already clear, and we won't have players upset because someone, player or DM, is calling them out on breaking a rule which they don't feel they actually broke. A little clarity turns a lose-lose situation into a win-win, any way you look at it.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
Empoweredfan
Posts: 499
Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2012 3:14 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Empoweredfan »

I'm sorry to say that this is nothing more than a roundabout then. Can't convince and won't change. While you should always try to see the others point of view, that only works when both sides do. So, if you wish the Dm's to see your point of view, then you should try to see theirs.

I assume that you are disapointed with them, as you keep mentioning them and the changing views of the community. And seeing as I am part of the community, and clearly don't agree, there is obviously another side to see the issues from.
Nawiel: Stubborn woodpecker from the deep.
- "Responsibility is a curse, importance, an illusion."


Deleniel Vanaer: Wood Elven Sor. . . cook.

If you put your foot in your mouth. . . don't start walking. . .
User avatar
Moridin
Retired Staff
Posts: 582
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2012 10:14 pm
Location: SK, Canada

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Moridin »

Just saying - in the game Baldur's Gate, a paladin was attacked on the road right outside the Friendly Arm inn by Hobgoblins and had her ring stolen from her. For reference: Joia.
Characters:
Lomith Dy'nesen Journal
User avatar
Empoweredfan
Posts: 499
Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2012 3:14 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Empoweredfan »

Point taken. But that doesn't take into account our server's history. Too much trouble on the map should have an effect.

But again. If pvp is handeled right, there is no issue at all. Pvp by th fire is alright, as long as there is ooc acceptance of what an why it happens.
Nawiel: Stubborn woodpecker from the deep.
- "Responsibility is a curse, importance, an illusion."


Deleniel Vanaer: Wood Elven Sor. . . cook.

If you put your foot in your mouth. . . don't start walking. . .
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Boddynock »

Empoweredfan wrote: I assume that you are disapointed with them, as you keep mentioning them and the changing views of the community. And seeing as I am part of the community, and clearly don't agree, there is obviously another side to see the issues from.
I mention the DMs solely because the rules are under their purview, and decisions to review or change them will be theirs to make.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
Hawke
Posts: 1245
Joined: Sun Aug 01, 2010 6:11 pm

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Hawke »

My own opinion...

If there are guards in line of sight or can reasonably hear what is going on (loud clanging of steel or spell) then the guards would interfere with the fight.

This included Player Run guilds that have guards outside on the FAI map.

They are there to protect the interest of their employer, and no one will come to the Inn if there is bloodshed and spells exploding everywhere, which cuts into the bottom line.

To ignore the guards it to metagame. And that is a no no as much as I understand these things.

Like above, someone mentioned, there are literally hundreds of other locations one could PvP or duel.

I dont understand how this is an actual issue once more.
If the text is this color, I am on duty, everything else is just my humble opinion.
User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Maximvs »

I think the guards would interfere with things happening eyesight or even ear shot, considering they got a few back up inside the inn as well. Depends on what, depends on who, of course, but basic survival dictates that you must know your surroundings ; even all manner of strange sounds from afar would be at least investigated by one scout. They obey Bentley Mirrorshade and he's a good fellow. Telling your guards to do nothing when something happens 10 meters outside is a pretty cold hearted thing to do, which to me, doesn't make sense.
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!
User avatar
Stonebar
Retired Staff
Posts: 938
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2011 5:10 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Stonebar »

This is the issue, there are two types of bullies those that look for a fight all the time, and those who love to talk smack knowing that they can't be touched.
* The first can be handled with every option is on the table. If someone is a jerk, there is a cost of business.
* The second one in a "Guarded" area has free reign to be a verbal bully at no cost. They can call a Dwarf's mother a Goblin street walker, and it's the Dwarf that gets the perma strike out of it.

So the camp is fine as it is. Let people act, and the chips good or bad fall where they may, that's what makes this an RP server the aspect of chance mixed with encountering others new and old.

PS: I'm no PvPer powerbuilder etc... etc... bla bla, and despite playing all Dwarves it's been some years sense I PvPed, as I try to avoid it... but if it happens it happens that's life.
Revenark Stonehold Kingswarden of Stonebar. Despite the weight of his vows he will never allow himself to fail his responsibility to family regardless of personal cost[/strike]

Forum name honors the Stonebar alliance. I'm not Stonebar
User avatar
Blame The Rogue
Posts: 653
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Blame The Rogue »

Stonebar wrote:* The second one in a "Guarded" area has free reign to be a verbal bully at no cost. They can call a Dwarf's mother a Goblin street walker, and it's the Dwarf that gets the perma strike out of it.
i understand your point, but the dwarf in this situation should reply with, "step over here, down the road, out of sight of the inn, and i'll teach you some dwarven manners."

if the bully goes, pvp in a permitted area. problem solved

if the bully doesn't go, all present see that he's all bark and no bite. problem solved

i'm in agreement that there are plenty of areas where appropriate ic pvp can take place
Last edited by Blame The Rogue on Fri Jul 29, 2016 7:22 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."
User avatar
matelener
Retired Staff
Posts: 972
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 6:02 am

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by matelener »

Maximvs wrote:I think the guards would interfere with things happening eyesight or even ear shot, considering they got a few back up inside the inn as well. Depends on what, depends on who, of course, but basic survival dictates that you must know your surroundings ; even all manner of strange sounds from afar would be at least investigated by one scout. They obey Bentley Mirrorshade and he's a good fellow. Telling your guards to do nothing when something happens 10 meters outside is a pretty cold hearted thing to do, which to me, doesn't make sense.
Bentley built a safe and open to all fortress in the middle of dangerous lands. The adventurers, though, prefer to stay at an unguarded campfire outside of the walls. Should he send the guards outside (and risk their lives), if all that the adventurers have to do is step through the gate inside?

IMHO no.
User avatar
grymhild
Recognized Donor
Posts: 585
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
Location: Chicago, IL

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by grymhild »

I think that can see several of different ways looking at these these issues; complications, frustrations, perspectives, ideas, priorities, biases and goals.

my own are "evolving" from hearing other people's ideas, but aside from a few rather unfortunate and poorly worded comments and questions, lately I've kind of been quieter and tried to avoid posting my own rather passionate thoughts and opinions on this and several other threads that in the past.

there are reasons that I've been quiet, some that I'd rather not get into especially because I don't want to derail this thread.

so back on topic, here's what I see as some of the main issues.

1) some people don't enjoy some pvp
2) some people enjoy some pvp
3) some people build for PvP, some don't
4) DMs are not usually present (at least as DMs) during pvps
5) anecdotally, in my experience, DMs usually don't -want- to get involved in PVP
6) trying to get a dm involved takes times and often is immersion breaking
7) players have vastly different play-style, builds, experience, and pc levels at PVP
8) pvp complaints can be a headache for the DMs and people involved
9) some players care a great deal about lore and seeing integrity, continuity, and believability
10) some people want a casual or light hearted experience
11) everyone is here to have fun (I hope)
12) everyone enjoys different things


those aren't in any particular order, and there are plenty of things missing, or that could be worded better.

but the biggest issue that I see is that we don't all have the same understandering of the rules. both rules as written and rules as "intended" ( I put scare quotes around "intended" because I think that we could ask 30 players what the intention behind a rule is and get at least 15 different answers)

anyway, I don't think that trying to get clarity on the rules should be called rules lawyering. that word has a lot of baggage.
User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: The campfire outside FAI and just generally that whole r

Unread post by Maximvs »

matelener wrote:
Bentley built a safe and open to all fortress in the middle of dangerous lands. The adventurers, though, prefer to stay at an unguarded campfire outside of the walls. Should he send the guards outside (and risk their lives), if all that the adventurers have to do is step through the gate inside?

IMHO no.
I said it always depends, on who and what. One or two drow outside the walls, I believe, would be dealt with quickly. A bigger force would surely instill them to wall up tight. I agree though, that remaining outside when a drow party approaches is stupid. Not ooc stupid, but ic at least.
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!

Return to “General Discussion”