Why is Necromancy evil?

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

fearknight2003
Posts: 354
Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 8:53 pm

Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by fearknight2003 »

It makes no sense. Animate Dead doesn't affect the spirit at all, it literally just animates the mindless corpse. What's inherently evil about zombies?

Don't say anything about 'going against the natural order', we have Raise Dead and Resurrection which screw it up a lot worse.
It was a fun year (I think). Bye.
User avatar
Moridin
Retired Staff
Posts: 582
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2012 10:14 pm
Location: SK, Canada

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Moridin »

I think its more so due to the perception that messing with someone's remains is immoral in real life. How would you feel if your uncle bob rose from his grave, as a mindless zombie controlled by some unknown wizard?
Characters:
Lomith Dy'nesen Journal
User avatar
Moltrazahn
Posts: 915
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:33 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Moltrazahn »

It may have something to do with several things...

First. There is the moral of it. Like posted above with uncle bob.
Second is what the gods decide. Most rules and creeds aredecided by the various pantheons in the setting. If they say it's bad. It's bad.
Third could be because you actively use negative energy... by its very name... is negative matter.
Za'than Za'amal(Elsewhere!)
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)

Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"

"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
JCVD1
Posts: 447
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2013 4:21 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by JCVD1 »

All wrong.

In DnD, there are planes of existance : Chaos, Law, Evil and good.

Being evil is being influenced by the planse of Evil (Hells, Negative plane, etc.)

Being good is being influenced by the positive planes AKA Heavens.

And so on.

Now. the Evil spells are depicted in its description. Exemple:
Create Undead
Necromancy [Evil]
Level: Clr 6, Death 6, Evil 6, Sor/Wiz 6
Components: V, S, M
Casting Time: 1 hour
Range: Close (25 ft. + 5 ft./2 levels)
Target: One corpse
Duration: Instantaneous
Saving Throw: None
Spell Resistance: No
Or
Mindrape (3.5e Spell)
Mindrape
Enchantment [Evil, Mind-Affecting]
Level: Dementation 9, Sor/Wiz 9
Components: V, S
Casting time: 1 standard action
Range: Medium (100 ft. + 10 ft./level)
Targets: One creature
Duration: Instantaneous
Saving Throw: Will negates
Spell Resistance: Yes

Note that these 2 spells have the Evil descriptor but aren't both from Necromancy.

Necromancy in itself, isn't evil. It's one of the faces of the Weave (schools).

The reason why a zombie creation is an evil act, is because it creates an evil Being that's ALWAYS chaotic Evil. Undeads are made with/from the negative energy plane.

Morality has nothing to do. Because even in Thay, for exemple, making an army of undeads isn't morally improper.

The gods and the rules of the universe is what defines an evil act. It seems pretty black an white when people prefer shades of grey, but this is what DnD is.
Karond
Posts: 2221
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 10:47 am
Location: Sweden

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Karond »

But not all undead are evil.

We had a several pages long topic about this before. The real reason? The only one that can be explained properly and defended from that entire long topic?

It's evil because some pnp book says so. That's it.
User avatar
Lockonnow
Posts: 3123
Joined: Fri Oct 15, 2010 12:10 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Lockonnow »

well something sould be evil or else it is not fun right
Tsidkenu

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Tsidkenu »

Karond wrote:It's evil because some pnp book says so. That's it.
Bingo, although JCVD's explanation is slightly more satisfying.

A lich is evil because the act of lichdom is evil as described in some or other sourcebook. A baelnorn is not evil because the act of its lichdom is not evil, being a decree with the blessing of the Good-aligned Seldarine.

So your topic title is not quite correct. Necromancy is not necessarily evil (hey, I've written two IG books about the subject, one on magic & morality and a second on Necromancy specifically. . . non-canonical though!). Opalescent Glare (Clr/Wiz/Sorc 5th), for example, is a save or die Necromancy spell but is good-aligned. Read the spell descriptors. If it has [Evil], it is evil, simply because that's how evil is in the Forgotten Realms campaign setting.
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by TheLier »

Yeah. It is DnD. Some things are evil, some are good. Becuse the gods said so.
fearknight2003
Posts: 354
Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 8:53 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by fearknight2003 »

TheLier wrote:Yeah. It is DnD. Some things are evil, some are good. Becuse the gods said so.
The gods who are, themselves, labeled on the same morality system as any other beings? What determines Lathander good, for example?
It was a fun year (I think). Bye.
DreWalker
Posts: 253
Joined: Wed Mar 20, 2013 12:43 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by DreWalker »

there is a spell called mindrape? :shock:
Irrtana-Yathrin
Draya- surviving
User avatar
Kiran
Posts: 809
Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2016 12:21 pm
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Kiran »

DreWalker wrote:there is a spell called mindrape? :shock:
What she said :shock:
Player of:

Damian Pascal, - Run away/dead. - Background - Corruption from Within
Amenthes Serb, Knight - Gone missing/Supposed dead Background
Tamzim Renima, mercenary - Handed over to the fist. Background
Kiran, Golden Wheel - Presumed dead
Althalous Fenwick, Paladin of Mystra. - A memory lost
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by TheLier »

fearknight2003 wrote:
TheLier wrote:Yeah. It is DnD. Some things are evil, some are good. Becuse the gods said so.
The gods who are, themselves, labeled on the same morality system as any other beings? What determines Lathander good, for example?
Himself. He is the epitome of one type of good. A cosmic power. Gods are very different from mortals. They very rarely change, as they embody their portfolio.
JCVD1
Posts: 447
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2013 4:21 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by JCVD1 »

DreWalker wrote:there is a spell called mindrape? :shock:

There is. It's a very very evil spell found in Book of vile darkness, page 99.
Mindrape
Enchantment [Evil, Mind-Affecting]
Level: Sor/Wiz 9
Components: V, S
Casting Time: 1 action
Range:Medium (100 ft. + 10
ft./level)
Target: One creature
Duration: Instantaneous
Saving Throw:Will negates
Spell Resistance: Yes
The caster enters the mind of a creature,
learning everything that creature
knows. The caster can erase or
add memories as she sees fit and alter
emotions, opinions, and even alignment.
When the caster is done, she
can leave the creature insane (as
described in the insanity spell) or
seemingly unaffected, without any
memory of the intrusion.
Severe changes to personality and
changes to alignment can be corrected
by a break enchantment spell
(although an atonement spell might be
needed as well, depending on circumstances).
Alterations to memories and
subtler thoughts can be restored only
through use of a miracle or wish.
User avatar
Moltrazahn
Posts: 915
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:33 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Moltrazahn »

Because AO and his master deemed it so!

But as stated it's true. It's evil because it says it's evil. Some places won't chase you with pitchforks for doing it tho.

Sadly forgotten realms and dnd in general has its foundations in some areas set rather black and white.
Za'than Za'amal(Elsewhere!)
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)

Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"

"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
Storm Munin
Posts: 1355
Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:03 am
Location: Sweden, Alfheimar expat

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Storm Munin »

Mindrape?
Relax, it has not been implemented on the server yet. :twisted:

Considering the past and current position of blasting anything allowed evil vs the resistance to mindcontrol evil I do not foresee the more naughty enchantment spells going ingame anytime soon.

Mindrape, mindwipe and quite a few others being homebrew spells however.
Enslave, Insanity, Geas, Modify memory (just imagine how many unfortunate souls could be saved from instant death and not be an inconvenience to explain for our dear villainry), Soul Dominion and their spell friend are sadly missed in the enchanter list of spells though.
Consent being a must for some, but that go for simpleton pvp situations as well.
On second though some server rules would need modification to allow for successfull Enslave.

Even if the mighty leecherous "good" Elminster Aumar himself has a record in this field of arcane study as a habitual user. ;)


@Moltrazahn
I thought that was actually the whole point of DnD and the genre at large.
Overthinking something supposed to be a less complex moral system than real life does cause inconvenient questions, true.
"Drojal zhah obdoluth dorb'd streeak, Lueth dro zhah zhaunau dorb'd ogglin."
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.

PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.

Return to “General Discussion”