Why is Necromancy evil?
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
Ariella
- Retired Staff
- Posts: 1412
- Joined: Sat Jul 20, 2013 11:57 am
- Location: Australia
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
It should also be noted that some types of reanimation necromancy can actually effect the soul of the individual. Pulling them from their respect after life and trapping them upon the prime as an abomination.
-
TheLier
- Posts: 388
- Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
The way I look at morality and aligment in DnD is simple.
To be a good or evil, you have to be above a certain bar. Your aligment is the sum of your qualites, be that chaotic, evil, lawful or good.
However there are things which move you above else to one category, and some actions are bound to be evil/good/lawful or chaotic. For example, spell with evil descriptor, are evil, no matter what.
Some acts may cause an imminent aligment shift (for example a warlock pact).
If someone does not qualify for good or evil, they are netural. Most people are. However, being evil does not mean you are some sort of maniac. An envious farmer or a greedy merchant are evil, when their actions cause real harm. In DnD morality, intent rarely matters at all, and never too much. Your aligment is the sum of your past actions, and might not have anything to do with your current state of being.
And of course there are actions which pretty much make your permanent evil (to stay on the necromancy-evil topic)
To be a good or evil, you have to be above a certain bar. Your aligment is the sum of your qualites, be that chaotic, evil, lawful or good.
However there are things which move you above else to one category, and some actions are bound to be evil/good/lawful or chaotic. For example, spell with evil descriptor, are evil, no matter what.
Some acts may cause an imminent aligment shift (for example a warlock pact).
If someone does not qualify for good or evil, they are netural. Most people are. However, being evil does not mean you are some sort of maniac. An envious farmer or a greedy merchant are evil, when their actions cause real harm. In DnD morality, intent rarely matters at all, and never too much. Your aligment is the sum of your past actions, and might not have anything to do with your current state of being.
And of course there are actions which pretty much make your permanent evil (to stay on the necromancy-evil topic)
-
Arn
- Posts: 906
- Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2012 7:44 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
There actually is an in-game religious philosophy that also questions the conventional good/evil labeling system.fearknight2003 wrote:The gods who are, themselves, labeled on the same morality system as any other beings? What determines Lathander good, for example?TheLier wrote:Yeah. It is DnD. Some things are evil, some are good. Becuse the gods said so.
"The Way states that all things in the Celestial Universe affect and are affected by all others. There is no Good, Evil, Law or Chaos only the forces of the Universe . . . " See Page 28 of this book.
Maybe the gods in D&D are powerful enough that they get to just say what "forces of the Universe" are Good or Evil, including themselves. Which would mean that Good and Evil is every bit as subjective as the Way suggests, with no more meaning than what the gods enforce.
But that would also imply the gods have all reached a consensus on the Good/Evil labeling convention, which is weird, considering all their differences in opinions. What made them all agree on what is Good or Evil?
Mi-Le (彌勒) - "Meditate, monks. Do not be negligent, lest you regret it later." ((-Saṃyutta Nikāya 35.146))
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-
Rhifox
- Posts: 3962
- Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Above is how I see it. Good and Evil are labels. They describe very real things, definitely, but the words themselves are just that: Words. Words only have as much power as people give them. The gods/cosmic forces have defined what those labels mean, but that doesn't stop people from having their own subjective takes on morality itself.
In other words, blue is blue because we as human beings have defined that particular color as being blue. And that word brings several ideas and feelings to our mind. But to an animal, it is not blue, because animals do not have an understanding of our human language and human labels. That color will always be that color--it is a real color, it exists--but what we choose to call it and how we choose to feel about it is ultimately up to no one but ourselves. Consider how nowadays for children blue is seen as a "boy" color, and pink as a "girl" color... it used to be the opposite.
Raising the undead (not necromancy as a whole) is Evil because the gods have defined that as an Evil act, and it uses cosmic forces that are labeled as Evil forces. Those forces that are defined as Evil will always be those forces, that cannot be changed. But some sapient beings on Toril may not agree or even know about that word choice, or that moral definition. Raising the undead will always, no matter what you call it, fall under "Evil" energy, the cosmic element that is "Evil" in the DnD universe, but the word used to label that cosmic force is only as caging as people choose to let it be. It'd be defying the gods and most mortal societies to call it something else, to feel differently about its moral nature, but it's not impossible to do so.
Of course, that choice would then fall under the "Chaotic" cosmic force, because it'd be rebelling against the cosmic "language".
In other words, blue is blue because we as human beings have defined that particular color as being blue. And that word brings several ideas and feelings to our mind. But to an animal, it is not blue, because animals do not have an understanding of our human language and human labels. That color will always be that color--it is a real color, it exists--but what we choose to call it and how we choose to feel about it is ultimately up to no one but ourselves. Consider how nowadays for children blue is seen as a "boy" color, and pink as a "girl" color... it used to be the opposite.
Raising the undead (not necromancy as a whole) is Evil because the gods have defined that as an Evil act, and it uses cosmic forces that are labeled as Evil forces. Those forces that are defined as Evil will always be those forces, that cannot be changed. But some sapient beings on Toril may not agree or even know about that word choice, or that moral definition. Raising the undead will always, no matter what you call it, fall under "Evil" energy, the cosmic element that is "Evil" in the DnD universe, but the word used to label that cosmic force is only as caging as people choose to let it be. It'd be defying the gods and most mortal societies to call it something else, to feel differently about its moral nature, but it's not impossible to do so.
Of course, that choice would then fall under the "Chaotic" cosmic force, because it'd be rebelling against the cosmic "language".
What made English-speaking human society all agree on blue being blue? Someone starts calling something something, and gradually other people come to use that label to describe it, and on and on until it becomes the word for that thing.Arn wrote:What made them all agree on what is Good or Evil?
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
-
AlwaysSummer Day
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 1170
- Joined: Sun Jun 24, 2012 11:27 pm
- Location: Detroit, Michigan
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Karond wrote:But not all undead are evil.
We had a several pages long topic about this before. The real reason? The only one that can be explained properly and defended from that entire long topic?
It's evil because some pnp book says so. That's it.
Should have been /topic
Roland; svirfneblin fist of the forest and eco terrorist.
Heinrich Von Rittermark; Everwatch Knights of Helm
Frederick Von Rittermark; Paladin of Azuth/Mystra
Erik Von Rittermark; Unknown
Heinrich Von Rittermark; Everwatch Knights of Helm
Frederick Von Rittermark; Paladin of Azuth/Mystra
Erik Von Rittermark; Unknown
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
There's a few things I remember which I sadly can't quote because it's been so long since I read the source.
1) There is a non-evil God whose clergy are sometimes honored with being brought back as undead to protect temples and sacred sites. (I can't even remember the God...)
2) I remember reading somewhere that a spirit knows if their body is being used without their permission. (Again, I can't even find where I heard this)
Am I crazy here?... Don't answer that last one
1) There is a non-evil God whose clergy are sometimes honored with being brought back as undead to protect temples and sacred sites. (I can't even remember the God...)
2) I remember reading somewhere that a spirit knows if their body is being used without their permission. (Again, I can't even find where I heard this)
Am I crazy here?... Don't answer that last one
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
Arn
- Posts: 906
- Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2012 7:44 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
But then, as pointed out earlier in this thread, why isn't a baelnorn "Evil"? Under our definition, the gods don't call a baelnorn "Evil" because the forces involved somehow do not have the objective traits that "Evil" refers to.Rhifox wrote:Those forces that are defined as Evil will always be those forces, that cannot be changed. But some sapient beings on Toril may not agree or even know about that word choice, or that moral definition. Raising the undead will always, no matter what you call it, fall under "Evil" energy, the cosmic element that is "Evil" in the DnD universe, but the word used to label that cosmic force is only as caging as people choose to let it be.
I agree that a label is just a label, but if they refer to forces with objectively definable traits, we should be able to figure out what those traits are (without the subjective judgments inherent in the Good/Evil labeling system). "Blue" and "pink" refer to different objective visual traits. "Attraction" and "repulsion" refer to different objective magnetic traits. So let's say those traits objectively exist, regardless of what we subjectively think of them. So what kind of objective traits do "Good" and "Evil" refer to? Do such objective traits actually exist?
Best I can think of is that "Good" and "Evil" refer to forces that have different objective mental traits. "Good" forces evoke selflessness, while "Evil" forces evoke selfishness. So maybe a lich is evil because the forces and intention used to create a lich are selfish, while a baelnorn is created in selfless service?
I'm sure the above analysis can be picked apart pretty quickly. Trying to flesh out D&D morality is an iffy prospect. But it's the best I got!
Mi-Le (彌勒) - "Meditate, monks. Do not be negligent, lest you regret it later." ((-Saṃyutta Nikāya 35.146))
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]
((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))
Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Okay I found the answer to one of my points. A Lawful Neutral God that allows the use of undead... Jergal
Edit: This is a big "you're welcome" to my fellow DMs from the headache caused by future priests of Jergal.
It could be argued that Priests of Jergal might not get evil points for creating undead if used to serve Jergals ethos.In ethos, Jergal is colder and more inhumane than his master, sanctioning the use and creation of undead by his followers, provided they serve the cause of advancing death in the world. He is not evil or malicious, but impassively records the death of all things.
Edit: This is a big "you're welcome" to my fellow DMs from the headache caused by future priests of Jergal.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
Blame The Rogue
- Posts: 653
- Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
baelnorn are good-aligned
they sacrifice their life to become a lich to eternally guard elven crypts containing untold treasures
untold because one rarely comes back from a quest to steal artifacts from an elven crypt guarded by a baelnorn
they sacrifice their life to become a lich to eternally guard elven crypts containing untold treasures
untold because one rarely comes back from a quest to steal artifacts from an elven crypt guarded by a baelnorn
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."
-
Hoihe
- Posts: 4719
- Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 2:25 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Torm is another god. Yes, Torm. The same god with the stereotypical paladins.Flasmix wrote:There's a few things I remember which I sadly can't quote because it's been so long since I read the source.
1) There is a non-evil God whose clergy are sometimes honored with being brought back as undead to protect temples and sacred sites. (I can't even remember the God...)
2) I remember reading somewhere that a spirit knows if their body is being used without their permission. (Again, I can't even find where I heard this)
Am I crazy here?... Don't answer that last one
And look at this spell: https://dndtools.net/spells/book-of-exa ... ction--86/
Necromancy [Good]
Level: Cleric 3, Druid 3, Sorcerer 4, Wizard 4, Wrath (BE) 3,
Components: V, S,
Casting Time: 1 standard action
Range: Touch
Target: Evil creature touched
Duration: Instantaneous
Saving Throw: Fortitude negates
Spell Resistance: Yes
The subject contracts an affliction selected from the list below, which strikes immediately (no incubation period).
Afflictions deal damage only to evil creatures.
Any evil creature takes damage equal to that listed plus its Charisma bonus.
An evil elemental or evil undead takes an extra 1 point of damage, and an evil outsider or an evil cleric of an evil deity takes an extra 2 points.
The DC listed is for the subsequent saves (use affliction's normal save DC for the initial saving throw).
Notice the Good descriptor. CASTING THIS SPELL CHANGES YOUR ALIGNMENT TOWARDS GOOD. IT'S NECROMANCY!
On the server, we have: https://dndtools.net/spells/book-of-exa ... artyr--87/
Blood of the Martyr
(Book of Exalted Deeds)
Necromancy (Healing) [Good]
Level: Apostle of Peace 4, Champion of Gwynharwyf 4, Cleric 4, Paladin 4,
Components: V, S,
Casting Time: 1 standard action
Range: Medium (100 ft. + 10 ft./level)
Target: Willing creature
Duration: Instantaneous
Saving Throw: None
Spell Resistance: Yes
You may transfer your own hit points directly to a target creature within range.
You must transfer at least 20 points.
Transferred hit points are damage to you.
The creature takes your transferred hit points as if receiving a cure wounds spell and cannot gain more hit points than its maximum allows; any excess points are lost.
This spell transfers only actual hit points, not temporary hit points.
An unconscious target is considered a "willing creature" for purposes of this spell.
In essence:
Evocation: Working with Fire, Cold, Electric, Acidic, Sonic and Force energies.
Conjuration: Working with the plane of X. Orb of X is basically conjuring energy from that plane directly. In 3E+, manipulation of positive energy was moved here
Transmutation: What it says on the tin
Divination: Learning about stuff
Illusion: Messing with the senses. As a subschool, using shadowstuff
Enchantment: Messing with the brain directly
Necromancy: Manipulation of Positive/Negative energy. In 3E+, manipulation of positive energy was moved to Conjuration for some absurd reason.
And yes, in 2E, healing injuries was necromancy!
For life to be worth living, afterlife must retain individuality, personal identity and memories without fail - https://www.sageadvice.eu/do-elves-reta ... afterlife/
A character belongs only to their player, and only them. And only the player may decide what happens.
A character belongs only to their player, and only them. And only the player may decide what happens.
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Where does it say Torm allows for undead? I couldn't find anything
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
Hoihe
- Posts: 4719
- Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 2:25 pm
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Not exactly sure. I remember a DM having an ancient Tormite site with an artifact guarded by Tormite undead and assumed it was based on lore.Flasmix wrote:Where does it say Torm allows for undead? I couldn't find anything
For life to be worth living, afterlife must retain individuality, personal identity and memories without fail - https://www.sageadvice.eu/do-elves-reta ... afterlife/
A character belongs only to their player, and only them. And only the player may decide what happens.
A character belongs only to their player, and only them. And only the player may decide what happens.
-
Flasmix
- Posts: 2504
- Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
- Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
Here's a list of all Evil spells from all schools.
http://alcyius.com/dndtools/spells/desc ... index.html
http://alcyius.com/dndtools/spells/desc ... index.html
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
-
Moltrazahn
- Posts: 915
- Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:33 am
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
I need to sit down a moment. This stuff is deep! @.@
Za'than Za'amal(Elsewhere!)
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)
Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"
"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)
Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"
"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Why is Necromancy evil?
so I think if I have this right... Protection from Evil has the Good descriptior, therefore clerics of evil Gods shouldn't be able to cast it?