Why is Necromancy evil?

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Hawke
Posts: 1245
Joined: Sun Aug 01, 2010 6:11 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Hawke »

I feel that maybe TSR should have called the school of Necromancy something else. Because when someone says "I am an expert at the school of Necromancy" They get burned at the stake for being a creator of undead, when in fact, he has an alternate form of healing and protection and happens to be Lawful Good. :P

Other than the few obscure spells in PnP (and a few in game now, thank you) pretty much if you dont create undead, you are ok... But people are people and will go with stereotyping, so use the N word at your own risk.
If the text is this color, I am on duty, everything else is just my humble opinion.
User avatar
Hoihe
Posts: 4719
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 2:25 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Hoihe »

Tekill wrote:I have read fantasy fiction that showed necromany in a more scientific light. It was more of a study of death as a way to do things like prolong life. Those necromancers were creepy but respected.
Necromancy used to kill cancer cells. Necromancy used to reanimate dead tissue..etc.

In Forgotten realms Necromancy is more about entrophy and undeath and not about just the study of death itself. The spells used in Necormancy as previously mentioned all tend to be pretty wicked.

Necromancy in Forgotten realms is more about controlling 'negative energy'.
Forgotten realms has focuses strongly on the duality of good vs evil. Negative energy being the opposite of positive energy - well thats guilt by association right there.

It should be easy to list reasons why undead are evil. Most societies would consider the desecration of a dead body as immoral or evil. Undead carry diseases. Undead attack the living. Even the non wicked undead are considered unaturally trapped between this world and the afterwold- often also trapping a soul.
Because negative energy is the unlife force of undead and because negative energy is the bread and butter of the schools of necromancy - we can logically conclude that -Undead is bad, therefor necromancy is bad.

So play it safe and burn the necromancers!!!

Negative energy is not evil. I can think of a way to make negative energy positively affect life: Have someone visit the positive energy plane without protection. Bring them back before they die. Negative energy would save their life that would otherwise be doomed.
Hawke wrote:I feel that maybe TSR should have called the school of Necromancy something else. Because when someone says "I am an expert at the school of Necromancy" They get burned at the stake for being a creator of undead, when in fact, he has an alternate form of healing and protection and happens to be Lawful Good. :P

Other than the few obscure spells in PnP (and a few in game now, thank you) pretty much if you dont create undead, you are ok... But people are people and will go with stereotyping, so use the N word at your own risk.
I think this could be a nice IC initiative by scholastic mages!
For life to be worth living, afterlife must retain individuality, personal identity and  memories without fail  - https://www.sageadvice.eu/do-elves-reta ... afterlife/
A character belongs only to their player, and only them. And only the player may decide what happens.
User avatar
Flasmix
Posts: 2504
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Flasmix »

Hawke wrote:I feel that maybe TSR should have called the school of Necromancy something else. Because when someone says "I am an expert at the school of Necromancy" They get burned at the stake for being a creator of undead, when in fact, he has an alternate form of healing and protection and happens to be Lawful Good. :P

Other than the few obscure spells in PnP (and a few in game now, thank you) pretty much if you dont create undead, you are ok... But people are people and will go with stereotyping, so use the N word at your own risk.
It's more of an uneducated PC issue, I agree completely. I've had some really dumb PC's accuse me of Necromancy when I used Weird, an illusion spell, because it caused instant death.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by TheLier »

Flasmix wrote:
Hawke wrote:I feel that maybe TSR should have called the school of Necromancy something else. Because when someone says "I am an expert at the school of Necromancy" They get burned at the stake for being a creator of undead, when in fact, he has an alternate form of healing and protection and happens to be Lawful Good. :P

Other than the few obscure spells in PnP (and a few in game now, thank you) pretty much if you dont create undead, you are ok... But people are people and will go with stereotyping, so use the N word at your own risk.
It's more of an uneducated PC issue, I agree completely. I've had some really dumb PC's accuse me of Necromancy when I used Weird, an illusion spell, because it caused instant death.

IC confusion is always fun. I like when people don't rp a level 1 fighter as Mr.Sourcebook. They heard necromancers kill with spells, you killed with a spell. Makes sense! :D

---
(Not for Flasmix):

On an OOC level, I don't understand why this comes up time and time again. You can't be a goodie and use vamp feast. Becuse that is in the rules. Also, both PM/BM (after the first x levels, when you get more then the simple "emo power") should be explicitly marked as evil, so there is no confusion.

Some things are evul, and will be. Just becuse. This is DnD, with a simple morality. Don't try to rule lawyer it, becuse it is not meant to be rule lawyered. Then it falls apart. Try to understand the spirit of the aligments not the written part.

They are the sum of your actions. Do something evil? Get's added. Won't make you go from LG to LE all the sudden (unless it is that bad), but you will go closer to it. Etc. In PnP this is a typical "DM decides" thing. For the time being, we have spells which are tagged.

Evil: It is evil. Becuse I said so.
Good: Same, just with good.
Everything else: Not inherently good or evil.

If you use an evil for a good cause, it is still evil, if the action itself is inherently evil. Example: *animate* dead. You should get evil points for it (coders, can you implement a mechanic for this? X chance to get Y evil points?). Jergal is more of a "sum of good and evil" type of netural in my eyes. He does both, but is not relly either. It balances out in the end.

EDIT: Not raise, animate dead, fair point, thids.
Last edited by TheLier on Thu Aug 25, 2016 6:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
thids
Posts: 1252
Joined: Sat May 25, 2013 11:05 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by thids »

^
agreed
except I think you mean animate dead, not raise dead.
Lord Maximilian Blackthorne - retired
User avatar
Young Werther
Posts: 863
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 8:42 pm
Location: Azkaban

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Young Werther »

It's rare for them to code in alignment ahifts due to abuse like paladin/ black guards and stuff.
Lockonnow wrote:greatest fear like the movie Hellraiser they show you what you most fear and take a Image of IT
chad878262
Posts: 9332
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:55 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by chad878262 »

yep, Bard/Paladin would be one of them, but there are others along lawful/chaotic axis and good/evil axis that would cause issues. Paladin/BG is actually a bit weak since when a Paladin "falls" they loose their powers.
Chord Silverstrings - Bard and OSR Squire / Tarent Nefzen - Arcane Wand Merchant and Master Alchemist / Irrace Arkentlar - Drow Adventurer / Finneaus Du'Veil - Gem Merchant and Executive Officer of SCCE

Tarent's Wands and Elixirs

A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
User avatar
Rhifox
Posts: 3962
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Rhifox »

TheLier wrote:Also, both PM/BM (after the first x levels, when you get more then the simple "emo power") should be explicitly marked as evil, so there is no confusion.
I don't agree with this at all. Blood magus is just calling on the power inherent in blood to beef up its spells. It doesn't make someone feel greater pain or suffering, it doesn't devote sacrifices to an evil god, it doesn't create or raise undead, it doesn't attack souls. It literally does not do anything, as a class, that DnD describes as "Evil". It has almost zero alignment restrictions in PnP because there's literally nothing about BM that's evil by itself. Its version on BG is frankly already more restrictive than it should be with the silly alignment hits. Whatever BG dev made the class tried to really force the idea that it's super evil and corrupt by giving it a radically altered description, but no such moral judgments were made in the original pnp class. It goes to show how easily an idea can be demonized just by how you write it.
Hidden: show
Complete Arcane wrote:BLOOD MAGUS
Death is the ultimate risk that spellcasters, like all adventurers, must contend with. Some are cut down before they have a chance at true glory; others find true peace only in the afterlife; and others are brought back from death by companions with the powerful magical resources to perform such a miracle. For a rare few such arcanists, this trip to the great beyond and back brings a new enlightenment—a comprehension of the body and its individual parts that transcends the understanding of those who have not experienced death and returned to tell the tale.

These newly raised spellcasters say that the first sound they hear upon returning to life is the pulse of life-giving blood in their veins. To these fortunate few, this flow of blood through their veins is sweet music: the sound of life. They can feel it reenergizing every particle of their form, flushing death away and leaving life in its place. It is thick and warm, and they greedily embrace it.

Such arcane spellcasters become blood magi: formerly deceased spellcasters who, when returned to life, gain an understanding of their blood’s importance, bequeathed by their close call. They learn to evoke magic from this vital fluid that sustains their lives. Blood magi cannot be trained, owing to the unusual nature of their enlightenment, and they are most likely to have first been sorcerers.

NPC blood magi are thus rarely, if ever, found in groups. They are more likely to be thinly scattered throughout a region’s spellcaster population.

...

Alignment: Any but Lawful Good

...

Bloodseeking Spell (Su): Beginning at 6th level, a blood magus can imbue his spells with the ability to draw blood from their targets. To use this ability, a blood magus must inflict a wound on himself; this is a free action that deals 3 points of damage to the blood magus and becomes a normal part of casting the spell. Damage reduction, if a blood magus has any, doesn’t apply to this damage. A bloodseeking spell deals an extra 1d6 points of damage to each target that takes damage from the spell. This extra damage applies only to spells that deal hit point damage, not to spells that deal ability damage, ability drain, or other kinds of damage. Constructs, elementals, oozes, plants, undead, and any creatures without blood or a similar substance within their bodies are immune to this effect.
Compare that with BG's description of the class.
Sacrifices are evil, yes. But blood mages aren't doing sacrifices. Blood magic is often associated with sacrifice, and certainly can perform sacrifices, and so it carries a negative connotation for this, but the class itself does not as a basic feature perform any sacrifices. It simply draws on the power in its own blood, or its target's blood, to make its spells a bit more powerful. For it to be sacrifice, for it to be evil, the blood mage would have to be killing/draining an innocent victim in a ritualized manner that creates undue suffering and/or is dedicated to an evil god. Blood magus doesn't do that. What a blood mage does is essentially what druids do with water: oh, you have this thing inside you, something that I understand and have control of, if you're my enemy I can use that against you.


Pale master is a bit more iffy, they actually have as class features things that are definitively described as evil in Book of Vile Darkness. On the other hand, DnD tends to give necromancy classes the benefit of the doubt and allow for the option of characters who maintain some level of discipline and self-control and balance their evil acts with good deeds and good intents. Very few players end up actually doing this, but the option is there.
Book of Vile Darkness wrote:Sometimes, a nonevil spellcaster can get away with casting a few evil spells, as long as he or she does not do so for an evil purpose.
Heroes of Horror wrote:Performing evil acts is a basic feature of the class, but some dread necromancers manage to balance evil acts with good intentions, remaining solidly neutral (most PC dread necromancers fall into this category.)

((dread necromancer's alignment description used because the class is functionally similar to PM))
Ultimately, adding new alignment restrictions just limits players options. Alignment restrictions should be used very sparingly, only when there is absolutely zero potential at all for a class to fit in that alignment. More classes should have their restrictions reduced, instead of expanded. There is never any positive to be found in reducing player options for RP.
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
User avatar
Hawke
Posts: 1245
Joined: Sun Aug 01, 2010 6:11 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Hawke »

Thids wrote:^
agreed
except I think you mean animate dead, not raise dead.
I have had characters accused of being Evil Necromancers for raising dead allies :P
If the text is this color, I am on duty, everything else is just my humble opinion.
User avatar
metaquad4
Posts: 1532
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by metaquad4 »

Hidden: show
Rhifox wrote:
TheLier wrote:Also, both PM/BM (after the first x levels, when you get more then the simple "emo power") should be explicitly marked as evil, so there is no confusion.
I don't agree with this at all. Blood magus is just calling on the power inherent in blood to beef up its spells. It doesn't make someone feel greater pain or suffering, it doesn't devote sacrifices to an evil god, it doesn't create or raise undead, it doesn't attack souls. It literally does not do anything, as a class, that DnD describes as "Evil". It has almost zero alignment restrictions in PnP because there's literally nothing about BM that's evil by itself. Its version on BG is frankly already more restrictive than it should be with the silly alignment hits. Whatever BG dev made the class tried to really force the idea that it's super evil and corrupt by giving it a radically altered description, but no such moral judgments were made in the original pnp class. It goes to show how easily an idea can be demonized just by how you write it.
Complete Arcane wrote:BLOOD MAGUS
Death is the ultimate risk that spellcasters, like all adventurers, must contend with. Some are cut down before they have a chance at true glory; others find true peace only in the afterlife; and others are brought back from death by companions with the powerful magical resources to perform such a miracle. For a rare few such arcanists, this trip to the great beyond and back brings a new enlightenment—a comprehension of the body and its individual parts that transcends the understanding of those who have not experienced death and returned to tell the tale.

These newly raised spellcasters say that the first sound they hear upon returning to life is the pulse of life-giving blood in their veins. To these fortunate few, this flow of blood through their veins is sweet music: the sound of life. They can feel it reenergizing every particle of their form, flushing death away and leaving life in its place. It is thick and warm, and they greedily embrace it.

Such arcane spellcasters become blood magi: formerly deceased spellcasters who, when returned to life, gain an understanding of their blood’s importance, bequeathed by their close call. They learn to evoke magic from this vital fluid that sustains their lives. Blood magi cannot be trained, owing to the unusual nature of their enlightenment, and they are most likely to have first been sorcerers.

NPC blood magi are thus rarely, if ever, found in groups. They are more likely to be thinly scattered throughout a region’s spellcaster population.

...

Alignment: Any but Lawful Good

...

Bloodseeking Spell (Su): Beginning at 6th level, a blood magus can imbue his spells with the ability to draw blood from their targets. To use this ability, a blood magus must inflict a wound on himself; this is a free action that deals 3 points of damage to the blood magus and becomes a normal part of casting the spell. Damage reduction, if a blood magus has any, doesn’t apply to this damage. A bloodseeking spell deals an extra 1d6 points of damage to each target that takes damage from the spell. This extra damage applies only to spells that deal hit point damage, not to spells that deal ability damage, ability drain, or other kinds of damage. Constructs, elementals, oozes, plants, undead, and any creatures without blood or a similar substance within their bodies are immune to this effect.
Compare that with BG's description of the class.

Sacrifices are evil, yes. But blood mages aren't doing sacrifices. Blood magic is often associated with sacrifice, and certainly can perform sacrifices, and so it carries a negative connotation for this, but the class itself does not as a basic feature perform any sacrifices. It simply draws on the power in its own blood, or its target's blood, to make its spells a bit more powerful. For it to be sacrifice, for it to be evil, the blood mage would have to be killing/draining an innocent victim in a ritualized manner that creates undue suffering and/or is dedicated to an evil god. Blood magus doesn't do that. What a blood mage does is essentially what druids do with water: oh, you have this thing inside you, something that I understand and have control of, if you're my enemy I can use that against you.


Pale master is a bit more iffy, they actually have as class features things that are definitively described as evil in Book of Vile Darkness. On the other hand, DnD tends to give necromancy classes the benefit of the doubt and allow for the option of characters who maintain some level of discipline and self-control and balance their evil acts with good deeds and good intents. Very few players end up actually doing this, but the option is there.
Book of Vile Darkness wrote:Sometimes, a nonevil spellcaster can get away with casting a few evil spells, as long as he or she does not do so for an evil purpose.
Heroes of Horror wrote:Performing evil acts is a basic feature of the class, but some dread necromancers manage to balance evil acts with good intentions, remaining solidly neutral (most PC dread necromancers fall into this category.)

((dread necromancer's alignment description used because the class is functionally similar to PM))
Ultimately, adding new alignment restrictions just limits players options. Alignment restrictions should be used very sparingly, only when there is absolutely zero potential at all for a class to fit in that alignment. More classes should have their restrictions reduced, instead of expanded. There is never any positive to be found in reducing player options for RP.
Regarding the Blood Magus/Magic speel:

Yes, and yes. Though, this server does have some homebrew corruption lore on most of Blood Magus' blood magic evidently, seeing as it shifts your alignment (a discrepancy between here and PnP). So, for the purposes of the server, the DM's homebrew lore trumps the source book lore.

Also, the tomb and blood source book labels them as any none lawful (dnd tools, which references tomb and blood, labels it as none lawful good. Though, tomb and blood makes no reference to a quasi-mandatory evil alignment, or to alignment shifts towards chaotic/evil upon use of the abilities.)

The way I figured was that on this server, all the abilities that use your own blood (level 1-4 blood magus abilities, spirit shaman blood magic) are not aligned inherently, but using someone else's blood (blood magus level 6-10 active abilities) is an evil action. It makes an amount of sense, atleast to me.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
fearknight2003
Posts: 354
Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 8:53 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by fearknight2003 »

Last night I had an encounter with a group of people who, after a fight he had, they all decided my character was an evil necromancer/warlock.
...the only spells he cast were Lesser Orb of Acid and Lesser Orb of Electricty.

It was really funny.
It was a fun year (I think). Bye.
User avatar
Rhifox
Posts: 3962
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Rhifox »

metaquad4 wrote:The way I figured was that on this server, all the abilities that use your own blood (level 1-4 blood magus abilities, spirit shaman blood magic) are not aligned inherently, but using someone else's blood (blood magus level 6-10 active abilities) is an evil action. It makes an amount of sense, atleast to me.
Ironically, I would consider the spirit shaman one the more evil variant. A blood magus, even on BG, is a talent learned by dying, then being returned to life and finding yourself open to the power in blood. It's rooted in the self, a sudden realization of one's own inherent capabilities. But a spirit shaman's blood magic is theoretically given to them by the spirits, because all of a spirit shaman's spells and abilities are given to them by the spirits. That means a shaman's blood magic actually is a sacrifice dedicated to another being... and the spirits most likely to grant power for sacrifices of blood are going to be evil spirits. The fact that it's voluntary wouldn't really change the fact it's a sacrifice of blood to a probably-evil being for a gift of power.

That's how I play it on mine, at least.
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
User avatar
Garn Greymoon
Posts: 288
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 12:19 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Garn Greymoon »

fearknight2003 wrote:Last night I had an encounter with a group of people who, after a fight he had, they all decided my character was an evil necromancer/warlock.
...the only spells he cast were Lesser Orb of Acid and Lesser Orb of Electricty.

It was really funny.
Yes that was funny thanks for being a good sport about it.

Vabo . . . . . Gnome Druid - The Mushroom Man
Dag . . . . . Gnome Bard - The Twang Fury
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Boddynock »

Rhifox wrote:... and the spirits most likely to grant power for sacrifices of blood are going to be evil spirits. The fact that it's voluntary wouldn't really change the fact it's a sacrifice of blood to a probably-evil being for a gift of power.
Why would they have to be evil? That is a pretty big assumption. It could also be simply that blood is highly valued as a sacrifice in the spirit world because it is populated entirely by incorporeal beings that have no blood.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
Young Werther
Posts: 863
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 8:42 pm
Location: Azkaban

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Young Werther »

Boddynock wrote:
Rhifox wrote:... and the spirits most likely to grant power for sacrifices of blood are going to be evil spirits. The fact that it's voluntary wouldn't really change the fact it's a sacrifice of blood to a probably-evil being for a gift of power.
Why would they have to be evil? That is a pretty big assumption. It could also be simply that blood is highly valued as a sacrifice in the spirit world because it is populated entirely by incorporeal beings that have no blood.
I consider more like feeding a pet that obeys commands. : P
Lockonnow wrote:greatest fear like the movie Hellraiser they show you what you most fear and take a Image of IT

Return to “General Discussion”