The server rules clearly state that people are expected to RP what is on their sheet, and for the most part I think people assume this means abilities, feats, etc, but what about the back stories for PrCs?
For example, the Daggerspell Mage PrC states
"In a reclusive monastery in the heart of an ancient forest, a varied group of druids and arcane spellcasters train together. The adherents of this monastery work to perfect a unique fighting and spellcasting style that relies on wielding a pair of daggers at all times."
So, in theory all the DsM in game should have made a pilgrimage to this monastery and have been accepted to learn their ways. Yet I've never seen it mentiond or talked about IC.
Hospitalers swear oaths of poverty. The Harper Agent PrC, obviously means that the character should have been recruited by the Harpers to be an agent. Arcane Scholar of Candle Keep, well... As the name implies, it should be only available to people who are studying magic at Candle Keep.
All of these are major events in characters' lives that should be a driving force in their RP.
Back when I was a more active player I often looked for Mage builds, and Arcane Scholar of Candlekeep was one of the more popular classes, and yet almost every time I went to CK it was a ghost town. How was CK producing so many scholars without people actually studying there?
My question is this: Do most people write these elements into their backstories, or do they just take whatever abilities they think sound cool and play the abilities on their sheets rather than where the abilities are said to come from?
Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
PJtheFey
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2015 5:58 am
- Location: Hanoi, Vietnam
-
Steve
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 8197
- Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
- Location: Paradise in GMT +1
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
I make the biggest effort possible, to honor the Class/PrC descriptions.
But sometimes...I just need to make that snowflake!!
But seriously, attempts should be made to consider the Class/PrC for what it is, and RP that accordingly. On that note, I would also prefer ASoC to just be renamed Arcane Scholar, since it was a NWN2 PrC, not D&D (if I'm not mistaken).
But sometimes...I just need to make that snowflake!!
But seriously, attempts should be made to consider the Class/PrC for what it is, and RP that accordingly. On that note, I would also prefer ASoC to just be renamed Arcane Scholar, since it was a NWN2 PrC, not D&D (if I'm not mistaken).
Jon Smythe - The Book of....
Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant
Sabross N'azza - Working...
Khelboros Wyrmstone
-
Rhifox
- Posts: 3962
- Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
As I wrote when you asked this question on Skype, I absolutely do believe people should be acknowledging the class flavor backgrounds.
If you're an arcane scholar, you better be someone who approaches magic with a scholarly and analytical bent (and should ideally be a wizard, not a sorcerer). If you're a hospitalier, you better have your oath of poverty. If you're a daggerspell mage you should have been trained in or by someone who was trained in that monastery. If you're a fist of the forest, you don't eat anything from a tavern and you don't sleep indoors. Etc.
On my characters I choose their classes first by the background of the class and how it works for my character's story. The mechanics come second. While Tarina is mostly just straight spirit shaman without multiclassing (though I did take a few barbarian levels), being a shaman very much defines who she is as a character. I did really want to take some druid levels to add some shapeshifting, but due to druid being a very, very heavy background/lore-based class, it just wasn't feasible to do on Tarina so I didn't.
On my red wizard, Saetra, she's characterized almost as much by her other classes as it is by red wizard. She's a devotee of Pale lore and has 'slept in a crypt alongside undead' as the class requires. The "science" of the class is something that she's very drawn to. Pale master's the sort of class that, flavor-wise, works great not just for necromancers, but also transmuters and abjurers. It's a class that revolves around the idea of manipulating your own body to enhance its durability through incorporating the great physical strengths of an undead creature. And though not quite as character defining, she's a frost mage for similar reasons: manipulation of her own body to integrate the strengths of a particular kind of magic.
A character's classes should not just be some words on a sheet and abilities you use to make them as powerful as can be. It should be something taken because that is who the character is. Same goes for attribute and skill scores, and feats taken.
If you're an arcane scholar, you better be someone who approaches magic with a scholarly and analytical bent (and should ideally be a wizard, not a sorcerer). If you're a hospitalier, you better have your oath of poverty. If you're a daggerspell mage you should have been trained in or by someone who was trained in that monastery. If you're a fist of the forest, you don't eat anything from a tavern and you don't sleep indoors. Etc.
On my characters I choose their classes first by the background of the class and how it works for my character's story. The mechanics come second. While Tarina is mostly just straight spirit shaman without multiclassing (though I did take a few barbarian levels), being a shaman very much defines who she is as a character. I did really want to take some druid levels to add some shapeshifting, but due to druid being a very, very heavy background/lore-based class, it just wasn't feasible to do on Tarina so I didn't.
On my red wizard, Saetra, she's characterized almost as much by her other classes as it is by red wizard. She's a devotee of Pale lore and has 'slept in a crypt alongside undead' as the class requires. The "science" of the class is something that she's very drawn to. Pale master's the sort of class that, flavor-wise, works great not just for necromancers, but also transmuters and abjurers. It's a class that revolves around the idea of manipulating your own body to enhance its durability through incorporating the great physical strengths of an undead creature. And though not quite as character defining, she's a frost mage for similar reasons: manipulation of her own body to integrate the strengths of a particular kind of magic.
A character's classes should not just be some words on a sheet and abilities you use to make them as powerful as can be. It should be something taken because that is who the character is. Same goes for attribute and skill scores, and feats taken.
Correct, it's a homebrewed class for NWN2. I also think it should be given an Intelligence requirement, because it's rather silly that a class that is designed around the analytical study of the underlying rules of magic is better for and more used by sorcerers than wizards. If ASoC had an Int requirement then those sorcerers would at least have to be as smart as wizards if they want to actually engage in what is supposed to be the wizard's motif.Steve wrote:But seriously, attempts should be made to consider the Class/PrC for what it is, and RP that accordingly. On that note, I would also prefer ASoC to just be renamed Arcane Scholar, since it was a NWN2 PrC, not D&D (if I'm not mistaken).
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
-
Kaosfury
- Posts: 18
- Joined: Sat Aug 27, 2016 12:09 pm
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
I agree you should be as accurate as possible. And the point is made if you take a special class or feed that requires a backstory you should incorporate that.
But on the same page I'm about 50% RP 50% PVE so I understand what it's like to need to take a class or take a feed or take something to overall balance your toon.
I love the role play but of course this game server is the most consistent role playing I've ever done
I'm pretty decent at it but I'm finding that your guys like deph here so I better get my RP hat on
But on the same page I'm about 50% RP 50% PVE so I understand what it's like to need to take a class or take a feed or take something to overall balance your toon.
I love the role play but of course this game server is the most consistent role playing I've ever done
I'm pretty decent at it but I'm finding that your guys like deph here so I better get my RP hat on
-
Kiran
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2016 12:21 pm
- Location: United Kingdom
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
I dont really know or care what most people do, that's their business and rp, I expect they know what they are doing and do so to enjoy their own rp and playing with their character day to day.My question is this: Do most people write these elements into their backstories, or do they just take whatever abilities they think sound cool and play the abilities on their sheets rather than where the abilities are said to come from?
For me personally, Think I have RCR'd Damien a couple of times now, from Cleric, to FVS, then full blackguard to a bit of a mix. Now I am looking at dropping FVS for a more full combat build with a very high healing next to it, meaning I had to add in some warrior of darkness to the build.
Does the above make my characters background a bit odd? Sure it does, does it make any difference to me or how I rp? Not in the slightest. I wont be wasting any time in game or on my background to explain these changes except to update the character sheet.
Personally I dont think backstories mean anything, characters adapt and change in game to who and what they rp with, my character in his very short time on server gone from one extreme to the other, all from actually murdering a hero in game played by a good aligned person to going out of his way to heal and care for the injured at some events. His background has no effect on this, mainly what he has experienced within the actual game or done has affected this.
Bit of a long reply to the question, so briefly.
Do most of people write these into their background? Probably, who knows, not my business.
Do they take whatever that sounds cool etc etc...: I do personally, I imagine others do as well, up to them really, their character, their rp, their fun for when not working or wanting to relax with a game.
As long as the DM's dont mind, and its not absolutely crazy I say go for it.
Player of:
Damian Pascal, - Run away/dead. - Background - Corruption from Within
Amenthes Serb, Knight - Gone missing/Supposed dead Background
Tamzim Renima, mercenary - Handed over to the fist. Background
Kiran, Golden Wheel - Presumed dead
Althalous Fenwick, Paladin of Mystra. - A memory lost
Althalous Fenwick, Paladin of Mystra. - A memory lost
-
PJtheFey
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2015 5:58 am
- Location: Hanoi, Vietnam
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
That's a good point, do the DMs mind?Kiran wrote: As long as the DM's dont mind, and its not absolutely crazy I say go for it.
After all, why bother including the introduction text for PrCs if people aren't expected to incorperate it into their character?
-
Pimple
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 1062
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2016 5:07 pm
- Location: CET (Discord: Pimple)
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
Well it is helpful for those of us who suck at lore 
"They're just furry and misunderstood."
"Is that why you are killing them?"
"Yes. They will atone in death."
"Ah. That will help them understand."
Sirion Te'dwa - Shop
"Is that why you are killing them?"
"Yes. They will atone in death."
"Ah. That will help them understand."
Sirion Te'dwa - Shop
-
TheLier
- Posts: 388
- Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
EDUCATE YOURSELF LOWLY PEONPimple wrote:Well it is helpful for those of us who suck at lore
j/k
Overall, the general consensus is pretty much ignoring the RP boundaries of classes. Like, ignoring how PM/BM/Paladin/Warlock should work. There seems to be near zero enforcement.
-
Blame The Rogue
- Posts: 653
- Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am
Re: Flavor Text vs Playing What's On Your Sheet
play what's on your sheet, yes
how much of that the character chooses to share with others, depends on each individual character
agreed. rename asoc to arcane scholar
how much of that the character chooses to share with others, depends on each individual character
agreed. rename asoc to arcane scholar
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."