Power level of a PC

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Rhifox
Posts: 3962
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Rhifox »

Steve wrote:It really boils down to the perception issue. Let me explain.

There are few to none battles/encounters our Characters lose. There are times when a Character makes a sacrifice of their life, but that is 99% premeditated Player decision. Without the random aspect of in-the-hands-of-the-Dice Roll Death, there is little to nothing our Characters learn to fear.

This perception—which can be seen both IC and OOC—drives a type of experienced disconnect from a security in truly understanding, and relating to, power level.

Power can be defined by what you maintain. Old age, for example, slowly takes power away. Our Characters seem to be infinitely blessed by non-degrating power, and then, when subjected to an interaction that seems altogether implausible based on past experiences—like defying avatars and beating lichs to a pulp—the resulting reaction is confusion.

Power level in general is screwed up herein BGTSCC, because the D&D game was never meant to be played outside a fixed Level spread, usually 3 Levels difference.

A solution to the gaming experience is to only interact with PCs and Areas that are equal to your own PC's level. That at least would balance out many of the inconsistencies currently present on this Server.

But then again, based on many recent comments by Players, the majority is shooting for Max Power and Max Level in the shortest time achievable. :|
Which makes the 'interacting only with PCs equal to your own level' solution rather infeasible except where tightly regulated via adventure groups. The majority of characters encountered will be different levels, and the ones that are the same level won't be the same for very long. Even when my character was low level, the majority of characters she interacted with were in their epics, as these characters are generally the ones involved with guilds and most roleplay.

Personally I can't really see anything that can be done about that except divorcing character level from the perception and treating all characters as roughly within the same range regardless of their actual level, despite the huge mechanical differences between 1 and 30. One way to help with that would be globally turning off the level marker on Scry and not letting people change it.

Of course the ideal would be lowering the cap (or upping the starting level) and rebalancing the entire server for a smaller range. But that will never happen.

As far as the fear of death thing... unfortunately even the three strikes rule tends to go unused by the DMs from what I hear, as players will bitch if they even get a strike, let alone an actual permadeath. Combined with the very powerful builds that are used to soloing everything, yeah. Makes many events rather dull when many characters refuse to take things as threats.

Maybe DMs should start calling for Will saving throws against Fear more often. Calling for fear rolls is something that I've seen very little of, even from creatures that are supposed to have an aura of fear like dragons or liches. It should really be done more. It's not quite the same thing as having the players actually afraid for their characters due to a real threat of death, but it at least would somewhat encourage them to RP fear in their characters when they fail the roll.
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

I sometimes question if we Players should really even apply such things as actual Level to our Characters, to our RP. Let me explain.

Does Johnny Sword REALLY know he is a Level 12 Fighter? No, in in-character terms and RP, he does not. What Johnny Sword DOES know is that he is a Master of his Weapon, and that after a number of days/months/years training and adventuring, he has achieved the skill to do much more damage and attack with such skill, others may refer to his abilities as epic (he may as well, if he has a big ego...like Randall).

My point is our Characters really have no idea about power level in any concrete terms, especially since the Dice are such factors in any outcome of Actions. Therefore every encounter could be of one where the antagonist is more skilled, more powerful than our Character, or...just lucky! And OOC upset-ness about losing to Bandits or Dracoliches or vampir rabbits should be checked at the door and let the Dice determine the outcome (and get off the DM and quit the blame).

In addition, should our RP be reflective of an OOC understanding our Characters WILL get more powerful? I say no, or at least, it is an OOC action bordering on metagaming to assume our Characters will get to be Level 30 mini-gods.

In my humble opinion, a level 30 Character should be open to chance-based failure. And if the Player accepts this to the fullest, meaning applying the aspect of chance-based death to their Character and their RP—then the Player does themselves and the Server a great service, because that puts Power back into a actual relative state.

And it clears up confusion.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Rhifox
Posts: 3962
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Rhifox »

I agree. That's how I try to RP at least. Perception divorced from level. My character's don't know what level they are, or what level other things are, they just know what things they are able to do. Everyone that raises a sword (or spell, or claw) is a potential threat, and just because you got lucky and managed to kill something like a dragon doesn't mean that jolly roger bandit can't get lucky too.
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
User avatar
metaquad4
Posts: 1532
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by metaquad4 »

Rhifox wrote:
As far as the fear of death thing... unfortunately even the three strikes rule tends to go unused by the DMs from what I hear, as players will bitch if they even get a strike, let alone an actual permadeath. Combined with the very powerful builds that are used to soloing everything, yeah. Makes many events rather dull when many characters refuse to take things as threats.
Thank you so, so much for touching on this.

I think, for the world-changing events, as well as events where a powerful enemy is being faced, permadeath strikes should be used when there is an element of danger involved. The PCs should be warned, and given an "out", but if the PCs continue along the path that will put them in danger then they should be given a permadeath when they die to the danger they are facing.

This would not only add an element of actual danger (rather than a saturday-night cartoon esque form of always knowing the outcome - that being heroes live and the world moves on until the next threat for the most part) but it would also enforce a bit of actual consequence for actions as well. If people think taking down a lich or a dragon is just a cakewalk, they will think again when permadeath strikes are involved. It won't be a cakewalk suddenly, it will be an actual threat that they will need to consider. DMs need to use these strikes for things other than executions, badly. It would solve a fair few major issues with OOC-IC player perception of power levels.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by TheLier »

Great points, but I would like to add something, stated in the OP, but a bit overlooked.

I think we need less dragons/liches/whatevers. If the scale of the "danger" goes down (honestly it is getting nonsensical that we are at the brink of imminent destruction several times during one year. It is prefectly valid in my eyes to develop a stoic perception of such by toons), the whole problem pretty much goes away.

A criminal overlord in BG, who you can't just beat up? Dukes having personal beef with people? Temple of Lolth plotting for more power?

You can throw in combat encounters in, but the point would be, that they are not that important, and in itself can't solve the situation. They might even make it worse, and have terrible consequences. (altough not setting-wrecking, on that note, it might be good not to have too many things which could cause that)

This is only my personal "elitist" opinion.
chad878262
Posts: 9332
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:55 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by chad878262 »

I feel so bad for the Campaign Coordinator DM's...

Two years ago the complaint was none of the events had an impact any more... there weren't enough server stretching campaigns that lasted long periods of time culminating in some major event... Now it's that there is too much of the same thing folks were begging for. While I can understand the 'overload' perhaps part of this also leads back to what Steve talks about fairly often in the sense that we have our level 30's that are always there to save the day and nothing bad ever happens to them. What if some massive demon / dragon / other BBEG actually won? What if the end of the campaign/year long server story ended with several major characters that have been around for 5 years being perma-killed based on the dice instead of being based on the players decision? My guess is a lot of people would leave, unfortunately... It would be an amazing story if the sword coast was plagued for YEARS by one BBEG before finally the right group of adventurers banded together and found a way to defeat it, but that would require lots and lots of failure which most folks are not willing to accept. *shrug* my point is you can't have it both ways... either we get to go around fighting lots of cool end game style content and then deal with the fact that in events, depending on the story being told and the DM running the event sometimes we are fighting epic style bandits....or we remove all the cool end game content and replace it with end bosses that are essentially beefed up orcs, humans, etc. By the same token either the DM's continue crafting annual challenges that put the server on the brink of destruction for all the hero's to go out and solve and we deal with the realism issues of all these calamaties occurring or we make piece with having far less epic/long term stories being told.

I'd caution folks to be careful what they wish for, The DM activity over the past 18 months is much higher than it was the first 6 months I played. That's a good thing for players, even if there are still not enough DM's to fill ALL the multitude requests that come through.
Chord Silverstrings - Bard and OSR Squire / Tarent Nefzen - Arcane Wand Merchant and Master Alchemist / Irrace Arkentlar - Drow Adventurer / Finneaus Du'Veil - Gem Merchant and Executive Officer of SCCE

Tarent's Wands and Elixirs

A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

chad878262 wrote:I'd caution folks to be careful what they wish for...
While this is in general a "rule" to live by, this is a game, not real life, and thus why not take risks? I mean really, is your digital Player Character so utterly important that you cannot place it in the ULTIMATE Risk vs. Reward system, and....ROLL THE DICE!

This is what D&D was about. I go with the assumption that NWN2 was based off this principle of a Game. Maybe it is a wrong assumption, and that BGTSCC is more like the Sims or one's precious goldfish, and we're surely not going to let Goldy die. :|

I'm being sharp and a bit sarcastic because I really think that preciousness many of us—hell, I care about my PC's storyline a lot—is holding back a much greater experience of this game.

A problem does exist in that the Risk vs. Reward system is poor. Why risk your Level 30 that took you 2 years to attain, when the rewards are...what exactly?!? This is probably the usual question/response from the general Player, and I understand it. Not everyone is just simply satisfied with the Story from Level 1 to Level 30. Some are not even that interested in the RP from Level 1 – 30, nor even RP at a low level! :shock: But that is fine: BGTSCC caters to all, right?

Power is transient. That is what makes it pretty awesome if you have it, maintaining it until your lose it. In the case of our Player Characters, working with the DMs and either personal or Server wide story arcs, the aspect of maintaining power and placing power ON THE LINE in order to influence the PW Environment in possibly Major ways—hell, even minor ways would be cool—is kinda what it is all about.

Glory in the Life of your Player Character. Player Characters that are played as immortals, cheapen that glory. And Power is truly achieved when there is actual challenge to acquiring it, and maintaining it.

You have to risk something. That makes it a challenging game worth playing.

EDIT: and please stop throwing around the word "complaint." It gets about as annoying as when someone mentions the "toxic" nature of the Forums, or Players, etc. Being critical is very different than complaining...and debate is a constructive thing!!

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Snarfy
Posts: 1430
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 12:14 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Snarfy »

TheLier wrote:You can throw in combat encounters in, but the point would be, that they are not that important, and in itself can't solve the situation. They might even make it worse, and have terrible consequences. (altough not setting-wrecking, on that note, it might be good not to have too many things which could cause that)

This is only my personal "elitist" opinion.
I'll second your opinion on this one. Too many encounters/events/antagonistic role-play situations rely on combat as the final and only solution. Unfortunately we as players have been programmed by an engine, mechanics, and a server that directly reward us(and greatly I might add) for continuously slaughtering our way through content as a means of progressing our characters. Is it any wonder then why things devolve into bloodshed 99 times out of 100? I tend to think not.

Needless to say, I do wish for more encounters that relied upon players utilizing the abilities of their characters that don't have to do with their capacity for carnage. This is coming from a guy who plays a skill-monkey main though, so I freely admit my bias.
There are no level 30's, only level 20's with benefits...
chad878262
Posts: 9332
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:55 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by chad878262 »

Steve wrote:
chad878262 wrote:I'd caution folks to be careful what they wish for...
While this is in general a "rule" to live by, this is a game, not real life, and thus why not take risks? I mean really, is your digital Player Character so utterly important that you cannot place it in the ULTIMATE Risk vs. Reward system, and....ROLL THE DICE!

This is what D&D was about. I go with the assumption that NWN2 was based off this principle of a Game. Maybe it is a wrong assumption, and that BGTSCC is more like the Sims or one's precious goldfish, and we're surely not going to let Goldy die. :|

I'm being sharp and a bit sarcastic because I really think that preciousness many of us—hell, I care about my PC's storyline a lot—is holding back a much greater experience of this game.

A problem does exist in that the Risk vs. Reward system is poor. Why risk your Level 30 that took you 2 years to attain, when the rewards are...what exactly?!? This is probably the usual question/response from the general Player, and I understand it. Not everyone is just simply satisfied with the Story from Level 1 to Level 30. Some are not even that interested in the RP from Level 1 – 30, nor even RP at a low level! :shock: But that is fine: BGTSCC caters to all, right?

Power is transient. That is what makes it pretty awesome if you have it, maintaining it until your lose it. In the case of our Player Characters, working with the DMs and either personal or Server wide story arcs, the aspect of maintaining power and placing power ON THE LINE in order to influence the PW Environment in possibly Major ways—hell, even minor ways would be cool—is kinda what it is all about.

Glory in the Life of your Player Character. Player Characters that are played as immortals, cheapen that glory. And Power is truly achieved when there is actual challenge to acquiring it, and maintaining it.

You have to risk something. That makes it a challenging game worth playing.

EDIT: and please stop throwing around the word "complaint." It gets about as annoying as when someone mentions the "toxic" nature of the Forums, or Players, etc. Being critical is very different than complaining...and debate is a constructive thing!!

Think you need to go back and re-read my post...Pretty sure I said it would be an amazing story if BBEG won the day and a bunch of epics got perma-dead along the way... I followed up with my guess being a lot of people would leave, because I think that would happen for better or worse, didn't say it would bother me, in fact I think I have said in the past I would be open to a world where death is permanent / only cured by getting resurrected/raise dead (thus if not found before server reset you are truly dead). But regardless, my point was actually more about the fact that such changes to an old server can have dire impacts. Frankly though I could have written the end better. My 'careful what you wish for' comment was aimed at the comment that there are too many OMG dire circumstances with the server metaplots. I was simply saying that the alternative (weak/no meta plot?) would make for some pretty mundane/boring storylines.

Not sure what the issue is with the word 'complaint'... But I would define comments indicating a dislike or desire for change as to current status quo as a 'complaint' I really don't have the desire to bust out the thesaurus and word smith my posts... replace 'complaint' with comment or opinion or whatever you like if it helps.
Chord Silverstrings - Bard and OSR Squire / Tarent Nefzen - Arcane Wand Merchant and Master Alchemist / Irrace Arkentlar - Drow Adventurer / Finneaus Du'Veil - Gem Merchant and Executive Officer of SCCE

Tarent's Wands and Elixirs

A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

chad878262 wrote:changes to an old server can have dire impacts.
It can, surely. But Players can also change the paradigm, and the Server would follow suit. How about that?!? ;)

As for using "complaint": Complaining for me is when someone goes "I don't like this...wah wah wah." And doesn't delve into the issue, making critical decisions of empirical experience or academic study, nor providing any alternatives for consideration.

I don't like to validate the argument that changes are going to cause Players to leave BGTSCC. I interpret that line of thinking as a sort of fear mongering—and I'm not saying you are doing this Chad, although you reference it in your post. Players have ALWAYS left BGTSCC, and guess what? Players are still COMING to BGTSCC, because it is the best CRPG Permanent Server out there, imho.

But if considering change is always put up against "how many Players will leave?" or worse, just the statement "Players WILL leave, because xyz...," we shackle the possibilities for improvement of the Role-Play experience.

Luckily, Players can do much to adjust or test out or experiment or adopt new ways of RPing, and actually trying to experiment with self-made challenges. It also goes a long way to do this with others, so you can have a greater experience of the Game.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Maecius
Retired Admin
Posts: 11639
Joined: Sat May 16, 2009 4:24 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Maecius »

Just an aside to everyone in this thread, or following this thread: We are actively recruiting DMs, with an open application period until the 16th.

It'd be one way to help develop stories and story consistency that run more in line with your vision for an improved server, I'd think? Becoming one of the storytellers.
User avatar
Blame The Rogue
Posts: 653
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Blame The Rogue »

i feel most folks come here to tell their character's story

they cant tell that story if the character is dead

i would never involve any of my pcs in a situation where strikes and or permdeath were in the mix. unless of course it was time in my eyes to retire said character

to me, it makes sense that there's such a thing as a standard low level bandit, which most pcs would quickly throttle, and hero bandits, which would give my character and their party a run for our money

in a game based on imagination, i don't feel it's too much to ask, for players in a dm event, to believe and understand the notion, of a hero bandit

that being said, i don't think the goal of any dm should be to kill players, but to challenge them, as they tell a story, and make the characters part of that story. if it is to be a very challenging encounter, then a couple characters may die. but that's a byproduct of a challenge in a story, and not the goal itself. i'm sure occasionally, in an attempt to challenge a party, party wipes happen. but this is not intentional. it's not easy to gauge what a party can and cant do, from the dm's point of view
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by TheLier »

chad878262 wrote:
Steve wrote:
chad878262 wrote:I'd caution folks to be careful what they wish for...
While this is in general a "rule" to live by, this is a game, not real life, and thus why not take risks? I mean really, is your digital Player Character so utterly important that you cannot place it in the ULTIMATE Risk vs. Reward system, and....ROLL THE DICE!

This is what D&D was about. I go with the assumption that NWN2 was based off this principle of a Game. Maybe it is a wrong assumption, and that BGTSCC is more like the Sims or one's precious goldfish, and we're surely not going to let Goldy die. :|

I'm being sharp and a bit sarcastic because I really think that preciousness many of us—hell, I care about my PC's storyline a lot—is holding back a much greater experience of this game.

A problem does exist in that the Risk vs. Reward system is poor. Why risk your Level 30 that took you 2 years to attain, when the rewards are...what exactly?!? This is probably the usual question/response from the general Player, and I understand it. Not everyone is just simply satisfied with the Story from Level 1 to Level 30. Some are not even that interested in the RP from Level 1 – 30, nor even RP at a low level! :shock: But that is fine: BGTSCC caters to all, right?

Power is transient. That is what makes it pretty awesome if you have it, maintaining it until your lose it. In the case of our Player Characters, working with the DMs and either personal or Server wide story arcs, the aspect of maintaining power and placing power ON THE LINE in order to influence the PW Environment in possibly Major ways—hell, even minor ways would be cool—is kinda what it is all about.

Glory in the Life of your Player Character. Player Characters that are played as immortals, cheapen that glory. And Power is truly achieved when there is actual challenge to acquiring it, and maintaining it.

You have to risk something. That makes it a challenging game worth playing.

EDIT: and please stop throwing around the word "complaint." It gets about as annoying as when someone mentions the "toxic" nature of the Forums, or Players, etc. Being critical is very different than complaining...and debate is a constructive thing!!

Think you need to go back and re-read my post...Pretty sure I said it would be an amazing story if BBEG won the day and a bunch of epics got perma-dead along the way... I followed up with my guess being a lot of people would leave, because I think that would happen for better or worse, didn't say it would bother me, in fact I think I have said in the past I would be open to a world where death is permanent / only cured by getting resurrected/raise dead (thus if not found before server reset you are truly dead). But regardless, my point was actually more about the fact that such changes to an old server can have dire impacts. Frankly though I could have written the end better. My 'careful what you wish for' comment was aimed at the comment that there are too many OMG dire circumstances with the server metaplots. I was simply saying that the alternative (weak/no meta plot?) would make for some pretty mundane/boring storylines.

Not sure what the issue is with the word 'complaint'... But I would define comments indicating a dislike or desire for change as to current status quo as a 'complaint' I really don't have the desire to bust out the thesaurus and word smith my posts... replace 'complaint' with comment or opinion or whatever you like if it helps.
For the first part, sorry then, I thought you were being sarcastic.

The second one, I think we can find a middle ground. But I already made suggestions on what I would like to see. More subtle "antagonists' (heck I don't the we need things like that, get an NPC push an agenda, some players might even ally for it), less of the "OMG die" things.
User avatar
King Of Clouds
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2013 10:42 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by King Of Clouds »

I think many people in this thread have had very valid points about the issue of having epic players and the balance of how DMs could make it both challenging and interesting. There is also the issue of fame and achievements and power not meeting properly (as with the Arkaine example) because everyone are sort of in the same line with this system and availability of greater gear is limited because of favoritism issues (which is good!).

I have a lot to say about this topic, so I'm going to throw in my thoughts for the matter. Since this is going to be madly long message into the various aspects of the topic, I've formatted each sub-topic in their own heading.

1. About DnD's core design issues

First and foremost it's good to remember that DnD has some really bad design flaws, which have never been properly addressed in its mechanics.

The core issue is that essentially a single dragon of ancient or older age cannot be harmed by a common soldier by any means due to their DR. It doesn't matter if there was 500 or 50.000 soldiers shooting arrows at the thing, but if a red wyrm has DR of 20, 30 SR and 42 AC, it's a statistical impossibility that an army with bulk of its members consisting of level 1 warriors or low level mages can ever do a bloody thing against the dragon. Just the same, Bruenor Battlehammer couldn't have never killed the shadow dragon because his AB was too low to have any chance to hit the thing and energy drain breath weapon really wouldn't help the chances. The reality is the same with epic characters with linear "all stat" progression (discussed further below): a group of 50 level 1 warrior (or let alone their captain, the reknown level 6 fighter with 2 amazing attacks per round!) guards would be a complete joke to the level 20 fighter with great cleave. There might be one or two blows that they could land, but nothing that your basic healing potion couldn't fix for a few petty attacks of opportunity. Simply put: Numbers of weak NPCs don't matter in DnD 3.5.

This is where the adventurers become important and crucial element of power mechanics of the game. Most communities need adventurers badly and the game is designed around the clash of those daring people that have made it past the risky endeavour of becoming monster slayers and reaching a whole new potential and magnificient gear. (Evil and good) adventurers are meant to fight one another, while the smaller communities desperately hope that they take their quarrel somewhere else. Sometimes these clash, hundreds of people die and then the paladin orders/Harpers/other major groups get called in to deal with the chaos, so the responsible adventurers will be seriously challenged and hunted for their crimes. Of course in large cities there are larger garrisons of progessional soldiers, mages, priests, basic siege gear, but most importantly GOLD that will buy them the services of adventurers. That's why even a high-level cleric of Bhaal that would start to kill masses of people in Baldur's Gate would be soon dealt with; not necessary by local town militia but every adventurer of the region (good, neutral or evil alike) interested in claiming the bounty (and perhaps loot his good adventuring gear if nobody was watching!). That's why there is balance in DnD, but it's not focused around the passive world, cities and their militias but the very adventurers that the common folk admire and/or hate and fear.

2. About DnD and Epic levels

Now that the design issues are covered, I want to notify that overall it's good to remember that DnD is not properly designed for level 20+.
The whole game system essentially gives you a ton of tools for levels 1-20, but after that the system simply and plainly breaks apart. Epic Level Handbook essentially throws the rules back to the DM if he wants to deal with campaigns and people that can kill a dragon without breaking a sweat.

Non-epic PCs will always have issues and risks in defeating an ancient dragon or a lich (let alone demi lich!) because of their limited saves, HP and utility (AB, damage, skills, etc). If you give people 10 extra levels with full progression in every aspect of the classes we'll have people with 60+ AC, 70-100 skill rolls (with superb gear naturally), damage output of hundreds/round and so on. Such numbers simply don't work together well with DnD engine, where your average guard of a village (or the whole hundred of them) should have 4-5 hp and 1d10+1 damage with that rusty old halberd. Even epic creatures scale poorly to this rating because the numbers simply go so badly out of hand past 20. That is also why probably less than 5 % of the monsters fit in the "epic" category; it's simply ridiculous to design campaigns involving enemies that are powerful enough to destroy entire kingdoms alone. You can only have so many archdukes of hell that you kill before it's time to call it enough.

This is sort of the same issue as what is present in all MMORPG/Diablo style "it's all about numbers" -games, where someone with significantly lesser numbers (levels) cannot ever do anything noticeable to the other creature with greater numbers (levels). It's the ant vs. dinosaur issue, which makes those games really boring to play, but most importantly it simply strips the game of all realism by skyrocketing the balance issues of low levels compared to high levels.

3. Issues of NWN2 and Epic levels

There are even issues in the NWN2 core and how it follows epic levels, which contradicts the DnD rules of how epic levels are considered. Basically in NWN2 fighters get full BAB and HP progression, a whole bunch of epic feats, while mages get essentially no direct spell power, but they can invest feats for single or several uses/day epic spells. The progress in mathematical terms is linear, which is devastatingly bad for balance.

To compare these systems, in DnD epic levels don't progress work this way at all. One major change is that no classes get any BAB progression whatsoever, and instead just +1 flat ab every odd epic levels. This means no extra attacks after 20 or mages/clerics with 4+ attacks/round unless they were level 16 fighters! Saves get minimal +1 bonus every even level, which is +5 at level 30 (compare that to the bonuses you can get from gear).

In matter of fact the only thing that progresses "normally" are hit points and bonus ability scores, that allow a character to become truly "epic" in terms of their potential (a human as strong as a titan for example). For most classes the power of epic levels is actually founded around epic feats, which are the true source of epic power (powers like devastating critical, dragon shape, epic divine might, epic two weapon fighting, etc). For spellcasters epic levels are a whole different story as they get access to epic magic, which is based upon researching and developing new spells. Epic spells are incredibly powerful, but risky to cast (most backfire upon the caster with deadly consequences). It's also absurdly costly progress even for DnD and a gamble where that epic spell that required 5 years span of collecting funds for can reshape the realms and shatter towns, but it might also destroy you in the process. Think of epic mages like people with a mini-nukes in their pocket. They suit rather poorly for PW worlds to begin with, although with careful balancing even epic mages might be playable.

Overall the "major progression" caps at 20 though and after that characters will merely develop godlike individual skills that can make them fearfully powerful. They still get small bonuses to HP or chance to hit, but it's actually a lot smaller bonus than what items meant for near-epics will provide, so to grow in power they have to continue adventuring to claim more legendary gear and risk their lives in the process. In mathematical terms this means significantly smaller progress in levels past 20, which makes non-epic monsters like liches still dangerous for epic characters.

So essentially the NWN2 system past level 20 is simply and plainly broken beyond repair in its current form. In other words: it enhances the power differences too dramatically and makes the regular monsters or PCs completely useless in DM quests and overall PW roleplay.

There's one more example of a completely different setting that I want to bring to the table to compare the system: All those who played original Baldur's Gate series know that in 2E rules all classes would stop developing already around level 10. There are no ability score boosts, so for most races having 18 strength is as good as it gets, except if you find gear to boost your stats. This meant that only the toughest dwarf with crazy 19 constitution would ever have hope to get around 200 hp (and spontaneous regeneration!), which would be considered truly epic, but still with rather good portion of mortality. This really changes the way how the game works because characters (even epic) cannot ignore even the lucky 20's, where those 30 town guards come at you and cut 1/4 of your health off with a 3x critical of that halberd. The risks become very real and a level 20 mage can blast that epic warrior with 20d8 damage dealing horrid wilting or hold person that is very difficult to save against. Then again that same (unbuffed) mage would be minced by a meager level 10 assassin, let alone a fighter attacking him with the use of invis potion and a knockdown. There is a good deal of balance and dangerous realism in a system like that.

So the biggest issue that we face in this server and engine are:
1) Mobs of enemies can't be represented realistically due to the server/system limitations
2) Even if mobs of enemies could be used, their potential to harm level 30 character would be next to none
3) Epic level availability for everyone is overall bad thing
4) Linear power progression on epic levels is overall very bad thing
5) Epic levels + linear progression for everyone is a complete catastrophy to balance out with this engine.

4. My fix suggestion

So what can we do about the fact that our system is broken and any compensation methods from DMs will be more or less fruitless?

One option is to do nothing and take the server into more or less social server where mechanics are rather irrelevant or design stuff that challenges the super buffed-up powergamers (such as the new adventuring location + shop in Baator or the DM quests with mega-powerful creatures). Unfortunately this leads to the powergamers or extremely rich, wand-possessing PCs taking the complete spotlight in the battle-oriented DM quests, where nobody else can do anything useful except perhaps buffing those folks and staying out of the way. In the long term this naturally guides the flow away from game mechanics to social RP, but people will continue to get annoyed with quests that are designed to deal with those madly powerful builds.

The other option is to change the system rather dramatically, but in a way that would deal least amount of damage to the existing player base. My solution is a system of one NWN1 server where I played around a decade ago. To my experience of playing these games for about 14 years that server had the best system I've ever seen, because it fit so well for DnD settings and also PW world.

In this server there was a soft cap of 15 after which they could progress by RP/DM quests to hard cap of level 20. Getting past the soft cap to hard cap normally took at least a year of active roleplay, participation to events and guild roleplay, which encouraged people to get social with their characters. To keep things interesting people could still find good items, which were quite similar to the power level of BG2 or the stuff that the server has right now (except for the latest epic stores that have been added in). Basically people could find relatively good +3 gear, but even +5 stuff did exist for the more legendary folks. Muc hof the potential power level was determined by gear, rather than build. Availability of decently good gear kept warrior classes in balance with mages and clerics and the hard cap made sure that the classes had sufficient, but not unrealistic power.

If people wanted to get to epic levels it was possible, but they had to undergo an epic quest that was always pre-planned by the head DM team and which you had to apply for separately in the forums. If accepted, there were serious chances that the participating character would die permanently in this process. In case that happened, the players were granted a chance to make a new level 20 character, which meant they wouldn't have to grind their way up, but their story, all the lore related to that old character was forever lost. This meant that some people didn't want to take the risk and instead settled for "reasonably powerful but not epic" -scale, which meant they would forever stay mechanically slightly in the shadow of those truly epic. If they did however survive they could ascend to the legendary epic levels (and local fame!) and progress "normally" (in very steep exp curve), although even most epic people were level 21-23. This system should technically work also in NWN2 without serious changes to the NWN2 core if the level 20+ would be kept in check and only a handful few would ever rise to level 25+.

If this kind of system would be introduced to the server, there could be a rule that everyone beyond level 15 would be reduced and soft-capped to level 15 (with full RCR rebuild option). All items could remain in their possession because they are already well designed for this level scale. After that several people with more serious achievements to show could be granted levels between 16-25, but probably not more than that to keep the end of the level scale still ahead of them.

This would probably require some changes to several adventuring areas and particularily bosses, but MOST places should be fine as they are and now just require more varied and bigger groups. The loot system would be good to go as it is because it fits well for these levels. This would however, mean that the big bosses of DM quests wouldn't have to be so ridiculously overpowered and designed for fully powergamed level 30 characters.

I'm not really expecting this to happen, but despite everyone's personal preference to what they would prefer, this would be the only way how to introduce far better realism and balance to the game. Naturally not all people would be happy with their level loss and the RCR hassle would be quite big amount of work for the DMs, which would be inevitable with any major change.

If anyone has other reasons to believe why this wouldn't be good for server, I'd be glad to hear them though.

Thanks for reading for those who made it this far!
Player of: Gondael • Blaric Brimsbane • Teth Zorastryl • Kain • Z'eed Auzkovyn • Durin Khazrudh
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by NegInfinity »

King Of Clouds wrote:Simply put: Numbers of weak NPCs don't matter in DnD 3.5.
You're wrong about that. This bit was addressed in order of the stick, by the way.

In case of significantly large numbers, your ac becomes irrelevant. 50 thousand untrained xbowmen shooting at a single target in d&d 3.5 means almost guaranteed 2500d10 damage. In case of damage resistance, knowing the type of resistance will help, and as long as resistance is known, anything will go down in few rounds.
King Of Clouds wrote:It doesn't matter if there was 500 or 50.000 soldiers shooting arrows at the thing, but if a red wyrm has DR of 20, 30 SR and 42 AC,

Just the same, Bruenor Battlehammer couldn't have never killed the shadow dragon because his AB was too low to have any chance to hit the thing and energy drain breath weapon really wouldn't help the chances.
Actually D&D addresses ac issues with natural 20 roll. It always connects. If you're fighting against ac of one million and roll 20, your hit connects to the target. In similar fashion, natural 20 ability roll (not skill roll) alwyas succeeds. On the flip side roll of 1 always fails.

Regarding dragons, they have resistance of X/magic type, meaning an army with enchanted +1 bows (or just +1 arrows) can bring the dragon down. For example, if you have one thousand solders fire at the dragon at once, 50 of them will hit the target. Great Wyrm has 39d12 + 312 HP, meaning 780 hp max. If you can keep shooting in the same numbers, dragon will go down in 15 rounds. That's at maximum hp and minimum damage. Wasting this many soldiers will be bloody expensive, of course, as well as finding so many enchanted bows, but that doesn't take siege weapons into account.

Return to “General Discussion”