Power level of a PC

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

King Of Clouds wrote:I'm not really expecting this to happen, but despite everyone's personal preference to what they would prefer, this would be the only way how to introduce far better realism and balance to the game. Naturally not all people would be happy with their level loss and the RCR hassle would be quite big amount of work for the DMs, which would be inevitable with any major change.

If anyone has other reasons to believe why this wouldn't be good for server, I'd be glad to hear them though.
I would support this change 100%. Why? Because at a certain point, the extreme imbalance of Levels as it exists currently on BGTSCC seems to railroad Play into either a) grinding to Epics to reach max power in order to influence Role-play/the Environment, b) eschew grinding to Epics but then creating "Player Let down," which is a feeling that lower-then-Epic Characters have little to no chance to make any actual affect on Role-play/the Environment.

In addition, it would put Adventurers/PCs more in-line with the well-known NPCs of this Sword Coast. I think that is important, because not only does it create better "realism," having PCs regularly kill Dracolichs for craps and giggles, just degrades the sense of D&D immersion (for me, at least).

Nice post KoC!

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by NegInfinity »

King Of Clouds wrote:If this kind of system would be introduced to the server, there could be a rule that everyone beyond level 15 would be reduced and soft-capped to level 15 (with full RCR rebuild option). All items could remain in their possession because they are already well designed for this level scale. After that several people with more serious achievements to show could be granted levels between 16-25, but probably not more than that to keep the end of the level scale still ahead of them.
I think that if this gets implemented, a lot of people will quit and the server will die. It is this simple.

The proposition seem to be based on assumption that levels are more important than characters, personality and roleplay, and that anything above level 15 is somehow very special.

Basically, as far as I can tell in roleplaying communities people occasionally start believing in various ideas regarding about how things should be done "properly". So they wield those ideas as some sort of holy banner, and try to implement them. When the ideas get implemented, community usually gets messed up and dies in flames.

Ideas can be "levels should be capped to X!" "equipment should be capped to Y!", "d&d should be rebalanced!". As soon as someone gets enough power to implement something like that, everything goes to hell, using the road paved with good intentions.

It is not about level caps, it is about people. Feeling passionate about some d&d ideas (and maybe for a good reason), but it is worth to consider how many people will quit because of a proposed change. I have impression that people sometimes just forget that they REQUIRE other humans to play here, and their amazing ideas they feel so passionate about may reduce number of other players significantly.

So, with all that in mind I think the best idea would be not to look for new and amazing ways to break the good thing, but instead leave the server be, concentrate on fixing bugs (and not "balance issues") in spells and classes instead. Without trying to cap anything or anyone.
User avatar
gedweyignasia
Custom Content
Posts: 1353
Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2013 11:27 pm
Location: EST/UTC-4

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by gedweyignasia »

Make Raise Dead and Resurrection follow the PnP rules once you hit Lv 21+. If you don't get raised, you go all the way back to Lv 20. (Re-generate the player's corpse where they died each reset so you don't get bugged down to Lv 20.)

PnP rules for Raise Dead/Resurrection (the broad strokes) :
1) You lose a full level (not drained, you lose the full level's worth of XP)
2) It costs 5000gp for Raise Dead; 10,000 for Resurrection


Suddenly epic characters have high stakes for dying, so they don't just shrug off battles with dragons and liches.
User avatar
Blame The Rogue
Posts: 653
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Blame The Rogue »

there are a lot of nwn 2 servers out there with more rules than bg. and no pvp rules. they have level caps. permadeath. harsh death scripts. and all those servers are dead

see the pattern? we don't need more rules, nor lose pvp rules, nor level caps, nor permadeath or harsh death scripts. none of these things enhance rp. none of these things make the server more fun. they do however, seem to be great at turning servers into ghost towns
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by NegInfinity »

Blame The Rogue wrote:there are a lot of nwn 2 servers out there with more rules than bg. and no pvp rules. they have level caps. permadeath. harsh death scripts. and all those servers are dead

see the pattern? we don't need more rules, nor lose pvp rules, nor level caps, nor permadeath or harsh death scripts. none of these things enhance rp. none of these things make the server more fun. they do however, seem to be great at turning servers into ghost towns
Yep. And speaking of level caps....

Let's say someone spent months bringing incredibly difficult concept to a maximum power. When someone suddenly introduces a very low level cap, the concept is essentially scrapped and months of effort spent on it are undone. How would a player feel about that, hmm?
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

What would Players prefer: DMs spending time crafting just-the-right-amount-of-power mobs/NPCs in order to mechanically challenge an Epic Level Group, or spending time crafting storylines for a wider range of Lower-than-epic-levels Group, because mobs in the Toolset are pre-made/ easily available?

Do Players come to BGTSCC in order to reach Level 30 mechanics in a Sandbox, or do they come to BGTSCC in order to RP a Character, that grows in relevance to the environment as they level from 1 to X?

So why does X need to be set at 30 to be successful?!? Why not up it to 40 (which is possible)? Is the INCREASE fundamentally better?

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
chad878262
Posts: 9332
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:55 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by chad878262 »

M3ntalist said it best in the treasure discussion. BG caters to many styles of play. Some people live in time zones where DMs are never online when they play, some enjoy level/loot grinding, some the campfire rp, some like low level adventure rp...you can do all of those and anyone else's rp impacts you only to the extent that you allow it. I don't consider it acceptable to take away one style completely because it fits another style better. Your characters story is what you make of it, so long as you aren't imposing that story on other players there are few limits as to what details you add.
Chord Silverstrings - Bard and OSR Squire / Tarent Nefzen - Arcane Wand Merchant and Master Alchemist / Irrace Arkentlar - Drow Adventurer / Finneaus Du'Veil - Gem Merchant and Executive Officer of SCCE

Tarent's Wands and Elixirs

A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
User avatar
King Of Clouds
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2013 10:42 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by King Of Clouds »

NegInfinity wrote:
King Of Clouds wrote:Simply put: Numbers of weak NPCs don't matter in DnD 3.5.
You're wrong about that. This bit was addressed in order of the stick, by the way.

In case of significantly large numbers, your ac becomes irrelevant. 50 thousand untrained xbowmen shooting at a single target in d&d 3.5 means almost guaranteed 2500d10 damage. In case of damage resistance, knowing the type of resistance will help, and as long as resistance is known, anything will go down in few rounds.
Mathematically you're right. If you have a full standing army of say Waterdeep against one person you might get access to this sort of numbers. While not even going to the physics of shooting 50 000 arrows at a target with less than 1m2 surface ratio, there are some game-mechanic facts that you have to remember. In order to bring forth soldiers of such scale you need weeks if not months of preparation to gather the people, equip them with the gear and then meet this villain in an open field of war, where he would willingly become the target of these archers. In fact getting something like 50 archers in plain sight to shoot at one medium-sized target is already a really demanding task, especially if the target is fighting inside the town, let alone indoors. More realistic scenario would be to try to destroy the building and bury the person within.
King Of Clouds wrote:It doesn't matter if there was 500 or 50.000 soldiers shooting arrows at the thing, but if a red wyrm has DR of 20, 30 SR and 42 AC,

Just the same, Bruenor Battlehammer couldn't have never killed the shadow dragon because his AB was too low to have any chance to hit the thing and energy drain breath weapon really wouldn't help the chances.
Actually D&D addresses ac issues with natural 20 roll. It always connects. If you're fighting against ac of one million and roll 20, your hit connects to the target. In similar fashion, natural 20 ability roll (not skill roll) alwyas succeeds. On the flip side roll of 1 always fails.

Regarding dragons, they have resistance of X/magic type, meaning an army with enchanted +1 bows (or just +1 arrows) can bring the dragon down. For example, if you have one thousand solders fire at the dragon at once, 50 of them will hit the target. Great Wyrm has 39d12 + 312 HP, meaning 780 hp max. If you can keep shooting in the same numbers, dragon will go down in 15 rounds. That's at maximum hp and minimum damage. Wasting this many soldiers will be bloody expensive, of course, as well as finding so many enchanted bows, but that doesn't take siege weapons into account.[/quote]

Admittably, the dragon example is a little bit better in 3.5E than it was in 3E. In 3E most of that damage reduction was based on /+3 weapons or something of that scale. No kingdom in the timeline we're talking about has the gear or funds to gather such gear to make damage against the dragon realistic. At the same time you gotta remember that the dragon can scorch something like 100 soldiers easily with one breath while taking some of the arrows, so it's not like this harassing is going to continue for long enough to make much of a difference against the dragon DR.

But my point wasn't exactly to discuss dragon fight, but rather how common soldiers would be able to deal with an epic-level adventurer. Good points anyway!
NegInfinity wrote: I think that if this gets implemented, a lot of people will quit and the server will die. It is this simple.
Blame The Rogue wrote: there are a lot of nwn 2 servers out there with more rules than bg. and no pvp rules. they have level caps. permadeath. harsh death scripts. and all those servers are dead

see the pattern? we don't need more rules, nor lose pvp rules, nor level caps, nor permadeath or harsh death scripts. none of these things enhance rp. none of these things make the server more fun. they do however, seem to be great at turning servers into ghost towns
That may be the case indeed. Or it may not. We may never know how the community would truly react on such a change.

I fully admit that it might be risky to try to implement something like that in the server because it has always been possible to reach full level 30 in BG by merely grinding enemies and this would fundamentally change the server. However, do take into account that the player base may also change over time and one of the most important tasks of the server is to make sure that the server fits for its target audience.

This game is both unfortunately and fortunately so low in players altogether that you don't have much choices between servers. I admit that of course people can always rage quit the whole NWN2 if they get too offended by such things. People can do that also because they feel tired of the current system and the pointlessness of fighting CR=50 zombies or brigands as Atlas spoke of earlier.
NegInfinity wrote:The proposition seem to be based on assumption that levels are more important than characters, personality and roleplay, and that anything above level 15 is somehow very special.

Basically, as far as I can tell in roleplaying communities people occasionally start believing in various ideas regarding about how things should be done "properly". So they wield those ideas as some sort of holy banner, and try to implement them. When the ideas get implemented, community usually gets messed up and dies in flames.

Ideas can be "levels should be capped to X!" "equipment should be capped to Y!", "d&d should be rebalanced!". As soon as someone gets enough power to implement something like that, everything goes to hell, using the road paved with good intentions.
I'd ask you to re-read my post because I wasn't saying that "We must implement this right now because I say so!".

I addressed that most of this discussion is related to mechanical problems with the engine and epic level system of the game, which I explained in the earlier points of my post. Non-epic characters fit the game system better and the difference between power potential of a two level 15's and level 30's is game-breakingly massive. This is the issue that we may choose to change or leave as it is, but that fact will remain in either case.

You also tend to make rather big assumptions in behalf of the community, which I understand partially as I mentioned in my earlier message. However, without open discussion there's not chance for development.
NegInfinity wrote:It is not about level caps, it is about people. Feeling passionate about some d&d ideas (and maybe for a good reason), but it is worth to consider how many people will quit because of a proposed change. I have impression that people sometimes just forget that they REQUIRE other humans to play here, and their amazing ideas they feel so passionate about may reduce number of other players significantly.
Fully agree with you there. The people make this server and their happiness should be the priority #1. No big changes should be made because someone said so. A wise man once told me "One of the most important things I've learned is the fact that you're right doesn't matter most often". My idea therefore, might be just as good as someone else's, but it's more about what the developers and the community as a whole feel would be the best direction to evolve the server.
NegInfinity wrote:Yep. And speaking of level caps....

Let's say someone spent months bringing incredibly difficult concept to a maximum power. When someone suddenly introduces a very low level cap, the concept is essentially scrapped and months of effort spent on it are undone. How would a player feel about that, hmm?
I've spent perhaps 2-3 years of combined active time in this server, reaching level 30 with perhaps 5-6 characters in my time. Experience is of course important part of your character, but ultimately it's not going to be just you, who'll lose it, but everyone will be toned down and given a fresh start to continue the pursuit of progress. Basically what I propose is that all level 30's will be level 15's, except for some people who have been in more respectful positions could progress a bit further as they have played a bigger impact on the server than the rest.

Personally despite my long time invested in achieving all those levels I'd be glad to reduce all of my characters to level 15 for instance as I know none of them have been that important. The overall balance would matter more for me than the fact that I can cast epic gate and summon an angel that dies in 3 seconds against a single average brigand in a DM quest (and please don't take me wrong, I'm not blaming the DM team for this).
NegInfinity wrote:So, with all that in mind I think the best idea would be not to look for new and amazing ways to break the good thing, but instead leave the server be, concentrate on fixing bugs (and not "balance issues") in spells and classes instead. Without trying to cap anything or anyone.
In this aspect we stand in different opinion, but I underst and respect the reasoning behind yours nevertheless.
Player of: Gondael • Blaric Brimsbane • Teth Zorastryl • Kain • Z'eed Auzkovyn • Durin Khazrudh
User avatar
mrm3ntalist
Retired Staff
Posts: 7859
Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 5:31 pm
Location: US of A

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by mrm3ntalist »

Steve wrote:What would Players prefer: DMs spending time crafting just-the-right-amount-of-power mobs/NPCs in order to mechanically challenge an Epic Level Group, or spending time crafting storylines for a wider range of Lower-than-epic-levels Group, because mobs in the Toolset are pre-made/ easily available?
A DM, ( not an ADM ) should be able to challenge Epic level groups. Void made certain that no ADM became a DM without understanding using the client and the mechanics and without getting training to do that. What use is a dm that cannot mechanically provide a challenge for epic characters? Most players here can create storylines. What the players cant do ( because the dont have the client ) is create mobs etc to support those storylines.
Do Players come to BGTSCC in order to reach Level 30 mechanics in a Sandbox, or do they come to BGTSCC in order to RP a Character, that grows in relevance to the environment as they level from 1 to X?
It shouldnt matter which of the two. BGTSCC is supposed to be a server that caters for characters from lvl1 to 30.
So why does X need to be set at 30 to be successful?!? Why not up it to 40 (which is possible)? Is the INCREASE fundamentally better?
The server supports 1 to 30. Not 40. It should not matter how slow or fast one wishes to get to 30
Last edited by mrm3ntalist on Sat Sep 10, 2016 8:06 am, edited 2 times in total.
Mendel - Ranger, Harper, Villi | Malaggar Tiabbar - The Crimson Chord |Elias Raemir The Unyielding Aegis | Nikos Berenicus - Initiate of the Mirari | Efialtes Rodius - Blood Magus
User avatar
Blame The Rogue
Posts: 653
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Blame The Rogue »

Steve wrote:What would Players prefer: DMs spending time crafting just-the-right-amount-of-power mobs/NPCs in order to mechanically challenge an Epic Level Group, or spending time crafting storylines for a wider range of Lower-than-epic-levels Group, because mobs in the Toolset are pre-made/ easily available?

Do Players come to BGTSCC in order to reach Level 30 mechanics in a Sandbox, or do they come to BGTSCC in order to RP a Character, that grows in relevance to the environment as they level from 1 to X?

So why does X need to be set at 30 to be successful?!? Why not up it to 40 (which is possible)? Is the INCREASE fundamentally better?
dms have to carefully choose mobs for each individual party. that will never change. and they still manage to spin a good tale as well

players come here to have fun ic and also to have their characters reach their full potential

lvl 30 cap is plenty. and the entire server is balanced towards that. every area. every mob. every chest. every prc. the list goes on
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by NegInfinity »

King Of Clouds wrote:I've spent perhaps 2-3 years of combined active time in this server, reaching level 30 with perhaps 5-6 characters in my time. Experience is of course important part of your character, but ultimately it's not going to be just you, who'll lose it, but everyone will be toned down and given a fresh start to continue the pursuit of progress. Basically what I propose is that all level 30's will be level 15's, except for some people who have been in more respectful positions could progress a bit further as they have played a bigger impact on the server than the rest.
There was an experimental server that attempted to introduce level15-based system with different progression. It is also now dead. Honestly, I don't even remember what its name was, just remember that they had some classes application-only

And speaking of development, there's plenty of unfinished work already - bugfixes and all. No need to make things even more complicated.
King Of Clouds wrote:I'd ask you to re-read my post because I wasn't saying that "We must implement this right now because I say so!".
I perfectly understand that you have good intentions and that you believe that your proposition will improve the server, but I'm firmly convinced that attempting to implement this proposition will kill it instead. I have not heard any argument that could convince me that there's even a tiny chance of something like that not going wrong and I think that there's a zero chance for any sort of positive outcome if your proposal ever gets implemented.

As they say "the road to hell is paved with good intentions".
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

mrm3ntalist wrote:Void made certain that no ADM became a DM without understanding using the client and the mechanics and without getting training to do that.
I kinda wonder how you know exactly what Void made certain, and not. I, however, can tell you for certain the Void did absolutely ZERO to train me on the Client, and he BROUGHT me into being a DM, whether I wanted to or not (true story).
mrm3ntalist wrote:What use is a dm that cannot mechanically provide a challenge for epic characters? Most players here can create storylines. What the players cant do ( because the dont have the client ) is create mobs etc to support those storylines.
What use is a story when a DM cannot create a challenge for Epic Characters? Most players can create epic character challenges, by not power building their builds (with current Server Content). What the DMs can't do—it seems—is create a challenge that challenges PC storylines, because the Players are always moaning about losing, unfairness and lack of realism.

mrm3ntalist wrote:It shouldnt matter which of the two. BGTSCC is supposed to be a server that caters for characters from lvl1 to 30.
Except it doesn't. It caters to long-term and high-level involvement. There is little to no incentive to stay low level, because there is—at least in the last 5 years—little ability and support to influence the Environment on a low level Character (not to mention constantly "in danger" of being wifflestomped by higher level toons, which just shouldn't be possible in a game based on D&D).
mrm3ntalist wrote:The server supports 1 to 30. Not 40. It should not matter how slow or fast one wishes to get to 30.
You're right: it shouldn't matter. But is does matter. If it didn't matter, than whether 15–20, 30 or 40 cap level, the Game would be the same Game. I think you missed my point, earlier, btw.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
mrm3ntalist
Retired Staff
Posts: 7859
Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 5:31 pm
Location: US of A

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by mrm3ntalist »

Steve wrote: I kinda wonder how you know exactly what Void made certain, and not. I, however, can tell you for certain the Void did absolutely ZERO to train me on the Client, and he BROUGHT me into being a DM, whether I wanted to or not (true story).
Like you, there are other xDMs that talk about their time.
What use is a story when a DM cannot create a challenge for Epic Characters? Most players can create epic character challenges, by not power building their builds (with current Server Content). What the DMs can't do—it seems—is create a challenge that challenges PC storylines, because the Players are always moaning about losing, unfairness and lack of realism.
Ah same story, different day. Powerbuilding, lvl30s etc. There are many players that create great stories. One of those were is you, since i consider the draconomicon story, one of the best i took part in. For a dm to do that, it should be a given. About handling epic characters, i cant believe there are dms that can, ( i mentioned void but there are newer ones, Nilbog, Bloodlust, Theophanies etc) and others that cant. Its all down to learning to do it
Except it doesn't. It caters to long-term and high-level involvement. There is little to no incentive to stay low level, because there is—at least in the last 5 years—little ability and support to influence the Environment on a low level Character (not to mention constantly "in danger" of being wifflestomped by higher level toons, which just shouldn't be possible in a game based on D&D).
I agree with you on that. It is no fun to play a lvl1. However there are events that will take place for such characters. There are players to play together - look a tthe adventuring parties being formed lately.
You're right: it shouldn't matter. But is does matter. If it didn't matter, than whether 15–20, 30 or 40 cap level, the Game would be the same Game. I think you missed my point, earlier, btw.
I might missed your point. Personally never had a problem whether my char was 10, 20 or 30. But i prefer going to 30 and seeing my chars full mechanical potential in action.
Mendel - Ranger, Harper, Villi | Malaggar Tiabbar - The Crimson Chord |Elias Raemir The Unyielding Aegis | Nikos Berenicus - Initiate of the Mirari | Efialtes Rodius - Blood Magus
Karond
Posts: 2221
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 10:47 am
Location: Sweden

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Karond »

On level caps; Have you considered going the other way? Instead of limiting character levels, just increase the monsters. The result is the same, except we don't lose content or player efforts.

On mechanical limitations; It's not just levels. It's the engine's inability to have creatures, particularly really big ones, attack more than one target at once. This makes bosses much easier than they should be, no matter your power.
Steve wrote:What the DMs can't do—it seems—is create a challenge that challenges PC storylines, because the Players are always moaning about losing, unfairness and lack of realism.
I think they're capable of it, it's just a tradition to railroad for the player's benefit. Brings less drama, fewer complaints and all that.
DM Pun Pun
Posts: 1424
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2014 4:52 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by DM Pun Pun »

mrm3ntalist wrote: A DM, ( not an ADM ) should be able to challenge Epic level groups. Void made certain that no ADM became a DM without understanding using the client and the mechanics and without getting training to do that. What use is a dm that cannot mechanically provide a challenge for epic characters? Most players here can create storylines. What the players cant do ( because the dont have the client ) is create mobs etc to support those storylines.
Just to respond to this, because it is an interesting comment. We have done this, and like everything, its received mixed feelings. Catering to the top 5% of the server usually leads the rest of the server feeling left out, or worse, make players believe there is some imaginary arms race and the only way to even compete is being max level(which is not the case). And even then, sometimes that upper echelon despises the fact they have to work for anything because their characters are so optimized that failure should NEVER happen. I've had players chew me out in tells because "mobs shouldn't do that" and "my character is way too powerful to lose to this". I think the most prominent example of this was the Virtuous Soil.

So we can mechanically raise the bar to scale it towards epics. Its totally doable. But if we were to do that for every pivotal, defining moment on this server, then we would become a ghost town for some players would just give up trying to meet the "standards" of our events. And whats worse is that many players who join the server believe they need to get to max level as fast as possible in order to enjoy our events, and that is clearly not the case.

Return to “General Discussion”