Power level of a PC

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

Re: TheVoid...and speaking about perceiving the needs of the Server:
TheVoid wrote:Most of us old timers have moved on in terms of the game world if not fully exodus'd from the PW like the fleeting elves to their ancestral lands. It will be hopefully a more exciting era since old ties can be truly forgotten or at least held at a very far distance as new ideas and a fresh, unbias perspective, and direction start to rejuvenate the PW.

Whatever you do, just stand your ground on things you know are right and don't be a pussy about it. That's my advice if it means anything or not.
Anyway, I stick to my ground that Epic Levels in a 1–30 sandbox SERIOUSLY imbalances the mechanics, and the Server. THAT effect role-play, in fundamental ways.

As far as I can tell, there are VERY FEW events taking place for beginning Characters, or even, established-yet-lowbie level Characters. Show me, and I'll then agree.

And just because an adventuring party is forming...man, how many of those form and burn out? How many of those actually have an affect on the game world?

Personally, I have never had a problem whether my Character was 1–30. But I disagree that there is some fundamental and better aspect to the Game at level 30 "full potential." So we'll just have to disagree there.

I stand my ground to say that at every level, one can RP their "full potential," and THAT is good gaming. The whole meta around EXPECTING your Character to eventually get to Lvl 30, is a whole crap issue on its own!!

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Aelcar
Posts: 1552
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2011 1:41 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Aelcar »

DM Pun Pun wrote:
mrm3ntalist wrote: A DM, ( not an ADM ) should be able to challenge Epic level groups. Void made certain that no ADM became a DM without understanding using the client and the mechanics and without getting training to do that. What use is a dm that cannot mechanically provide a challenge for epic characters? Most players here can create storylines. What the players cant do ( because the dont have the client ) is create mobs etc to support those storylines.
Just to respond to this, because it is an interesting comment. We have done this, and like everything, its received mixed feelings. Catering to the top 5% of the server usually leads the rest of the server feeling left out, or worse, make players believe there is some imaginary arms race and the only way to even compete is being max level(which is not the case).


Why top 5%, Pun Pun? If you know how to challenge epics, that doesn't mean it's all you do. It's a tool in your DM arsenal: you use it when you need it. That way you cater to 100% of the population, including that 5%, which some said is "impossible" (glad to see you have a different opinion, and a different story to tell).
And even then, sometimes that upper echelon despises the fact they have to work for anything because their characters are so optimized that failure should NEVER happen. I've had players chew me out in tells because "mobs shouldn't do that" and "my character is way too powerful to lose to this". I think the most prominent example of this was the Virtuous Soil.


It's a misconception on their side, and one of aspects of growth the community needs help with. Yet, this is a rare brand of posts: nobody wants to talk about it, when it's sorely needed.

As a DM, making characters (no matter how optimized) fail or surprising them with certain monster abilities is NEVER wrong. However, there is a key aspect DMs should always provide to players: counterplay. Example:

- A virtuous soil peasant, no RP, no warning, no intel whatsoever, one-shoots the lvl 30 character. That's extremely bad.

- A virtuous soil peasant appears. In former RP sessions, investigations, hearsay and such, PCs came to know there are some of them that are extremely dangerous. The DM introduces the encounter, telling the PCs a few RP lines to introduce the "chill in the air" as he comes. At that point, when their coffee cups are down and they are ready to fight, if they die, it's their problem.

This is the difference between excellent DMing and DM killing someone. It's the difference between spawning a bunny that one-shoots a lvl 30 Fighter, and spawning the Blight after months of RP: both will kill you with ease, but the intel you have on the second provides enough counterplay that you can work around it. Key word: CAN. You also can lose, and should accept it.
So we can mechanically raise the bar to scale it towards epics. Its totally doable. But if we were to do that for every pivotal, defining moment on this server, then we would become a ghost town for some players would just give up trying to meet the "standards" of our events. And whats worse is that many players who join the server believe they need to get to max level as fast as possible in order to enjoy our events, and that is clearly not the case.
You don't need to "raise the bar". It's just about examining the party you need to DM, and if it's an open event, make sure the majority of spawns can be handled by the weakest PCs in the lot, and have a few big ones targeting the strongest. You can even split parties per levels, it's been done a lot by you guys and it works well.

Tailoring, more than raising.
Aelcar Lightbringer, Knight of the Merciful Sword: Disappeared after the victorious defense of the Gate against The Blight.

Olath M'elzar Valshar The Black, The Phantom Wizard: Retired Steward of the School of Necromancy and former Eye of the 7th Circle.
User avatar
Rhifox
Posts: 3962
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Rhifox »

Steve wrote:or do they come to BGTSCC in order to RP a Character, that grows in relevance to the environment as they level from 1 to X?
That, for me. But without the level thing. Like I said in my earlier post, on this kind of server, I can barely even recognize levels as an RP mechanic at all.
NegInfinity wrote:There was an experimental server that attempted to introduce level15-based system with different progression. It is also now dead. Honestly, I don't even remember what its name was, just remember that they had some classes application-only
Well I don't know if this is the one you were thinking of, but my old server did originally have a 15 soft cap 20 hard cap, as King of Clouds' suggestion goes. Many application-only classes as well (including warlock and FS). And it was quite good and active. It was not the cap that killed it, what killed it was inconsistent leadership and a refusal to stick with a system, resulting in server wipes because they thought people had gotten to 20 too fast and wanted to reset the playing field.

Server wipes are what kills server. Major changes in a downward direction is what causes players to lose faith and leave. So yeah, the suggestions aren't feasible, but only because they require a major nerf to achieve. On their own, the actual suggested mechanics are good, and work fine.
Steve wrote:But I disagree that there is some fundamental and better aspect to the Game at level 30 "full potential." So we'll just have to disagree there.
Yup. For me, getting to the 10 level range as the people I RP with was enough to satisfy me (20, for interacting at "roughly" the same level with 30s). After that, every level more was just a nice bonus but ultimately meant little. Hitting 30 did not make me feel like any new and amazing possibilities were opened to me, it just marked the point at which levels stopped coming.
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
User avatar
Lambe
Posts: 544
Joined: Tue Jan 26, 2010 5:38 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Lambe »

My first server on NWN2 10 years ago (funnily enough I played with Void there) had a soft level cap of 12, with a token system given out by a sole DM to whoever he found worth his salt in RP. One token, one level up past level 12. It had an extensive crafting system, low-magic world (highest you can find is a +2). It also had a strict resurrection system where your corpse drops on the spot, persisting through resets, with your gear lootable on your corpse and you can't resurrect yourself through some dialogue option. It was quite hardcore, but as you can probably imagine it was also a small community.

Having known BG and hearing gripes from both sides all these years, I can say going into a direction like the one above will not work without alienating a number of people. IMHO, if anything needs to change, it's not the server itself, as far as I can tell server identity and description hasn't changed since the moment I found it interesting 7 years ago. It's why I play here. What needs to change is the culture.
DM Pun Pun
Posts: 1424
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2014 4:52 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by DM Pun Pun »

Steve wrote:
And just because an adventuring party is forming...man, how many of those form and burn out? How many of those actually have an affect on the game world?
Personally, I think these adventuring parties burn out because they are a collaboration of alts. Alts allow players a break from what their main character is going through, but when things go down, you will rarely see an alt get involved. The player is going to use their trusty main, which they have more invested in and would rather see the plot as part of their tale.

Adventuring parties are nice, its a good way to build communication with the rest of the community. But ultimately, players only have time for 1 character when all is said and done, and that character is usually not a part of a forum created adventuring group.
User avatar
mrm3ntalist
Retired Staff
Posts: 7859
Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 5:31 pm
Location: US of A

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by mrm3ntalist »

Steve wrote:Personally, I have never had a problem whether my Character was 1–30. But I disagree that there is some fundamental and better aspect to the Game at level 30 "full potential." So we'll just have to disagree there.

I stand my ground to say that at every level, one can RP their "full potential," and THAT is good gaming. The whole meta around EXPECTING your Character to eventually get to Lvl 30, is a whole crap issue on its own!!
As you said, we will have to disagree :) Nothing worng there.
DM Pun Pun wrote:
mrm3ntalist wrote: A DM, ( not an ADM ) should be able to challenge Epic level groups. Void made certain that no ADM became a DM without understanding using the client and the mechanics and without getting training to do that. What use is a dm that cannot mechanically provide a challenge for epic characters? Most players here can create storylines. What the players cant do ( because the dont have the client ) is create mobs etc to support those storylines.
Just to respond to this, because it is an interesting comment. We have done this, and like everything, its received mixed feelings. Catering to the top 5% of the server usually leads the rest of the server feeling left out, or worse, make players believe there is some imaginary arms race and the only way to even compete is being max level(which is not the case). And even then, sometimes that upper echelon despises the fact they have to work for anything because their characters are so optimized that failure should NEVER happen. I've had players chew me out in tells because "mobs shouldn't do that" and "my character is way too powerful to lose to this". I think the most prominent example of this was the Virtuous Soil.

So we can mechanically raise the bar to scale it towards epics. Its totally doable. But if we were to do that for every pivotal, defining moment on this server, then we would become a ghost town for some players would just give up trying to meet the "standards" of our events. And whats worse is that many players who join the server believe they need to get to max level as fast as possible in order to enjoy our events, and that is clearly not the case.
You dont need to raise the bar... Why that is the first response? There is a build up to every plot. Use that build up to cater both for low levels and epics. Then depending on the type of the final event and what types of players take part, you can plan accordingly. The Blight was such a final event. We all knew that the Blight is supposed to be some mean boss. Most, even epics, avoided it. There were many other spawns that could help lower levels busy, then all together fight the Boss. It was a fight that kept everyone busy, but i will agree it requires much preparation, technical knowlwdge and help from other DMs.
Mendel - Ranger, Harper, Villi | Malaggar Tiabbar - The Crimson Chord |Elias Raemir The Unyielding Aegis | Nikos Berenicus - Initiate of the Mirari | Efialtes Rodius - Blood Magus
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by NegInfinity »

Rhifox wrote: Well I don't know if this is the one you were thinking of, but my old server did originally have a 15 soft cap 20 hard cap, as King of Clouds' suggestion goes. Many application-only classes as well (including warlock and FS). And it was quite good and active. It was not the cap that killed it, what killed it was inconsistent leadership and a refusal to stick with a system, resulting in server wipes because they thought people had gotten to 20 too fast and wanted to reset the playing field.
The server I spoke of was trying to redesign dnd progression around level 15 cap idea. It was granting feats every two levels, and they were very unusual... now I can't remember what it was called, and where it was located. I just think that people place too much value into an arbitrary level being "a holy cap" of sorts.

Mechanically, most of the characters I play become enjoyable PAST level 15, somewhere around 16..18 range, some of them get power earlier than that, but the main issue that with level cap this low there's less room to customize. That's an opinion.

mrm3ntalist wrote:You dont need to raise the bar... Why that is the first response? There is a build up to every plot. Use that build up to cater both for low levels and epics. Then depending on the type of the final event and what types of players take part, you can plan accordingly. The Blight was such a final event. We all knew that the Blight is supposed to be some mean boss. Most, even epics, avoided it. There were many other spawns that could help lower levels busy, then all together fight the Boss. It was a fight that kept everyone busy, but i will agree it requires much preparation, technical knowlwdge and help from other DMs.
Have you ever fought a 2k hitpoint level 5 attack dog? As a weapon master? I've run into something like this in one of the events in the past, whee people raided a thief hideout near bg. I also remeber running for my life from a giant flaming cow (I think it was 5 stories tall) and getting killed by vampiric-feast casting house cat (which I suspect was level 100), and fighting some huge snakes at south of candlekeep, whose hp bar could rival those of jrpg bosses. Stuff like this feels... off.

Speaking of blight... I think I missed the whole blight plot, and I'm not sure if the big event with troll fights was part of it. In that event near the end trolls had really ridiculous set of resistances, it wasn't possible to hit them with anything physical I could throw at them. Then again, standing at a pile of dead casters as an unbuffer non-magical charcters without a scratch was fun.
User avatar
Hawke
Posts: 1245
Joined: Sun Aug 01, 2010 6:11 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Hawke »

Let's make sure this thread keeps the path that was intended...

(no, no yellow text... unless you want it heh)

The level system for NPCs on events should not even be considered. PnP the DM can adjusted whatever they saw fit, and did not mean that the beast had to be an equal level.

Plus this is a game with a fundementally hard bugs that cannot be fixed, and you have to be very literate to go out and construct all your NPCs as a DM and then come up with some on the fly that would reduce or increase the challenge to your players for an event.

I really wouldn't read too much into the strict mechanics of things on the server... moreso the "mindset" of where things actually fall.

Honestly, I give two farts to the entire reduction of player strength. Power tends to congregate in the same area... that is why conflict of greater scales apply more to these areas than others. I say if a level 30 hangs out on the Sword Coast.. then yes, they are capable of pissing off the gods.... but let's face it.. that whole level 20 thing being on the same level of Gods... was 2nd Ed...3rd and beyond kind of threw that out the window, especially when they were creating more critters at the higher levels to give DMs tools to create stories and still challenge their players.
If the text is this color, I am on duty, everything else is just my humble opinion.
DM Pun Pun
Posts: 1424
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2014 4:52 pm

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by DM Pun Pun »

NegInfinity wrote:
Rhifox wrote: Well I don't know if this is the one you were thinking of, but my old server did originally have a 15 soft cap 20 hard cap, as King of Clouds' suggestion goes. Many application-only classes as well (including warlock and FS). And it was quite good and active. It was not the cap that killed it, what killed it was inconsistent leadership and a refusal to stick with a system, resulting in server wipes because they thought people had gotten to 20 too fast and wanted to reset the playing field.
The server I spoke of was trying to redesign dnd progression around level 15 cap idea. It was granting feats every two levels, and they were very unusual... now I can't remember what it was called, and where it was located. I just think that people place too much value into an arbitrary level being "a holy cap" of sorts.

Mechanically, most of the characters I play become enjoyable PAST level 15, somewhere around 16..18 range, some of them get power earlier than that, but the main issue that with level cap this low there's less room to customize. That's an opinion.
A common thing in 3.5 PnP these days is a level 6 cap, with levels that add feats and abilities afterwards. It keeps your PC honest, as in you will die if you do things foolishly, but it keeps that progression and development going. It is an interesting way to play the game and allows the DM to not have to unleash hell every time he is to challenge the players.
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

Rhifox wrote: on this kind of server, I can barely even recognize levels as an RP mechanic at all.
.
Hi Rhifox,
I was hoping you could clarify this comment, for me. Considering it is asked by the Administration of this Server to "play your Character Sheet," and thus Levels = Skills and Feats, doesn't what we Role-play a Character stem from what they actually can do?

Which is also to point out, if our Character Sheets do say Epic Character, then I totally understand the problem where one is RPing being some Epic Individual, yet are wifflestomped by some City Guard, or Flaming Fist officer, or XYZ that is NOT an Epic Foe.

Which goes back to the OP, I think.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Aelcar
Posts: 1552
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2011 1:41 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Aelcar »

Steve wrote:if our Character Sheets do say Epic Character, then I totally understand the problem where one is RPing being some Epic Individual, yet are wifflestomped by some City Guard, or Flaming Fist officer, or XYZ that is NOT an Epic Foe.

Which goes back to the OP, I think.
How do you know?

That XYZ is no epic foe, I mean.

He/she/it just handed your epic ass to you, right? Seems pretty epic to me.

The problem here is: MOST XYZ should NOT be able to do that. Once that condition is met, and the "world" recognizes this, everything is suddenly in order.
Aelcar Lightbringer, Knight of the Merciful Sword: Disappeared after the victorious defense of the Gate against The Blight.

Olath M'elzar Valshar The Black, The Phantom Wizard: Retired Steward of the School of Necromancy and former Eye of the 7th Circle.
User avatar
Rhifox
Posts: 3962
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Rhifox »

Steve wrote:
Rhifox wrote: on this kind of server, I can barely even recognize levels as an RP mechanic at all.
.
Hi Rhifox,
I was hoping you could clarify this comment, for me. Considering it is asked by the Administration of this Server to "play your Character Sheet," and thus Levels = Skills and Feats, doesn't what we Role-play a Character stem from what they actually can do?

Which is also to point out, if our Character Sheets do say Epic Character, then I totally understand the problem where one is RPing being some Epic Individual, yet are wifflestomped by some City Guard, or Flaming Fist officer, or XYZ that is NOT an Epic Foe.

Which goes back to the OP, I think.
Well, simply that level does not mean anything to me, from an IC standpoint. Skills and abilities do. What does level even mean? It's a number. It has no substance. When you take a feat, it has substance. It represents something within the world, something that you can do and act with. But a level just represents some "general" level of "power". My characters do not look at somebody and see their level. What they do see, are the feats that person can accomplish, or the skills they can perform. I RP based on what my characters can see and react to. Someone with a higher level has a broader range of abilities, certainly, so they can be considered more skilled than other people by sheer versatility, but I don't see it as something that dictates "this person is a god among men"... which is what 30 levels is "supposed" to be.

For me level of power only goes up so high as the environment permits. As I see it, characters on BG have a broader ability range, but not a higher one. They're better than the common person, definitely, and epic characters are better than the common adventurer, but not to the degree that exists in pnp epic adventures. It's a matter of defining what epic is. In classic DnD, "epic" is associated with planar adventures, fighting and serving directly on behalf of the gods. On BG, I associate "epic" with something to the equivalent of "super adventurer", in which epic is just someone who is powerful enough to be a major player in a city/kingdom and has a broader range of abilities than other people do. You're still going around doing local city/regional adventures, you're a hero but you're not a demigod. In which case, some guards or flaming fist officers might also be "epic", heroes among the guards.

I choose to define epic by how it comes across on BG, rather than the pnp definition. Epic spells are not spells of wide reaching power capable of unmaking (or making) the world, they're fairly basic spells only slightly more powerful than our other spells, which themselves are rather nerfed from their sheer pnp potential (mordenkainen does not break divine artifacts and vaporize every single magical item someone is wearing. Earthquake does not create aftershocks felt miles away. Summon Elemental IX does not create elementals the size of mountains. You cannot flood all of Baldur's Gate with a level 9 spell. Etc.).

In other words, I judge things by a what-you-see-is-what-you-get perspective. And what we see, while powerful, is significantly more mundane than characters of our levels would be in pnp. The 1-30 range is absolutely massive, by dnd standards, but by server standards I judge it much, much, much narrower.
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

Aelcar wrote:How do you know?

That XYZ is no epic foe, I mean.
I play Characters with high INT, or high WIS. Either should allow my Toon to realize that if that Flaming Fist Guard was truly an Epic Warrior, they ABSOLUTELY WOULD NOT BE SHLEPPING FOR A MERCENARY COMPANY!!

:twisted:

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Steve »

Rhifox wrote: Well, simply that level does not mean anything to me, from an IC standpoint.
Okay, I understand now. When said earlier as "RP mechanic," that appeared more of an OOC perspective. Cheers.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Aelcar
Posts: 1552
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2011 1:41 am

Re: Power level of a PC

Unread post by Aelcar »

Steve wrote:
Aelcar wrote:How do you know?

That XYZ is no epic foe, I mean.
I play Characters with high INT, or high WIS. Either should allow my Toon to realize that if that Flaming Fist Guard was truly an Epic Warrior, they ABSOLUTELY WOULD NOT BE SHLEPPING FOR A MERCENARY COMPANY!!

:twisted:
Both are up to the DMs. Much like us IRL, no matter how smart or skilled, characters don't know everything. And so it happens that a master of the arcane like Kor'Vain can be wrong about a matter of magic he is insufficiently informed about, or simply make a wrong call, and a fine conoisseur of humanoid nature with a massive amount of common sense like Jon Smythe can be wrong in evaluating someone else "ceteris paribus" (all other conditions being equal).

The reason why that very skilled mercenary is right there, is up to the DM who placed him there at that point in time. All players have a right to ask, in a normal situation (as in: didn't kill several guards in front of witnesses the day before and now they're magically back at Maltz as if nothing happened...) is counterplay.

Finally, I find myself in agreement with Rhifox in considering characters "exceptionally skilled adventurers", more like "lvl 6/12/15/20/25/whatnot" or any such thing, as I wrote previously in this very thread.
Aelcar Lightbringer, Knight of the Merciful Sword: Disappeared after the victorious defense of the Gate against The Blight.

Olath M'elzar Valshar The Black, The Phantom Wizard: Retired Steward of the School of Necromancy and former Eye of the 7th Circle.

Return to “General Discussion”