I apologize for not having been clear the first time. Glad it's cleared up.Steve wrote:Okay, I understand now. When said earlier as "RP mechanic," that appeared more of an OOC perspective. Cheers.Rhifox wrote: Well, simply that level does not mean anything to me, from an IC standpoint.
Power level of a PC
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
Rhifox
- Posts: 3962
- Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 2:34 am
Re: Power level of a PC
Tarina — The Witch of Darkhold, a dealer in spirits and black magic
-
Steve
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 8197
- Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
- Location: Paradise in GMT +1
Re: Power level of a PC
Aaaaand...that's where I'll call bull crap, and get myself banned! lol.Aelcar wrote:The reason why that very skilled mercenary is right there, is up to the DM who placed him there at that point in time.
But seriously, DMs make mistakes. Maybe rarely, but they do. And sometimes, the "very skilled merc" really shouldn't be THAT skilled, but only IS that skilled, because the DM doesn't want your PC to "win" the situation. Or ruin their storyline, cause...wait for it...my PC is frickin' Epic, man, and the sheet says so, so, so, there!
Look, it's complicated. But it could be less complicated, when less Levels are involved!
I never said my Characters should "know everything," nor do I want to Win every situation. In fact, I've been begging for DMs to put my Characters to the Test, every since TheVoid was on this Server, who, btw, chickened out on me!! This is why I call on using DCs for so much interaction, since it gives Chance to the situation, instead of Railroading (and just have to "follow along," which applies to both DM and Player!).
Jon Smythe - The Book of....
Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant
Sabross N'azza - Working...
Khelboros Wyrmstone
-
King Of Clouds
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2013 10:42 am
Re: Power level of a PC
I feel like adding a case story to my previous post and the recent discussion about the value of achieving those 30 levels. This concerns the plague troll quest that NegInfinity mentioned earlier and my experiences participating to the event.
At that time I was playing my dwarf character Durin who was around level 15 and actually quite powerful character for his level and relatively well equipped. The trolls were threatening to attack the dwarf hold of troll hills and I happened upon a group of dwarves recruiting people to help with the invasion. This was a perfect chance for him to prove his worthiness in battle. Or so I thought at first.
During the beginning of this event there were several battles in the southern hills that went smoothly, until the DM started the major onslaught in the crossroads area north of the burned-down village. To represent the "big fight" the DMs started spawning the big super-powered trolls that I assume was supposed to represent the full force of a troll army.
There first weird thing was that were about 20+ PCs (of which some could've been level 30 but not insanely enough powerbuilt for these kind of enemies) who took their place to stand about 10-20 meters from the bloody fight. Some of them were just chatting casual stuff and making jokes about the situation as the frontline warriors were chopping off troll body parts like some weird meat-processing factory. The reason was that they probably knew that they couldn't do anything else without getting ripped apart in seconds and this was the time when all they could do was to step back and try to be entertained. The only realistic thing would've naturally been to run off screaming, but then they would've lost the quest exp and chance to witness the outcome. So there they were, watching the fight like some sort of a sport event. The only thing that was missing was someone selling (troll meat?) hot dogs and selling "Go dwarves!" -flags for the audience.
Durin, the sacred defender of Gorm Gulthyn and the dwarves however, was obliged to join the fight so I moved him to the frontline. Despite the fact that he should've been considered relatively well-trained (and already halfway to level 30), he was absolutely annihilated by these trolls. There were some moments where he could land several lucky blow or two against the madly high AC-possessing enemies with literally thousands of hit points, but if a single one of the lesser troll enemies decided to focus on him, a few blows (with 95% hit chance) were enough to reduce him to near-death. It was basically utterly useless MMORPG-style "You entered into the wrong dungeon kid" -kind of situation; he simply didn't belong there and now got his ass handed to him in front of the audience. Great.
I did my best to try and RP his retreat to the pile of people to hurl throwing axes (that I knew would never land due to the crazy AC) from the mass of gossiping observers and heal, but every second I started to grow more and more tired with the whole situation. It was humiliating for my dwarf to be so utterly useless and I was seriously thinking that I'd just log off because I had simply had enough. I chose to ignore my ill feelings and force myself to stick around though because it would've been quite catastrophic for my character RP to abandon the battlefield where his people were being overrun by giant trolls. He could've never justified that to his god or his people.
So the fight went on and after about 20 waves of enemies the DMs started to spawn giant two-headed trolls to perhaps represent the captains of the troll horde. Then one focused on my character. I think it took 1/3 of a round (2 seconds) that I saw my 200 hp characters with full buffs disappear from sight of a familiar loading screen. That troll didn't even finish his single 6 second round to kill my character with its asburdly high AB and damage output. Someone from the "audience" brought him back to life, but his buffs were gone (and of course one does not simply rest in DM quest). So I tried to continue to hurl axes or flank some enemies or try to tank the lesser trolls when they attacked the crowd from the sides. This got Durin killed a few more times and left me with two possible options:
1) Die like a dog and be actually repeated burden to some other player's raise dead scroll reserves (until they would've had enough of raising that noob/Leeroy Jenkins)
2) Run like a dog
3) Join the audience and grab a seat (+ a hot dog).
It all became clear that all that Durin could do was to stay out of the way of the level 30's fight and perhaps throw in a single bless or mass aid every now and then (as if that mattered when their AB was around +40 to +50, yay.). For a while I was actually thinking that I could just throw Durin to the battle one more time and permakill him, since in that way he would've had his "honorable" battle and got ripped apart defending a hold. A nice fitting end for a defender of Gorm. However, this option would've been absurd because I still liked the concept of my character and he was just about to start to bloom in terms of his build-potential and social aspects. I also thought that it would've really sucked to throw him to the trash just because I chose to attend to a DM quest where he shouldn't have ever joined the first place. So the event ended, my character lived, but I noticed a significant drop of enjoyment to play him anymore. How could I justify his worthlessness in the combat and say that one day he's going to be that glorious level 30 and worth more than a door rug.
After these realizations suddenly the whole game started to once again feel uninteresting for me, because the event was too harsh reminder about the fact that if you're not level 30 you're worth absolutely nothing in these kind of events. From there we get to the second fact: If you don't join the events you're worth nothing to the server lore and important storylines (except perhaps as the glorious storyteller, or a successful hot dog salesman). So I started to play him less and less and then RL summer came so I took a long break from the server altogether. Now I'm back and hopeful for this game once more, empowered by the FR lore illusion of playing the good old Baldur's Gate saga once more and I try to keep that spirit running for as long as I can.
My point of the story, which I feel actually really sorry to say, is that after seeing more than a few of these kind of events I've come to the conclusion that I simply don't want to join DM events anymore, with level 30 or otherwise. The reason is simply that by doing so I risk losing interest in playing the game entirely due to lost immersion and impossible demands from RP point of view when opposed by game mechanics. It should be noted that I do -know- the mechanics like my own pockets and I could build myself a superb powerhouse if I felt the need to do so. However, the way how I design my characters is that I go with the full package: stats, skills, classes, appearance, etc. I simply wouldn't enjoy to play your "Joe the average epic weapon master" with min-maxed abilities and build-creativity level of a potato. However, because many of the events are so absurdly way out of league for powerful, but not ULTRA-POWERFUL level 30 characters and they have the potential to make me quit playing the game, I choose to actively avoid them. Nowadays I enjoy more to chat with people around FAI, go adventuring to various places and even doing weekly quests where I'm not reminded of the un-optimized nature of my characters build.
So my long story was that in my opinion events for level 30's are not for me and make me want to quit playing the game. What's my point besides this rant?
The fact that this scenario would've been significantly different situation if instead of level 30 characters we would've had people of level 15-20 and fitting monsters according to those levels. You could still have a two-headed troll, but it wouldn't have to have 10 000 HP, 50 AC and do 100 damage per hit 6 times per round in order to be a challenge. Instead we could have one with 200-500 hp, 30 AC and 20-40 damage as the game is intended. This means a level 10 fighter could get a hit at it, wouldn't die in the fight in a second and mages that can cast that 20d8 horrid wilting will really tear that troll and his pals a new one (but only a few times until he's out of spell slots). The key point is that the difference in potential shrinks significantly the lower the level cap is. Also in this level scale the role of the actually legendary PCs becomes much more precious as they may be the only ones able to defeat the big boss that CAN have that 40-50 AC and 1000-2000 hp + 40 damage per hit 3-4 times per round (which is much but not an utter instakill also for that level 10).
People would still be able to adventure and gather gear, but the best jewels of the system are saved for the most dedicated. Achieving them would feel like much greater thing than joining the level 30 club with just about every other player of the server. I would absolutely love to also perhaps one day witness that my character that has lived past hundreds of fights would be able to cast Gate to have an Angel ally join the fight against the epic pale master archmage that can cast that legendarily dangerous spell Vampiric Feast at level 21. It'd be so rewarding to have an actual RP and combat potential to use that Angel for something more than triggering a trap on a chest as Sirion once mentioned. I'm saying this because for example in that DM event the Gate spell Angel would've probably been killed in one-on-one fight with a single lesser troll. That's, along with the fact that it's average arsenal of 50% of server's spellcaster population is not very impressive in my opinion.
It should be also noted that I am not looking to even be this legendary hero because I don't have the time for it and I'll gladly leave this role for other people. This is why I don't even aim to build my characters like this. I'd be however, happy to be the useful sidekick of that said legendary hero or part of the group that did survive the onslaught, but not if my role was to be a popcorn muncher while my RP role would oblige otherwise.
Finally: Please don't mistake any of this as an attack towards the DM behind this event or DM team altogether. I know you're doing hard and precious work for the server overall, while struggling with quite serious balancing issues. I know that most of the time you've probably chosen the best case scenario that is available in these cirumstances. I have all the respect for your work and you cannot please everyone with your events. I will also say it once more that I don't seek to demand that you have to change everything to suit my playing needs.
However, I must say that with my experiences involving some of the latest events, my conclusion is that I'd rather just avoid them altogether. It all boils down to the game mechanics and the fact that in this server with the current rules the game turns into a World of Warcraft or Diablo 3 -style number scale based hack'n'slash where only those with sufficient power level can do absolutely anything in events.
So I'll continue to play my character, I might even join an event every now and then (especially if it doesn't involve fighting!), but the way how the things are currently I'll focus my time on the server on the social aspects because if I get reminded too much about the realities of the absurd game mechanics, it just kills my fun and I'll probably end up taking a long break or finally retiring from NWN2 altogether.
Thanks for reading this. Discussion (even of completely opposite opinions) is more than welcome.
(( Edited after publishing to fix one small grammar issue ))
At that time I was playing my dwarf character Durin who was around level 15 and actually quite powerful character for his level and relatively well equipped. The trolls were threatening to attack the dwarf hold of troll hills and I happened upon a group of dwarves recruiting people to help with the invasion. This was a perfect chance for him to prove his worthiness in battle. Or so I thought at first.
During the beginning of this event there were several battles in the southern hills that went smoothly, until the DM started the major onslaught in the crossroads area north of the burned-down village. To represent the "big fight" the DMs started spawning the big super-powered trolls that I assume was supposed to represent the full force of a troll army.
There first weird thing was that were about 20+ PCs (of which some could've been level 30 but not insanely enough powerbuilt for these kind of enemies) who took their place to stand about 10-20 meters from the bloody fight. Some of them were just chatting casual stuff and making jokes about the situation as the frontline warriors were chopping off troll body parts like some weird meat-processing factory. The reason was that they probably knew that they couldn't do anything else without getting ripped apart in seconds and this was the time when all they could do was to step back and try to be entertained. The only realistic thing would've naturally been to run off screaming, but then they would've lost the quest exp and chance to witness the outcome. So there they were, watching the fight like some sort of a sport event. The only thing that was missing was someone selling (troll meat?) hot dogs and selling "Go dwarves!" -flags for the audience.
Durin, the sacred defender of Gorm Gulthyn and the dwarves however, was obliged to join the fight so I moved him to the frontline. Despite the fact that he should've been considered relatively well-trained (and already halfway to level 30), he was absolutely annihilated by these trolls. There were some moments where he could land several lucky blow or two against the madly high AC-possessing enemies with literally thousands of hit points, but if a single one of the lesser troll enemies decided to focus on him, a few blows (with 95% hit chance) were enough to reduce him to near-death. It was basically utterly useless MMORPG-style "You entered into the wrong dungeon kid" -kind of situation; he simply didn't belong there and now got his ass handed to him in front of the audience. Great.
I did my best to try and RP his retreat to the pile of people to hurl throwing axes (that I knew would never land due to the crazy AC) from the mass of gossiping observers and heal, but every second I started to grow more and more tired with the whole situation. It was humiliating for my dwarf to be so utterly useless and I was seriously thinking that I'd just log off because I had simply had enough. I chose to ignore my ill feelings and force myself to stick around though because it would've been quite catastrophic for my character RP to abandon the battlefield where his people were being overrun by giant trolls. He could've never justified that to his god or his people.
So the fight went on and after about 20 waves of enemies the DMs started to spawn giant two-headed trolls to perhaps represent the captains of the troll horde. Then one focused on my character. I think it took 1/3 of a round (2 seconds) that I saw my 200 hp characters with full buffs disappear from sight of a familiar loading screen. That troll didn't even finish his single 6 second round to kill my character with its asburdly high AB and damage output. Someone from the "audience" brought him back to life, but his buffs were gone (and of course one does not simply rest in DM quest). So I tried to continue to hurl axes or flank some enemies or try to tank the lesser trolls when they attacked the crowd from the sides. This got Durin killed a few more times and left me with two possible options:
1) Die like a dog and be actually repeated burden to some other player's raise dead scroll reserves (until they would've had enough of raising that noob/Leeroy Jenkins)
2) Run like a dog
3) Join the audience and grab a seat (+ a hot dog).
It all became clear that all that Durin could do was to stay out of the way of the level 30's fight and perhaps throw in a single bless or mass aid every now and then (as if that mattered when their AB was around +40 to +50, yay.). For a while I was actually thinking that I could just throw Durin to the battle one more time and permakill him, since in that way he would've had his "honorable" battle and got ripped apart defending a hold. A nice fitting end for a defender of Gorm. However, this option would've been absurd because I still liked the concept of my character and he was just about to start to bloom in terms of his build-potential and social aspects. I also thought that it would've really sucked to throw him to the trash just because I chose to attend to a DM quest where he shouldn't have ever joined the first place. So the event ended, my character lived, but I noticed a significant drop of enjoyment to play him anymore. How could I justify his worthlessness in the combat and say that one day he's going to be that glorious level 30 and worth more than a door rug.
After these realizations suddenly the whole game started to once again feel uninteresting for me, because the event was too harsh reminder about the fact that if you're not level 30 you're worth absolutely nothing in these kind of events. From there we get to the second fact: If you don't join the events you're worth nothing to the server lore and important storylines (except perhaps as the glorious storyteller, or a successful hot dog salesman). So I started to play him less and less and then RL summer came so I took a long break from the server altogether. Now I'm back and hopeful for this game once more, empowered by the FR lore illusion of playing the good old Baldur's Gate saga once more and I try to keep that spirit running for as long as I can.
My point of the story, which I feel actually really sorry to say, is that after seeing more than a few of these kind of events I've come to the conclusion that I simply don't want to join DM events anymore, with level 30 or otherwise. The reason is simply that by doing so I risk losing interest in playing the game entirely due to lost immersion and impossible demands from RP point of view when opposed by game mechanics. It should be noted that I do -know- the mechanics like my own pockets and I could build myself a superb powerhouse if I felt the need to do so. However, the way how I design my characters is that I go with the full package: stats, skills, classes, appearance, etc. I simply wouldn't enjoy to play your "Joe the average epic weapon master" with min-maxed abilities and build-creativity level of a potato. However, because many of the events are so absurdly way out of league for powerful, but not ULTRA-POWERFUL level 30 characters and they have the potential to make me quit playing the game, I choose to actively avoid them. Nowadays I enjoy more to chat with people around FAI, go adventuring to various places and even doing weekly quests where I'm not reminded of the un-optimized nature of my characters build.
So my long story was that in my opinion events for level 30's are not for me and make me want to quit playing the game. What's my point besides this rant?
The fact that this scenario would've been significantly different situation if instead of level 30 characters we would've had people of level 15-20 and fitting monsters according to those levels. You could still have a two-headed troll, but it wouldn't have to have 10 000 HP, 50 AC and do 100 damage per hit 6 times per round in order to be a challenge. Instead we could have one with 200-500 hp, 30 AC and 20-40 damage as the game is intended. This means a level 10 fighter could get a hit at it, wouldn't die in the fight in a second and mages that can cast that 20d8 horrid wilting will really tear that troll and his pals a new one (but only a few times until he's out of spell slots). The key point is that the difference in potential shrinks significantly the lower the level cap is. Also in this level scale the role of the actually legendary PCs becomes much more precious as they may be the only ones able to defeat the big boss that CAN have that 40-50 AC and 1000-2000 hp + 40 damage per hit 3-4 times per round (which is much but not an utter instakill also for that level 10).
People would still be able to adventure and gather gear, but the best jewels of the system are saved for the most dedicated. Achieving them would feel like much greater thing than joining the level 30 club with just about every other player of the server. I would absolutely love to also perhaps one day witness that my character that has lived past hundreds of fights would be able to cast Gate to have an Angel ally join the fight against the epic pale master archmage that can cast that legendarily dangerous spell Vampiric Feast at level 21. It'd be so rewarding to have an actual RP and combat potential to use that Angel for something more than triggering a trap on a chest as Sirion once mentioned. I'm saying this because for example in that DM event the Gate spell Angel would've probably been killed in one-on-one fight with a single lesser troll. That's, along with the fact that it's average arsenal of 50% of server's spellcaster population is not very impressive in my opinion.
It should be also noted that I am not looking to even be this legendary hero because I don't have the time for it and I'll gladly leave this role for other people. This is why I don't even aim to build my characters like this. I'd be however, happy to be the useful sidekick of that said legendary hero or part of the group that did survive the onslaught, but not if my role was to be a popcorn muncher while my RP role would oblige otherwise.
Finally: Please don't mistake any of this as an attack towards the DM behind this event or DM team altogether. I know you're doing hard and precious work for the server overall, while struggling with quite serious balancing issues. I know that most of the time you've probably chosen the best case scenario that is available in these cirumstances. I have all the respect for your work and you cannot please everyone with your events. I will also say it once more that I don't seek to demand that you have to change everything to suit my playing needs.
However, I must say that with my experiences involving some of the latest events, my conclusion is that I'd rather just avoid them altogether. It all boils down to the game mechanics and the fact that in this server with the current rules the game turns into a World of Warcraft or Diablo 3 -style number scale based hack'n'slash where only those with sufficient power level can do absolutely anything in events.
So I'll continue to play my character, I might even join an event every now and then (especially if it doesn't involve fighting!), but the way how the things are currently I'll focus my time on the server on the social aspects because if I get reminded too much about the realities of the absurd game mechanics, it just kills my fun and I'll probably end up taking a long break or finally retiring from NWN2 altogether.
Thanks for reading this. Discussion (even of completely opposite opinions) is more than welcome.
(( Edited after publishing to fix one small grammar issue ))
Player of: Gondael • Blaric Brimsbane • Teth Zorastryl • Kain • Z'eed Auzkovyn • Durin Khazrudh
-
NegInfinity
- Posts: 2449
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am
Re: Power level of a PC
King Of Clouds, I've read your post, and have some thoughs for share.
In my opinion part of your negative experience stem from the desire of your character to be, well, "important". It is not an accusation, just an opinion. People often want their character to be a hero or important, so as mighty level 1 necromancer with plans to ascend to godhood and become new Bhaal, they walk out of the gate ... and accidentally bump into Asmodeus himself, while being armed with ambitions and burning stick. Whoops.
That's, in my opinion, where complaints about power level come from - from aiming too high or expecting too much, expecting character become a hero or important. I don't mean anything bad about that, mind you.
In my experience the server works best when you stop aiming high and go with the flow. If the character is scared and would like to run, he or she should run, even if that means abandoning xp or not witnessing the end of the quest. If the character is obliged to charge into the fight against all odds, then the character should do that even if it means permadeath. If someone decided to raise you, well, it was their decision, their wasted scroll, and as a player you owe them nothing. Your character could get really scared, run (possibly while breaking an oath to defend the hold) and keep having nightmares and feeling guilty about that for weeks, for example.
Desire to witness the end and get xp is an OOC concern, character knows nothing about the OOC concern, and by following your OOC goals instead of IC ones, you're ruining your own fun because you destroy the flow of the story. And there are a lot of OOC concerns in your post - AB, AC, levels, hitpoints, xp, amount of damage, desire to see the outcome, etc.
The key point about the server I'd recommend to realize is that this is not a PnP campaign, and the world does not revolve around specific character, specific party, guild or anything like that. The world just exists, and characters pop in/out of it. Because of this you may end up "on the wrong street" in a fight you can't handle. And because of this the most enjoyable way to play it is to concentrate on character's story, even when the story goes in the way you did not expect or foresee.. or even when the story ends up as "and they all died horribly". Meanwhile any attempt to play this as a PnP session will probably result in hurt feeligns and disappointment, and will produce more threads about power level and the like.
Just a few thoughts on the subject.
I believe if you think that your character should run, then your character should run. You can get xp elsewhere later and ask about outcome later. Wanting xp and wanting to see the outcome is OOC reasoning.King Of Clouds wrote:The only realistic thing would've naturally been to run off screaming, but then they would've lost the quest exp and chance to witness the outcome.
It is not about being level 30. It is about picking your fights wisely. I had several level 30 chars that would get destroyed in this event, or even in some of relatively safe epic areas. Level matters less than your abilities. Meanwhile the unbuffed character of mine - the one standing on the pile of dead casters without a scratch wasn't much tougher than your dwarf but probably dealt couple of thousands points of damage during the fight.King Of Clouds wrote: fter these realizations suddenly the whole game started to once again feel uninteresting for me, because the event was too harsh reminder about the fact that if you're not level 30 you're worth absolutely nothing in these kind of events.
In my opinion part of your negative experience stem from the desire of your character to be, well, "important". It is not an accusation, just an opinion. People often want their character to be a hero or important, so as mighty level 1 necromancer with plans to ascend to godhood and become new Bhaal, they walk out of the gate ... and accidentally bump into Asmodeus himself, while being armed with ambitions and burning stick. Whoops.
That's, in my opinion, where complaints about power level come from - from aiming too high or expecting too much, expecting character become a hero or important. I don't mean anything bad about that, mind you.
In my experience the server works best when you stop aiming high and go with the flow. If the character is scared and would like to run, he or she should run, even if that means abandoning xp or not witnessing the end of the quest. If the character is obliged to charge into the fight against all odds, then the character should do that even if it means permadeath. If someone decided to raise you, well, it was their decision, their wasted scroll, and as a player you owe them nothing. Your character could get really scared, run (possibly while breaking an oath to defend the hold) and keep having nightmares and feeling guilty about that for weeks, for example.
Desire to witness the end and get xp is an OOC concern, character knows nothing about the OOC concern, and by following your OOC goals instead of IC ones, you're ruining your own fun because you destroy the flow of the story. And there are a lot of OOC concerns in your post - AB, AC, levels, hitpoints, xp, amount of damage, desire to see the outcome, etc.
The key point about the server I'd recommend to realize is that this is not a PnP campaign, and the world does not revolve around specific character, specific party, guild or anything like that. The world just exists, and characters pop in/out of it. Because of this you may end up "on the wrong street" in a fight you can't handle. And because of this the most enjoyable way to play it is to concentrate on character's story, even when the story goes in the way you did not expect or foresee.. or even when the story ends up as "and they all died horribly". Meanwhile any attempt to play this as a PnP session will probably result in hurt feeligns and disappointment, and will produce more threads about power level and the like.
Just a few thoughts on the subject.
-
King Of Clouds
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2013 10:42 am
Re: Power level of a PC
Thank you for the post, good and constructive points. I want to also offer a few notes of my own.
The biggest personal wish that I had after a few rounds of getting "dwarf-tossed" around by the trolls was a clean way out. If this had been a single player game I would've closed the application and said that this game sucks, I'm not having fun and for the time being I don't want to play it any more. These thoughts were completely shared with also my girlfriend who was playing the dwarf druid and trying to participate to the fight. While I may be a bit biased with my experience in playing on other kinds of servers and rule systems, she has only ever played NWN2 on this server and found the event disturbing and unpleasant (also she played level 21 druid with relatively powerful shapeshifting and did much better than Durin in the fights).
My problem was indeed that there wasn't any reasonable way how I could ICly withdraw from the incredibly OOCly unpleasant situation without seriously hurting my character's RP in the process. This was a mistake from me because it killed my inspiration for this game for months to come, but in future I know better.
So what I wanted to say was that the overall issue with events like this was that people DO use OOC reasoning to deal with IC or especially game-engine related conflicts, which immensively reduces the immersion. In this case, the problem wasn't with those who were fighting or even the people that tried to offer healing or other services to the fighters because they were playing a realistic part of their roleplay. The issue was that there were people that were treating this situation as if it was all just a big joke. I get them, because in OOC point of view it actually was; probably nobody in that group could've done much to help in that situation so they had to just stick there in one spot like a herd of sheep while watching the shepherd fight the wolf pack. Perhaps some even took off, I don't know, but most people chose to stay till the end since they made the decision to join.
In order for Durin to have been of ANY use whatsoever in this fight he should've been level 25+. This is extremely high requirement in terms of time for my busy schedule, but also it's precisely the reason why people are obsessed with the disliked trend of getting level 30 first and starting to RP later. To do otherwise will turn your character as one of those "observers". Even if you didn't want to be the big hero of the day, most people don't want to be a deadweight, which is inevidable for most non-powergamed characters that aren't level 30 in events like this.
In other words: This system generates self-sustaining system to turn players into powergamers, it strains DMs with the fact that they have to learn to master the system instead of just running quests with regular monsters and it creates twisted circumstances, such as these "level 50 bandits/guards"
The reason why I mentioned the exp was that there was a whole bunch of other people who did -not- join the battle and merely came there to see what's happening. I can totally understand that and I won't even judge that they might want to stick until the end to get the outcome and exp. The problem was that these people grew obviously tired with the continuous passive fighting, got bored and started to just behave as they would next to FAI campfire. In other words: Quests like this attract people that are like flies; They hang out there just to be part of something important and since it's good way to earn exp and get something to gossip about. This sort of trend is however, damaging for the RP spirit because if there's a huge fight involving hundreds of creatures and people getting killed you can't just sit there and chat about your new boots or latest FAI bar hookup. Then again what can you do about it?
These people cannot actually jump in to the fight because it's too much and if you have to wait for about 2 hour long static battle between the monsters and the "heroes" (translating: combat-ready level 30's) you do eventually want to figure out some ways to entertain yourself. If the enemies were slightly less crazy, even those slightly less heroic folks might grab their average +3 blade and do some damage because they would have some purpose besides of being bored in one pile.
Also to be completely honest in addition to the exp case I explained before I didn't even care to see the outcome of that battle. I simply wanted to get out of there because this event wasn't designed for a character such as myself, who isn't level 30 and that is precisely my point. When you make the average standard that most events should be aimed for such levels, you inevidably run to the problem how do you challenge the group's highest possible fighter, which in other terms is usually either someone with superb gear and/or optimized combat build.
Basically it WILL turn into an arms race of a sorts between powergamers and the DM involved in managing the quest. This is not necessarily always a bad thing; I truly and really appreciate good area builders that make versatile and challenging enemies, but there is limit to everything, such as the epic brigands/guards examples represent. Personally I don't want to start to play the few optimal builds that can squeeze every last bit of numbers out of the engine in order to manage myself in events if I intentionally exaggarate the issue a bit.
I thus also disagree also with your "it's not the levels but the abilities" -comment. Levels define all your potential. They are the "horsepowers" of your car, the potential how "fast you can go" and overall what room do you have to play with. If the requirements are put high, you may fall under the category where you can compete. It's kind of like "You need PhD to get this job" and when every job starts to require PhD masses of people become unemployed or do everything they can to get their hands in that degree.
I stayed because I had to stay or take my leave because of OOC reasons and deal with the RP consequences, such as the examples that you mentioned. Just like I explained about the permadeath, I however, felt that I didn't want to kill him off because of a quest that was so unpleasant for me to begin with. If I had been involved in its build-up for months and it was the great battle where he did his best but was bested, it'd be a different situation, but in this case ending up in the wrong fight without a proper warning and killing him off permanently for it? No thanks. I simply feel that it's wrong to say that the -player- has to deal with the RP consequences of malfunctional game mechanics. It should be everyone's right to kill off their characters, ruin their reputation and turn them into fallen paladins, etc when they feel that the circumstances are good for that, not because the DM had to spawn level 50 troll to give good fight for the other level 30's.
If you make a new character and the DM spawns an Asmodeus just to kill you, I don't want to have anything to do with it and just continue RP as usual. When there are dozens of people and RP involved, this becomes naturally much harder thing to do. Also, there is a difference between a level 1 necromancer fighting Asmodeus and un-optimized level 20-30 character getting his ass handed to him by a common bandit.
My solution would be to lower the level cap for everyone and the problem would be solved. There may be of course other problems related to people being unhappy that they're no longer level 30 etc, but that doesn't remove the fact that this system is the prime reason why it is incredibly difficult to design monsters suited to challenge powerful level 30's and the rest that would also like to be useful.
I won't force my views on anyone, but I do wish to speak out my experiences because I see other people have had similar ones in their end.
The passive tense was deceiving, I admit, but I wasn't actually talking about myself.NegInfinity wrote:King Of Clouds, I've read your post, and have some thoughs for share.
I believe if you think that your character should run, then your character should run. You can get xp elsewhere later and ask about outcome later.King Of Clouds wrote:The only realistic thing would've naturally been to run off screaming, but then they would've lost the quest exp and chance to witness the outcome.
The biggest personal wish that I had after a few rounds of getting "dwarf-tossed" around by the trolls was a clean way out. If this had been a single player game I would've closed the application and said that this game sucks, I'm not having fun and for the time being I don't want to play it any more. These thoughts were completely shared with also my girlfriend who was playing the dwarf druid and trying to participate to the fight. While I may be a bit biased with my experience in playing on other kinds of servers and rule systems, she has only ever played NWN2 on this server and found the event disturbing and unpleasant (also she played level 21 druid with relatively powerful shapeshifting and did much better than Durin in the fights).
My problem was indeed that there wasn't any reasonable way how I could ICly withdraw from the incredibly OOCly unpleasant situation without seriously hurting my character's RP in the process. This was a mistake from me because it killed my inspiration for this game for months to come, but in future I know better.
So what I wanted to say was that the overall issue with events like this was that people DO use OOC reasoning to deal with IC or especially game-engine related conflicts, which immensively reduces the immersion. In this case, the problem wasn't with those who were fighting or even the people that tried to offer healing or other services to the fighters because they were playing a realistic part of their roleplay. The issue was that there were people that were treating this situation as if it was all just a big joke. I get them, because in OOC point of view it actually was; probably nobody in that group could've done much to help in that situation so they had to just stick there in one spot like a herd of sheep while watching the shepherd fight the wolf pack. Perhaps some even took off, I don't know, but most people chose to stay till the end since they made the decision to join.
In order for Durin to have been of ANY use whatsoever in this fight he should've been level 25+. This is extremely high requirement in terms of time for my busy schedule, but also it's precisely the reason why people are obsessed with the disliked trend of getting level 30 first and starting to RP later. To do otherwise will turn your character as one of those "observers". Even if you didn't want to be the big hero of the day, most people don't want to be a deadweight, which is inevidable for most non-powergamed characters that aren't level 30 in events like this.
In other words: This system generates self-sustaining system to turn players into powergamers, it strains DMs with the fact that they have to learn to master the system instead of just running quests with regular monsters and it creates twisted circumstances, such as these "level 50 bandits/guards"
I think this is where you misunderstand the purpose of my point quite critically there because you repeatedly mentioned this exp question and seeing the outcome as my decision. Personally I didn't actually care about the exp at all, because at these levels I could simply spend an hour or two grinding hill giants or something and get more than enough exp in the process. In matter of fact, I would've easily got 3-4 times more exp by killing hill giants instead of participating to the event (and truth be told probably had more fun doing that).NegInfinity wrote:Wanting xp and wanting to see the outcome is OOC reasoning.
The reason why I mentioned the exp was that there was a whole bunch of other people who did -not- join the battle and merely came there to see what's happening. I can totally understand that and I won't even judge that they might want to stick until the end to get the outcome and exp. The problem was that these people grew obviously tired with the continuous passive fighting, got bored and started to just behave as they would next to FAI campfire. In other words: Quests like this attract people that are like flies; They hang out there just to be part of something important and since it's good way to earn exp and get something to gossip about. This sort of trend is however, damaging for the RP spirit because if there's a huge fight involving hundreds of creatures and people getting killed you can't just sit there and chat about your new boots or latest FAI bar hookup. Then again what can you do about it?
These people cannot actually jump in to the fight because it's too much and if you have to wait for about 2 hour long static battle between the monsters and the "heroes" (translating: combat-ready level 30's) you do eventually want to figure out some ways to entertain yourself. If the enemies were slightly less crazy, even those slightly less heroic folks might grab their average +3 blade and do some damage because they would have some purpose besides of being bored in one pile.
Unfortunately you cannot choose your fights in DM events. You can either back down into the "observer's row" or join the battle (or of course leave), but essentially there isn't usually an option where people can just run and fight somewhere else. This is just purely because generally DMs design quest stages carefully and most often there are those people that are able to fight even the toughest enemies. I don't think it's positive for anyone's RP that people are forced to become mere observers. In general the issue that we have a whole bunch of people who're just having a cup of afternoon tea in middle of battlefield is absurd to begin with. But it is also inevidable consequence of having mega-powerful enemies that can give a challenge to the level 30's.NegInfinity wrote:It is not about being level 30. It is about picking your fights wisely. I had several level 30 chars that would get destroyed in this event, or even in some of relatively safe epic areas. Level matters less than your abilities. Meanwhile the unbuffed character of mine - the one standing on the pile of dead casters without a scratch wasn't much tougher than your dwarf but probably dealt couple of thousands points of damage during the fight.
Also to be completely honest in addition to the exp case I explained before I didn't even care to see the outcome of that battle. I simply wanted to get out of there because this event wasn't designed for a character such as myself, who isn't level 30 and that is precisely my point. When you make the average standard that most events should be aimed for such levels, you inevidably run to the problem how do you challenge the group's highest possible fighter, which in other terms is usually either someone with superb gear and/or optimized combat build.
Basically it WILL turn into an arms race of a sorts between powergamers and the DM involved in managing the quest. This is not necessarily always a bad thing; I truly and really appreciate good area builders that make versatile and challenging enemies, but there is limit to everything, such as the epic brigands/guards examples represent. Personally I don't want to start to play the few optimal builds that can squeeze every last bit of numbers out of the engine in order to manage myself in events if I intentionally exaggarate the issue a bit.
I thus also disagree also with your "it's not the levels but the abilities" -comment. Levels define all your potential. They are the "horsepowers" of your car, the potential how "fast you can go" and overall what room do you have to play with. If the requirements are put high, you may fall under the category where you can compete. It's kind of like "You need PhD to get this job" and when every job starts to require PhD masses of people become unemployed or do everything they can to get their hands in that degree.
My character is a paladin, more or less chosen of a god whose pantheon is to protect dwarves against hazards. The point whether he's important for the fight or not is quite irrelevant to this issue per say, but I do have to maintain believeable reaction from my character towards battles like this. He's also immune to fear (as stated in his build), so he should fight for as long as he can.NegInfinity wrote:In my opinion part of your negative experience stem from the desire of your character to be, well, "important". It is not an accusation, just an opinion. People often want their character to be a hero or important, so as mighty level 1 necromancer with plans to ascend to godhood and become new Bhaal, they walk out of the gate ... and accidentally bump into Asmodeus himself, while being armed with ambitions and burning stick. Whoops.
That's, in my opinion, where complaints about power level come from - from aiming too high or expecting too much, expecting character become a hero or important. I don't mean anything bad about that, mind you.
In my experience the server works best when you stop aiming high and go with the flow. If the character is scared and would like to run, he or she should run, even if that means abandoning xp or not witnessing the end of the quest. If the character is obliged to charge into the fight against all odds, then the character should do that even if it means permadeath. If someone decided to raise you, well, it was their decision, their wasted scroll, and as a player you owe them nothing. Your character could get really scared, run (possibly while breaking an oath to defend the hold) and keep having nightmares and feeling guilty about that for weeks, for example.
I stayed because I had to stay or take my leave because of OOC reasons and deal with the RP consequences, such as the examples that you mentioned. Just like I explained about the permadeath, I however, felt that I didn't want to kill him off because of a quest that was so unpleasant for me to begin with. If I had been involved in its build-up for months and it was the great battle where he did his best but was bested, it'd be a different situation, but in this case ending up in the wrong fight without a proper warning and killing him off permanently for it? No thanks. I simply feel that it's wrong to say that the -player- has to deal with the RP consequences of malfunctional game mechanics. It should be everyone's right to kill off their characters, ruin their reputation and turn them into fallen paladins, etc when they feel that the circumstances are good for that, not because the DM had to spawn level 50 troll to give good fight for the other level 30's.
If you make a new character and the DM spawns an Asmodeus just to kill you, I don't want to have anything to do with it and just continue RP as usual. When there are dozens of people and RP involved, this becomes naturally much harder thing to do. Also, there is a difference between a level 1 necromancer fighting Asmodeus and un-optimized level 20-30 character getting his ass handed to him by a common bandit.
My core issue and proposal is exactly to change the mechanics as I explained in my earlier post. The "play your stats" RP-enforcing rule and issues with overbuffed monsters are the key problem that many people have been discussing in this thread about.NegInfinity wrote:Desire to witness the end and get xp is an OOC concern, character knows nothing about the OOC concern, and by following your OOC goals instead of IC ones, you're ruining your own fun because you destroy the flow of the story. And there are a lot of OOC concerns in your post - AB, AC, levels, hitpoints, xp, amount of damage, desire to see the outcome, etc.
My solution would be to lower the level cap for everyone and the problem would be solved. There may be of course other problems related to people being unhappy that they're no longer level 30 etc, but that doesn't remove the fact that this system is the prime reason why it is incredibly difficult to design monsters suited to challenge powerful level 30's and the rest that would also like to be useful.
Totally agree with you there. That's why my overall personal conclusion is that I'll avoid big DM events involving large fights altogether in future, because I don't enjoy the way how they have to be managed accordingly with the highest power level of certain powerful individuals.NegInfinity wrote:The key point about the server I'd recommend to realize is that this is not a PnP campaign, and the world does not revolve around specific character, specific party, guild or anything like that. The world just exists, and characters pop in/out of it. Because of this you may end up "on the wrong street" in a fight you can't handle. And because of this the most enjoyable way to play it is to concentrate on character's story, even when the story goes in the way you did not expect or foresee.. or even when the story ends up as "and they all died horribly". Meanwhile any attempt to play this as a PnP session will probably result in hurt feeligns and disappointment, and will produce more threads about power level and the like.
Just a few thoughts on the subject.
I won't force my views on anyone, but I do wish to speak out my experiences because I see other people have had similar ones in their end.
Player of: Gondael • Blaric Brimsbane • Teth Zorastryl • Kain • Z'eed Auzkovyn • Durin Khazrudh
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: Power level of a PC
King of Clouds, thank you so much for describing your personal experiences and thoughts about this.
I've felt like that so many times on this server, I just want to let you know that you are NOT ALONE.
~grymhild
I've felt like that so many times on this server, I just want to let you know that you are NOT ALONE.
~grymhild
Drathyrra [perma-dead]
Gilia Glandertor [inactive]
Grimhildr Ulvsdatter [active]
Iradortha "Iri" Umbrynthal [inactive]
Jhasina Harika yr Nar'ysra el Ifrit Khalid yi Memnon [active]
Lanathalas [retired]
Mhaev of Cathyr [retired]
Nevaetriel Rilae'ar'an, Kerym'quaress ath Eilistraee [jounal] [It's complicated]
N'essa [perma-dead]
Shaytessa Umbrynthal [bio] [journal] [???]
Shryl [retired]
Sssiks [active]
Ssinyrr [bio] [active]
Hathran Tatyana [active]
Vierdra Zau'afin [inactive]
Gilia Glandertor [inactive]
Grimhildr Ulvsdatter [active]
Iradortha "Iri" Umbrynthal [inactive]
Jhasina Harika yr Nar'ysra el Ifrit Khalid yi Memnon [active]
Lanathalas [retired]
Mhaev of Cathyr [retired]
Nevaetriel Rilae'ar'an, Kerym'quaress ath Eilistraee [jounal] [It's complicated]
N'essa [perma-dead]
Shaytessa Umbrynthal [bio] [journal] [???]
Shryl [retired]
Sssiks [active]
Ssinyrr [bio] [active]
Hathran Tatyana [active]
Vierdra Zau'afin [inactive]
-
NegInfinity
- Posts: 2449
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am
Re: Power level of a PC
Typical approach in this case is "my duties call me" followed by either leaving the zone or even by logout. You can also teleport away if you have a caster around (like that druid).King Of Clouds wrote: The biggest personal wish that I had after a few rounds of getting "dwarf-tossed" around by the trolls was a clean way out.
It is almost always possible to invent a reason for someone NOT to be somewhere.
it is really just abilities. The thing here is that one of ways to get more abilities is by getting more levels, but there are other approaches. It is not impossible to make a character that can take on threats that overlevel him or her by 10 levels.King Of Clouds wrote: I thus also disagree also with your "it's not the levels but the abilities" -comment. Levels define all your potential. They are the "horsepowers" of your car, the potential how "fast you can go" and overall what room do you have to play with.
Alright I see where you're coming from, but I cannot agree with your conclusion and proposed "solution".King Of Clouds wrote: My core issue and proposal is exactly to change the mechanics as I explained in my earlier post. The "play your stats" RP-enforcing rule and issues with overbuffed monsters are the key problem that many people have been discussing in this thread about.
The root of the problems with the troll event you described is taht big events devolve into a mess. ALWAYS. It has nothing to do with level cap. It is not incredibly difficult to make a monster that challenges level 30, because every class has a counter to it. However, in situations that involve 20+ people it becomes nearly impossible to even keep track of what is going on. Even if you set level cap to level 16, an event that has large crowd in it, will play pretty much the same way. Nothing will change.
What would make more sense would be making more events for smaller groups, like classic group of six. Meaning that whoever is suitable or got there first, can participate, but the rest will have to do something else. That will make the situation much easier to manage for DMs, and there will be no way for people to stay on the sidelines and watch.
In order to avoid future unpleasant events, it might make sense to keep away from anything that has very large number of people in it.
-
Karond
- Posts: 2221
- Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 10:47 am
- Location: Sweden
Re: Power level of a PC
I think your issue, which is understandable, is related more to the kind of event you experienced rather than it trivializing your character. If the DM or DMs had made the trolls level 10-ish, I don't think you would have more fun with it. You would have done more damage, yes, but the trolls would fall so fast from the level 30 powerbuilds around you that your feelings might end up being the same. If realism was sought, the issue may not be that your character was killed in an instant from a troll 50 times your size, but that some people weren't.King Of Clouds wrote: If the enemies were slightly less crazy, even those slightly less heroic folks might grab their average +3 blade and do some damage because they would have some purpose besides of being bored in one pile.
In big events characters drown each other out and it tends to boil down to mindless slaughter. Having events with individuals of a reasonable level difference, and being part of a group of 3-5, is by many preferable.
-
Calodan
- Posts: 2032
- Joined: Fri Apr 19, 2013 12:21 pm
- Location: Missoula Montana BIG SKY COUNTRY
Re: Power level of a PC
This is one of the hardest things to do when groups start screaming about events being INCLUSIVE. Basically Little Bobby is wandering by and sees that Little Jimmy is having a party. Well Little Bobby wants to party too but he was not invited. He also sees Little Susy whom he knows has been invited but he has not. So he gets mad and says the group is not being INCLUSIVE and then round and round we go about how the DMs are not being fair.......It is a vicious cycle that really would be remedied if we had about four million DMs to cover everyone in small groups....then again it may not as a particular DM spends all their time with one group that DM will then get punished for not including anyone that happens by then either. It is just one of those things. I would love smaller groups myself as well. 4-8 or so for good adventures. Less chat in the box too. Easier to make a good story but since BG is so busy as in full server on event days that gets even harder to do.What would make more sense would be making more events for smaller groups, like classic group of six.
Kory Sentinel
"We should take the army head on!"
"... it sounds like a terrible idea, but look at that smile."
"And he just sounds so confident ... he is a favored soul."
"Even if we don't survive, he will, and isn't that what matters?" -Red Lancer
"We should take the army head on!"
"... it sounds like a terrible idea, but look at that smile."
"And he just sounds so confident ... he is a favored soul."
"Even if we don't survive, he will, and isn't that what matters?" -Red Lancer
-
NegInfinity
- Posts: 2449
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am
Re: Power level of a PC
I'd say little bobby takes a hike after being questioned how the heck he entered a DM map. Since the little bobby is also probably an adult he should be able to handle that and find a next event to enjoy.Calodan wrote:This is one of the hardest things to do when groups start screaming about events being INCLUSIVE. Basically Little Bobby is wandering by and sees that Little Jimmy is having a party. Well Little Bobby wants to party too but he was not invited.What would make more sense would be making more events for smaller groups, like classic group of six.
Small events in general are more enjoyable, and big stuff (with server-lagging amount of chat) can happen once in a while.
Speaking of more enjoyable BIG dm events, there was a time where a big event was split into several parties, each of them in a separate location. That also worked well. IIRC an attempt to do that was made in troll event as well, but it looks like parties should've been split further.
-
AlwaysSummer Day
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 1170
- Joined: Sun Jun 24, 2012 11:27 pm
- Location: Detroit, Michigan
Re: Power level of a PC
King of Clouds. . . That is a damn fine wall of text. Only got about halfway through the first one but I wanted to say that I have seen many events where people stand around and RP while waiting for xp.
I hate this. Many times these characters have no reason to stay there aside from thinly veiled excuses. The DMs hands are tied too in situations like these. He who stays gets xp. I have had characters that were central to the event leave to get help only to basically get cut off from any further RP let alone reward. Meanwhile Billy PMed Willy halfway into the event and now they will stand by portraying the peanut gallery and net a cool 2k xp each. Why would a pair of neutral evil druids be watching the trial of a paladin in zhenthil keep? Uhhh they are here for drinks?
/Rant
Edit: The three things I wish DM's did more in regards to events are -
1: Small groups of 3-6 players. This is attainable if they set out for it from the beginning. Single events (not series) in DM zones are easiest.
2: Level restrictions. Just announce "nobody over X". That is full proof but once again DM zones are advisable.
3: Living world "events". No xp rewards. No gold rewards. No epic story. The stable hand just wants to talk about horses. The guard just wants to get a short break. The tree branch happened to startle you as it fell. This can be a simple description, a pointless conversation, or any example of a living, breathing world.
I remember when I first started. A DM took control of the guard outside of the Fields of the Dead and warned our party about it. When we chose to enter he wished us luck. That was all. No undead spawns. No extra loot. No xp. No idea which DM it was. It made the world pop though and left a memory that has lasted years.
I hate this. Many times these characters have no reason to stay there aside from thinly veiled excuses. The DMs hands are tied too in situations like these. He who stays gets xp. I have had characters that were central to the event leave to get help only to basically get cut off from any further RP let alone reward. Meanwhile Billy PMed Willy halfway into the event and now they will stand by portraying the peanut gallery and net a cool 2k xp each. Why would a pair of neutral evil druids be watching the trial of a paladin in zhenthil keep? Uhhh they are here for drinks?
/Rant
Edit: The three things I wish DM's did more in regards to events are -
1: Small groups of 3-6 players. This is attainable if they set out for it from the beginning. Single events (not series) in DM zones are easiest.
2: Level restrictions. Just announce "nobody over X". That is full proof but once again DM zones are advisable.
3: Living world "events". No xp rewards. No gold rewards. No epic story. The stable hand just wants to talk about horses. The guard just wants to get a short break. The tree branch happened to startle you as it fell. This can be a simple description, a pointless conversation, or any example of a living, breathing world.
I remember when I first started. A DM took control of the guard outside of the Fields of the Dead and warned our party about it. When we chose to enter he wished us luck. That was all. No undead spawns. No extra loot. No xp. No idea which DM it was. It made the world pop though and left a memory that has lasted years.
Roland; svirfneblin fist of the forest and eco terrorist.
Heinrich Von Rittermark; Everwatch Knights of Helm
Frederick Von Rittermark; Paladin of Azuth/Mystra
Erik Von Rittermark; Unknown
Heinrich Von Rittermark; Everwatch Knights of Helm
Frederick Von Rittermark; Paladin of Azuth/Mystra
Erik Von Rittermark; Unknown
-
Maecius
- Retired Admin
- Posts: 11639
- Joined: Sat May 16, 2009 4:24 pm
Re: Power level of a PC
That could have easily been me, AlwaysSummer. 
I learned my DMing from Sir_Carnifex, notoriously our stingiest DM ever, and like him I tended to mostly focus on bringing the world to life and making PCs feel like heroes and villains of note for their players.
I'd frequently flat out forget to hand out XP at the end of my events. Most of my rewards, when I did reward players, were RP-based: The Thieves Guild robbed a nobleman's vault (no items, just bragging rights and NPC resources), the heroes broke up a bandit blockade and got supplies to the front line to impact the outcome of the war, for helping Bentley save his inn the masked weirdo got a free pass to enter with mask on as long as he presented the signed pass at the gate and properly identified himself there, etc. I let players affect the world over allowing the world to empower players (through mechanical advantages).
I never got a complaint (to my face anyway) about it, but it's not a style everyone appreciates. Some people just want to break open monsters like they're XP pinatas. And there's nothing wrong with that.
I think it comes down to DM styles, event types (there's not a lot a lone DM can do besides spawn monster when they're under pressure to entertain thirty people in a huge event, as everyone's talking over each other and it can be a challenge just keeping track of the RP), and expectations and skill levels.
Some DMs, especially new DMs, won't have the skill level to handle high pressure events as smoothly as a practiced DM might. When I first started DMing I could easily kill a whole party by just spawning the wrong monster on them (we've since added Challenge Rating indicators, but even those need to be weighed against the party and their builds). Some DMs are also comfortable with large combat events or events based on fighting, where others might host an event where nobody even draws their sword. Knowing which DM does what, and what kind of event you're joining, can be important to navigating those situations.
If a DM does a shout about a battle or smoke being seen in the sky or whatever, you can probably expect a huge fight where low level characters are going to be playing the cheerleader role. If a DM shouts for five people with evil PCs levels 10-14 to hit him or her up, first come first serve, it's probably going to be a more carefully balanced event.
Unfortunately, the only time large events really become manageable enough to tell a really immersive story is when 4-5 DMs are managing it. It's how we handled the Amn-Gate War, and it was a lot of fun DM-side too. But it requires the commitment of the whole DM team, and an open weekend, neither of which is always possible for everyone!
I suppose my point is that DMs will always do their best, but you have to remember it's hard work on a clunky client, and they don't always have the backup and control that they need to pull off a really big event on their own. So try not to hold them to impossible standards if you can. Particularly in those large events, and especially when they're newer, because it really is a lot to manage and a lot to learn.
I learned my DMing from Sir_Carnifex, notoriously our stingiest DM ever, and like him I tended to mostly focus on bringing the world to life and making PCs feel like heroes and villains of note for their players.
I'd frequently flat out forget to hand out XP at the end of my events. Most of my rewards, when I did reward players, were RP-based: The Thieves Guild robbed a nobleman's vault (no items, just bragging rights and NPC resources), the heroes broke up a bandit blockade and got supplies to the front line to impact the outcome of the war, for helping Bentley save his inn the masked weirdo got a free pass to enter with mask on as long as he presented the signed pass at the gate and properly identified himself there, etc. I let players affect the world over allowing the world to empower players (through mechanical advantages).
I never got a complaint (to my face anyway) about it, but it's not a style everyone appreciates. Some people just want to break open monsters like they're XP pinatas. And there's nothing wrong with that.
I think it comes down to DM styles, event types (there's not a lot a lone DM can do besides spawn monster when they're under pressure to entertain thirty people in a huge event, as everyone's talking over each other and it can be a challenge just keeping track of the RP), and expectations and skill levels.
Some DMs, especially new DMs, won't have the skill level to handle high pressure events as smoothly as a practiced DM might. When I first started DMing I could easily kill a whole party by just spawning the wrong monster on them (we've since added Challenge Rating indicators, but even those need to be weighed against the party and their builds). Some DMs are also comfortable with large combat events or events based on fighting, where others might host an event where nobody even draws their sword. Knowing which DM does what, and what kind of event you're joining, can be important to navigating those situations.
If a DM does a shout about a battle or smoke being seen in the sky or whatever, you can probably expect a huge fight where low level characters are going to be playing the cheerleader role. If a DM shouts for five people with evil PCs levels 10-14 to hit him or her up, first come first serve, it's probably going to be a more carefully balanced event.
Unfortunately, the only time large events really become manageable enough to tell a really immersive story is when 4-5 DMs are managing it. It's how we handled the Amn-Gate War, and it was a lot of fun DM-side too. But it requires the commitment of the whole DM team, and an open weekend, neither of which is always possible for everyone!
I suppose my point is that DMs will always do their best, but you have to remember it's hard work on a clunky client, and they don't always have the backup and control that they need to pull off a really big event on their own. So try not to hold them to impossible standards if you can. Particularly in those large events, and especially when they're newer, because it really is a lot to manage and a lot to learn.
r e s o u r c e s :
- BG:TSCC Wiki
- Community News
- Server Rules and Information
- Supporting BG:TSCC-
=Thunderbolt=
- Posts: 180
- Joined: Wed Oct 02, 2013 11:12 am
- Location: Funland
Re: Power level of a PC
Reading through King Of Clouds grand wall of text is like my own experience during recent times I have been active in the server and the few events I have been involved in. Not all of them, but majority.
Whenever rarely I would have time to play(entirely my own life choice, not the servers fault), I don't feel like joining because of these absurd situations and power-level.
Whenever rarely I would have time to play(entirely my own life choice, not the servers fault), I don't feel like joining because of these absurd situations and power-level.
*nods*
-
Tantive
- Posts: 1100
- Joined: Thu Dec 03, 2015 10:40 am
Re: Power level of a PC
There is a definite problem for events when those lumped together are required to make a difference, but the disparity between levels was a problem. This we've seen over and over, but last campaign - we saw a solution!
I want to bring up an example where a massive battle had occured which every one had a stake in fighting. The last Undead war within Baldurs Gate. It has had a few creative solutions to split up fights and still be involved avoiding everyone being lumped together.
Split events, which occur ICly on the same time scale.
Monday a battle, Tuesday a battle - They occured at the same time ICly, but you could only be involved with one of them, as they happened simultaneously on different sides of the walls.
They even split up Level ranges for certain battles. Giving a recommended minimum and enforced maximum for the level. Even the final battle had spread load and content from one district to another.
Brilliant. Bigger chance for people to get involved in the same storyline, and to stay relevant for a character.
I would ask the DM's to consider such solutions again, if even to collaborate with each other for one day to the next, to cover a greater range of players.
I want to bring up an example where a massive battle had occured which every one had a stake in fighting. The last Undead war within Baldurs Gate. It has had a few creative solutions to split up fights and still be involved avoiding everyone being lumped together.
Split events, which occur ICly on the same time scale.
Monday a battle, Tuesday a battle - They occured at the same time ICly, but you could only be involved with one of them, as they happened simultaneously on different sides of the walls.
They even split up Level ranges for certain battles. Giving a recommended minimum and enforced maximum for the level. Even the final battle had spread load and content from one district to another.
Brilliant. Bigger chance for people to get involved in the same storyline, and to stay relevant for a character.
I would ask the DM's to consider such solutions again, if even to collaborate with each other for one day to the next, to cover a greater range of players.
Elyssa Symbaern - Bladesinger
Isioviel Fereyn - Elven Ranger
Charisa Flomeigne - Scion of Siamorphe
Isioviel Fereyn - Elven Ranger
Charisa Flomeigne - Scion of Siamorphe
-
Blame The Rogue
- Posts: 653
- Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am
Re: Power level of a PC
to further tantive's suggestion
the war against the bhaalists was done brilliantly in this manner. and not only did they split groups, but they chose strong leaders for each group, and different types of characters were able to truly shine
archers for instance, were there right behind the blockade, shooting and ducking, etc. shining in such a way archers can shine
the war against the bhaalists was done brilliantly in this manner. and not only did they split groups, but they chose strong leaders for each group, and different types of characters were able to truly shine
archers for instance, were there right behind the blockade, shooting and ducking, etc. shining in such a way archers can shine
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."