I think it might make sense to break the problem down into pieces and see what each side objects to.
----------
It would seem that Staff side objects to practice of rebuilding the same character....
In my case I believe that mechanism has good impact on the server because it allowed to create something new without a loss, in case if you run into trouble, which allows playing on the server with limited playtime.
Multiple people think that RCR greatly improved the atmosphere of the server, and that removing it would make people quit.
Then there's ability to fix a build mistake you couldn't predict.
-------
With all that in mind, I think it would make sense if:
1. RCR into a different character would be 100%, but the player is allowed to start at lower level.
2. RCR into a different character would be limited to one per week (that's enough time to figure out that concept isn't working).
3. RCR into the same character would be 50%, unless DM granted a token.
4. RCR into the same character would be available at all times, but at 50% unless DM-granted token is used.
Honestly, I think this is the best solution. It would hinder "build fine-tuning", allow making a new concept, which will reduce grinding, encourage rp AND allow playing with limited playtime.
-------------
Boddynock wrote:A new level 30 toon has no time to develop as a character,
I completely disagree with it. Level 30 toon has all the time in the world to develop as a character. We have many long term players that has been at level 30 for years and at this point a lot of people don't remember their "journey" of getting there. Brand new level 30 wouldn't be very different. Epic level content, by the way, is frankly horrible and not enjoyable. Forcing someone who went through it once to go through this agan is not something I'd do.
P.S. Why do people keep bringing level 30 first? Getting there takes time either way.