How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

This is like the Big Issue that comes up in so many different forms, and I really wonder how and why other Players relate to their gaming experience/effort.

How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your (ability to) Role-play? Mechanics here is defined by one or all of what exists on your PC's Character Sheet: Level, Abilities, Feats, DCs...you name it.

One way to look at it is: the way I RP my Fighter is by the mechanics represented on his Character Sheet.

Another way to look at it is: simply having the Class on my Character Sheet determines who the Fighter is, how he "works," etc. Same with adding multi-classing—it all combines, and the mechanics are "irrelevant" to the RP.

And another way to look at it is: by Server Rules, being asked to RP our PCs Character Sheet to the best of our abilities...are Players locked out of forms of RP—per specific Character—unless it is literally listed on said sheet? So getting all that is possible—i.e. Level 30–is like the DEFINING moment of the PC's RP (possibilities).

There are probably hundreds of ways to look at it. How do you make the Character "live," either by the mechanics, or besides them?

I honestly think that via responses, I might gain some insight on why it is so important for Players to see a X amount faster process of Leveling, on a Server that is meant to cater to all types of RP from level 1 through 30.

And, honestly, I fear that somehow, somewhere, it was lost the idea or experience that each Level was/is an integral part to the RP experience of BGTSCC. Not just being a low level, but the actual level your PC is at that moment. As in: the higher you go, the higher you fly..., which is debatable.

Cheers.
Last edited by Steve on Mon Sep 26, 2016 12:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by TheLier »

I could write pages about this, but I will keep it very short and simple, becuse if I don't I will be writing a game philosophy essay.

I want mechanics to show what my toon skills is, compared to others. I want all toons to feel like they are different, and mechanics to show that very thing.

When these don't work, and suddenly the fighter is a better sneaker then the rouge, that hurts my enjoyment.

Overall, mechanics support and confirm roleplay, and not the opposite. You RP your toon and that shows on the sheet. Not you have a sheet and from that you make up the personality.

But that is just my opinion on that matter.
User avatar
AlexBnt
Posts: 176
Joined: Thu Jan 28, 2016 2:56 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by AlexBnt »

I personally find "playing my sheet" to be fairly easy when it comes to my rp. That being said, it's because I tailored my character's sheet to how I wanted to be able to rp him. Low wisdom let's me make him make all the low wisdom decisions that he constantly makes. Low charisma let's me play him as an extremely abrasive person. That also goes for the skills that I picked for him.

The problem that I see is when someone rolls a high Int character, but they have trouble playing an intelligent character. Or they make someone with high deplomancy or high bluff, but as a player do not know how to be diplomatic or a good liar.
Mathias Vakkari - Quartermaster of House Blackrose
Xelarian Cannister - Guard of Candlekeep Probably dead in a ditch somewhere
Sir Johnri Ghyrsora - Knight of Thay Gone and forgotten
User avatar
kleomenes
Recognized Donor
Posts: 2416
Joined: Fri Mar 29, 2013 10:30 pm
Location: Serving the Black Hand

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by kleomenes »

TheLier wrote:Overall, mechanics support and confirm roleplay, and not the opposite. You RP your toon and that shows on the sheet. Not you have a sheet and from that you make up the personality.

But that is just my opinion on that matter.
Well said, though
Vadim Morozov, Dreadmaster.
Former Characters: Mel Darenda, Daug'aonar, Dural Narkisi, Cynric Greyfox, Ameris Santraeger, Cosimo Delucca, Talas Marsak.
User avatar
metaquad4
Posts: 1532
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by metaquad4 »

I play a lot of spellcasters, and for me, mechanics do affect role-play substantially. In this sort of D&D-esque D20 system, mechanics are intermingled into our RP. Our character sheets determine what our characters are capable of, and the dice determine how our capacities interact with other entity's capacities. This would be the case, even without the "play your character sheet" rule, as it is a part of any d20 RPG. The "play your character sheet" rule just emphasizes it even more, and in a more strict capacity.

I find leveling to be an important aspect. It allows you to do more (more skills, higher skill levels, more feats, more abilities) and for me (as I play a spellcaster) it gives me more toys (spells) to play with. For a fighter, I imagine it would give the same via martial feats and other feats. It allows my character to participate in more RP (hunting RP, conflict RP between player groups, RP that requires characters with particular talents, etc) and events.

In short, its a d20 system. Mechanics are most certainly going to effect RP. I think the only time mechanics don't impact RP are dedicated forum RP and chatroom RP, as well as any potential game persistent worlds where you can RP anything, not just your character sheet.

Though, I personally find systems less enjoyable for most RP since it makes it difficult to pit characters against other characters or the environment without a solid basis for determining what they can and can't do (which, is what mechanics are) and a system to streamline interactions.

"You RP your toon and that shows on the sheet. Not you have a sheet and from that you make up the personality."

I find doing the opposite to be easier. I figure out what I would want to do in a party, then I design my character's build around that. Then, when I have what the character can do (the character sheet) laid out, I can determine who they are and why they can do what they can do.

Doing the opposite, at least from my perspective, can lead to situations where say. . .you RP something that you cannot mechanically represent. I find doing it the way I do avoids such sticky situations. And it lets me create a build I know I will enjoy playing, as opposed to the RP leading me to a build that I can't stand playing.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
User avatar
Calodan
Posts: 2032
Joined: Fri Apr 19, 2013 12:21 pm
Location: Missoula Montana BIG SKY COUNTRY

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Calodan »

This is a loaded question but I will bite. :D

Everything this game is based upon is the mechanics of how it works. From the engine itself to your PC you have. There is only one part of RP that does not. I would call it THE SPARK OF LIFE. This is in essence the personality of the PC. They are our creations and thusly they are unique in how they act in that sense but even this is to some degree based upon what the PC sheet looks like which is made up of a background story for people like me. I try to think of some reason for their being. What drives them then I put to paper (Even in a video game we can not escape the old PnP :lol: ) the PC and the build. Sometimes it is a measuring stick build that I modify for the personality but overall that sheet or mechanic controls every aspect of the RP from creation. That sheet mechanic is based upon the game mechanic. For new players to the server that is all it is based upon is the sheet mechanic. They have no clue about how this server is built yet so not one build at first is made from meta information. For us who have been here not one build we make is based upon just one mechanic. We now know how the server is built. So our PC will now be better suited to the rigors of the coast. We now know how the main body of consistent RPers act. So our PC will be built to better suit RP with those groups. We now know how many DMs build their events and who has the hardest events to do. As a result our PC will now be built to be a demi-god hero. Not really but basically we will take our hardest event we have done and then build to survive that. In the end mechanics controls every aspect of our RP and choices.

At least that is how I feel about it. Specifically here where the world is set before you and your piece is moved around in a life like manner now. No longer do we sit at a table and tell a story. The DM sets the pieces and then hits animate now. Turns are different so the RP is more controlled by the mechanics now.
Kory Sentinel
"We should take the army head on!"

"... it sounds like a terrible idea, but look at that smile."
"And he just sounds so confident ... he is a favored soul."
"Even if we don't survive, he will, and isn't that what matters?" -Red Lancer
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by aaron22 »

i believe that the things you want your PC to know or have knowledge in should be represented in your sheet.. if you have 0 bluff you should either not try to lie or be quite incapable of doing it properly. with 3-5 being likely the gross average. if you have 0 survival skill skill you should have much difficulty putting up a basic tent. WAY TOO OFTEN do i see people not play their sheet and do what they want instead.

so your min/maxed character sheet looks quite unplayable if this is done? you were the one that puts the points where they are after all.

the game does allow you to have at least minor or basic knowledge (1-4pts) in some things based on your ability scores and different feats associated with races and classes. this gives you the ability to give yourself a rounded playable character for RP purposes.

like what was said before and surely after. you create the numbers to reflect how you want the PC to be played.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
AlwaysSummer Day
Recognized Donor
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Jun 24, 2012 11:27 pm
Location: Detroit, Michigan

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by AlwaysSummer Day »

In my opinion the saying "play your character sheet" is wrong. You should play your character and make your sheet reflect that as closely as possible. After all there is no "fear of rodents" feat or "lumberjack" skill.

Now to answer your main question. In my opinion levels /builds are extremely important for Events. If you are too weak expect to be pushing daisies in the beginning middle and end. It is also important when PvP is taken into account. I generally hate PvP but if you want to play a character that isnt easily bullied by the first bard or FS they run into you had better at least have a few tricks up your sleeves.
Roland; svirfneblin fist of the forest and eco terrorist.
Heinrich Von Rittermark; Everwatch Knights of Helm
Frederick Von Rittermark; Paladin of Azuth/Mystra
Erik Von Rittermark; Unknown
arakes99
Retired Staff
Posts: 440
Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2010 10:42 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by arakes99 »

If you are a 10 int, non human fighter / paladin / name any other 2 skill point per level class, arguing that without at least 1 rank in this or that skill means your character can't even walk through a forest only goes to highlight limitations and failings of balancing a game like this. Whereas bards/rangers/rogues can be good at everything there is with almost no sacrifice to the main skills they want.

Survival being required to do something like putting up a tent, or bluffing to even attempt to tell a lie seems like a far stretch to me.

On the flip side, you should have ranks in those skills to be good at whatever it is your doing. My character is terrible at detecting lies, and at lying. And I RP that to my fullest. If another terrible lier, with 0 bluff lied to him. There is a good chance they would succeed as it would all come down to dice rolls. And even at -1 bluff I might be able to lie to someone with 15 sense motive. Your skill just suggests how much time you have spent training at "Difficult" tasks, with dice rolls showing the random luck of the world.

Having to RP a low skill point character like an inept moron that can't even speak properly was never the intention of this system I think. The idea is more that a highly skilled character can open a magical, highly complex lock, survive in the ice cold wilds for weeks on end while tracking something in the snow, or discern the nature of a powerful spell.

Not whether or not they can open a leather satchel or set up a tent.
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by NegInfinity »

Steve wrote: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your (ability to) Role-play?
Mechanics here is defined by one or all of what exists on your PC's Character Sheet: Level, Abilities, Feats, DCs...you name it.
They does not affect my "ability" to roleplay, but they significantly limit available options.

Mechanics go hand in hand with "play your sheet" rule. At lower level characters are weaker. Their stats are lower, their skills are low as well, and they don't know much. At level one you can't go to some amazing patrols or join some expedition to a distant land (well, you can, but you'll die). You won't be able to spot an assassin, invisible mage, scare someone, lie to them and be convincing, or fight someone in duel with a chance of winning.

You can play a very amazing personality, however, but your character will be equivalent of an npc. One good example would be a J-whatever-her-name-is of Illmatter which gives you berry quests. That's potential job for your level 1 character. Another one would be a street vendor, beggar, random drunk in a bar, and the like. Low level characters are also going to be very similar to each other in their sheets.

As your character gets stronger and improves, their selection of feats, stats, abilities, equipment and skills set them apart from everyone else. Bonus points if the choices reflect their development via story, meaning your selection of skills and levels go hand in hand with events that affect you charactersr.

As much as people would like to believe that "levels don't matter", that's simply not true. Levels don't really matter, but your ABILITIES are incredibly important, and one way to gain abilities is via getting levels (another one is pile of grandfathered gear, which still won't get you very far). One could try to pretend being mighty archmage or a skilled fighter right after walking off the boat in harbor, but that illusion won't last long, becasue, let's face it, a street guard will be able to kill your character by sneezing at him/her. So after getting their illusions shattered your character will have to either face the reality or continue being delusional laughing stock.

----

In short, choices made via leveling process, allocation of skillpoints, selection of gear, spells and weapons are customization of your characters that reflect what they are and the path they took. They're also very important if you participate in events other than campfire/bar chats... and even in campfire/bar chats, your skills and knowledge will significantly hinder what your character is capable of saying or knowing. You can ignore leveling process if your'e essentially playing an npc. There were peopel who were quite successful at it too, and it could be fun. But as long as you try to do anything other than that, you'll be limited by mechanics, your character's skills and your character's sheet.

=====

Speaking of which, one of the interesting options available to mechanically weak characters is being a Damsel In Distress, or a McGuffin.

So, let's say there's a chaotic-stupid Level 1 human fighter (str 8 dex 10 con 17 int 9 wis 8 cha 18) which just HAPPENS to be the favorite niece/nephew of lawful evil level 30 arcanist nicknamed "One that makes sky rain blood". Picking the role of that level 1 fighter would bring a lot of grief to the arcanist, and might lead to hilarious situations. The issue is that character's role will be mostly passive once they start trouble and get knocked out. Once again - an NPC, a damsel in distress, a McGuffin, or something similar. At some point the arcanist might just get fed up with it and put his troublesome relative into permanent state of solipsism.
Grinning
Posts: 57
Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2015 5:04 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Grinning »

arakes99 wrote:If you are a 10 int, non human fighter / paladin / name any other 2 skill point per level class, arguing that without at least 1 rank in this or that skill means your character can't even walk through a forest only goes to highlight limitations and failings of balancing a game like this. Whereas bards/rangers/rogues can be good at everything there is with almost no sacrifice to the main skills they want.

Survival being required to do something like putting up a tent, or bluffing to even attempt to tell a lie seems like a far stretch to me.

On the flip side, you should have ranks in those skills to be good at whatever it is your doing. My character is terrible at detecting lies, and at lying. And I RP that to my fullest. If another terrible lier, with 0 bluff lied to him. There is a good chance they would succeed as it would all come down to dice rolls. And even at -1 bluff I might be able to lie to someone with 15 sense motive. Your skill just suggests how much time you have spent training at "Difficult" tasks, with dice rolls showing the random luck of the world.

Having to RP a low skill point character like an inept moron that can't even speak properly was never the intention of this system I think. The idea is more that a highly skilled character can open a magical, highly complex lock, survive in the ice cold wilds for weeks on end while tracking something in the snow, or discern the nature of a powerful spell.

Not whether or not they can open a leather satchel or set up a tent.
+1 to all this.

In most systems you always have the opportunity to roll, even if you have a negative modifier. A player shouldn't feel limited by the skill points he has allocated when performing actions, but results may vary. :D
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by aaron22 »

agree with you on the roll makes for the rare moment where the idiot gets it right. i like that and support it. it is absolutely right on the money. i am just guessing here, but the dc for lifting a tent would be what? 6,8 maybe 14 at worst. so sure anyone should be able to put one up. makes sense. and it is not uncommon to have a person in RL with what i would put a zero at survival. we all know them.

on the other hand.. how many people do you know or could even imagine are so bad at any of the conversation skills that they would deserve a zero score. maybe it is me but i am imagining a story being told to me by a 5 year old. and not a very adorable 5 year old at that. i do not know any adults that are that poor at social skills. but there is quite an abundance of them on the sword coast. but you wouldn't know it if you talked with them. because they are not RPing what is on their paper.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
chad878262
Posts: 9332
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:55 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by chad878262 »

aaron22 wrote:agree with you on the roll makes for the rare moment where the idiot gets it right. i like that and support it. it is absolutely right on the money. i am just guessing here, but the dc for lifting a tent would be what? 6,8 maybe 14 at worst. so sure anyone should be able to put one up. makes sense. and it is not uncommon to have a person in RL with what i would put a zero at survival. we all know them.

on the other hand.. how many people do you know or could even imagine are so bad at any of the conversation skills that they would deserve a zero score. maybe it is me but i am imagining a story being told to me by a 5 year old. and not a very adorable 5 year old at that. i do not know any adults that are that poor at social skills. but there is quite an abundance of them on the sword coast. but you wouldn't know it if you talked with them. because they are not RPing what is on their paper.
This is a really great post Aaron. The issue is though, especially for skill deficient classes that many will take mechanically beneficial skills over any skill for RP use (not all, but many). I personally have a hard time rolling classes that are not skill point heavy because I like to give some bluff, diplomacy and/or intimidate as well as 1-5 points in several lore skills, maybe even 10 in one of them. This makes me feel like the character is well rounded in some ways, whereas a Fighter with Tumble of 10, UMD of 11 and Heal of 33 would seem a bit of an idiot savant (man, that guy knows nothing about medicine, herbs, or bone structure, but he sure can cauterize and bandage a wound!)

We shouldn't really enforce our idea's of 'good rp' on others though and only DM's can enforce rolls so as it stands you kind of have to assume that the amazingly charismatic speaker actually has a high charisma and some points in diplomacy (or bluff)...
Chord Silverstrings - Bard and OSR Squire / Tarent Nefzen - Arcane Wand Merchant and Master Alchemist / Irrace Arkentlar - Drow Adventurer / Finneaus Du'Veil - Gem Merchant and Executive Officer of SCCE

Tarent's Wands and Elixirs

A Wand Crafter's guide to using wands
User avatar
Garn Greymoon
Posts: 288
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 12:19 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Garn Greymoon »

None, i come up with an idea and go for it. The rolls will dictate what my character does or does not know. He can have 40 in a skill but if he isn't from the region he doesn't know crap about it. Also IMO there's a certain hand waving and understanding that any adventurer knows a few common things which i will never roll for.

* starting a camp fire
* putting up a tent
* cooking a piece a meal (now how it tastes is another matter, but i hand wave it)

There's only so much nitpicking I'll do, past a point it becomes un-fun. The key things for me are knowledge skills, sneaking, and interaction skills. Those I find you need ranks in to really "shine".

Also it maybe just me, but i find the DC's to be absolutely ludicrous, @ 30 we are talking with rolls having skills of 60-80. If you compare that to PnP most DC's are set from 10-30. Any higher than that is god-hood. So I have a bit of a hard time taking that seriously.

I mean what do you say? Ok....your stealth is so good that Ao couldn't even find you? Good job?

This sort of stuff doesn't thankfully come up very often, at least in my travels. I usually let the RP dictate the direction and if the other player can convince me of their character doing something without a roll - good on ya! Your rping like a pro and have my utmost respect.

Vabo . . . . . Gnome Druid - The Mushroom Man
Dag . . . . . Gnome Bard - The Twang Fury
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by aaron22 »

Garn Greymoon wrote:This sort of stuff doesn't thankfully come up very often, at least in my travels. I usually let the RP dictate the direction and if the other player can convince me of their character doing something without a roll - good on ya! Your rping like a pro and have my utmost respect.
So if my zero skill half orc with 6 cha and 6 int tells you the history of kalimshan and convinces you to part with your favorite sword because it would be best for his holy knighthood of orc saints without even a roll then that is good rp? sounds like everyone has done poorly there
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley

Return to “General Discussion”