How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by NegInfinity »

Steve wrote:it is possible the PC can roll a d20 and succeed.
Skills do not auto-succeed at natural 20. They also do not auto-fail on one.
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/skills/usingS ... killChecks
It only works on Stat-based checks (dex/str/con/etc), attack rolls and saves. Not on skills.
Steve wrote: Essentially, in Role-play, a Character can do anything they want
They can't. You can't fly and can't be an awakened cockroach, for example. You can't use abilities like the ones used by gods. Trying to do so seriously would be a godmoding.
Steve wrote: So in this line of thought, to RP your Character Sheet of 33 Lore: Arcana, as being the most knowingest of Mages about the Art, is totally possible...until said Mage fails a DC check setup by either the Engine or the DM. And then, that PC is NO LONGER the knowingest Mage, are they?
The most knowledgeable mage would probably have skill between 50 and 60 points. Not a mere 33.

Basically, you're moving a goalpost and try to prove that skills are irrelevant That indirectly encourages godmoding the server.

If someone believes that their character "can do anything", they should probably just write a book isntead.
aaron22 wrote:how many of you have a embarrassing low amount of points in your social skills. and now you wish to justify this by saying i dont like rolling conversations.. well i dont want to roll tumble when my fat dwarf wants to cross the chasm. if you had penalties that made you look stupid when you failed your bluff or diplomacy check in a conversation. more people would put points into it. or stop trying to do something they are evidently not good at.
There are multiple locations on the server that do that, actually, by rolling reflex save. So your proud mighty fighter can trip over something insignificant and faceplant on the ground. This is hilarious, actually, when it happens.

And yeah, good point about social skills. Low charisma and low social skills characters definitely shouldn't be using overly convincing and incredibly elaborate arguments.
Mallore
Posts: 458
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2016 3:08 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Mallore »

I do not roll Bluff, Diplomacy or the like unless a DM asks, if a player asks me to. Sure I can roll it but I become a bit offset by that, maybe its breaking my game immersion or breaking my wrap on my character.

For starters if I was to roll bluff it gives away my characters intentions, it offers OOC information. Now should I trust my fellow player that the roll made will or will not be consideration for their characters reaction? Yes I should, as they should trust I have sufficient skill to bluff them. Should I also trust that the very fact a roll was made will also not color their opinion? sure.. once again though, I got the skill and playing by sheet.

But I follow play your sheet. My Rogue is pretty high on Social Skills so much I can not take things like tumble to get max AC. Just not enough skill points are available to me at int 14. Couldn't get int 16 because of the Hips dex requirement. Which would mean losing cha, wisdom as well to make that work.... and no I wasnt gonna dump stat. I also really bad at building.


My drow.. she has no diplomacy and it shows. She just barks at people and expects them to fall in line..

I leave things to the player im Roleplaying with.
Jane of Here and There (Jane Price)

...also

Jennifer and A Drow.
User avatar
Pimple
Recognized Donor
Posts: 1062
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2016 5:07 pm
Location: CET (Discord: Pimple)

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Pimple »

Mallore wrote:I do not roll Bluff, Diplomacy or the like unless a DM asks, if a player asks me to. Sure I can roll it but I become a bit offset by that, maybe its breaking my game immersion or breaking my wrap on my character.

For starters if I was to roll bluff it gives away my characters intentions, it offers OOC information.
Doesn't this completely ignore the other player's sheet though? Doing nothing to ascertain if the other player's character would see through the lie..?
"They're just furry and misunderstood."
"Is that why you are killing them?"
"Yes. They will atone in death."
"Ah. That will help them understand."


Sirion Te'dwa - Shop
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

Kauaiian wrote:For me, dip classes for benefits without proper RP to back it are more irksome. Non worshipping clerics for example.
This is something I was thinking about, myself, recently.

Besides the Fist of the Forest PrC—or any other 3 lvl PrCs I'm forgetting about—when is a dip not about mechanical power, versus...well, what else is there to say?

Is dipping for 3 really a bad thing. No. Does it make RP of a Character better or worse. No, because RP is a thing a Player does, and what a PC is—good or bad role-play is a Player skill! :lol:

But dipping, besides its obvious use for mechanical empowerment, do 3 levels constitute a true reflection of a Class/PrC, such that one would or could—as in Kai's example—call themselves a Cleric, as an in-character identification? Is 4 levels enough? 5, 6, 7, etc?

I don't ask this to be ridiculous, I ask because of: RPing a Level 1 Cleric. That is, by Sheet definition, a Cleric. When does the Cleric become a Fighter...when it reaches a Level of 4 Fighter / 3 Cleric? Or is it not until X percentage of the Classes/PrCs???

My point above is that Class/PrC splits are one thing at Level 30, but a totally other thing at Level 1 through X. And THAT is something that determines the Character at their low level existence, right? Or are Levels 10 and below kinda an RP wash, and really shouldn't be invested in much, concerning role-play/development/storyline?

It further begs the question then: do our PCs run around saying "Hi, I am Steve the Tempest!," or "Behold! I am a Blackguard in the Army of Darkness." Again, does the Class make the Character, so defined? Especially related to PrCs, which are far more specific than Fighter/Rogue/Wizard/Cleric (in type). Conversely, can you have 12 levels of Fighter, and NOT call yourself a Fighter?!?

@Negs:
Hidden: show
do you think your "corrections" on my earlier post actually have any benefit to the conversation? Or are you enjoying feeling superior, in the moment...even if you are actually not reading what I wrote clearly, thus responding with interpretation.

Anyway: I wrote d20, not "roll a hard 20 and auto-succeed." So thank you for the unnecessary link to something I already know. As for "do whatever," it was a generalization of attempts, and your exaggeration in response is just plain silly. As for the goalpost comment: you have no blippin' idea about what I am trying to do, so do yourself a favor and stop thinking you know. Okay?

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
Grinning
Posts: 57
Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2015 5:04 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Grinning »

And now we realize why DnD was never meant to be played without a DM :lol:
Mallore
Posts: 458
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2016 3:08 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Mallore »

Pimple wrote:
Mallore wrote:I do not roll Bluff, Diplomacy or the like unless a DM asks, if a player asks me to. Sure I can roll it but I become a bit offset by that, maybe its breaking my game immersion or breaking my wrap on my character.

For starters if I was to roll bluff it gives away my characters intentions, it offers OOC information.
Doesn't this completely ignore the other player's sheet though? Doing nothing to ascertain if the other player's character would see through the lie..?

At about as much strength it ignores my own.

Never will I stop someone on their own rolling a sense motive. Plenty of people have and I'm quick to send them a tell.

Nor do I refuse a players request for rolls. Though I find this has never lead to better role play.

I suppose I come from an age when these things where not skills. You had to think as a player. I also come from an age where you couldn't use these rolls on other pc's and it was only on npcs.

I believe a bit should be on a player but I practice basic curtesy in all my role play. Though it is not my job to remind a player of their own sheet. :). Which is stated in either or both the players hand book or the DMG
Last edited by Mallore on Mon Sep 26, 2016 5:34 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Jane of Here and There (Jane Price)

...also

Jennifer and A Drow.
User avatar
Thorsson
Posts: 1293
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Thorsson »

Kauaiian wrote:For me, dip classes for benefits without proper RP to back it are more irksome. Non worshipping clerics for example.
This shows a certain shallowness. I can easily see ways to RP a dip in Cleric. For instance I was sent to the church at a young age, but never got on with the life and was thrown out for stealing or fighting, or even singing rude ditties.

Now I don't approve of Cleric dips, but that's a mechanical matter.
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by NegInfinity »

Steve wrote:
Hidden: show
do you think your "corrections" on my earlier post actually have any benefit to the conversation?
Hidden: show
I say/write what I think. I expect you to be an adult that can handle that. If you start inventing "reasons" for anything I write, that's not my problem. You're also not obliged to respond to anything. Okay?
User avatar
Kauaiian
Recognized Donor
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:59 am
Location: Europe

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Kauaiian »

Thorsson wrote:
Kauaiian wrote:For me, dip classes for benefits without proper RP to back it are more irksome. Non worshipping clerics for example.
This shows a certain shallowness. I can easily see ways to RP a dip in Cleric. For instance I was sent to the church at a young age, but never got on with the life and was thrown out for stealing or fighting, or even singing rude ditties.

Now I don't approve of Cleric dips, but that's a mechanical matter.
If you stop worshipping shouldnt you stop drawing benefits?
User avatar
Thorsson
Posts: 1293
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Thorsson »

Kauaiian wrote:If you stop worshipping shouldnt you stop drawing benefits?
Who says you stopped worshipping? You stopped being a Cleric, which is not the same thing at all.
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
User avatar
Pimple
Recognized Donor
Posts: 1062
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2016 5:07 pm
Location: CET (Discord: Pimple)

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Pimple »

Mallore wrote:You had to think as a player.
Seriously? Yea... nevermind.
"They're just furry and misunderstood."
"Is that why you are killing them?"
"Yes. They will atone in death."
"Ah. That will help them understand."


Sirion Te'dwa - Shop
User avatar
Kauaiian
Recognized Donor
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:59 am
Location: Europe

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Kauaiian »

Thorsson wrote:
Kauaiian wrote:If you stop worshipping shouldnt you stop drawing benefits?
Who says you stopped worshipping? You stopped being a Cleric, which is not the same thing at all.
Well okay. If you stop being a cleric shouldnt you stop recieving cleric benefits?
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by TheLier »

Thorsson wrote:
Kauaiian wrote:If you stop worshipping shouldnt you stop drawing benefits?
Who says you stopped worshipping? You stopped being a Cleric, which is not the same thing at all.
Well, you know, just like the "paladin" FS, the non-worshipping "cleric" is a thing too. And this is why I ask for RP enforcement of classes...

But I'm a bloody elitist.
User avatar
sweetlikesplenda
Posts: 875
Joined: Thu Sep 27, 2012 4:16 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by sweetlikesplenda »

To respond to the class dip part:

I personally don't mind if people dip (For one thing, I am not sure why they are dipping. Maybe they dipped in to rogue purely because they can get skill points necessary for a diplomatic/intimidating/taunting/etc type and they are not focused on additional benefits of the class. Who am I to say?), because I know for myself I am not building a Race/Class/Alignment combo, I'm building a character.

I guess, since people have been using RL as an example of skills and how they should work, I personally am not one single way. I'm educated, at times I love being social and at others I enjoy my solitude, I love and play volleyball and play on several teams, I practice a Shaolin style of Kung Fu, I love camping and often go free climbing with friends, I also enjoy reading on my breaks at work, I am religious and practice it, I pick up and learn things quickly, etc. So, what class would I be? I have elements of cleric, fighter, monk, rogue, wizard, Bard, and Ranger, which that isn't counting any PRCs.

I dip partially because I don't feel my PC fits in to a cookie cutter mold of what the class description says and feel he fits several. Also, I feel this game would be very boring if we had only pure or almost completely pure classes for our PCs. Which isn't to say anything against those that do chose to pick pure or mostly pure builds; that is just the way you see our character. But, I think the variety allows for fun possibilities.
Aaron Lyonaler - Favored Soul of The Red Knight, House Lyonaler, Knight of the Radiant Heart, Advisor to Duke Eltan
Bio, Journal

"A proper example is a greater weapon for Good than the sword."
-Aaron Lyonaler
User avatar
Thorsson
Posts: 1293
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Thorsson »

Kauaiian wrote:
Thorsson wrote:
Kauaiian wrote:If you stop worshipping shouldnt you stop drawing benefits?
Who says you stopped worshipping? You stopped being a Cleric, which is not the same thing at all.
Well okay. If you stop being a cleric shouldnt you stop recieving cleric benefits?
If you stop stealing should you receive Rogue benefits? If you stop having fights...

Your horizons are just too narrow; you're cutting yourself off from hordes of roleplay possibilities.

Mind you I rather agree with the Lier - you should certainly believe in your Deity if you are to retain spellcasting, for instance. Why would your Deity grant you spells if you didn't?
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it

Return to “General Discussion”