How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

Grinning wrote:And now we realize why DnD was never meant to be played without a DM :lol:
Ding! :lol:

The dungeon master known as "DM The AI" is a total character sheet meta-gaming prick. Sometimes funny, mostly disappointing.

But at least they are always on the Client!! :lol:

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Kauaiian
Recognized Donor
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:59 am
Location: Europe

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Kauaiian »

Thorsson wrote: If you stop stealing should you receive Rogue benefits? If you stop having fights...

Your horizons are just too narrow; you're cutting yourself off from hordes of roleplay possibilities.

Mind you I rather agree with the Lier - you should certainly believe in your Deity if you are to retain spellcasting, for instance. Why would your Deity grant you spells if you didn't?
Both stealing and fighting arent bestowed upon you by a God though. Domain benefits and spellcasting are, in exchange for being a cleric of that God and worshipping.

I understand the possible RP possibilities, but the discussion here is about mechanics affecting RP which happens quite often from what I see on the builder. Whether youre a fallen cleric, fake cleric, prior cleric or whatever aspect of the spectrum you choose, if you have cleric levels and not RPing as such, shouldnt you stop reason the benefits?
Last edited by Kauaiian on Mon Sep 26, 2016 6:14 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Young Werther
Posts: 863
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 8:42 pm
Location: Azkaban

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Young Werther »

Certain rolls (bluff) open the door for meta-gaming and besides that how do you counter a feinter's super dope 60+ bluff if rolls are all that matter? Don't like. I think a character's personalty and other factors besides would effect how a bluff or even other skills works to a large extent and that require *gasp* situational bonus's to roll. (see needing a DM)

As they say "role play not roll play".
Lockonnow wrote:greatest fear like the movie Hellraiser they show you what you most fear and take a Image of IT
Mallore
Posts: 458
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2016 3:08 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Mallore »

Pimple wrote:
Mallore wrote:You had to think as a player.
Seriously? Yea... nevermind.

Let me clarify just a bit

You had to think as a player. This meaning that you had to consider if your character would know or not. How would it react. Could it believe the Orc or not. It was the ultimate control of ones character, while also sharing in the addition of creating the story.


Things where not left to dice. There was no dice to tell you how to feel. There was just you and your game groups shared story, and how you all felt the result should be. Even if this was not talked about at the table the other players trusted you to make the truest decision to your character.
Jane of Here and There (Jane Price)

...also

Jennifer and A Drow.
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

Kauaiian wrote:... if you have cleric levels and not RPing, shouldnt you stop reason the benefits?
It kinda comes down to the Player, and to the extent they can successfully portray a Character with a religious aspect to them, in the terms that define what a Cleric is.

The point of how a Character could retain the benefits of Domains when not actively being all Cleric-y and shit...I understand it, and again, this is the heart of the discussion: how do the mechanics make or break the role-play?

Being elitist about these issues is good for the individual, but not the group, I would offer. Unless, of course, the group is totally like-minded, which does happen, from time to time, even on BGTSCC.

But there is also a practical limit here: our Characters only progress forward. So, even if we wished to "forget" a mechanical aspect, in our role-play, we can't just "take it off the Sheet," until the RP determines it comes "back to life."

A limitation I imagine would be nearly impossible to fix, in this CRPG, but totally possible, in PnP.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Kauaiian
Recognized Donor
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:59 am
Location: Europe

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Kauaiian »

Steve wrote:
Kauaiian wrote:... if you have cleric levels and not RPing, shouldnt you stop reason the benefits?
It kinda comes down to the Player, and to the extent they can successfully portray a Character with a religious aspect to them, in the terms that define what a Cleric is.

The point of how a Character could retain the benefits of Domains when not actively being all Cleric-y and (#2)...I understand it, and again, this is the heart of the discussion: how do the mechanics make or break the role-play?

Being elitist about these issues is good for the individual, but not the group, I would offer. Unless, of course, the group is totally like-minded, which does happen, from time to time, even on BGTSCC.

But there is also a practical limit here: our Characters only progress forward. So, even if we wished to "forget" a mechanical aspect, in our role-play, we can't just "take it off the Sheet," until the RP determines it comes "back to life."

A limitation I imagine would be nearly impossible to fix, in this CRPG, but totally possible, in PnP.
Oh I completely agree. But you wanted a discussion, so... :lol:
User avatar
Thorsson
Posts: 1293
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Thorsson »

Kauaiian wrote:Both stealing and fighting arent bestowed upon you by a God though. Domain benefits and spellcasting are, in exchange for being a cleric of that God and worshipping.

I understand the possible RP possibilities, but the discussion here is about mechanics affecting RP which happens quite often from what I see on the builder. Whether youre a fallen cleric, fake cleric, prior cleric or whatever aspect of the spectrum you choose, if you have cleric levels and not RPing as such, shouldnt you stop reason the benefits?
There's a lot of difference between a fake Cleric (shouldn't have any powers whatsoever), a fallen Cleric (should have had those powers taken from him and it is within DM's capabilities here on BGTSCC) and a lapsed Cleric. I think lapsed is the one you're looking for.

Deities might well be prepared to put up with a lapsed Cleric as long as you're still a worshipper of theirs (which your sheet says you are). They might not have given up on you; they may feel that a bit of a priest is better than no priest. They might have other plans for you. I could go on...
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

That I did! ;)

It is very interesting to read the personal perspective, and how individuals approach their RP in relation to the mechanics...which is easy to see, can be limiting, but creative within that limitation.

I'm glad it was put out there the aspect of d20 gaming, and that our Character Sheet doesn't so much prohibit attempts or actions, but does dictate to an extent the outcome.

And that the outcome, is part of role-playing, as well.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by aaron22 »

nwn2 and bgtscc does not support pure d20 gaming folk. if that were true than why are many of the skills unusable without at least 1 point of training.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
Side
Posts: 238
Joined: Sun Jun 27, 2010 8:29 pm
Location: Michigan USA

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Side »

How do you make the Character "live," either by the mechanics, or besides them?
In my opinion this is a flawed question. If you chose one over the other you are missing out on a very important aspect of what your character is and could be. Mechanics shows what your character is, where as the life we infuse into our characters show what they want, what they think, and how they feel.

A character sheet will never tell you whether a character wanted to be an actor, even though it can tell you they would have made a bad one. Good RP simply cannot exist without mechanics, and mechanics are meaningless without good RP.

The only sticking point I can think of is when it comes to knowledge. A character sheet can show when someone knows a lot about geography, but it cannot show what they know exactly. On the other side you can learn about geography in RP, but that learning process doesn't directly change your character sheet in any way.

RP and mechanics are two sides of the same coin, but even a coin has it's sides separated. The player has to draw the line somewhere and decide when RP demands a change to the character sheet, when it can exist regardless of the character sheet, and when it should be limited in order to abide by what the character sheet says.

There is no perfect system where the two can coexist perfectly, so we just have to try the best we can.
Passiflora wrote: AS A DROW you will kill DUERGARS for like..... lvl 9 to 25. A DAMN LOT OF DUERGARS.
User avatar
Garn Greymoon
Posts: 288
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 12:19 am

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Garn Greymoon »

For clerics I'm a firm believer if you don't at least follow your deities dogma and portfolio then you should lose access to all your cleric spells and benefits when it's related to divine power and spell casting.

The diety is bestowing that power upon their followers.

On the matter of characters, I like to first envision who a character is throughout the culmination of their experiences. What is the concept?

For instance just because I may wield a dagger doesn't necessarily mean I'm a rogue or if it's a great sword I'm a fighter. What I'm trying to get at is the combination of classes I like to create my own pseudo class.

I.E. Sword Mage

Could be wiz and fighter or a sorcerer and eldritch knight. Maybe bard / paladin

Vabo . . . . . Gnome Druid - The Mushroom Man
Dag . . . . . Gnome Bard - The Twang Fury
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

aaron22 wrote:nwn2 and bgtscc does not support pure d20 gaming folk. if that were true than why are many of the skills unusable without at least 1 point of training.
Yes, you're correct about this. Though I believe the Engine will roll DCs on your PC, in some instances, even if there are no Skill points on the Sheet.

I wonder if this could be mechanically changed with scripting?

However, in DM events, a PC could make a Roll against a DC, or take a 10/20.

But even if this isn't a pure d20 environment, that shouldn't then result in creating the environment that our PCs are incapable of doing something, unless they are invested in X number of Skill points, right? Without Skill Point investment, the PC in question is simple just prone to failure.

Which is kinda a funny idea for RP, actually: the Character that tries over and over again to be diplomatic, but constantly fails at it. :lol:

Again, that gets to my OP: how do Players (individual practice) RP their PCs doing things that are NOT reflected by the mechanics on the Character Sheet?

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Steve »

Side wrote: Good RP simply cannot exist without mechanics, and mechanics are meaningless without good RP.
Define good?!? ;)

But joking aside, how does what you say reflect the current Level of the PC? Some Players like to debate that without achieving full mechanical potential, their full RP potential is thus limited. Or, simply not fun.

Do you think "good RP" can exist at Level 1? For you, Side, when does "good RP" actually get good?

///Apologies for just snipping out this quote, out of all that you wrote...it's only what I had time to respond to.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
taylorstar
Posts: 118
Joined: Thu Dec 15, 2011 2:36 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by taylorstar »

I've RP'd characters claiming they are the best or they are the strongest since level one, at times i have to spin it to make it like a false sense of confidence or even arrogance but as the levels progress it tends to prove it self. So mechanics don't really hold much sway on the characters I play sometimes the abilities I play but I always tend to RP a more expanded version of the character than what the mechanics would portray.

With that said there is only so many times I can play a character that has ended up face down eating dirt after being so easily destroyed in PvP so other peoples use of the mechanics and their understanding of how to make builds (while fair play) simply can very quickly force my RP in a direction I don't really like and I lose interest in the character and game sometimes.

I've played characters that lose or are wimps and aren't meant to win in fights, they are equally fun and entertaining to play for a certain extent until their purpose is served.

On the subject of classes I always tend to pick classes that would represent the character more or their profession and personality, the way they act, do they use a bow or sword? are they noticeable or can they slip it out in the blink of an eye? are they devout in their belief of a deity? All of these represent decisions in how I make my character.
I play Medune I think? maybe? probably? I'm not really certain.
Also Rafio priest of Silverbeard
And Jenny Jango in a party near you, and your buying the ale! *wink*
Step_Mac
Posts: 62
Joined: Thu May 19, 2016 7:19 pm

Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?

Unread post by Step_Mac »

One of the things I really like about this place is how much everyone is on the same page on these things. As such, +1. I personally enjoy RPing incompetence in all the areas a PC has no points.

The only thing I will add is that I like occasionally letting the dice tell me what to do -- this is how I implement the point that many people have made about low skill point PCs still getting to roll a 1d20. It works in reverse too, however. If someone is trying my PC's patience, or he's severely tempted to be a giant jerk, I'll roll Will. It comes out low, well, I bite the bullet even if it means bad things for him.

If he's trying to tell a lie, and getting caught means bad, bad things? I'll roll -- not to impose his skills on someone else, but to keep myself honest. It's my way of taking a deep breath, and saying, "welp, here goes something that's going to hurt. A lot."

Return to “General Discussion”