Kauaiian wrote:... if you have cleric levels and not RPing, shouldnt you stop reason the benefits?
It kinda comes down to the Player, and to the extent they can successfully portray a Character with a religious aspect to them, in the terms that define what a Cleric is.
The point of how a Character could retain the benefits of Domains
when not actively being all Cleric-y and shit...I understand it, and again, this is the heart of the discussion: how do the mechanics make or break the role-play?
Being elitist about these issues is good for the individual, but not the group, I would offer. Unless, of course, the group is totally like-minded, which does happen, from time to time, even on BGTSCC.
But there is also a practical limit here: our Characters only progress forward. So, even if we wished to "forget" a mechanical aspect, in our role-play, we can't just "take it off the Sheet," until the RP determines it comes "back to life."
A limitation I imagine would be nearly impossible to fix, in this CRPG, but totally possible, in PnP.