I've done that on occasion to, mostly where I'm not sure how my character would react. The resultant roll is then used in some way to inform future actions as well...Step_Mac wrote:The only thing I will add is that I like occasionally letting the dice tell me what to do -- this is how I implement the point that many people have made about low skill point PCs still getting to roll a 1d20. It works in reverse too, however. If someone is trying my PC's patience, or he's severely tempted to be a giant jerk, I'll roll Will. It comes out low, well, I bite the bullet even if it means bad things for him.
How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
Thorsson
- Posts: 1293
- Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
-
Thorsson
- Posts: 1293
- Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
Is anyone disagreeing with this at heart?Garn Greymoon wrote:For clerics I'm a firm believer if you don't at least follow your deities dogma and portfolio then you should lose access to all your cleric spells and benefits when it's related to divine power and spell casting.
Wasn't this one of the main points about how Clerics have been changed on BGTSCC? At one point DMs might take away your powers; I can understand why that has fallen out of favour, but still, it has a point.
The practical problem is one of enforcement, but if most people voluntarily accept it, then maybe that's not so much of a problem. My voluntary adherence to the principle is the reason my Dwarven Defender won't be "doing a Karond" and getting 3 Cleric levels.
At the risk of de-railing the thread (so please don't bite too hard), I'd prefer that Favored Soul description was also changed such that the RP was more restricted still.
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
-
Side
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Sun Jun 27, 2010 8:29 pm
- Location: Michigan USA
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
To me all it takes for good RP is for someone to try. I mean really try. It doesn't have to be detailed, or even memorable, but so long as you give it your all it's good. We all have met someone who's RP was just an afterthought...Steve wrote:Define good?!?Side wrote: Good RP simply cannot exist without mechanics, and mechanics are meaningless without good RP.![]()
But joking aside, how does what you say reflect the current Level of the PC? Some Players like to debate that without achieving full mechanical potential, their full RP potential is thus limited. Or, simply not fun.
Do you think "good RP" can exist at Level 1? For you, Side, when does "good RP" actually get good?
///Apologies for just snipping out this quote, out of all that you wrote...it's only what I had time to respond to.
For how it reflects on current PC level I think it is best summed up with an analogy of a house. The mechanics are your foundation. They are pretty much set in stone (ignoring RCR). You can expand upon it with level ups, but it's really not going to change a whole lot outside of the plan you have made. Sometimes you can change your plan and build a new addition, or cancel something you were working on, but at the end of the day it's just a foundation.
RP is the house itself. It grows and changes far more rapidly than the foundation. Sometimes the inside changes, sometimes just the outside, but it can exist in a near constant state of change. The structure of the house itself doesn't usually change much (character identity, background, and so on) even though it can, but the smaller details come and go fairly quick.
Usually a house is built to fit it's foundation. A small house requires a small foundation, and a large house requires a large foundation. You can build a small house on a large foundation if you want to, but you're going to get some strange looks.
That said, there is a limit to how large of a house you can build on any given foundation. You simply cannot build a mansion on a 20 square foot foundation. You can plan out the mansion and slowly build upon the foundation and house until you get there, but you can't just put up a mansion without a foundation that will support it.
To put it simply a level 1 can have great RP, but there is only so much they can reasonably achieve and still be level 1. By the time you put in the effort to achieve something impressive you would have likely leveled up at least once. There's a reason the number that describes mechanical growth is called experience after all.
Technically this does mean you can't reach "full RP potential" until you hit level 30, but does that really matter? By the time you hit level 20 you're already locked into your classes. By 25 you have most of the feats you're ever going to have, and by 29 you really shouldn't care anymore. +1 AB (depending on class) and a few skill points isn't going to make or break your RP, where as a level 1 could easily be broken if he gets in over his head.
All that really matters here is where each player draws their line. For my drow weapon master that line is at level 25. When I hit 25 she will have everything she needs to RP the role I want her to fill. Sure she gets more mechanical strength in the next five levels, and there's a few role play focused feats after that too, but she doesn't need all of that. Once she hits 25, and barring any RP that changes her plans, she will have everything she needs. Until then she will be RPing the journey that leads her to that goal. I'll gladly go into more detail in a PM if anyone wants that, but I think this is enough for one post.
Passiflora wrote: AS A DROW you will kill DUERGARS for like..... lvl 9 to 25. A DAMN LOT OF DUERGARS.
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
a lot... sometimes in amazing ways, and sometimes in frustrating ways. :/How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
I know that this thread is focused on our server, and how the mechanics affect rp, and I will try to get to sharin my experiences on this server, but to really talk about those experiences, I think maybe I should talk about how I see role playing in general.
Several years ago, goddess has it been ten already?, I used to be involved a little in the Indie RP scene.
we talked a lot about rpg theory and design, and we asked questions about what is fun, what is frustrating, and big questions about 'why' some things that seem to be good ideas, sometimes don't work out very well.
well, some people came up with ideas and some insights , and as we talked (and sometimes argued!) about these ideas, some of them started coalescing and evolving.
and though some of the ideas were controversial, and I was resistant at first, these discussions profoundly changed how I saw roleplaying, and how I played in and ran rp games, and I think it really helped me (although some may disagree
now this was years ago, and I'm not as up to date on what some the current thoughts are, but one of the game designers that I really respect is Ron Edwards, who wrote an article a quite a while ago that I think applies to this thread, "System Does Matter"
http://www.indie-rpgs.com/_articles/sys ... atter.html
also, here's a link to a list of articles that I think are really useful
http://www.indie-rpgs.com/articles/
anyway, I'm on my phone and there is soooo much more that I'd like to say, so ill try to organize and share my thoughts about how things work (and don't) on our server.
((hug))
~Grymhild
Last edited by grymhild on Tue Sep 27, 2016 6:39 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Drathyrra [perma-dead]
Gilia Glandertor [inactive]
Grimhildr Ulvsdatter [active]
Iradortha "Iri" Umbrynthal [inactive]
Jhasina Harika yr Nar'ysra el Ifrit Khalid yi Memnon [active]
Lanathalas [retired]
Mhaev of Cathyr [retired]
Nevaetriel Rilae'ar'an, Kerym'quaress ath Eilistraee [jounal] [It's complicated]
N'essa [perma-dead]
Shaytessa Umbrynthal [bio] [journal] [???]
Shryl [retired]
Sssiks [active]
Ssinyrr [bio] [active]
Hathran Tatyana [active]
Vierdra Zau'afin [inactive]
Gilia Glandertor [inactive]
Grimhildr Ulvsdatter [active]
Iradortha "Iri" Umbrynthal [inactive]
Jhasina Harika yr Nar'ysra el Ifrit Khalid yi Memnon [active]
Lanathalas [retired]
Mhaev of Cathyr [retired]
Nevaetriel Rilae'ar'an, Kerym'quaress ath Eilistraee [jounal] [It's complicated]
N'essa [perma-dead]
Shaytessa Umbrynthal [bio] [journal] [???]
Shryl [retired]
Sssiks [active]
Ssinyrr [bio] [active]
Hathran Tatyana [active]
Vierdra Zau'afin [inactive]
-
Clockwork
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 4:08 pm
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
Whenever I see a discussion of this nature, I always like to link this.
There's a lot you can take away from that blogpost, but the key thing is this: when you can confidently match or exceed most human achievements by level 5, then player characters can be awesome even at low levels. By this measurement, even just a handful of ranks spread across various skills represents significant investment. Characters don't have to have 20+ skills or epic levels to be capable of or achieve anything.
There's a lot you can take away from that blogpost, but the key thing is this: when you can confidently match or exceed most human achievements by level 5, then player characters can be awesome even at low levels. By this measurement, even just a handful of ranks spread across various skills represents significant investment. Characters don't have to have 20+ skills or epic levels to be capable of or achieve anything.
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
unless DMs set DCs for sneaking past guards at DC 70, or bluffing a Drow matron at DC 75... etc. (both of those examples btw are from real play on bgtscc)Clockwork wrote:Whenever I see a discussion of this nature, I always like to link this.
There's a lot you can take away from that blogpost, but the key thing is this: when you can confidently match or exceed most human achievements by level 5, then player characters can be awesome even at low levels. By this measurement, even just a handful of ranks spread across various skills represents significant investment. Characters don't have to have 20+ skills or epic levels to be capable of or achieve anything.
:/
-
Clockwork
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 4:08 pm
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
Well, don't know the context but it's DM fiat to say if something is impossible. Equally, players are allowed to succeed.
I wouldn't read too much into it though. When I've used the DM client in the past I've often picked DCs at random if I want to obfuscate the difficulty for whatever reason.
I wouldn't read too much into it though. When I've used the DM client in the past I've often picked DCs at random if I want to obfuscate the difficulty for whatever reason.
-
Steve
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 8197
- Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
- Location: Paradise in GMT +1
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
It is a very interesting blogpost, thank you for sharing.Clockwork wrote:... when you can confidently match or exceed most human achievements by level 5, then player characters can be awesome even at low levels. By this measurement, even just a handful of ranks spread across various skills represents significant investment. Characters don't have to have 20+ skills or epic levels to be capable of or achieve anything.
I think the obvious difficulty here is when the game sandbox is of a range such that we see on BGTSCC, the Level 1 through 30 range. If Level 1–5 is human, and beyond 5 is superhuman...level 30 is almost beyond God like! No wonder so many Players rush to get there! lol.
But even if we apply the half-upheld idea that on BGTSCC, levels of a PC are considered halved when comparing to NPCs/mobs, then still, a Level 15 PC is not just 3x more powerful than the utmost of RL human comparison of Level 5, but exponentially more powerful.
I actually think that is something beyond a capability to role-play!
Jon Smythe - The Book of....
Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant
Sabross N'azza - Working...
Khelboros Wyrmstone
-
grymhild
- Recognized Donor
- Posts: 585
- Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 3:58 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
I believe dm fiat should be used with extreme caution, to avoid metagaming, railroading and deprotagonizing the players and their characters, or making arbitrary and inconsistent rulings in order for the dm to achieve a predetermined outcome.
I believe that one the primary roles of a DM is to provide a consistent and believable (within the context of the setting) simulated world for the PCs to act in.
if the town guards are mostly soldiers with in game terms, 1-3 levels in warrior, then their spot and listen, which are cross-class skills should be at most 2-8 (and that upper range is only if they have exceptional wisdom scores and or skill focus feats... ). so the passive DC to sneak past a guard should be about DC 12-18.
throw in a few situational modifiers (which btw should sometimes also help the PCs and not just hurt them) and you might get a DC of 15-25.
in theory, PCs should have the same DC of sneaking past them no matter what their (the PC's) level is
of course this all breaks down when you have min-maxed epic PCs, and plentiful magical gear and spell bonuses stacking - that shouldn't stack in the first place, resulting in a Red Queen's Dilemma. :/
I believe that one the primary roles of a DM is to provide a consistent and believable (within the context of the setting) simulated world for the PCs to act in.
if the town guards are mostly soldiers with in game terms, 1-3 levels in warrior, then their spot and listen, which are cross-class skills should be at most 2-8 (and that upper range is only if they have exceptional wisdom scores and or skill focus feats... ). so the passive DC to sneak past a guard should be about DC 12-18.
throw in a few situational modifiers (which btw should sometimes also help the PCs and not just hurt them) and you might get a DC of 15-25.
in theory, PCs should have the same DC of sneaking past them no matter what their (the PC's) level is
of course this all breaks down when you have min-maxed epic PCs, and plentiful magical gear and spell bonuses stacking - that shouldn't stack in the first place, resulting in a Red Queen's Dilemma. :/
-
TheLier
- Posts: 388
- Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
grymhild wrote:I believe dm fiat should be used with extreme caution, to avoid metagaming, railroading and deprotagonizing the players and their characters, or making arbitrary and inconsistent rulings in order for the dm to achieve a predetermined outcome.
I believe that one the primary roles of a DM is to provide a consistent and believable (within the context of the setting) simulated world for the PCs to act in.
if the town guards are mostly soldiers with in game terms, 1-3 levels in warrior, then their spot and listen, which are cross-class skills should be at most 2-8 (and that upper range is only if they have exceptional wisdom scores and or skill focus feats... ). so the passive DC to sneak past a guard should be about DC 12-18.
throw in a few situational modifiers (which btw should sometimes also help the PCs and not just hurt them) and you might get a DC of 15-25.
in theory, PCs should have the same DC of sneaking past them no matter what their (the PC's) level is
of course this all breaks down when you have min-maxed epic PCs, and plentiful magical gear and spell bonuses stacking - that shouldn't stack in the first place, resulting in a Red Queen's Dilemma. :/
DnD falls apart after like, level 15. Skills inflate, toons become demigods. Pretty much little can stop them.
So, as DMs in my experience railroad here a lot, you can expect impossible, or near impossible DCs, as a good bluffer, has a maxed bluff with all bonuses. You can call it an arms race. Anything less then maxed, means you are not good enough. And as there is no RP enforcement or such, I don't expect that to change.
-
NegInfinity
- Posts: 2449
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
With (player's) skill, gear, some planning maybe coupled with thorough knowledge of in-game mechanics, a low level character can occasionally take out threats 10 levels above theirs. Level 12 can defeat level 24, occasionally, especially if level 24 gets overconfident.Clockwork wrote:Whenever I see a discussion of this nature, I always like to link this.
There's a lot you can take away from that blogpost, but the key thing is this: when you can confidently match or exceed most human achievements by level 5, then player characters can be awesome even at low levels. By this measurement, even just a handful of ranks spread across various skills represents significant investment. Characters don't have to have 20+ skills or epic levels to be capable of or achieve anything.
However, there's a limit to this, and there are characters that NEED high skills or specific levels to be capable of achieving something specific (without godmoding and breaking "play your sheet" rule).
-
Clockwork
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 4:08 pm
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
Yes that's a tricky one and I'm not sure what the solution is. I don't think that DnD was really designed to accommodate more than half a dozen high level PCs under DM supervision in the world at anyone time.Steve wrote:It is a very interesting blogpost, thank you for sharing.Clockwork wrote:... when you can confidently match or exceed most human achievements by level 5, then player characters can be awesome even at low levels. By this measurement, even just a handful of ranks spread across various skills represents significant investment. Characters don't have to have 20+ skills or epic levels to be capable of or achieve anything.
I think the obvious difficulty here is when the game sandbox is of a range such that we see on BGTSCC, the Level 1 through 30 range. If Level 1–5 is human, and beyond 5 is superhuman...level 30 is almost beyond God like! No wonder so many Players rush to get there! lol.
But even if we apply the half-upheld idea that on BGTSCC, levels of a PC are considered halved when comparing to NPCs/mobs, then still, a Level 15 PC is not just 3x more powerful than the utmost of RL human comparison of Level 5, but exponentially more powerful.
I actually think that is something beyond a capability to role-play!Though we may try.
Either accept that there are dozens of virtual demigods hanging around and adjust accordingly, with all the RP implications that entails, which is by the letter of DnD rules. Or some form of dissonance is required to hand wave it into a nonissue (ie everything is relative).
-
NegInfinity
- Posts: 2449
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
The demi-god argument pops up from time to time, and as far as I can tell the only thing to do is to accept that server world is different from the one in pnp. Basically, here you can have level 30 city guard, and level 1..5 is no longer a "normal human". Well, maybe 1..5 is a normal human, but extremely powerful people are not unheard of.Clockwork wrote:Yes that's a tricky one and I'm not sure what the solution is. I don't think that DnD was really designed to accommodate more than half a dozen high level PCs under DM supervision in the world at anyone time.Steve wrote:It is a very interesting blogpost, thank you for sharing.Clockwork wrote:... when you can confidently match or exceed most human achievements by level 5, then player characters can be awesome even at low levels. By this measurement, even just a handful of ranks spread across various skills represents significant investment. Characters don't have to have 20+ skills or epic levels to be capable of or achieve anything.
I think the obvious difficulty here is when the game sandbox is of a range such that we see on BGTSCC, the Level 1 through 30 range. If Level 1–5 is human, and beyond 5 is superhuman...level 30 is almost beyond God like! No wonder so many Players rush to get there! lol.
But even if we apply the half-upheld idea that on BGTSCC, levels of a PC are considered halved when comparing to NPCs/mobs, then still, a Level 15 PC is not just 3x more powerful than the utmost of RL human comparison of Level 5, but exponentially more powerful.
I actually think that is something beyond a capability to role-play!Though we may try.
Either accept that there are dozens of virtual demigods hanging around and adjust accordingly, with all the RP implications that entails, which is by the letter of DnD rules. Or some form of dissonance is required to hand wave it into a nonissue (ie everything is relative).
You could think of it as some sort of "reflection" or "alternative version" of faerun. "Magical alternative version" also explains time-travelling shenanigans that routinely happen when someone manages to travel 20 miles without time actually advancing in the world.
-
Clockwork
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 4:08 pm
Re: How Much Does Mechanics Affect Your Role-play?
Well, it's not mutually exclusive. We just calibrate our expectations for a world where level 30 guards are common, and all the implications from that ("demigods are common"). Perhaps the guard is a former adventurer who took the proverbial arrow to a knee and retired.
Or realise that it's a game with abstractions, and that level 30 guard is a stand in for the body and authority of the whole watch, who can't be represented fully in game.
(As an aside, I'm not sure why a guard needs to be level 30, because, by dnd rules, he's practically a god. If it's to give the players a challenge, well, there's other ways to do that aside from deifed guards).
The travel thing is easy. All travel is at the Speed of Plot.
Or realise that it's a game with abstractions, and that level 30 guard is a stand in for the body and authority of the whole watch, who can't be represented fully in game.
(As an aside, I'm not sure why a guard needs to be level 30, because, by dnd rules, he's practically a god. If it's to give the players a challenge, well, there's other ways to do that aside from deifed guards).
The travel thing is easy. All travel is at the Speed of Plot.