So I was just reading a recent suggestion about improving the Weapon Master class. I loved the idea, but a small discussion started in it that touched on the RP of having Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker together. We're no longer allowed to hijack a suggestion thread with a discussion/argument (thank goodness) so I was going to leave it alone.
But if there's one thing that gets me going it's this topic right here.
So here's my take on the two classes. (My opinion on what the classes mean. Some things might not be entirely accurate to PnP or NWN2.)
Weapon Masters are just that. They are masters of their chosen weapon, and work to make it an extension of their body. They use their weapon as if it just a part of their arm; effortlessly and without required thought.
There is nothing inherently lawful about this. Self discipline extends across all alignments. If being lawful was a requirement I see no reason for the drow to have so many weapon masters. Sure the drow are not always chaotic, but it would be quite the coincidence for every single one of their weapon masters is also lawful.
Frenzied Berserker, on the other hand, is all about the thrill of battle. They want to lose themselves in that feeling of excitement, and in PnP they become so involved in that feeling they no longer care about who is a friend and who isn't. Every target is equally good.
When a Frenzied Berserker is in a Frenzy they don't magically forget how to fight properly. They fight about as well as they always have, if not better. They know how to use their weapon just as well as they did before the fighting started. Nothing chaotic about it, they are just extreme adrenaline junkies who pay more attention to fighting than to who they are fighting when that high comes along.
So what about these two classes is incompatible? What makes it so they cannot interact perfectly well with one another? Even if a Frenzy did make someone lose all control the goal of a Weapon Master is to learn to use their weapon without thought. On top of this why exactly is Barbarian allowed to take levels of Weapon Master? The description of Rage makes it seem far more detrimental to a Weapon Master than the description of Frenzy, even though the whole "without thought" thing covers that too.
I've seen posts about this on the forums of other servers and their logic made absolutely no sense to me. It's one of the reasons I never stuck around to see how I liked them and came back to btgscc. There doesn't appear to be any reason these two classes cannot work together outside of balance concerns, and no one seems to want to call it on that alone. At least this server will outright say "X class combo is too strong together" and leave it at that. No need to try and justify it.
Am I missing some key detail that ties it all together? I can't quite figure out whether I'm legitimately missing something or if it's just faulty reasoning people keep using. As someone who has spent a lot of time trying to properly role play both of these classes together it's an issue that's dear to my heart, so if I'm in the wrong on this one I really want to know.
Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
Moderators: Moderator, DM
-
Side
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Sun Jun 27, 2010 8:29 pm
- Location: Michigan USA
Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
Passiflora wrote: AS A DROW you will kill DUERGARS for like..... lvl 9 to 25. A DAMN LOT OF DUERGARS.
-
Eclypticon
- Posts: 1009
- Joined: Mon May 30, 2011 7:26 pm
- Location: USA
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
That is a well articulated argument. Thanks for sharing it.
I think some people draw a correlation between the monk and the weapon master. There is a level of discipline in both classes. Monk is a lawful class, and thus, weapon masters aught to be. I'm sure there are other reasons too.
Congrats on your 100th post!
I think some people draw a correlation between the monk and the weapon master. There is a level of discipline in both classes. Monk is a lawful class, and thus, weapon masters aught to be. I'm sure there are other reasons too.
Congrats on your 100th post!
-
Tantive
- Posts: 1100
- Joined: Thu Dec 03, 2015 10:40 am
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
Though the monk's discipline is more then its art, it is in the code they live their lives. Different for each sect ofcourse but they follow a code which is where the lawful comes in from.
If we for the moment take historical examples of berserkers, they could be bodyguards to royal and noble courts. Their frenzying would be more of a trancelike state where they induce themselves into a self made madness. Even possibly induced with ingested drugs of sort. In that stage though, they act like shock troops, but that doesn't mean they always are. If you are going to be swinging instinctively without a sane mind, you have to have some great control over your weapon or you get cut down first.
If we for the moment take historical examples of berserkers, they could be bodyguards to royal and noble courts. Their frenzying would be more of a trancelike state where they induce themselves into a self made madness. Even possibly induced with ingested drugs of sort. In that stage though, they act like shock troops, but that doesn't mean they always are. If you are going to be swinging instinctively without a sane mind, you have to have some great control over your weapon or you get cut down first.
Elyssa Symbaern - Bladesinger
Isioviel Fereyn - Elven Ranger
Charisa Flomeigne - Scion of Siamorphe
Isioviel Fereyn - Elven Ranger
Charisa Flomeigne - Scion of Siamorphe
-
NegInfinity
- Posts: 2449
- Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
There's nothing incompatible. Not sure if there's anything to discuss.Side wrote: So what about these two classes is incompatible?
If we were talking about something like Man At Arms Frenzied Berserker, some sort of "Knight" class, or Berserker Monks, that would be a different deal.
Weapon Masters are not lawful. Mastery could be achieved through rigorous training and warriors code, but it could also be achieved through using the weapon a LOT.
-
AC81
- Posts: 934
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:58 am
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
Weapon masters and frenzied berserkers should be allowed as a class combination.
RP aspect:
We have a world of dragons, magic, extra-planar beings and gods walking the world. Why is it a stretch to think that a swordsman could master two different ways of fighting, or three, or four different styles? Nowhere does it say a weapon master must be lawful. This is people reading too much into the class description.
Mechanical aspect:
From a mechanical power perspective, this class is no longer even close to one of the strongest build combo's. There are many hard counters to this combo, it's a one-trick pony. Also, we've had nerf's in place on the server to directly affect this combo. Slashing resistance, damage % immunity for no reason, crit immune bosses for no reason. Next comes the UMD/CL fix and basically all melees drop to the bottom of the food chain (except the Dwarven Defenders which curiously no-one seems willing to open up a discussion about). If we as a community decide we want to ban this combo, I think we need to start trimming the top of the tree first (FS's, Druid's, Bard's, certain Wizard prc's)
I'm not sure why there is a sudden push to ban/nerf a variety of things in this pw. Are we suddenly all dissatisfied with our own PC's performance and thus start looking at reducing the fun of others?
RP aspect:
We have a world of dragons, magic, extra-planar beings and gods walking the world. Why is it a stretch to think that a swordsman could master two different ways of fighting, or three, or four different styles? Nowhere does it say a weapon master must be lawful. This is people reading too much into the class description.
Mechanical aspect:
From a mechanical power perspective, this class is no longer even close to one of the strongest build combo's. There are many hard counters to this combo, it's a one-trick pony. Also, we've had nerf's in place on the server to directly affect this combo. Slashing resistance, damage % immunity for no reason, crit immune bosses for no reason. Next comes the UMD/CL fix and basically all melees drop to the bottom of the food chain (except the Dwarven Defenders which curiously no-one seems willing to open up a discussion about). If we as a community decide we want to ban this combo, I think we need to start trimming the top of the tree first (FS's, Druid's, Bard's, certain Wizard prc's)
I'm not sure why there is a sudden push to ban/nerf a variety of things in this pw. Are we suddenly all dissatisfied with our own PC's performance and thus start looking at reducing the fun of others?
Draviir - Luskanite mercenary and trader of exquisite goods.
Quinath Nar - Monastic warrior from Waterdeep
Quinath Nar - Monastic warrior from Waterdeep
-
Storm Munin
- Posts: 1355
- Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:03 am
- Location: Sweden, Alfheimar expat
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
Being seriously pissed off has no correlation to a major loss of tactile ability afaik.
Especially since muscle memory has nothing to do with emotion.
Train at something to be accomplished without thought for long enough and it will become an instinctual action set off by a perceptual/mental trigger. No thought attached.
It is something that are not easy to untrain by the way.
Salvatore has it down right with the Hunter perspective on Drizzit the drow pony imho.
The excuse there being a barbarian 1 dip for rage.
Weaponmaster and frenzied berserker should and do work fine together.
No, I dont drive one.
Edit:
Lets not confuse the House title of Weaponmaster with the class of Weapon Master, a Weaponmaster may very well be a Weapon Master but it would in no way be mandatory.
Since a Weaponmasters job description is to train recruits with whatever weapon they have the best talent with correlating with the needs of the House (drill master).
Meanwhile a Weapon Master is an individual personally focused on fighting with one type of weaponry (sniper).
Especially since muscle memory has nothing to do with emotion.
Train at something to be accomplished without thought for long enough and it will become an instinctual action set off by a perceptual/mental trigger. No thought attached.
It is something that are not easy to untrain by the way.
Salvatore has it down right with the Hunter perspective on Drizzit the drow pony imho.
The excuse there being a barbarian 1 dip for rage.
Weaponmaster and frenzied berserker should and do work fine together.
No, I dont drive one.
Edit:
Lets not confuse the House title of Weaponmaster with the class of Weapon Master, a Weaponmaster may very well be a Weapon Master but it would in no way be mandatory.
Since a Weaponmasters job description is to train recruits with whatever weapon they have the best talent with correlating with the needs of the House (drill master).
Meanwhile a Weapon Master is an individual personally focused on fighting with one type of weaponry (sniper).
"Drojal zhah obdoluth dorb'd streeak, Lueth dro zhah zhaunau dorb'd ogglin."
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.
PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.
PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.
-
Moltrazahn
- Posts: 915
- Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:33 am
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
Also... what inspires more terror than some large burly redhead going "Hi.. my names John. .. I'm a frenzied weapon-master troll-lodge beserker". Besides. As already mentioned. In a world where you got dragon's. Elves. Giant worms with maws big enough to swallow you whole...even a bloodthirsty rage-induced barbarian will eventually learn a trick or two when welding his/her favorite object for killing. It just become instinct after enough practice.
Za'than Za'amal(Elsewhere!)
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)
Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"
"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
Thumbler Trunk-son(Also Elsewhere!)
Inanis Umbra(Active)
Molag'ur(He stink!)
Myhun Kren: "You should change Za'thans mask to green, and run around yelling "Somebody STOP ME!"
"You are a spastic pony" - HDM Arrakeen
-
Storm Munin
- Posts: 1355
- Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:03 am
- Location: Sweden, Alfheimar expat
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
A tiny bearded man in a horned leather cap claiming the name of Tim the sorcerer while leveling hilltops with his wand?
Any woman in a bride gown when you are the groom?
Any woman in a bride gown when you are the groom?
"Drojal zhah obdoluth dorb'd streeak, Lueth dro zhah zhaunau dorb'd ogglin."
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.
PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.
PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.
-
Blackman D
- Retired Staff
- Posts: 4818
- Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 5:43 am
- Location: IL
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
i do have one, tho my post in the other thread was made more from experience than a bias to keep the combo
it is a glass cannon, a high damage melee fighting style, it does great damage output but has horrible defense and depending on your items and the weapon you use it is heavily reliant on magic for survival, something it doesnt even have easy access to - it definitely is a one trick pony
my fighter was originally 12 F / 7 WM / 3 SD / 8 BG, halberd WM with +8 str, damaged topped out around 150, back in the day this was really good but also back in the day the content wasnt nearly as hard
then we started getting mobs with more hp and hit a lot harder, not to mention all the anti magic stuff so even if you did use UMD for extra AC you were in the same boat as any other caster with dispels and breach, particularly breach since it will strip all of your AC
obviously the usefulness of my high damage dealing fighter was going down and it actually wasnt till the SD nerf that the opportunity to redo him came up because of the limited time 100% rebuilds for SD
he did rp the SD/BG part but the core of his rp is simply around the fact that he is a halberd WM, the F/WM part so when i got the chance to redo him he kept 12 F / 7 WM and picked up 5 FB for more damage and 6 DC for saves and a bit of a rp conversation from a BG to a DC
even with this tho its not like it suddenly became unstoppable, damage increased to 220, but the fact that he is a two handed weapon user and thus has horribly low AC still makes him a glass cannon, but at least a cannon that could keep up with the content if he was in a party, didnt really need the AC or heals, just other people to share the hits
it is a strong combination but it also has limitations
it is a glass cannon, a high damage melee fighting style, it does great damage output but has horrible defense and depending on your items and the weapon you use it is heavily reliant on magic for survival, something it doesnt even have easy access to - it definitely is a one trick pony
my fighter was originally 12 F / 7 WM / 3 SD / 8 BG, halberd WM with +8 str, damaged topped out around 150, back in the day this was really good but also back in the day the content wasnt nearly as hard
then we started getting mobs with more hp and hit a lot harder, not to mention all the anti magic stuff so even if you did use UMD for extra AC you were in the same boat as any other caster with dispels and breach, particularly breach since it will strip all of your AC
obviously the usefulness of my high damage dealing fighter was going down and it actually wasnt till the SD nerf that the opportunity to redo him came up because of the limited time 100% rebuilds for SD
he did rp the SD/BG part but the core of his rp is simply around the fact that he is a halberd WM, the F/WM part so when i got the chance to redo him he kept 12 F / 7 WM and picked up 5 FB for more damage and 6 DC for saves and a bit of a rp conversation from a BG to a DC
even with this tho its not like it suddenly became unstoppable, damage increased to 220, but the fact that he is a two handed weapon user and thus has horribly low AC still makes him a glass cannon, but at least a cannon that could keep up with the content if he was in a party, didnt really need the AC or heals, just other people to share the hits
it is a strong combination but it also has limitations
everyone is evil till proven otherwise
-
Side
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Sun Jun 27, 2010 8:29 pm
- Location: Michigan USA
Re: Weapon Master and Frenzied Berserker
Thanks for the replies everyone, you've helped set my mind at ease.
Passiflora wrote: AS A DROW you will kill DUERGARS for like..... lvl 9 to 25. A DAMN LOT OF DUERGARS.