


Moderators: Moderator, DM











The Way of the Blade
Scroll 1: Knowing your mentor and opponent
If you seek out instruction in martial, or the two-handed fighting arts there are several considerations to appraise before committing to studying with them:
Do they have a clear study approach and identifiable methodology?
Does their understanding come from years of private effort, or the recent collections of other novices?
Do they have an actual program of drills and exercises with proven results?
Have they any actual accomplishments or achievements in this craft?
Does physical conditioning and martial intent come across in their displays?
Do they convey maturity and sincerity in their efforts?
Do they exhibit concern with high standards, or more with artificial competitions and living-history escapism?
Do their activities seem focused more on a historical combat discipline or a modern combat sport?
Do they have demonstrable skill and experience in self-defence teachings?
Is their background in the authentic demonstration of this material, or is it derived from other styles such as sport fencing credentials or stage-combat theory?
Do they promote a sense of camaraderie, ethical conduct, and scholarship, or do they seem commercial, theatrical, sportified, or amateurish?
Is their curriculum run by committee or is someone competent in authority?
And lastly, do they seem to need you more than you need them?
These are important matters that at their heart are issues of character and motive as much as method and goal. Throughout history experienced martial artists of all styles discovered that, in the long run such factors, which might seem to have nothing to do with learning to fight, in fact, have everything to do with the kind of fighter you become. Every student of the martial arts must live with the real consequences of how they train, and with whom they train, not the good intentions of either.
Lastly, there is something else to consider when acquiring practice partners. Finding opponents who equally match one’s particular level of ability can be difficult. Quite often they are either noticeably superior or inferior. Though one may practice with individuals with whom you are better than and can readily outperform, it is important not to allow yourself to become lax. Resist the feeling to fight softer or to quit trying in an effort to somehow make things "more interesting and challenging." This attitude not only does a disservice to your true skills, but also to your sparring partner by not offering them an honest test. Practice like this surely leads to bad habits and weakens one’s edge. This is not to say that when facing those you are truly superior to that one should always crush and overwhelm them. Not at all. For in those cases, you obviously need to teach and instruct without diminishing an individual or breaking their spirit. On the other hand, if one faces partners against whom you are soundly beaten, one must avoid the urge to view it entirely in terms of simply something we failed to do or entirely in terms of something the opponent did. This is not useful for growth as a student of the art. Victory or defeat is always a matter of that which we do or fail to do, in combination with that which an adversary did or failed to do. Sometimes the two are indistinguishable. Seek partners who share the same motivations, objectives, and values in the craft. If you share the same values and objectives, then you will find a matching approach and method. It will then be all the easier to learn together.



















