Empoweredfan wrote:No reason for law abiding citizen to fear the wrath of criminals right by the best fortified tavern for miles around, ruled over by a powerful mage. It isn't about rules. It's about common sense.
A person ALWAYS, regardless of location, has to fear the wrath of criminals, just turn on the news. And while there may be punishments for criminal acts, both in game and in the real world, when has that ever stopped them from occurring? The issue, it seems here, is that by calling people to use "common sense" you will always end up with people that land on different outcomes. As you said, your feelings towards PVP has been shaped by our experiences with it, and that holds true for all of us. With that in mind everyone's "common sense" or their expectations of what might occur, are colored by their past experiences. This is the reason for a difference of opinion on what should be expected in this area, because "common" sense isn't often a "common" thought shared between people of different backgrounds (similar to how it si common sense to tip wait staff here in the US, but not in other countries).
What a rules review would accomplish is taking into account the desires of the community and staff to establish a clear set of expectations. And despite several DMs chiming in with the rules and what they say, there is STILL discussion, which tells me that there is still room for a difference in interpretation. If we can take strides to lessen the chance that tw people will read the same rules and come to different conclusions, then we are taking strides to avoid these sorts of things in the future, and THAT is what is being asked for (at least by me, as I speak only for myself).
So when I gave that example, and I make the arguments I did above, I didn't do so in an attempt to convince you that you are wrong, but rather to point out that there is another side to this and that it isn't quite as black and white as we might like it to be. Both sides can be different and both can be valid, but rules can't do that. Rules have to be written in a way that expresses their desired intent as clearly as possible, that gives us all a guideline on which to base our actions despite any differences of opinion that were almost certainly learned by a difference in experiences.
There is currently a discussion going on about the expectations of PC behavior in Soubar as well, that discussion doesn't exist solely because there are no NPC guards there and therefore the rules say PVP is ok. They exist because of the culmination of experiences with different DMs enforing different things in the confines of Soubar added to that fact that the rules say PVP is prohibited only on maps where guards are present. The result of all of that is a number of DM/Player interactions in which no one wins, no one feels good about it. We have DMs who likely feel that they shouldn't have to waste their time enforcing something that everyone should understand already, and players upset that one DM allows a thing that another doesn't but the rules say this, and the lore seems to support it, and blah blah blah blah.
Now that Soubar thing is another conversation, and I am not trying to derail things here, but the solution there is the same as it is here. Ensure that the rules players have available are clearly expressing their intent. If we do that, we won't have any more situations where players are upset because they think someone else broke the rules, we won't have DMs upset they have to spend time dealing with something they think is already clear, and we won't have players upset because someone, player or DM, is calling them out on breaking a rule which they don't feel they actually broke. A little clarity turns a lose-lose situation into a win-win, any way you look at it.