Why is Necromancy evil?

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
thids
Posts: 1252
Joined: Sat May 25, 2013 11:05 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by thids »

It’s worth noting that if you look at the ratio of good, neutral,
and evil deities in Faerûn, there are a disproportionate number
of good-aligned deities compared to neutral or evil deities. You
see this if you compare the thirty fully described deities in the
FORGOTTEN REALMS® Campaign Setting, or just the greater and intermediate deities of Faerûn, or all the deities described in
Chapter 5 of that book: Good-aligned deities outnumber those
with a neutral aspect, and they outnumber evil deities as well.
This means there are more good influences in the world than
evil or neutral ones (though the evil ones tend to be more overt
and careful in their influence). There are more good-aligned
adventurers in Faerûn than neutral or evil ones, not just because
of divine influence but because Faerûn calls out for good heroes.
Faerûn is an interesting place, to be sure, when viewed in terms
of good and evil. The goddess of magic is good, so all magic
ultimately comes from a good source, and while she can restrict
magical access to only good creatures, she does not do so or risk
upsetting the balance of power in the world. The god of the dead
is neutral, seeing death as an inevitable thing but not something
he wants to promote or encourage before its due time. Several
nongood deities allow paladins in their service, promoting only
the most lawful and good aspects of their faith. The god of
knowledge is neutral, while the gods of literature and song are
good. The protector of caravans is neutral, while the goddess of
festhalls is good. While the D&D game views good and evil in a
more black-and-white sense than what exists in the real world, it
is clear that in Faerûn, these concepts are not so cut-and-dried.
That said, we can use the godly portfolios to determine
there are some things in Faerûn that are definitely good or evil. Nature, rather than being an indifferent or neutral force, is often good (Chauntea, Eldath, and Mielikki are good, while Silvanus is neutral) . Hereditary rule by qualified nobles is associ-ated with good—Cormyr is the only true human monarchy and
is considered a good nation; Mulhorand is ruled by lawful good
hereditary priest-kings; Evermeet and the Great Rift clans are
good monarchies. Light, whether sunlight or moonlight, is good
(Lathander, Selûne, Horus-Re, Eilistraee, and Sehanine Moonbow
are good deities of light, dawn, or the moon). Undeath, wanton
killing, and destruction are evil (Bhaal, Myrkul, Velsharoon,
Kiaransalee, Cyric, Talos, Set, and Malar). Oppression, conquest,
and inflicting suffering are evil (Bane, Loviatar, Lolth, Gruumsh,
Urdlen, Deep Duerra, and Talona), as are darkness and thievery
(Mask, Shar, and Vhaeraun).
When viewed in this way, the deities of the setting help define
the borders of Faerûnian morality. In short: Life, concern for
others, and respect for nature are good, while disruptions of the
natural cycle and abuse of power are evil. Thus it is quite possible
for a powerful good government to act in an evil manner by
abusing its power, destroying nearby lands, or engaging in war
for the sake of glory or territory.
Trump card: Champions of Valor.
Lord Maximilian Blackthorne - retired
User avatar
ShortRedandLoud
Posts: 46
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 2:52 pm
Location: Minneapolis

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by ShortRedandLoud »

Moles are evil.

Source: Urdlen
A gnome. It menaces with a fell and terrible power. - - - (148)
User avatar
Arn
Posts: 906
Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2012 7:44 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Arn »

Boddynock wrote:The fact is, that even with the "selfish vs. selfless" metric, you still use one to define the other, and so they aren't objective. Something is selfless if it is intended only to benefit others, selfishness is acting to benefit solely oneself. The are opposites, and in the absence of selfishness, no one would be considered selfless, they would just be normal.
If we're using "selfish/selfless" and really only meaning "greedy/generous", I think you're probably right. But what if you use "selfish/selfless" as a spectrum of how strong the ego identity is? In this way, the concepts of "selfish" and "selfless" are actually rooted in the concept of self, rather than being exclusively defined only as opposites of each other. IE: how strongly is a person thinking about himself when he does something? So maybe selfish/selfless could still be an "objective" metric, as long as that concept of self exists.

But I mean, ultimately, is anything really objective? To take one of your examples, it is true there is no up or down in space, there is simply one direction versus another. But those directions aren't really objective, either; you still use one direction to define another.

Similarly, in the absence of the concept of self, there is no selfish/selfless spectrum. But almost paradoxically, it's only by being selfless that you can be free of the concept of self and transcend the selfish/selfless (or Good/Evil) spectrum. It's actually how I RP the Way, which says there is no Good or Evil, etc.
Mi-Le (彌勒) - "Meditate, monks. Do not be negligent, lest you regret it later." ((-Saṃyutta Nikāya 35.146))
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]

((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))

Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
User avatar
metaquad4
Posts: 1532
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 12:51 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by metaquad4 »

The way I see it, they are semi OOC tools. They are used in the metagame for players in order to manage characters and certain game mechanics. They are semi IC as well, in that certain planes embody certain alignments, as do certain beings (gods, outsiders, etc) in lore (is that IC though? Or an OOC tool, again. Are characters aware of these ideals?). Imo the characters aren't aware of them to the degree that we (the players) are.
aka aplethoraof (on discord too)
User avatar
Deathgrowl
Recognized Donor
Posts: 6604
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2011 6:10 pm
Location: VIKING NORWAY!

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Deathgrowl »

Boddynock wrote:The planes don't do anything but exist, they have no opinions regarding values and take no actions.
This is not entirely accurate, I'm afraid. All planes have traits along the lines of good/evil and law/chaos. For instance the Limbo is "strongly chaos-aligned". Non-chaotic characters suffer a -2 penalty on all Charisma-, Wisdom-, and Intelligence-based checks. Celestia is mildly lawful and mildly good. Evil and chaotic characters suffer -2 to charisma checks. Chaotic evil characters suffer -4 to charisma checks

Now, you can argue that this is numbers and mechanics and not IC, but it manifests IC. The plane itself makes you less intelligent, less wise and definitely less charismatic unless you share the values associated with the words that name the alignments.

Again, there is a reason why spells like protection from evil exist and that the casters who created the spell knew what it meant, as well as the casters who have learned it knows how it work - at least those who have a certain spellcraft training.
Laitae Lafreth, became Chosen of Mystra, former Great Reader of Candlekeep
Nëa the Little Shadow
Uranhed Jandinwed, Guide of Candlekeep

Free music:
http://soundcloud.com/progressionmusic/sets/luna
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by TheLier »

Deathgrowl wrote:
Boddynock wrote:The planes don't do anything but exist, they have no opinions regarding values and take no actions.
This is not entirely accurate, I'm afraid. All planes have traits along the lines of good/evil and law/chaos. For instance the Limbo is "strongly chaos-aligned". Non-chaotic characters suffer a -2 penalty on all Charisma-, Wisdom-, and Intelligence-based checks. Celestia is mildly lawful and mildly good. Evil and chaotic characters suffer -2 to charisma checks. Chaotic evil characters suffer -4 to charisma checks

Now, you can argue that this is numbers and mechanics and not IC, but it manifests IC. The plane itself makes you less intelligent, less wise and definitely less charismatic unless you share the values associated with the words that name the alignments.

Again, there is a reason why spells like protection from evil exist and that the casters who created the spell knew what it meant, as well as the casters who have learned it knows how it work - at least those who have a certain spellcraft training.
I mostly agree. Good and evil are cosmic powers. And even though "aligments" are not something which exists as an IC concept, their effects are quite visible.


About the Lathander issue:

The answer is rather simple, his actions -had- to be good. Otherwise he would have fallen. I don't think that any sourcebooks states that it was an evil action to do so. And yes, in DnD you have to accept, that morality is strange, sometimes not logical at all.

In my opinion, as the gods can fall too, planes are better representation of the aligments, even though they are usually an extreme. (Like, I'm sure most LN toons won't be comfortable on Mechanus) In this case, however, a set cosmology would help. Shame the DM team still seems reluctant to make a ruling on that, even though it would be -very- important.
User avatar
LISA100595
Retired Staff
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2011 12:23 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by LISA100595 »

Necromany itself is not Evil but there are Evil described Spells in the School and other Schools of Magic as well, as noted above.

Even in the Order of the Silver Rose we use Non-evil Necromancy Spells. This is the reason we can have Wizards and Sorcerers in the guild as long as they do not use the Evil aligned or described spells.

Seraphim wrote:*List of forbidden spells. (according to SRD 3.5e): http://www.dandwiki.com/wiki/SRD:Evil_Effect / http://alcyius.com/dndtools/spells/desc ... index.html
Lady Elvina Aira-S'efarro - The Order of the Silver Rose
Nai'KaBael Oakenshadow - EDE former ArchDruidess and Wife and Mate of Mendel
Salaria - Bounty Hunter half-sister of Darius Brothers
Angelina Northstar - Holy Warrior of Tyr / Knight of the Silver Rose
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Boddynock »

Deathgrowl wrote:
The plane itself makes you less intelligent, less wise and definitely less charismatic unless you share the values associated with the words that name the alignments.
.
Come on, that's like saying that the desert makes you thirsty on purpose. The planes don't do something, they are something (I.E.- Water doesn't make you wet when you get into a pool, you make yourself wet by immersing yourself in water). Things happen in the environment of that plane because the environment by default affects everything in it. Evil things in a good aligned plane suffer because they are a "fish out of water" so to speak.

And show me where the creators of the protection from alignment spells (the IC creators, not the authors) had definite knowledge of the alignment system and how it worked. Your assumption here makes a big leap, and then you present it as fact. It simply isn't true that the existence of a protection from alignment spell tells us something about the method or reasons for it's creation from a lore perspective. There could be any number of explanations.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
thids
Posts: 1252
Joined: Sat May 25, 2013 11:05 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by thids »

Detect [Alignment] spells are totally OOC mechanics.
Lord Maximilian Blackthorne - retired
User avatar
TheLier
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2015 10:07 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by TheLier »

Thids wrote:Detect [Alignment] spells are totally OOC mechanics.
A paladin knows, that if he can "detect" you, you are evil. That is PnP. He won't say, that you are LE/NE/CE, but he will know you are evil. Also, toons must have at least some kind of knowledge of this. And if the spell works against you, that means, by definition, you are either good or evil. You can argue about the definitions, -IC-, but OOC, it is quite clear how it works.
User avatar
Deathgrowl
Recognized Donor
Posts: 6604
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2011 6:10 pm
Location: VIKING NORWAY!

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Deathgrowl »

Boddynock wrote:
Deathgrowl wrote:
The plane itself makes you less intelligent, less wise and definitely less charismatic unless you share the values associated with the words that name the alignments.
.
Come on, that's like saying that the desert makes you thirsty on purpose. The planes don't do something, they are something (I.E.- Water doesn't make you wet when you get into a pool, you make yourself wet by immersing yourself in water). Things happen in the environment of that plane because the environment by default affects everything in it. Evil things in a good aligned plane suffer because they are a "fish out of water" so to speak.
You're arguing semantics. Fine. The plane doesn't act on the creature, but the creature experiences environmental differences from other planes. This is irrelevant to what I said, though. The plane has alignment traits and they manifest ICly.
Boddynock wrote:And show me where the creators of the protection from alignment spells (the IC creators, not the authors) had definite knowledge of the alignment system and how it worked. Your assumption here makes a big leap, and then you present it as fact. It simply isn't true that the existence of a protection from alignment spell tells us something about the method or reasons for it's creation from a lore perspective. There could be any number of explanations.
You have a better potential explanation, or are you just going to discard mine without a counter because it is inconvenient to acknowledge alignments having IC manifistations and consequences?
Laitae Lafreth, became Chosen of Mystra, former Great Reader of Candlekeep
Nëa the Little Shadow
Uranhed Jandinwed, Guide of Candlekeep

Free music:
http://soundcloud.com/progressionmusic/sets/luna
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Boddynock »

Deathgrowl wrote:
You have a better potential explanation, or are you just going to discard mine without a counter because it is inconvenient to acknowledge alignments having IC manifistations and consequences?
No, I'm going to discard your explanation due to lack of supporting evidence. My choice not to present an alternative argument has no bearing on the merits of yours.

Its also hardly semantics to differentiate between a pane being able to hold opinions versus being a passive environment. Going back to the water example, water is wet simply because that is intrinsic to what it is, that is what we define it as, the water has no say in the matter. The planes are the same way, they simply are what they are, and other beings define them (remember this discussion is not about what the rules say, but why they say what they do, which often isn't explained).

And touching on the Lathander thing, if his actions had to be good to prevent his fall, but we know that his actions would not typically be considered good by FR standards, it lends credence to the idea that intent does in fact matter, and it matters quite a bit.

And to address the selfless/selfish thing... Perhaps you are right, but in the perspective of the FR setting, a person could be wholly and selflessly devoted to his church, the church of Loviatar, and be evil as f*%k, so I think perhaps we have taken it in the wrong direction.
But yes, objectivity does exist. The space example, directions do require a subjective method by which to describe them, but the absence of that method does not change the direction, that is simply fact. Similar to temperature, the temperature doesn't change whether it is given in F,C, or K. In that same vein, goodness does. The absence of evil removes the need for the term "good" as a descriptor, which implies it was simply a construct of society and the only thing that can define it is it's opposite, making it purely subjective.

You could argue that the acts that are considered good do not change if evil goes away, and that is true. But if evil ceased to be, if everyone was charitable for example, it wouldn't be good anymore. It would simply be the normal way of things.

That boils down the discussion to whether or not the acts that are considered good are intrinsically good, in the absence of evil, or are they not? I say they are not, healing the sick and feeding the poor is good because Ilmater says it is good. He defines good in that way, and by following his dogma you are considered good and more likely to reap his blessing in this life or the next.

Revenge, often considered evil or bad by normal moral standards, is neutral when carried out in the name of Hoar or Sheverash, but likely still regarded as evil when done so under the auspices of Kiransalee. Not because vengeance is evil or neutral or good, but because the morality of the act is defined by the gods paying attention.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Steve »

healing the sick and feeding the poor is...
Never judge a book by its cover. Ulterior motives may lurk at every "good" act. Most times, OOC "understanding" of situations breeds a labeling of Evil, when the act is good.

My point is, then: Evil or Good exists both in the Act and the Concept. Such is the mystery of life.

As for the OP: Necromancy as a concept is not Evil. But as an Act, it can very well be made through evil Acts.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
Arn
Posts: 906
Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2012 7:44 pm

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Arn »

Boddynock wrote:a person could be wholly and selflessly devoted to his church, the church of Loviatar, and be evil as f*%k
I actually wonder if it's possible to be selflessly devoted to causing pain to others, since that kind of sadism/masochism strongly suggests the presence of an ego identity. But I understand your point.
Mi-Le (彌勒) - "Meditate, monks. Do not be negligent, lest you regret it later." ((-Saṃyutta Nikāya 35.146))
-Monk of the Old Order and the Way. Will not kill.
-[IC Journal]
-[Bio]

((Feel free to reach out to Mi-Le for RP!))

Wendi - The Witch of the Wide. [Bio]
Samuel
Meredith
Boddynock
Posts: 834
Joined: Mon Apr 12, 2010 1:30 am

Re: Why is Necromancy evil?

Unread post by Boddynock »

Arn wrote:
Boddynock wrote:a person could be wholly and selflessly devoted to his church, the church of Loviatar, and be evil as f*%k
I actually wonder if it's possible to be selflessly devoted to causing pain to others, since that kind of sadism/masochism strongly suggests the presence of an ego identity. But I understand your point.
I suppose it depends on whether you derive pleasure from the infliction of pain, or simply do it because your self identity is wholly wrapped up in the dogma of the faith. At that point I believe it may be theoretically possible to pursue such ends with no self-gratification involved. However, it is much more likely that even selfless acts are not entirely without reward. People in real life often feel a sense of self-fulfillment after some sort of charitable activity, IE helping others often makes one feel good about oneself. But I am not really convinced someone can so completely separate themselves from their own idea of self-identity that they could pursue a lifetime of goals with no self-gratification or sense of reward. People aren't wired to work that way.

But, I don't think it is possible to lead an entirely selfless life and remain sane. At some point, you have to do something that makes you feel good about yourself. If volunteering at the children's hospital gives you a sense of fulfillment and makes you feel good about what you are doing, it isn't selfless, because you are benefiting from it. And while you may be able to put yourself second and others first, you still have to put yourself on that list somewhere.
Liam the Golden
Illdraen, Guerilla Skirmisher of Sshamath
Guy "Knife-Ears" Masterson
Boddynock Namfoodle, Illusionist Extraordinaire! (temporary leave of absence, again)

"Liam the Golden, so I have heard,
Yet truly none can polish a...
" - Ameris Santraeger, 2016

Return to “General Discussion”