Deathgrowl wrote:
You have a better potential explanation, or are you just going to discard mine without a counter because it is inconvenient to acknowledge alignments having IC manifistations and consequences?
No, I'm going to discard your explanation due to lack of supporting evidence. My choice not to present an alternative argument has no bearing on the merits of yours.
Its also hardly semantics to differentiate between a pane being able to hold opinions versus being a passive environment. Going back to the water example, water is wet simply because that is intrinsic to what it is, that is what we define it as, the water has no say in the matter. The planes are the same way, they simply are what they are, and other beings define them (remember this discussion is not about what the rules say, but why they say what they do, which often isn't explained).
And touching on the Lathander thing, if his actions
had to be good to prevent his fall, but we know that his actions would not typically be considered good by FR standards, it lends credence to the idea that intent does in fact matter, and it matters quite a bit.
And to address the selfless/selfish thing... Perhaps you are right, but in the perspective of the FR setting, a person could be wholly and selflessly devoted to his church, the church of Loviatar, and be evil as f*%k, so I think perhaps we have taken it in the wrong direction.
But yes, objectivity does exist. The space example, directions do require a subjective method by which to describe them, but the absence of that method does not change the direction, that is simply fact. Similar to temperature, the temperature doesn't change whether it is given in F,C, or K. In that same vein, goodness does. The absence of evil removes the need for the term "good" as a descriptor, which implies it was simply a construct of society and the only thing that can define it is it's opposite, making it purely subjective.
You could argue that the acts that are considered good do not change if evil goes away, and that is true. But if evil ceased to be, if everyone was charitable for example, it wouldn't be good anymore. It would simply be the normal way of things.
That boils down the discussion to whether or not the acts that are considered good are intrinsically good, in the absence of evil, or are they not? I say they are not, healing the sick and feeding the poor is good because Ilmater says it is good. He defines good in that way, and by following his dogma you are considered good and more likely to reap his blessing in this life or the next.
Revenge, often considered evil or bad by normal moral standards, is neutral when carried out in the name of Hoar or Sheverash, but likely still regarded as evil when done so under the auspices of Kiransalee. Not because vengeance is evil or neutral or good, but because the morality of the act is defined by the gods paying attention.