When I first saw this thread pop up I thought, 'Great, another one to lock,' and let me tell you my mouse cursor hovered over that lock button for some time. But despite the generally negative opening which comes rather close to breaching forum rule #3, I decided to leave it alone and I'm actually glad I have in this case.
I'd like to quote the points that have resounded the most with my experiences of the server over the last few years:
Deathgrowl wrote:the only rule the server really ought to need is "don't be an arse"
Tantive wrote:Its extremely hard to make a compelling character or roleplay for an evil character focussed on conflict, perceptionally for others players that they'de want to engage in it... It's best served in meaningful and short doses.
Blame The Rogue wrote:every person here controls the destiny of their own character, but not the destiny of other characters
Sapper Woody wrote:We are here to tell the story of the Sword Coast. This isn't "Baldur's Gate: The Reineke Ingenium Chronicles". My character is NOT the protagonist. He is a part of a bigger picture. If I controlled my story and destiny, there are MANY things I would change.
This last two points I want to specifically comment on at the risk of slightly moving this thread away from the OP: How many of us are not only willing to let other players influence our characters, but the
DM team as well? I'll raise my hand as guilty. I've always wanted to be the one in control of my character's destiny, but D&D isn't really about that is it? The very essence of d20, the mechanical representation of the (un)luck of life, is that anything can happen which you are simply not in control of. We have
partial control of our character's destinies, in that we choose what they do, say, attack, cast, attempt, etc. But there are a myriad of uncontrollables, just like in real life, that we can simply do nothing about except pray a roll/check/whatever turns out in our favour and lets us live one more combat round.
Yes, the PvPers out there need every bit of maturity as the anti-PvPers when the RP opportunity for conflict arrives: PvP encounters need to be meaningful & significant and not 'Wile E. Coyote vs Roadrunner' cartoon encounters that have no true meaning, really, due to PC 'immortality'. Yes, the DM team needs to be respectful & realistic (realistic as defined by the Forgotten Realms campaign setting, which includes magic!) in how they treat PCs and the consequences they impinge on them for successful/failed actions. That's what the DMs should be there for, to tell us when we rolled a 1 trying to jump 6ft to clear a 100ft deep chasm that 'Sorry, while launching into your jump you slipped on some loose rocks you failed to notice. Falling, you've sustained 10d6 lethal damage and have perished as a result.' And DMing is not easy on a persistent world such as ours when you have up to 96 competing voices/plans/goals all vying for attention and place.
And I'm sure at some point we've all been that person that throws their hands in the air at the P&P table, emitted a loud groan and a few choice expletives and asked ourselves 'Why?! What did I do wrong to deserve that?! I put so much effort into that character! This DM hates me!' But we didn't do anything wrong, neither did the DM (necessarily!) hate us. We were participating in a game which loosely represents the luck of real life: good things appear to happen to some, bad to others, and with no explicable explanation for either.
My point is similar to Deathgrowl's: Maturity, folks. Craft a story that -engages- other players and makes them willing to participate. The only reason this server has so many irritating rules (like PvP RP outs) is because there are
always those who will abuse whatever system is in place for poops and giggles, nothing more. And I'm not here for that. Are you?