Enough with the rp bias whining!

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
Sapper Woody
Recognized Donor
Posts: 330
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2016 5:15 pm

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Sapper Woody »

Blame The Rogue wrote:the important thing to remember, aside from following the pvp rules, is that everyone is here to tell their character's story. every person here controls the destiny of their own character, but not the destiny of other characters
I 100% disagree with this. We are here to tell the story of the Sword Coast. This isn't "Baldur's Gate: The Reineke Ingenium Chronicles". My character is NOT the protagonist. He is a part of a bigger picture. If I controlled my story and destiny, there are MANY things I would change.

My character is in conflict with Luke Darius right now, for instance. My character wanted to sit down and talk, and Luke was unwilling. If I were telling my story, Luke would have sit down and we'd have discussed it and come to an understanding. I'm not going to complain and say that he's ruining my RP. Rather, I'm going to accept it as part of my character's story.

Same with the Malarite. He has entered the story of the Coast. Now everyone is jumping on this bandwagon of "You don't control my destiny" and in doing so, is trying to control the Malarite's story.

So, the main thing to remember is that you are NOT telling your story. You are contributing to the story of the coast. This is not Lord of the Rings, where we follow a party who will eventually succeed. This is Game of Thrones, where anyone could die at any second.

The control you DO have, is when your character's story is over. If my character dies, I'm not done with him. I will work with people to bring him back. I don't feel his story is over. But I'm not going to start harassing people OOC because I don't like the way they are playing, as long as it isn't game or immersion breaking.

Otherwise, I'd be all up in arms about Luke Darius' conflict with Rein. Because I'll be honest, I'm not enjoying it. But it's part of the story, and it is developing how it will.
Reineke Villame
Biography

Huego Bellecovum
Journal
User avatar
Blame The Rogue
Posts: 653
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2010 10:10 am

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Blame The Rogue »

i'll agree to disagree

this is why the pvp rules exist

you are welcome to your opinion

happy gaming
"Before you die, you should know why you lived."
Israe
Posts: 431
Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2012 3:22 pm

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Israe »

The community often drives those of us who are considerate into quitting "Evil" rp. I've done my best with my PC's to never meta-game any knowledge (To include levels). I've been level 14, and attacked a level 30 over an argument that still results in "Your character needs to lose weight" Jokes (Looking at you AoS).

But overall, the problems I've experienced are that a player has a bad experience with one PVP'er who was evil, and blames all the evil players. I've had bad experiences from "Good guys" who KoS me. I've had some utterly ridiculous experiences as well.

Generally roll with the punches, express your OOC concerns. If you enter a situation you don't like, then most of us Evil PC's will accomodate you. Sometimes OOC is involved, such as if you run into my PC Jys, she will often target you (most especially if you're an elf.) I usually ask ooc if they're interested in that RP, and if not I'll have her get distracted by something.

What grinds my nerves is most of the ones whine, when they face your PC they say something smart, or threaten you. Calling my PC a filthy drow, when she is known to be evil is grounds enough for her pride to strike him and hurt you very badly.

But generally you want an RP out, you'll get one, my experience with the Malarite was positive both times. He's considerate OOC'ly.
Wolfshear
Posts: 217
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 3:16 pm

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Wolfshear »

PvP or otherwise, evil rp and actions have been stifled on this server for a long time...Years even.

This is nothing new and has existed for as long as I have ever played here. Should it be this way? No, most certainly not....But it is unfortunatly the reality of the server and has been for a long time.

Now don't get me wrong, every now and again evil players get thrown a bone and are allowed to actually do something cool or fun, but those instances are few and far between...Growing even less as time goes on, I could probably count on one hand the actual evil or morally questionable actions i've been able to take that didn't just involve random pvp.

Of course there are a large number of people that like to bury their head in the sand and decry anyone that says anything like this, deny that this is even a thing. Even to go so far as to accuse the morally questionable as being "pampered".

Im not even just talking about lack of dm attention or bias. Other players themselves whether they intend to or not, can be incredibly unsupportive or in some cases even oocly hostile toward any sort of questionable character.

A fine example is that I get treated as if I am playing my main evil character regardless of what character I am currently playing. Not everyone does this intentionally and that is fine..But more than a few do even if they would otherwise pretend they do not. Either way it is an unfortunate thing that has happened to more than one morally ambiguous player.

What Israe said about evil players being driven to quit evil is entirely correct. The vast majority of evil players I have known over the years get sick of the utterly hostile and lets be honest, ooc enviroment. They either quit the server entirely or make a good or neutral chracter.

There is a reason alot of the old evil players arent playing evil, there is a reason even new evil players that are fantastic rpers don't last long. People honestly need to stop being in denial that there isn't a problem.


Those are just my two cents.
Last edited by Wolfshear on Sat Dec 16, 2017 7:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Selengil -Irritable Elven Wizard
Arkos - Your not so friendly neighbourhood Tiefling
User avatar
Steve
Recognized Donor
Posts: 8197
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2015 5:42 am
Location: Paradise in GMT +1

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Steve »

Wolfshear wrote:PvP or otherwise, evil rp and actions have been stifled on this server for a long time...Years even.
Hidden: show
This is nothing new and has existed for as long as I have ever played here. Should it be this way? No, most certainly not....But it is unfortunatly the reality of the server and has been for a long time.

Now dont get me wrong, every now and again evil players get thrown a bone and are allowed to actually do something cool or fun, but those instances are few and far between...Growing even less as time goes on, I could probably count on one hand the actual evil or morally questionable actions ive been able to take that didnt just involve random pvp.

Of course there are a large number of people that like to bury their head in the sand and decry anyone that says anything like this, deny that this is even a thing. Even to go so far as to accuse the morally questionable as being "pampered".

Im not even just talking about lack of dm attention or bias. Other players themselves whether they intend to or not, can be incredibly unsupportive or in some cases even oocly hostile toward any sort of questionable character.

A fine example is that I get treated as if I am playing my main evil character regardless of what character I am currently playing. Not everyone does this intentionally and that is fine..But more than a few do even if they would otherwise pretend they do not. Either way it is an unfortunate thing that has happened to more than one morally ambiguous player.

What Israe said about evil players being driven to quit evil is entirely correct. The vast majority of evil players I have known over the years get sick of the utterly hostile and lets be honest, ooc enviroment. They either quit the server entirely or make a good or neutral chracter.

There is a reason alot of the old evil players arent playing evil, there is a even new evil players that are fantastic rpers dont last long. People honestly need to stop being in denial that there isnt a problem.


Those are just my two cents.
This ^^.

Jon Smythe - The Book of....

Essaar Arkae - True Essential Servant

Sabross N'azza - Working...

Khelboros Wyrmstone
User avatar
V'rass
Posts: 1251
Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2015 1:48 pm
Location: Concord, N.H., USSA

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by V'rass »

Well im not going to be bound by this foolishness... if i ever play an evil, (and it might happen) i will make sure not to give a fig about any complaints. I will stay in the rules at all times and wont force rp on anyone but i will do evil rp and complaining when there is no cause for such is not going to make me stop or go away. I encourage all evils to follow suit, its time to stand up to the bias.
"To understand magic one must first understand magic."






Agathion Benedictus: Holy Priest. Retired for now.
Tiax Rules-All: Gnomish madman. Retired permanently.
Exordius Vrass: Cleric/Mage. Currently active.
User avatar
aaron22
Recognized Donor
Posts: 3524
Joined: Sat Feb 06, 2016 3:39 pm
Location: New York

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by aaron22 »

I play evil conflict oriented characters. It's tough sledding. I am inspired by those who like me have taken this role and all that comes with it and from it and endured it all to keep going. Many are gone now. Maybe to return. Maybe not. Some are still here though. You guys inspire me to keep on. Thanks.
Khar B'ukagaroh
"You never know how strong you are until being strong is your only choice."
Bob Marley
User avatar
Xanfyrst
Posts: 1274
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2009 2:12 am
Location: In Sierante's naughty dreams

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Xanfyrst »

Yeah, don't tell me about it. I've been dealing with that crap for 7-8 years now.
SANITY IS FOR THE WEAK.
Alistair the Red - Roaming Bounty Hunter and Underworld Contact.
Lord Eliphas Valkarian "the Deceiver" -Chosen Prophet of Bane, Autonomous Agent of the Zhentarim. Immortal? ×Returned from the Beyond×
Tsidkenu

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Tsidkenu »

When I first saw this thread pop up I thought, 'Great, another one to lock,' and let me tell you my mouse cursor hovered over that lock button for some time. But despite the generally negative opening which comes rather close to breaching forum rule #3, I decided to leave it alone and I'm actually glad I have in this case.

I'd like to quote the points that have resounded the most with my experiences of the server over the last few years:
Deathgrowl wrote:the only rule the server really ought to need is "don't be an arse"
Tantive wrote:Its extremely hard to make a compelling character or roleplay for an evil character focussed on conflict, perceptionally for others players that they'de want to engage in it... It's best served in meaningful and short doses.
Blame The Rogue wrote:every person here controls the destiny of their own character, but not the destiny of other characters
Sapper Woody wrote:We are here to tell the story of the Sword Coast. This isn't "Baldur's Gate: The Reineke Ingenium Chronicles". My character is NOT the protagonist. He is a part of a bigger picture. If I controlled my story and destiny, there are MANY things I would change.
This last two points I want to specifically comment on at the risk of slightly moving this thread away from the OP: How many of us are not only willing to let other players influence our characters, but the DM team as well? I'll raise my hand as guilty. I've always wanted to be the one in control of my character's destiny, but D&D isn't really about that is it? The very essence of d20, the mechanical representation of the (un)luck of life, is that anything can happen which you are simply not in control of. We have partial control of our character's destinies, in that we choose what they do, say, attack, cast, attempt, etc. But there are a myriad of uncontrollables, just like in real life, that we can simply do nothing about except pray a roll/check/whatever turns out in our favour and lets us live one more combat round.

Yes, the PvPers out there need every bit of maturity as the anti-PvPers when the RP opportunity for conflict arrives: PvP encounters need to be meaningful & significant and not 'Wile E. Coyote vs Roadrunner' cartoon encounters that have no true meaning, really, due to PC 'immortality'. Yes, the DM team needs to be respectful & realistic (realistic as defined by the Forgotten Realms campaign setting, which includes magic!) in how they treat PCs and the consequences they impinge on them for successful/failed actions. That's what the DMs should be there for, to tell us when we rolled a 1 trying to jump 6ft to clear a 100ft deep chasm that 'Sorry, while launching into your jump you slipped on some loose rocks you failed to notice. Falling, you've sustained 10d6 lethal damage and have perished as a result.' And DMing is not easy on a persistent world such as ours when you have up to 96 competing voices/plans/goals all vying for attention and place.

And I'm sure at some point we've all been that person that throws their hands in the air at the P&P table, emitted a loud groan and a few choice expletives and asked ourselves 'Why?! What did I do wrong to deserve that?! I put so much effort into that character! This DM hates me!' But we didn't do anything wrong, neither did the DM (necessarily!) hate us. We were participating in a game which loosely represents the luck of real life: good things appear to happen to some, bad to others, and with no explicable explanation for either.

My point is similar to Deathgrowl's: Maturity, folks. Craft a story that -engages- other players and makes them willing to participate. The only reason this server has so many irritating rules (like PvP RP outs) is because there are always those who will abuse whatever system is in place for poops and giggles, nothing more. And I'm not here for that. Are you?
User avatar
Blackman D
Retired Staff
Posts: 4818
Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 5:43 am
Location: IL

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Blackman D »

Xanfyrst wrote:Yeah, don't tell me about it. I've been dealing with that crap for 7-8 years now.
right?

remember when some of the surface players went down to the UD when cazna was around and i was playing shadera? man... talk about doing the wrong things around evil drow :lol:

my body count kept going up... totally wasnt my fault :snooty:
everyone is evil till proven otherwise
User avatar
Snarfy
Posts: 1430
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 12:14 pm

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Snarfy »

Wolfshear wrote:PvP or otherwise, evil rp and actions have been stifled on this server for a long time...Years even.

This is nothing new and has existed for as long as I have ever played here. Should it be this way? No, most certainly not....But it is unfortunately the reality of the server and has been for a long time...

~snip~
I could probably speculate a couple pages of spam as to why this might be, but...
Deathgrowl wrote:Former HDM Narshe often said that the only rule the server really ought to need is "don't be an arse". And that is essentially the point here.
... quite simply, some players are unable to distinguish between IC'ly being and arse, and OOC'ly being an arse. Playing an evil character, or even a morally ambiguous one, requires a certain degree of "being an arse" IC'ly. The natural response to this by many players, perhaps even subconsciously, is that the player of said evil character must be an arse too. Sadly, player/character separation just isn't what it used to be, and, more often than not, the way that "good-aligned" players OOC'ly behave towards evil-RP'er is...
... The vast majority of evil players I have known over the years get sick of the utterly hostile and lets be honest, ooc enviroment
... them being arses. Oh, what a conundrum.

The sad truth of it... is that evil RP is not sustainable in an environment that caters to tolerance, tip-toe'ing around everyone's OOC feelings, and magically getting along(either OOC'ly, or IC'ly). For evil RP to truly flourish, it would require having equal opportunity for evil players' machiavellian schemes coming to fruition as often as the good players do-gooding. If Camp Evil managed to sustain any kind of agenda, it would end up ruffling the feathers of Camp bake sale Good, and thus jeopardize the status-quo.

Once upon a time(like... 4 or 5 years ago) it was marginally sustainable, but not now. There are just too many players who get bent out of shape too easily, and we cant be upsetting people with pesky, over-arching, long term evil RP now, can we? /sarcasm

PS. This is coming from a long time player of a morally ambiguous character, who has seen his fair share of OOC arse-hattery directed towards himself, just for RP'ing a jerk.
There are no level 30's, only level 20's with benefits...
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by NegInfinity »

Blame The Rogue wrote:the important thing to remember, aside from following the pvp rules, is that everyone is here to tell their character's story.
I think that's wrong.

I've been playing to experience it, and not to tell it. Because I don't know what will happen.

Having a "life plan" your character is supposed to live through is a recipe for disaster. For example, if you decide that you're going to have an ultimate swordsman and run into the "ultimate swordsman +1" , you'll be defeated and the concept will be shattered.

This is the point where people usually get upset. Because they imagined it will go their way, and it didn't.
User avatar
Cenerae
Posts: 171
Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2017 7:57 pm

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Cenerae »

NegInfinity wrote:
Blame The Rogue wrote:the important thing to remember, aside from following the pvp rules, is that everyone is here to tell their character's story.
I think that's wrong.

I've been playing to experience it, and not to tell it. Because I don't know what will happen.

Having a "life plan" your character is supposed to live through is a recipe for disaster. For example, if you decide that you're going to have an ultimate swordsman and run into the "ultimate swordsman +1" , you'll be defeated and the concept will be shattered.

This is the point where people usually get upset. Because they imagined it will go their way, and it didn't.
Pretty sure he meant that we all want to roleplay our characters. Sure, the evil Banite or whatever should have a chance to capture a paladin and try to break them through torture or whatever. But the Banite should also be OOCly communicating and being generally respectful to the paladin's player, and give them a chance to interact. So they can still have fun while you're getting the sort of fun you wanted.

We should still be getting offered opportunities to roleplay even in losing a battle and in defeat, otherwise all we're doing is providing what amounts to being an NPC in someone else's power fantasy. Doing that to someone shows a great lack of respect for the other player and is something that is very likely to breed resentment. And yes, of course, this works both ways - the paladin can't very well go around deciding to make the Banite drop what he's doing just because the paladin has decided 'now is the time for me to show how virtuous I am!' without being likely to breed some resentment in the process.

Maybe some people *do* have the idea that their character is The Hero (or The Villain) and should never lose. This is another reason for OOC communication - so you can identify these people beforehand and not only save you from having a bad RP experience with such a person, but it also prevents that person from having any reason to throw a fit about it. Making assumptions that everyone on the server would be glad to go along with what you want to do - and when you decide you want to do it - without you needing to ask if they'd be interested? Seems to be what causes these sorts of topics to pop up in the first place.
NegInfinity
Posts: 2449
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:24 am

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by NegInfinity »

Cenerae wrote: Pretty sure he meant that we all want to roleplay our characters.
I can't read minds and don't know what was meant which is why I respond to what was written/said instead.

During my time here I did experience couple of times where alignment conflict escalated to OOC conflict, due to some odd beliefs held by sides. Like that "justice is supposed to prevail and good guys should win". However, those attitudes appeared on different sides and different alignments.

The thing about trying to tell their story is something that stood out as a frequent source of conflict.
Cenerae wrote:This is another reason for OOC communication
It is also possible to go overboard with OOC communication. If there are too many people involved, then they can end up debating for eternity and getting deralied.

In fact, I prefer to have no OOC communication, but like to interact with someone who doesn't have unreasonable expectations and can handle their character or circumstances thrown at them.
User avatar
Cenerae
Posts: 171
Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2017 7:57 pm

Re: Enough with the rp bias whining!

Unread post by Cenerae »

NegInfinity wrote:
Cenerae wrote:This is another reason for OOC communication
It is also possible to go overboard with OOC communication. If there are too many people involved, then they can end up debating for eternity and getting deralied.

In fact, I prefer to have no OOC communication, but like to interact with someone who doesn't have unreasonable expectations and can handle their character or circumstances thrown at them.
All I'm trying to get at is, you need to have some respect for the other player when you're trying to RP conflicts. As you say, you're not a mind reader, and neither am I. Maybe the person you're approaching would be cool with going along with whatever without you needing to ask. Maybe they want to know what your intentions are after the fact. Maybe they're just not interested. You're not going to know until you ask.

It's not really any different from OOCly asking someone if they want to join your party for clearing out x dungeon or if they want to come along to y event.

Return to “General Discussion”