Subject: Brain-storming the Underdark / Surface interaction
I noticed a trend in the thread with issues of how the rules are but I find it very hard to get anything actionable from references to the entire ruling. I'll post them below. Please identify what seems to be tripping people up and why. Please be concise and on point. This is a survey more than a discussion on what the rules should be.Flasmix wrote:It is in my opinion that a minority has ruined any surface/UD interaction for the majority. The minority being those who just go to the surface for just PvP purposes. I would like to see the UD/Surface rules slackened to where those who wish to travel can do so freely, but if it's just for PvP and there's repeated complaints about someone, they get punished directly.
To be honest, the current method of enforcement is just in place due to laziness and not wanting to enforce anything.
– Surface/UD Travel!
-You can be on the other side, but have some roleplay reason to be there (not just an excuse to grind or PvP). Stating that you are there to defeat such and such creature, or to test your skill is not a valid RP reason, that is grinding. We also do not consider general exploration, or Drow raids on the surface as a valid RP reason, although such can be fodder for DM moderated events. Please PM the team regarding this.
Valid RP reasons outside of the above are defined widely and do not require prior DM approval. Examples include meeting another PC to trade, or to RP over religion, or to establish contacts with another guild. We would ask however that you are able to state your reasons when a DM asks and abide by any decision that is made. Please note that it is not valid to grind once the reasons for travelling to the surface or underdark are complete. Stating that you are meeting a PC in Sshamath to acquire via trade rare and valuable items is a valid reason but grinding afterwards with your trading partner is still grinding.
The barrier between the Surface and UD is the Netherese Ruins. Those caught grinding on the opposite side of the Ruins from where they belong will be penalized from 1+ levels to being banned from the server.
Surfacers in the Underdark and Underdark-based characters on the Surface are consenting to certain criteria and vulnerabilities:
- You cannot grind monsters for experience
- You cannot search for loot (exploring dungeons for treasure, picking at gold piles, etc)
- You may not run quests
- If slain in PvP, you may be issued a permastrike. Your character can afford three permastrikes (Permastrike rules: http://www.bgtscc.net/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=25355)
The intent of this is to allow opportunity for ROLEPLAY and this is why we define RP reasons widely. It is not an opportunity to exploit different areas for their resources. The server is designed to allow both sides their share of quests, monsters and dungeons. Taking advantage of both sides is against the intent of our area builders and server design.
We also ask that players are respectful of the setting given the leniency of these rules. On the surface NPCs should be regarded as universally hostile to Underdark PCs and so maps with NPCs should be avoided where possible without DM supervision. In the Underdark, the peculiarities of Sshamath's lore should be respected and the Underdark itself should be considered a dangerous and hostile place. While we wish to facilitate roleplay between surface and Underdark we do not want to erode the setting and so may intervene in RP that is immersion breaking.
The DM team reminds Drow race players that Drow races would feel rather out of place on the surface in many respects even beyond just surface race hostility to them. We ask for the sake of proper lore immersion relating the race on the surface for Drow on the surface to be RPed as such. For example, Drow not living on the surface for a long period of time would have a strong negative physiological reaction to sunlight and other bright sources of light, and open spaces.
We note that the same goes for those visiting the Underdark. Lorewise these caverns are a dangerous, dark and confusing warren and we would ask players to observe their character's limitations as well as RPing around the hazard that travel through the Underdark would represent.