UD/Surface Rules

For Issues, Ideas, or Subjects That Do Not Fit Elsewhere

Moderators: Moderator, DM

User avatar
DM Theophanies
Retired Staff
Posts: 4144
Joined: Thu Feb 20, 2014 5:53 pm

UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by DM Theophanies »

I do not wish to derail the thread so i'll start a new one.

Subject: Brain-storming the Underdark / Surface interaction
Flasmix wrote:It is in my opinion that a minority has ruined any surface/UD interaction for the majority. The minority being those who just go to the surface for just PvP purposes. I would like to see the UD/Surface rules slackened to where those who wish to travel can do so freely, but if it's just for PvP and there's repeated complaints about someone, they get punished directly.

To be honest, the current method of enforcement is just in place due to laziness and not wanting to enforce anything.
I noticed a trend in the thread with issues of how the rules are but I find it very hard to get anything actionable from references to the entire ruling. I'll post them below. Please identify what seems to be tripping people up and why. Please be concise and on point. This is a survey more than a discussion on what the rules should be.
– Surface/UD Travel!
-You can be on the other side, but have some roleplay reason to be there (not just an excuse to grind or PvP). Stating that you are there to defeat such and such creature, or to test your skill is not a valid RP reason, that is grinding. We also do not consider general exploration, or Drow raids on the surface as a valid RP reason, although such can be fodder for DM moderated events. Please PM the team regarding this.

Valid RP reasons outside of the above are defined widely and do not require prior DM approval. Examples include meeting another PC to trade, or to RP over religion, or to establish contacts with another guild. We would ask however that you are able to state your reasons when a DM asks and abide by any decision that is made. Please note that it is not valid to grind once the reasons for travelling to the surface or underdark are complete. Stating that you are meeting a PC in Sshamath to acquire via trade rare and valuable items is a valid reason but grinding afterwards with your trading partner is still grinding.

The barrier between the Surface and UD is the Netherese Ruins. Those caught grinding on the opposite side of the Ruins from where they belong will be penalized from 1+ levels to being banned from the server.

Surfacers in the Underdark and Underdark-based characters on the Surface are consenting to certain criteria and vulnerabilities:
- You cannot grind monsters for experience
- You cannot search for loot (exploring dungeons for treasure, picking at gold piles, etc)
- You may not run quests
- If slain in PvP, you may be issued a permastrike. Your character can afford three permastrikes (Permastrike rules: http://www.bgtscc.net/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=25355)

The intent of this is to allow opportunity for ROLEPLAY and this is why we define RP reasons widely. It is not an opportunity to exploit different areas for their resources. The server is designed to allow both sides their share of quests, monsters and dungeons. Taking advantage of both sides is against the intent of our area builders and server design.

We also ask that players are respectful of the setting given the leniency of these rules. On the surface NPCs should be regarded as universally hostile to Underdark PCs and so maps with NPCs should be avoided where possible without DM supervision. In the Underdark, the peculiarities of Sshamath's lore should be respected and the Underdark itself should be considered a dangerous and hostile place. While we wish to facilitate roleplay between surface and Underdark we do not want to erode the setting and so may intervene in RP that is immersion breaking.

The DM team reminds Drow race players that Drow races would feel rather out of place on the surface in many respects even beyond just surface race hostility to them. We ask for the sake of proper lore immersion relating the race on the surface for Drow on the surface to be RPed as such. For example, Drow not living on the surface for a long period of time would have a strong negative physiological reaction to sunlight and other bright sources of light, and open spaces.

We note that the same goes for those visiting the Underdark. Lorewise these caverns are a dangerous, dark and confusing warren and we would ask players to observe their character's limitations as well as RPing around the hazard that travel through the Underdark would represent.
User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Maximvs »

People want more interaction, and people want these interactions to be the same as everywhere else. Perma strikes for such interactions isn't good. Either people can be perma killed everywhere or nowhere. By the way, your link seems bugged.
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!
User avatar
Aspect of Sorrow
Custom Content
Posts: 2702
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 7:11 pm
Location: Reliquary

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Aspect of Sorrow »

Agreed, but some risk should be apparent.
User avatar
Maximvs
Posts: 281
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 3:45 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Maximvs »

Some risk should be -everywhere-
MmmmMMMMmmm, tasty humanz, hmmmmMMM!!!
User avatar
Calodan
Posts: 2032
Joined: Fri Apr 19, 2013 12:21 pm
Location: Missoula Montana BIG SKY COUNTRY

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Calodan »

For me it is the entire ruling on Surface/UD travel. It just seems counterproductive to any interaction at all. I would think the server rules on PvP and other situations are concise and clear enough. The server should be open for RP. On all levels. Separating the server into two factions is in fact a form of segregation. I do not believe that to be a "GOOD" thing for the health of the server as a whole. The whole server should be in use by us all whether from the surface or the UD. No one who plays a PC on the server should be KOS either. At most specific summons can be KOS and grounds to initiate PvP via the rule set but having Drow on surface and other races in UD should all follow the same PvP rules and RP rules already set by the server. This special ruling on UD/Surface only convolutes the whole situation into a fight between two factions who should be generating RP together.
Kory Sentinel
"We should take the army head on!"

"... it sounds like a terrible idea, but look at that smile."
"And he just sounds so confident ... he is a favored soul."
"Even if we don't survive, he will, and isn't that what matters?" -Red Lancer
fearknight2003
Posts: 354
Joined: Fri Sep 25, 2015 8:53 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by fearknight2003 »

What if I wanted to play a Chaotic-Good drow ranger of Mielikki?
It was a fun year (I think). Bye.
User avatar
DM Theophanies
Retired Staff
Posts: 4144
Joined: Thu Feb 20, 2014 5:53 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by DM Theophanies »

So the issue seems to be the KOS and permastrikes which are bothering people? The risk is too high?
User avatar
Akroma666
Posts: 1886
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2012 2:24 pm
Location: California

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Akroma666 »

KOS is fair, perma.. no.. thats rough. Drow too strong to be running around not KOS.
Storm - The Blade Flurry
Druegar Grizzleclaw - The Mountain Ruin Tsar
Akroma Thuul - The Creepy Enchanter
Liliana Duskblade - The B*tch of Bane
Jamie Dawnbringer - The Light in the Darkness
User avatar
Blackman D
Retired Staff
Posts: 4818
Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 5:43 am
Location: IL

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Blackman D »

kinda hard to have KOS without perma strikes tho, people can run around facerolling with a powerbuild with KOS just fine, with perma strikes if killed they would be more reserved about it

should actually probably add that if your toon is perma killed from dying on the other side 3 times you cant RCR it also, that would really make people think about being a douche trying to pvp everyone all the time just because they have some uber powerbuild :P
everyone is evil till proven otherwise
User avatar
Kauaiian
Recognized Donor
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:59 am
Location: Europe

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Kauaiian »

Blackman D wrote:kinda hard to have KOS without perma strikes tho, people can run around facerolling with a powerbuild with KOS just fine, with perma strikes if killed they would be more reserved about it

should actually probably add that if your toon is perma killed from dying on the other side 3 times you cant RCR it also, that would really make people think about being a douche trying to pvp everyone all the time just because they have some uber powerbuild :P
+1
User avatar
Thorsson
Posts: 1293
Joined: Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:17 pm

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Thorsson »

What happened last time is this:

1. Numbers of Drow were bigger, because without the restrictions lots of people wanted to be Drizzt-a-likes; i.e. the power of Drow without any drawbacks (even light sensitivity is mechanically bugged)

2. There were constant streams of Drow on the surface, acting like they owned the place

3. Most actively sought PvP, often with lower level surface characters

I really don't want to go back to those days.
Life is far too important a thing ever to talk seriously about it
Storm Munin
Posts: 1355
Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:03 am
Location: Sweden, Alfheimar expat

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Storm Munin »

Yeah it were bad times when:

1. Random surfacers came down into the UD to shop items either totally ignoring roleplay or acting like they were gods when in town.

2. Swarms of a certain dwarf guild (with no lore foundation to their AWESOME prestige class whatsoever) fought their way through the UD players to reach the pitfiend with looting in mind or Sshamath with shopping in mind.
Anyone of them killed instantly revived by wand or scroll, any emote (if any) beyond the stylish -RAAAH, drow! prior to engagement the rare occurance.

3. Most surfacers actively avoiding roleplay unless they went down the I am a godlike human wizard line and its sidekicks.

Quite a few of the UD PvP raids to the surface back in 2010-2012, not all, were actually acted out by friends of mine in the mood of returning the favour right back at the surface players.

Coincidentaly what Thorsson wrote about and what I am writing about tended to happen a lot more frequently when there were no DMs around due to play hours.


I really dont want to go back to those days either. ;)
"Drojal zhah obdoluth dorb'd streeak, Lueth dro zhah zhaunau dorb'd ogglin."
"Existence is empty without chaos, Life is boring without enemies." So sayeth Lady Lolth, Queen of Chaos.

PC: Natalya, wandering enchantress.
User avatar
freekender
Posts: 649
Joined: Wed Sep 26, 2012 4:46 am
Location: Bilbao, Spain

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by freekender »

I didn't write on the thread Thophanies mentions because these threads have usually lead to nothing in the past but to opening cans of worms. But opening this one could mean than maybe (just maybe) now we can change this issue (and a big one IMHO, or this topic wouldn't pop up from time to time on the forums). I really hope so.

I think some of the problems here are the following:

1) UD/Surface conennections. And I don't mean tunnels connecting both. I mean areas where both UDers and surfacers can RP. RP, not just PvP.

2) KOS. I think the tipical "aargh, a drow; die" is not valid. First of all this question must be made: would that character know what drows are? That PvP must have RP reasons, as ALL PvPs. This involves heavy lore knowledge, so an easy guide on the forums could aid.

3) Traveling itself. The character must have RP reasons to do so.

4) UD and surface comparison. I think this is capital, and another topic that pops up from time to time. The UD is much smaller than the surface, and that makes people get bored/tired from it. And, more important, it has much less attention from DMs, which makes it less populated too. As an example, in 2015 we had more events and casual DM interaction in the UD and it was more populated.

To finalize I would ask to keep civilized and write only constructive ideas. Please, don't repeat one more time what usually happens with these type of threads.

I really hope this helps.
Myrualae - Chantress of Doron Amar
Snow - Sorcery and carrots!
Gomez de Aguirre - The Fabulous Knight of the Mystic Fire
Uelaereene Sai'zzel - Once I saw the stars...
Lilly Sai'zzel - Stormy snowflake
And more...
User avatar
Flasmix
Posts: 2504
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 9:22 am
Location: Cult of Skebbeton HQ

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Flasmix »

Oooh, a thread made off one of my comments :D Now I know I'm doing something right.

Well, since it's based off something I said which I stand by allow me to elaborate. While we do have rules in place, the enforcement of said rules from the DMs is non-existant to outright hostile. I'll throw you a couple examples,

1) Another character and mine had made the trip to the surface to try and gain contacts for our mercenary guild. The Sending Spell works wonders once you get to know someone and don't need to make the trip to contact the other PC. Anyways, my companion had some sort of bug come up and asked a DM for support. The DM simply said, "Well, you shouldn't be on the surface anyways." There was no questioning as to why they were there, just the blanket statement of 'You shouldn't be here'. What's the point of going 'Oh look, we do have rules see?' if the DMs don't seem to be on board and have their on prejudices on the matter?

2) When the transition had just broken, I was not aware of it and was going to make the journey to the surface to try and build on an old contact who we lost touch with. As a member of Bregan D'aerthe who is not a Drow and who lived on the surface originally, he is sort of the unofficial liasion since he won't be outright killed. When I came to the transition and found it didn't work I checked the forums, then paged a DM to confirm it's not working. The conversation went something like this;

DM: "Why do you want to go to the surface you're a UD character?" (An understandable question, but by wording it like this it's hinting at UD characters shouldn't be on the surface regardless)
Me: "I was reading our forums and found an old contact and since it's been ages since we talked to them, I was hoping to go meet with either the leader or a member."
DM: "Is the leader on? Are any other members on?"
Me: "No, the leader isn't on. I don't actually know any of the other members as I'm not a part of the guild and don't actively follow who they are. I was going to go to their base and wait for one there."
DM: "Are they expecting you?"
Me: "There's no way for them to expect me as I have no contact with them."

I can't remember the rest of it, but long story short, I got teleported back to Sshamath.

Every interaction I've heard of has lead me and others to believe that the DMs don't want anything to do with the UD. They prefer keeping the surface and UD separate and the vast majority of them do not run events for the UD. When I was a DM here, I ran events for both sides, often having what I call "UD" days where I just stayed in the UD except to help with bugs. Going in with the intention of running small one-off events had the potential to lead to some re-occuring characters and a mini-plotline. I digress, I'm getting way off point now.

While there are rules in place they are not the same ones the DMs enforce. Each has their own definition of RP and are more than happy to shut anybody down if they do not have a very exact and specific reason for going up there. I.E. "I'm going to meet Bob under the Apple Tree at 11:30 PM for some RP." It leads to a lot of Catch 22 scenarios, "Well I'm going up to get contacts for the guild, but I need a contact to build the contacts, but to get the contacts I need to get a contact to which I can then get contacts once I get that contact, etc, etc."

And hey, listen, I understand not wanting to deal with the headache of Drow Raids. There was a LOT of butt hurt and flak from players to the DMs to the point that it scarred them. I remember when the DMs changed it so raids could only happen if sanctioned by DMs, then a sanctioned raid took place, queue the incoming player butt hurt, there hasn't been a sanctioned raid since.

I am at the stage where I think one of two things needs to be decided; the DMs put some trust in UD players and allow them to be on the surface to RP (Not PvP) and to punish those who break the rules accordingly or we remove the UD entirely and turn it into just another dungeon for surfacers to go to or DM events.
Wirg to Pug: "Iz lat dun?"
Pugratix to a snarky militia man: "Mmmm. Not yet. I will live for hundreds of years and be heralded as one of the greatest forces of destruction on the face of the world. The only thing you can destroy is the outhouse."
User avatar
Kauaiian
Recognized Donor
Posts: 337
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:59 am
Location: Europe

Re: UD/Surface Rules

Unread post by Kauaiian »

Flasmix wrote: the DMs put some trust in UD players and allow them to be on the surface to RP (Not PvP) and to punish those who break the rules accordingly or we remove the UD entirely and turn it into just another dungeon for surfacers to go to or DM events.
Not sure how much of an effect it would have but why not a poll to see the majority?

Return to “General Discussion”